A . r 1'.' 1(1 'J) L i: Ji; it; - it if- i ' " ".-U-- . L -gggg BOB ; EnTSTSTR LKOM TORPEDO. THE liODBUTS . .PEiaoifiDM JOHPEDO CO. Office at (he Red Planing Mill, Comer of Pine and Secoud Streets, Near tbe ltatlruad,) TnJVSV'ILLE, PA. T. Owltin tn the forge and inoreastnp rturuAnd for the RwtMrii' TorpwIotH, and tlia late dociaion of thu Vatntnitionir of Ficetiw in retorting to Wra. Ketid prtumt. aud too d. wis km of Juio if. C. -Giieru-talntu&tke itobarts' pit-eat they Wva LOU'KUi.1) U-u jriu of tlwrir TorrHNioet VfWfiXTf PKn CENT. w that ororv Opmtor run fcfford to try ft Torpedo bel',.i finaadoning u Well. The following Is the decision i-endured by Ji;d" Oriixou tbe twentv-etwond (W) day of PentemW, J, Ui the Unit I'd States Clnait Oourt at Philiwkl. Dliirt. The cne wa Minted three dtivs bv Charles f. Keller or New York, b. K LucJinand S. A. Pnr vuvtmn of rittburjch, for dtfndtntrt, and ;eor"e iiriH (f PniludulpMa, and Geov-o U. L'hrtbiy.uf .iUio.gb, fur putimift OPINION OF JUDGE GRIEK. rn I wrlUi with dtfflenlty I can only ptnto the con Chuoon ti which my mind has come uftur a cureiu x. ruination of this oaf o. t 1 Ton compl iln un bun exhibited a patent dated 'JlitU uf Aintl, 18ti5. Tbia Is prima fitcieevj tunc ol jrutw) title, nwi put ou tne rttflinmtlonta the bur tkuof proif that the pnttnt id to id or worthless. 1 nee J not repent my rumurks tn the case of linod Tvir vh. Day ('J Wall, C C lfob; SSll.) but uuw uOopt them aa alTbrdinar a rule oi decision which ap piIM dourly to tne present cue. As the iiifrimceinent of the patent U admitted, the oulv qnention will be fls to the valid. ty ot com jjKi:nu'i pfttent of At -il si.j, in&s. "Itwiwftftr sptvuhnlon hud been rudnced to Vracr lee," and alter repeated experiments, tlmt the tMHipluinant miRnitcdil in overcoat hi he urejudiee nml )Kiorunceuf ttie poopltf on ihei enbject, nnJ jtt'retiii'iinK the public tiirti his invention wui ucul; lifter he hud euUUHrthed it ttrettt u'.Uity and v.iliid, und "when his gt-uiu aid patient petvevenmce, in ejiito of aurer undscoil,-' were completely euc ctwVul, that Heed, who liadoefnre made experi meut n the simu snblect. nnd w.ts uii8uccf8tful, imtlned that he hid the best riu'ht to the invention, , n-d after purchasing one or more cooipUinantVcrr liiloe.. he auoUed on the it uf November, ISrVT, litir a p iMil for MtihstantfnUy tho naniH cotuhinv tiuii td' device; midn U' hine contained in complain unt's patent. On trm loth of the (ame month the e.p'niient,s formed themtjlv into a conip uiy or citrooralion called "The Heed Totpedo Company, for the purpose of pirating tho cumplaiimut's in YePtion, and tipp irtimr the expunae of lltiitiou, ard tim defraud him iff the trait-- They have pe.1 revered, eeu lter