fft&&r ' r. r f - w 'vt " A. - - !f 1 If.? tT 1 tibune. tmnton THE ONLY SCRANTON PAPER RECEIVING THE COMPLETE NEWS SERVICE OF THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, THE GREATEST NEWS AGENCY IN THE WORLD. SCRANTON, PA., THURSDAY MORNING, NOVEMBER 20, 1902. TEN PAGES TWO CENTS. TWO CENTS. TEN RAGES lamS iSSSKBfiStHNi5?IBEi viSiffliSMS.'SB - A. W Li"S)flBWBMj&gggjbqSl8B MEMPHIS WELCOMES Enthusiasm at the Festivities Cele brating the Home-Gomina o! General Luke E. Wright. ROOSEVELT'S TRIBUTE TO GENERAL WRIGHT The Piesideut Attends Two Recep tions and a Banquet Given in Hon or of the Hcturned Vico-Qovevnor of the Philippines and Makes Ad dresses on Each Occasion The Enthusiasm of the Colored Popula tion Unbounded The Hcception Tendered Both the President and General Wright Was Remarkable for Exuberance and Good Nature. The Banquet. y Exclushc Wile from The Af'oci.m'il l'rrs. Memphis Trim., Nov. 1!. Although the festivities today celebrated the home coming (if General Luke. E. Wright , It is no reflection on thn warmth of the welcome extended to him to say that President Roosevelt's presence was the overshadowing feature of thc day. Ex cursion trains wvre run into the city, and ii. number of distinguished people were present to participate in thn cele bration. Among thorn were Governor Ronton McMillan and General Joseph "Wheeler. Tho programme was a. long one. Immediately after the president's arrival, there wan a parade through the streets Jo tho Gnyoso hotel, where a. breakfast was tendered the president and General Wright jointly by the ladles of Memphis. In tho afternoon the president attended and spoke at two receptions given in honor of Gen eral Wright, one at the Auditorium by whtto citizens, the other at a. hull in tho black section of the city by the colored people. Later therr was a col onial dames' tea at tho Gayoso and the festivities closed tonight with an elab orate banquet, at which the president delivered a speech. Including some brief remarks at breakfast, the presi dent spoke four times during the. day. Altogether it was a splendUl tribute to the affection and esteem in which Gen oral Wright Is held at home. That Mrs. Wright Is also exceedingly popular was made apparent by tho applause which greeted every reference to her. This was especially marked at the Audi torium, when tho president referred to the fact that his mother's brother served in the Confederate navy under her fattier, who was Admiral Semmos. Mayor Williams and Governor Mc Millan made addresses of welcome, and the audience was very enthusiastic when General Wright delivered his re sponse. He was greatly touched by tho compliment .liaid him by the presi dent's presence, and with the demon stration in his lionor. General Wright did not go deeply Jnto tho situation in tho Philippines in his remarks, but he emphasized tho fact, that the administration of the is lands, under both Presidents McKinley and Roosevelt had been of an absolute ly non-partisan character. President Roosevelt had not intended to speak at this reception, but in response to the insistence of. the assemblage, he ad dressed them briefly. Reception by Colored People. Tho reception tendered by tho col ored people was truly remarkable. Gen eral Wright earned their undying grati tude during the two yellow fever epi demics, twenty years ago, by remain ing hero when most of the whites had ,11 cd and seeing that tho sick were enre.d for. Tho hall was packed, galleries and pit, to he point of suffocation, and the whole spirit of the proceedings fu'oathcrt admiration of their friend. General Wright, In addressing the colored audience, talked chlolly of their future, telling them of tho illflleult problems before them. He said that It would perhaps have been better for both races had the change from slavery to citizenship not come so suddenly. Tho president's reception beggars de scription. The colored people became almost frantic, jumping up and down in their enthusiasm, and yelling them-, wives hoarse. Tho president's address to them gave the negroes tho highest degree of pleasure. At tho conclusion of tho president's speech, tho entire audience united in singing "Hod Ho With You Till AVe Meet Again." There were 200 guests nt the ban quet, tho uttendanco being limited to that number. Governor Longluo, of Mississippi, traveled from Jackson, Miss., to be present. Tho toasts were as follows: "Wel come," by the toastmastcrj "Response," by General Wright; "Our country," President Roosevelt; "Tho consent of tho governed," Judge Turton; "Tho Presidency," Alexander Cochrane, The President's Address, President Roosevelt said; It Is u real uml great pleasure to come to this typical city of tho Southern Mis sissippi vulley, in order to greet a typi cal American, a citizen of Tennessee, who deserves honor not only from his ttate, but from the entlro country Gen eral Luko i:. Wright. Wo have a right to expect it high standard of manhood from Tonessoe. It was ono of the llrst two states created west of tho Allegheny mountains, and It was In this stato that tho llrst self-governing community of American freemen was established upon water tlowlng Into the Gulf. Tho plo. neors of Tennossee wero among tho ear lest In that great westward march which hrust tho nation's border across tho con tinent to tho Pacific, and It Is eminently Utlng that a sou of Tennessee should tvw play so prominent a part la tho THE PRESIDMT lfyA. f . VSf. . . ft,,., tint. im.ft,,..Ht rf ftvnntlulnti ' 'nnil tho l'nclflc. There have been prvHiits or tho United Slates for but mv $n drcd und thirteen years, nnd durll 'x teon of those. yours Tennesseeans . '-n the whlto house. Hardihood and iVy i, and Iron resolution are of rlcht t".-- expected among tho sons of a i',';) which nurtured Andrew Jackson ana , ; Houston: which sent Into tho America' navy one of the most famous lighting 1 mlrais or nil time, Ftirnrgut. ,. There Is another reason why our coun try should be glad that. It was General Wright who rendered this service. Gen eral Wright fought with dUtlngulshed gallantry among tho gallant men who Served In tho armies of. the Confederacy (luring tho Civil war. Wo need 110 proof of the completeness of our reunion 11s a people. When the war with Spuln came, tho sons of tho mo.n who wore tho blue and the sons of tho men who wore the gray vied with one another in the effort to get Into the ranks and face a foreign foo under the old flag that, had been carried In triumph under Wlnlleld Scott and Zachary Taylor and Andrew Jackson. Tt was my own good fortune tu serve under that fearless lighter, old Joo Wheeler, a memory of which I shall always he proud, But If wo needed any proof of the unity of out- Interests. It would havo been afforded this very year by General Wright, tho ex-C'onfedcrato. In Iris administration ns acting governor of tho Philippine Islands. Upon him. during the months of summer rested a heavier burd"ii of responsibility than upon any other public servant nt that particular time: nnd not the least of his titles tu our regard is Ihn way in which ho was able to work on terms of cordial good-will with the head of the army, himself a m.in who had honored the blue uniform as Wright bad honored the gray. His Work Difficult. General Wrlcht's work has been as dif ficult as It was important. The events of the last four years have definitely decided that whether wo wish to or not, we must hereafter play a- great part In tho world. We cannot escape, facing tho duties. We may shirk them If wo arc built of poor stuff, or we may lake hold and do them if we a.re lit. sons of our sires but face them we must, whether wo will or not. Our duty In the Philip pine. M.inds lias simply been one of the duties that thus have cotne upou us. Wo are there, and wo run no morn haul down our flag and abandon the islands than we could now abandon Alaska. Whether we are glad or sorry that events forced us to go there Is aside from tho question; the point Is that, as tho Inevit able result of the war with Spain, we found ourselves in tho Philippines, and that wo could not leave thn Islands with out discredit. Tho Islanders were wholly unfit to govern themselves, nnd if we had left thorn would havn been n brief period of bloody chaos, and then some other nation would have stopped In to do tho work which we had shirked. It can not bo too often repented that there was no question that tho work had to bo done. All the question was. whether wo would do it well or ill: and, thank to tho choice of men like Governor Wrlfiht, It has been done well. Tho llrst and absolutely indespensahlo requisite Was order peace. The reign of lawless violence, of resistance to legitimate au thodity, tho reign of anarchy, could no more be tolerated abroad than It could bo tolerated bore In our own land. Flag Stands for Orderly Liberty. Tho American flag stands for orderly llliertv. and it stands for It abroad as it stands for it at home, Thn task of our soMii rs was to restoro and maintain or der in tho islands. The army had tho task to do, and It did it well nnd thor oughly. Tho fullest and heartiest praise belongs to our soldiers who in the Philip pines brought to n triumphant conclusion a war, small Indeed compared to tho gigantic struggle In which