the pie ininary injunction Very '. properly ginuted hv the District Judu. Let l decree he entered fur complainant for a per pt'tuat :iijiKiction. and a Master apixduted 10 take au account aocurding to the prayer of the till. U. C. GlilK, Judge.' Kotk. The pasn!tgp referred to bv .?tid::o ?rier in htrt former dvcls'un, 3 Wallace, p. 91), uUupIed as lipp 1 cable to til if case wa as follows: "It ia uu-lly the cnsitywhtm any val jnblo dincuv. ery 1h wade, or any new machine of jrrMit uii it U Inveufed, tl:at theaHentlun of the pubi c htu bom In and to tint subject pruviomly, and th.it many pereoos hv beea making reaoiuohes atid expwrf ments. i'hihjy tptu ii and mechanicians may have in smite m asnrK anticipntt d iu tin-lr so cii'ation the pxlti.ity or pro i'iiulity of piuh discovery or inventiiiii; mimy experimei.ts have Ven uceejifiHl ly tiiwt. coailug veiy near, ytrt falling short ot the lie'lred result. Thy h ive produced uothiusr bfme ileal. The invent hin when perfected may "truly be ld to be the cuUuinmitur point ot ma'iv oxpeil ltim i, 114- o!y by tne invunror, but bv tnnny tth- utt. 1!m tn iv liH'- iii-nHritd iiiiltiwilu hv tl..-i iitun.-. reHfiil exneriiunnM and failtirpa of others, but it I irivei the-n no riuitt to ca-m n hure of th. hnw.r nf tepruhipf thfr riiiccesful inventor It. )? when !pe 'u!atkm h:ia bsen rue-d t. pr.ieiice,' wncn ex lriiui'ul !;a-renulted hi ii:B:oV( r Hiid when ti'ftt ci-covery ha Iwu perfected oypatitut aitarontin tied experitiuut4! wlioa some int.v compound. Mi t. Juamiiftctuie. or maiij.iiiH ha- b-n ihu- jrodttced , which U useful to thopiildc thr.T th'i party inakim: it Lertoraus a public b"U'Ut-tirmul uutliltdto a pa-ent- And yet wtieii een iu- and p.trhnt. prfpevernnei )av at feuth iiLTedi"l, i-i H.d'e of nt en au'l von'i, aiitiio v.'iltuble hivuntioii or (ils'ioory, how -'Idonvia t followei bv veu-md ! Knvy rob him v' if the honor, hiln.aiHfulabjrs, !w rd'ets, ond pi- r ites rob .him of tne prolki. J-Ivory iiiis-ncco.-siul fxpeilmtjuer wh'j did or did r did ).ot comp viry im.tr nuking- a din !ove "y now clnim It, J'.vcrv ona who can invent, au i:iiprovemout or vary its form,! elaiiurt a right to idra e tho original dlscjvory. We ntHj not iiiiiim.aJ-i A'oso, or lilanchaid- or Wood north to prove fiat UU ii the tuual history of eve ly irT"&. UiHcov"ry or inventton. 'i'he pre:nt crisTi aodi annt "er chapter to this Ions and uniform Ulatory." 2 Wailace, 0. C. lie pjiU p. 20 i. Iliepnblic U antioivd acaml emhvlnsr any til the recularl, otithori.ed Agi!iiU f tile t'omp.i- - ) ) . since tiie Hdiiert i'ateut cover the uho of t.'ie 'i orpedi and hxplosivti materials fir oil Wflls. nod the U' of sii- h muieriaU by other pftitlrw irt n i Vx'X infiinemeat of then rights. Any p-mh-s in I tniuji any of the lU)Ht!iT8 PATENTS will im t1MU wltlt acwniiuf to la-.v, and a. nctinrf willfully ftod Kuowtnuly iadeHuuceuI UiV and the decisions . i.i" the CoitiU TueCon.pmv havo re or2an!2"d thoir hitK!nnfw vita ft view to aucotnmoUa'o Oil Men tn every part .f tho Oil iieL'hm. 