the older men whom I am addressing took part In the early sixties, but inconceivably harassing and illflleult, because It was waged mld tho pathless jungles of great tropic Is- Continued on Pago 10. ALLEGED PLOT TO KILL PRESIDENT Chief Wilkie, of the Secret Service, Places Little Confidence in Story of Mrs. Doxheimer. By Inclusive Wire from The Associated Press. Washington. Nov. 10. Chief Wllkio, of tlu United States secret service, in speak .ng today of Mrs. Lena Doxhcim nr's story of a plot to kill President Roosevelt, said that a searching inves tigation by operatives of the secret service proved conclusively that she was mistaken as to the facts. Chief Wllkle Is convinced that there has been no plot against the life of tho president, such as Mrs, Doxheimer de scribes. Ho believes, however, that sho Is an honest woman and sincere in her beliefs. Now York, Nov. 10. A search today of the records of the coroner's oillce, and inquiry of tho police of this city, failed to discover any knowledge of the suicides of a man named Mueller and a Mrs. Sehrocder, who, according to the disclosure of Mrs. Lena Doxheimer, of'Hoboken, killed themselves as a re lease from an unwilling anarchistic bargain to assassinate President Roose velt, Mrs. Doxheimer was III In bed today, her husband said, aa a result of tho excitement attending her disclos ures. She could not lie interrogated to. day as to the apparent errors In Iter statement, Mr. Doxheimer snid tho police had given orders that sho should not be questlonad. Steamship Arrivals. By itoliblvn Wire from 'flic Associated hen. New York. Nov. 19, Arrived: Oevlc, Liverpool; Friedcrich Der Grosse, Uio men; Amsterdam, Rotterdam; Majestic, Liverpool and Qucenstown. Cleared: La Touralne, Havre. Sailed: DouUchkiud, Hamburg; Oceanic, Liverpool, Arrived; Patrlclu, New York, ut Plymouth; Geor gia, New York, at Liverpool. Sailed: Cel tic, Now York via Queenstown. Passed: St. Louis. New York for Southampton; La Lorrulnse, Now York for Havre Rot. tcrdnm Rrrivcd; Noordam, New York via Boulogne Cherbourg Sailed: KaUor Wilhelm Der Grosso (from Bremen und Southampton), Now York. Qucenstown Arrived: Teutonic, New York for Liver pool. Dover Sailed: Kensington, Now York for Antwerp BIG PIRE IN PERSIA. Two Hundred Persons Perish in the Town of Hesht Fifteen Hundred Houses Are Also Wiped Out. Dy r..xchistc Wire from The AisoclJlctl I'rcM. London, Nov. 'JO. Tho St. Petersburg correspondent of tho Dally Mull tele graphs Unit a lire, lasting three days, has destroyed tho town of Resht, In Persia. Fifteen hundred houses nnd many warehouses wore wiped out, and 200 persons perished. The town of Resht. situated fourteen miles from Its port of Knzcllln, on the Ciwnlnn Ron. lines n nnYilllntlnn ostl- mated nt 2,000 to 30,000. It is theiuiir- Jcot for raw silks nnd cocoons, and has a oig import onu export irnun wun Russia. Tho city was almost depopu lated by the plague In 1S30. CASTRO CROWDING THE REV0L0TI0NISTS Will Prevent the Rebels from Recov ering from" the Effects of Their Dissensions. By Kxi'hi'hc Wire Irom The Aociati'd l'rc. Wllllamstnd, Island of Curacoa, Nov. 10. President Castro, of Venezuela, is energetically pushing operations to pre vent the revolutionists in that republic from recovering from the effects of their dissensions nnd tho Might of Gen eral Malos. Ono of the objects of JIu tos' departure, It Is said, is to make an attempt, to induce tho Colombian gov ernment, which Is notoriously unfriend ly to President Castro, to scud arms and ammunition to his men. Mntos also re lics on his wealthy friends In this isl and, with whom he Is conferring though sick. These persons have al ready contributed money in support of tho Venezuelan rovolutlon, but under tho belief that President Castro would flee from the country. Consequently, inadequate preparations were made, and hence tho present condition of the revo lutionists. Matos' future plans arc kept secret. Though his estates in Venezuela, have been confiscated, he still has money and can, if ho so chooses, continue the con test either personally or through Gen erals Rolando and Luciano Mcndoza, who arc still In the field. Tho general opinion In well informed circles, how ever. Is that Matos' aspirations to the presidency of Venezuela are absolutely ended. HART GIVES O'BRIEN A HARD PIGHT Six Lively Rounds Sparred at Phila delphiaQuaker City Pet Hissed by His Home Admirers. By rJxchiir Wile from Tho Asjod.neil Pip.-.-. Philadelphia, Nov. If). Marvin Hart, of Louisville, tonight gave Philadelphia Jack O'Brien one of the hardest tights of his career at the Ptmn Art Athletic, club. The men sparred six rounds nnd O'Brien's showing in the last round disappointed his friends. In the first three rounds tho bout, was all O'Brien, who also hud the fourth round by a shade. Beginning with the fifth, the bout was clearly Hart's. The Ken tuckian rushed in without paying the slightest regard to Jack's jabs. In a clinch toward the end of the round, Hart was wrestled to the floor and ho took the limit. As soon as ho re gained his feet, however, he wont after O'Brien nnd landed two hard blows on tho hitter's body, with telling effect. In the sixth round, Hart started to rush things, but in his over-anxiety, he swung wildly. O'Brien could not withstand his boring tactics, and lost bis guard just for an Instant, when Hart landed a short right-hander on tho jaw. O'Brien went down, and, af ter struggling to his feet began hug ging. Hart swung both right and left around O'Brien's body. Thesu punches evidently hurt O'Brien, who slipped twice. The house Was in an uproar, and for the first time O'Brien was hissed by his home admirers. Hart himself was showing tho effects of his hard work, and though he hit O'Brien often about tho body and sent his head back with straight lefts on sev eral occasions, ho could not get In the punch that would have secured for him the verdict. A LITTLE CHILD BURNED TO DEATH Daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Thomns Miller, of Mayfleld, Cremated Alive This Morning. Special to the Scranlon Tribune. Mnylleld,' Nov. 20. Tho littlo (i.year old daughter oc Mr, and Mrs. Thomas Miller, of Mnylleld, was burned to death, in a fire which early this morn ing destroyed a double dwelling which they occupied. Tho dwelling Is located near tho Delaware und Hudson station and was occupied by tho Miller family und by Patrick McDonald and family. The blusso broke out shortly after 1 o'clock und the Millers were aroused from their slumbers by the smell of smoke. There wero four children and it wits thought nt llrst that all got out safely, but it wun discovered a few minutes Inter that tho little girl was missing, The grief of the frantic, parents when they learned this was pathetic in tho ex. treme. The dwelling was completely con sinned by the llames. Superintendent Hutchinson Resigns. By Inclusive Who from The Associated J'ress, Pittsburg, Nov. 19. Superintendent Hutchinson, of the Pittsburg division of tha Baltimoro und Ohio, today tendered his resignation to bo offcctlvo Dccomber 1. Mr. Hutchinson has accepted tho posi tion of assistant general superintendent of tho Michigan Central railroad with headquarters at Detroit. WILL FAVOR MR.G0MPERS Snertal Committee Will Exoner ate President of the American Federation of Labor. SENSATION WILL WIND UP IN SMOKE Tho Subject of Autonomy of Trades Councils Taken Up and Floods of Oratory Are Poured Out A Strug gle Between the Branches of the Carpenters' Unions The Faction of tho Convention Opposed to tho Re-election of President Gompers Is Unable to Fix Upon a Rival Candidate. By llirhuhe Wire from The Associ.iti-il 1'reM, New Orleans, La., Nov. 19. The spe cial committee appointed to consider tho charges made by President Shaf fer, of the Amalgamated Association of Iron, Steel am Tin Workers, against president Gompers, of tho American Federation of Labor, will report to morrow, probably in the afternoon. As an investigation it will terminate) in the exoneration of President Gompers, nnd as a sensation It will probably wind up In tho wet firecracker clash. Mr. Shaf fer has not. only failed to substantiate his churges, but a member of the com mittee Is authority for the statement that bo lias never made any, to that body at least. Ho bus appeared before tho committee, and when he came away declared he had presented his charges. Tho committee says he. did not formu late them. In the absence of direct ac cusations there can be but ono result. The subject of autonomy of trades councils was taken up today. Floods of oratory were poured out. but nothing was settled definitely. The principal fight today was in the old struggle be tween tho United Brotherhood of Car penters and Joiners and the Amalga mated Association of Carpenters. The former organization asked for the revo cation of tho charter of the latter be cause of the practices contrary to tho interests of trades union movement, its avowed object being to force the other organization into Its own ranks. After several hours of debate, the matter was referred to a committee, of cloven, five from each organization, and an umpire to bo selected. Tho commission will meet before March 1, 190H. and endeavor to bring about an amalgamation of the two or ganizations. No