'ihev have ennttovtd the most sfiidcilt Avui and Assfrlat'ta tnit cm b:) proem ed itirihe biwine.-j- Kteh Torptido 1 labeled with duo af pitiait, t lpoiher witli tlm prlo of tho Tof p-d , and si-'ned by nil ollic r of the 'on.p iityf m vnry Opi-rator wifmiiu,' a Turptdo may know its price and whether It c tail from our olllc:t. 'pe.utor will cuiifer ft favor by reporting to this Office any ueu licence of AkciU!. The following named puraoin Inve born appoint ed Atceut.4 mid Asst-itaiit Aueuln for the Oil Koious of l'eaij(ilvia and Wedt Vl.gluiu IilST OF ACEXTS. T.TrsviM.K, cnrnciT run ani vrciM TV S'i'rll'HBN ..O.iK. orti, IImili.in, Citf-ir- hturo, addiVhd IKuuvlUu, ra AosUiuiitJt.hu Von ..fclC'IVO'-. Ttn'svii.i, onuitoit hun and viefxt- TV II. II 'fllOMAS. OUica and aJdiuan, Man. rion llo.uo. ' Itusxil a, Va. I MlAvtliliHtl AMU VICINITY CKOHOH I!;. TIM. Oilu'.u fill imlmr;:; rosldonra, Tltusvili-, 1'a An-'.a'aor. A A. We"'. K.N I'BHI'itl.iK t'LKASASTVJM.B, 11 KAN KA KM AN.i l'l'rilOi.j; w. (i&iy. VAN M.lhC. 0!H' nu t .tddi'oli. Cnino Uoi.ao, I'luaa uii'vtllf. Asi.!tant, 11. ('. Iltintlnut'iii. riDIUUl' AN I WBS'l' hUKOl.'Y CITAtt. r.UAKfC HtllOrt nnl o ulru..'Kxp o Ulllco. 'i'idl- ii'itH. I'a. Armani, r.. i: iicaninky. PKT.tlUiUAl ItKNIIIK A.MJ VICINITY lUvl 51.M.IN. Offlii.ninlaiMrei-n. Huiroh-tiiu Cou titf. A-wi'timt, Itl.arlRA lIlHcKI'ord. I'AKH ASU HlitOD KAK.MS and IHtrict.lvinff . a Oil 'r"k nod ''htTi'y Kim. from Story Kami to 1 iClinfwKville lA'ili.SSAITNnMiiS. ti-f.- jrr fc.iriu, I'u. Assi'tant . i,utli.:r B. k-aujidil's, C'h'irl" H. Oiwhfin mid t I'a n llovi MoiJLlf'WMlUVlM.U. OJL CI I Y AND U ( A. H. K V Si1. A liiois, Oil City or Kcno, Va Am airtM. N. Mono BitANiMN. ALONG TIIR AM.roMRNYT-IV wiLRKK t)lll-.:i! mdjiihlrin. Vrnnklln.l'a so'tnuu ass, vi)ri!t pa km ia.kk l.AMIi!.J lIOIIAItU W. HrSiiPlKLI). Mll-.e rtii a t't. ?n S -rubji'iuiH, 1'a A-iUUut, U. V l'or itirftjtd. il ldrcit Unl iutoi), Pa. '!' V I It ilNI A 1. I. ANORI.. and T. F fp'.'-'K vAd-v. I'ikernrtr. V ! t'irt'luH. uiaj-dly. TITUSVILLE ADVKRTIJiKMENT. $10, $10, $10 B17YS A HUYS A ooMsigS' CJcoklagStove i WITH FOCtt WITIIFOfK HOLES HOLES AND A ' AND A a a g e Uvon. o- e Oven. Call and we'll Show it , Call and we'll Sell it rat i;ex dullacss : A.t Ames'. Great Reduction ! IN stoves m mm, AT AMES. THE PEERLESS " IS STILL ' Witbcut Rival -... . in tun !tve Mrkt. nr-n.. hw rwl ..1 tli nrii-o ul tU ftwiritp 8'nvo tcu per cuu., liriui.