promise was made, however, by either organization that the aamlgamatlnn will be made. All hos tilities arc to cease pending the meet ing of tho commission. The applica tion of the Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners for the revocation of the charter of the Amalgamated Wood workers was then taken up. The fight was on grounds similar to those in dispute between tho United Brotherhood and the Am algamated Carpenters. After an ex tended debate the matter was laid over until 10 o'clock tomorrow. It is likely that an agreement will be reached sim ilar to that in the first case. Address by Mayor Schraitz. During the afternoon Mayor Schmltz, of San Francisco, addressed the con vention. A contest between delegates of tho International Typographical union and delegates of the Allied Trades over the ownership of the Allied Print ing Trades label has been withdrawn from the convention. All parties have agieed to a joint meeting of three delegates from each body, to be held in January, at which an agreement will be formed, the basis of which will be representation in ac cordance with numerical strength in the local Allied Printing Trades councils and the formation of a Supremo Coun cil, composed of two representatives of the International Typographical union and ono each from the Printing Press men's National union and the Book binder's National union, to which all local unions can appeal and whoso de cision Is to bo final. The faction in tho convention which Is opposed to the re-election of Presi dent Gompers as yet has been unable to fix upon a rival candidate. Vice President James Duncan has refused to commit himself In either Instance and Jnmes M. Lynch of the Typographical union is now spoken of as a cundldate. DEATHS OF A DAY. Py i:cliishe Whe from Tho Associated l're.. Yankton, S. D Nov. 19. Mrs. H. N. Davis, mother of tho lato Senator Citsh muri K. Davis, of Minnesota, died hero today at tho homo of her sou-ln-law. Judge Bartlett Tripp. Mrs. Davis had been very weak for some time on account of old' ace, Beading, Pn., Nov, 19. Rev, Father An thony Nuthe, pastor of tho Cathollo church at llally, this county, died today, aged 58. Ho was formerly located In Ashlnnd and Philadelphia. New York, Nov. 19.-Tho Marqulso Do Chambrun died yesterday, Shu v,ns the last graud-daughtur of Lafnyetto mid her llfo was notahlu for her constancy In maintaining tho family's cordial feeling for America, Her oldest sou, the Mnr (lulu Do Chambrun, who is a member of tho chamber of deputies, becomes tho ranking representative of the Lafayette family, He was formerly counsellor of tho Fronch embassy nt Washington and married a daughter of Mis. Bellamy Storer. Tho second son of tho deceased Marquise also lias an American wifo. Her third son represented tho Lafayette family at tho recent Bochnmbeau exer cises ut Washington and her only daugti. tcr Is the wife of tho Count Savorgnan de lirazza, tho explorer of tho Congo. Traction Men Receive Increase. Jly Kxclibira' Wire from The ismefated l'rcs. Reading, Nov. 19. Tho United Traction company today Increased its motormen and conductors from 10 2-3 cents to JIJJ cents an hour. BANDITS ROB GAMBLERS. Nearly Two Thousand Dollars Se cured from a Don In Columbia Heights, Minneapolis. Hy Kxelmhc Who Irom Tho Associated 1'im. Minneapolis, Nov. 19. In a fashion reminiscent of the Jnmcs-Yoitnger op erations, two bandits held up a gamb ling den nt Colombia. Heights, a suburb early tonight, and secured $1,943 from the owner of the place and in Irons, meanwhile seriously wounding Harvey Howard, the colored porter. While the bandit lender kept ,tho players nnd attendants covered with Ills revolver, his assistant riddled pock ets and tills. Ingram Flick, treasurer of tho resort, yielded $1,568, and tho manager $165. Patrons of the place were relieved of sums ranging from $10 to $10. N PRESIDENT WALTER TENDERS RESIGNATION Disagreement with Directors Causes the Head Official of tho Lehigh Valley to Stop Out. By tlKchislvr Wire from TIic Associated I'icp. Philadelphia, Nov. 19. President Al fred Walter, or tho Lehigh Valley rail road, today tendered his resignation to tho board of directors at tho regular monthly meeting or that body, to take effect November 30. Tho resignation was accepted. Tho only explanation of President Walter's action that could be obtained from the directors was that differences of opinion existed between tho president, and directors regarding the management of the company's af fairs. Mr. Walter left this city for New York Immediately after presenting his resignation. At the railway station ho was rjuestioned as to the causes which led to his retirement, hut he declined to make any statement, for publication. It Is said President Walter's action wan a surprise to most o'f the directors, only a few of them having any previous knowledge of his Intention. The annual meeting will bo held January 30. In railroad and tinanclal circles, the present financial policy of the Lehigh Valley company ,1s believed to bo the causa of the "difference" said to exist. President Walter, in bis last annual re port for the fiscal year ending June 30. 1902, recently published, announced that it would be necessary to adopt some fi nancial plan by which funds might bo secured from other sources than from thn net earnings of the company to meet the operating expenses, which Jiave frequently been so great as to it suit 111 a ueuciL insteau ot a prout. it is believed tho president's suggestions did not meet tho approval of the man agement. , Rumors have been current that an issue of $1,000,000 of collateral trust bonds under the mortgages ' of 1897 had been considered, but It could not be learned whether such action was 'taken at today's meeting of tho directors. Tho mortgage plan pro vides for the issuance of $10,000,000 of bonds, $7,000,000 to bo Issued at the rote of not more than S1.O00.00Q In any cal endar year, commencing with 1900. The recent attack upon President Walter and the management by A. 13. Cottier, a large New York stockholder, is be lieved here to have had no bearing on President Walter's retirement, as Mr. Walter is said to have been in accord w 1th Mr. Cottier's views. Mr. Walter was elected president of the Lehigh Valley railroad In 1S97, suc ceeding 13. P. Wilbur. He was regard ed as the choice of the Drexel-Morgau Interests, which a short time previous ly had become the dominating factors in the affairs of the company. Mr. Walter has had a wide railroad experience, dating from 1S72. Ho was at various times connected with the Pennsylvania railroad, tho Northern Central, tho Baltimoro and Potomac, the Baltimoro and Ohio nnd the New York, Lake Erie and Western. POUR MEN ARRESTED FOR EXTORTION They Are Charged with Sending Let ters Purporting to Have Been Written by Anarchists. by r.xclusivc Wiie from The Associated l'ice. New York, Nov, 19. Four men were arrested In Hoboken, N. J., today on a charge of complicity In an attempt to extort money from Cappel Rubens and O. K. Van Ojen, both wholesale grocers of Jersey City, who had tecolved through the mall letters purporting to have been written by anarchists de manding money and making threats. Tho arrests wero brought about by a decoy registered letter, addressed by the police to D, Strobe, at tho Jersey City postofllce, In accordance with a demand iu one of tho threatening let ters. When a young man called for the letter today, delivery was refused with out nn identification, and he was fol lowed by dateotlves from the jiostolllce to the nearest ferry, where ho met three other men, when all weru arrst d. The man who called for the letter said that he was Bartho strobe), son of a police oftlciul of Hamburg Ger many, and that since Ills return two weeks ago from a visit to that city, ho had been living In New York. He de nied all acquaintance with the other prisoners, who gave tho names of Jacob GunbetB, Fred Becker and Fritz Seeber and said that they had come from Now York to Hoboken to look for a chance to work their passage to Germany In a cattle ship, Oberlln's New President. By Ksclushe Wire fioni TIic Associated hci. Oberlln.O., Nov, 19 At tho annual meet Ing of trustees of Oherlln college today Dr. Henry Churchill King was elected to tho presidency or that 'institution to sue ceod tho lato Dr. John Henry Harrows. Dr. King was born' in Hillside, Mich., In 1S5S. Most of his college experience has been connected with the Institution of which ho Is now president. . Dr. King Is an author and lecturer of note. BURNS BRINGS UP A NEW COMPLICATION Almost Precipitates What May Yet Be the Most Interesting Inci dent of the Hearings. COMMISSION AVOIDS THE ISSUES Every One Proceeding as if It Was to Be Taken for Granted That the Question of the Recognition of the Union Was' Before the Commission-Non-strikers and Non union Men No Separate Organization. . After being on the witness stand for nearly five days before the strike com mission, answering the questions ot ten lawyers and the seven commissioners, John Mitchell, the miners' representa tive, was relieved at noon, yesterday, und tho examination of the second wit ness for the miners' side, Rev. Petor Roberts. Ph. D., was begun. Mr. Mitchell might have been under fire for several