-.Kjl wit!iiu t;ie timcu of ' VVo liav also on tuiwl tweu'j llfo riil.roi t varie ties Qt COOKING snovr.x, To'which wo invile ttie itttimtiim nf purc'iaxer unr pticu-. v 111 Iw fiiimJ luwur tlwn e.cr. .vcry8;ovi wjiraulfl. Call and "C ua octlS tl. At AES'. SAOTEKSOJJ'S WllOLKSALE Eiiqtapr Store llns beeu rfin"ved to No. ?0 Spring St, ASIEUICAX HOUSfi MaOVH. A I'L'LL ASiQCTMENT OF FINE and Lisa' will bb kpt and A contlnnancf of patronngo atug'.it tor. A s. infjrlallv! and luxurious Uas been fitted up in iear of th! store. wh(ro my funnrou;. fi!endn nod r a" ilntAi-ct-a aru cori'mlly IriMti'd to uend the'.!' leisure timu wltilo top.ins iu Titmvillc. UiiJU'iabcs- in t! American you vi!3 S i;ai3 i Tltmvlllo. fa .Oct. :9. 1870. tl PETROLEUM IRONWORKS i;ry:u, lilOii;.iu.tii ,V Co., SSSacSainists! trim asjd Rhiss Founili'rs. FOUGEu?, B'anitfactnri'rs of, H ULKR3, DRILLING MULLtV AND SASH TO'LS, SAW MILLS. I'U M PIS (i IMO.S, WALKING 1 ' HAM AND RAND WllKKL IKON-!, M,OWS. AND ALL KINDS OF CASTINGS. WHOLESALE i RETAIL DEALERS KI . FOR OIL WELLS, THuovi.le, Nov .8olh,lS69. tt M. S. SiJiJIONS C0t.UMN. SIM n 5 Goods Hons Washington-St. The r.aro-cst and Best Selected stock of Goods in Western Pennsylvania, and' sold at lall I THE PUEET .X of; &e., for Medicinal Purposes.' DRUGS, CHEMICALS, rCUS AND FIKST CLASS. faints, W tr and 13rus,ies. IMPOLITIC!) I Oil PT Vbefiauflt auortnion "vcr before oiTetel on Oil Orei-k. WALL PAPERS AND VIND3W SHADE LTDHti-pas'Hd for In-ari t y ami. nrljlnnlity Ui'bi0'us, c!ninpiit.'6 tttid liuraliliiiy. of 10US P!!!tS, THE CHOICEST BRANDS. ALL KINDS PRESCRIPTIONS ARE rUNCTTALLY COMPOUNDED AT ALL HOURS. ttT ICE COOL SODA WATER FRESH FROM TIIE FOUNTAIN, At SI5IIO.S'. I IT" Q vu mt a call sirs"." Enametiitlng lew of tho urtielei to t J..UI.J ut L. M. BTEBKBURffS Wft$liiitrtn-v&! Pctreleum K -litre, Til. FrlsncU Bint iiatroii1", on onJall. Ymir utiuutlon tu my 'bin'' 1 o.i!J ciilli Tim' nro .lull mi mom y ttu' t. Hut tu Ihiae Uiucn I'm lookiuK for light; TV llico who are lmllulni! rlan without nnnsbcr, I woald iufunu ilili l tl.o placato buy Lumber; My motto Utti!: 'Q ilcU M!i and innll 'roOt," For bilf iuiss 1 hnltl:y i.nu I tl.iiili much of U; tn q Rll'y n-v I nmhiT ! cmnd to uonj, Al1 as for blr.;.b f , I k-p No- 1 i Somp mny not 1o. k nt It in thn Hirht 1 fin, And for . osu 1 linvo ft nun'lty No. S; And to two w! n nr.- yaitli'u'iir j mmc nmy be, I slill liuvuhiiut'j.r qim.il cllul No I hive 'oM si n.onod I.uniV.er. Prwstd up ulue, Which I w.'il U uia low cash pile-, Such tn M k'ri:. I. iii!ni n'l Siding, ooih lloi p. ontl PrfMiod, Lath, ll.itt. l.a und Surf-nod I.unihir, r.11 of tl b.s:; I iilso hnvo 1!1 t.'ii)ibr of all kln(J, At piiccs u c.uuoaro with oil m:d luird tluie ; Uir.ls of TtmtHT knot cvti.tty on hud. And a box of C'lgtr of a very good bnind; y fAi-Uitii'H for'il lr? arc si:rr'v without mimhcr I a'iw;iv ke i jrod to-tins to diliv,:r g'iod Lunibtir; o if yrai want Lumber, I'.ouh, .Drjiieeu, Soft or Itird, cti wit! iii.dj:i.H w'.ir.t you wur at L. M b's Lntu Lor Va d. t,;!.ll;f Cassia sj In l?wnt f P.hIs Jtttcst Vrlt'sraiai of -rrn ihe r.i.ifrt,a r & FULLER t $J W in, have a large sioc: uf 'o. nn i't.i)1' ie mm f- of wovrv (r f,ii' hot-1, t!.r fvimiot fii 1 to pVug . ',-jr h?i it"v it" ' Kt lull, r.0 ct ctnt. iuvv. r H un till t ':r CLi-turtt l'pnrf nnt U vinldt-rl nv r 1 y fl f r. hi.-S IlllT'.HIlif , ""AliO lif ll'lrMirt 1 f : T li. U'ii L;y tun one.) a.iit ou a re uir CLton wi.-s. WW (J U At tKTI!OIiFfI (!K.TBK. POITEK & CU., Iknleiulu 5issl)iii'g i AU '. ofth" trlotrutKl TITTST 'N fAN- Tli KAC'iTi" if) 1 1,, tho hi-tln imirki'i ""Uftantly n liuud and for su'e l.y tho ton or cm load. OM'ICE AND YARD NEXT EAST OF STEKNRl'RG & CO S LUMI1ER YARD. I'OTTKH tCO., C0RRY, PA.. U'holnn1o rii'iilfrr nnd Mi toner of ntl khul Anthracit' 'il. J)' mIcih fiiplii J 11. any o.uiinU ty at fl.oi-t uouco Jo. t)U tnutt ru in Kti i-k O. t,. MVIS y;'lit. Pokroluum Ct-ntic, Pa., P. 0. Box !M!J. octK.-tf. ' E'JSiSKEt & SEHE3AL hlACliiHiSiS 1,1 d Uunlcra Iu till kindh ol WE1j!J'OOLS As I'lX't Nefosf-nry icr puttluu down and optr:.to ' vVoil. In ciinno.-lion vviih our iMAC'ltlc ' i wi- have u liirc-i! and wiiivonii-nt BLACKSMITH SHOP. 1 'Mirfarilltli'forVANrti-frnjItlNt!nri t.oi i Cl'llui by any fciiop lu Ihu Oil ltt'i;iooii. .S'jop niaj'JT 3I-jtii-st,o)j)os;i! 3'r.Cliiitiu b '.' l'lsilllti SNOll'tio 'Li., WINSOIl BUGS. C()I.CMN.: W8SO: BeOS., STORE. ESTABLISHED "Winsor J3ros3 MAIM STUEET, PSTUOIXl! I'CALKHS IN OIL, WELLj TbBINB AND CASING ! ALSO,' woRXivr, HA::ni:i,s & vves, STL'M'INT, HOXKS, CLAM '.-?, TOSC.H, INNH SU'iiKlJ RODS, KIVF.Tl'.l) JOINT Sl'CKnsnOD BOII.KIt lLill'f, CISTEKN t WKLL Pflirj, Every Description o nuiiplln for OIL REFINERIES. POOL'S, STEAM & GAS FITTINGS MELTING. PACKING AND IK);:;' KUtllY COMPRESSED IXN'fiS, X-Jl Tl 3D W ARE, IIoiiio TritntniiiR", Cur"'nlf re' Tool', DtillitiK und Plain I.tiltl Kii, Oiiknm, Nails. Ax-n. . Tft'oloanai'oc!i''t Cutlerj, A fall nftortiuiul of cwythlss In the UarJwM Liua. AND Topiiiiir Gloi"r HOME COMPANION. IRON GATE, amlj WHEAT Fill---' ote. Stoves. Linsv I-ntoriis A CMmW'i v 1 Winter fclii"'d liiirdOilt .Vi. 1 ISEFINEW OH'-; ( JI A5! VU)S CLOTHES WBlW- Jlnuufacturtr of COffiJ .TIN. sheet ircn ware: ISMOKfc STACKS . ..., foil" ... .. .. nnr run IN'" ,, ,i ;,:,..i,iih,,o,.iith.ciin."" REPAIR ShOP T!M AND friend-, for n the imt. vv.-ihulinscow. Dtw jilil'" ID contlnuanoc. r 7 .
Significant historical Pennsylvania newspapers