days more had not. the commission come to his rescue. Not less than half a. dozen times Tuesday nnd yesterday morning. Chairman Gray intimated very strongly to tho cross rxiimliiors that the commission was quite satisfied! that it. had gained from tho witness about all the information they could bring out from him that would lie- of use in the Investigation in hand, and that unless there was some thing new to suggest as a line of exam ination, it would he well to end the dis cussion of generalities and proceed to got at tho specific and detailed informa tion that might come from the anthra cite minors themselves. This had the effect of abbreviating the cross-examinations. Mr. AVolvcrton, who represents the reading company, finished with the wltness in about fivo minutes. As Mr. Mitchell was leaving the stand Chairman Gray thanked him cordially In the name of the commission for his assistance. Dr. Roberts on the Stand. Rev. Dr. Huberts, the second witness, is pastor of the Congregational church in Mnhonoy City, and formerly pastor of the Plymouth Congregational church, West Scranton, and the Olyphant Con gregational church. He eamo into the hearing mainly through his authorship of a book on the anthracite region, pub lished in 1901. For the past three weeks ho has been at the Mine Workers' head quarters In Wilkos-Barre. assisting in the preparation of the miners' case. "O, that mine enemy would write a book!" was brought forcibly to mind by Mr. Wolvorton's cross-examination of Dr. Roberts. The attorney hud care fullv l-ead tho doctor's work and noted 'numerous statements corroborative of the operators' contentions. These wero read to the witness to the accompani ment of enquiries us to whether or not he believed them to be true. The au thor, of course, had to admit his belief In their truth. Mr. Wolverton took es pecial pains to have the witness atllrin a passage rather severely criticizing Kngllsh-speaklng minors for refusing, through Indolence, to work more than live hours a day. A difficulty, of no mean proportions, with which the commission will liave.to contend, was brought up by Ira II, Burns, of this city, one of the counsel for the independent operators. It Is tho jurisdiction of tho commis sion, under tho terms of the proposition under which it was created, to decree whether or not an agreement shall be made with the minors' union. Tho com panies' offer explicitly provided that tho agreement .should ho between thorn nnd their own employes, and In their answers to the Mitchell statement, one and all declared "this subject was ex cluded from consideration by tho terms of tho submission under which tho com mission wns appointed." to uso the words of one of the answers.' Principal Reason, Tho principal reason assigned by the operators for their refusal to have any dealings with tho United Mine Work ers Is that the organization ,is made up principally of bituminous men. In the uns.wer of tho Reading company, Presi dent llaor, In a sort of aside, says if Uio ituthraclto miners would form a union of their own, his company would take up tho matter ot making a work ing agreement with It. In answer to a question by Attorney Wolvprton, of the Reading, yesterday, President .Mitchell declared cmphutlcjilly that a separate anthracite union was neither desirable nor possible, Despite this situation, Uio half of President Mitchell's opening address to tho commission dealt with the wisdom and expediency of tho United Mine Workers being recognized, and the major part of tho efforts ot tho oper ators' attorneys during tho past live days has been to show the contrary in this respect, Since tho hearltiHS began live duys ago, no 11110 has either claimed or de nied directly, or by other Inference than mentioned above, that tho ques. tion of recognition is before tho com. mission. Yesterday, however, Mr. Burns, whoso ollents, tho independent oper ators, did not declare iu their answer that tho question of recognition was or was not before the commission, pro ceeded to a discussion with tho com inlssloucrs of tho right of employers to retain men who worked during the strike, nnd to hlro non-union men in the future, providing' the commission grants the fourth demand of the miners that tho union be recognized. Judge Gray consulted tho other com missioners for a time, nnd then an nounced that according to tho com missioners' reading of the submission agreement, the "non-striking" miners wero not to bo displaced. Ho madn some other comments, but religiously avoided saying anything that would In dicate how the commissioners view thia delicate question of their jurisdiction. Did Not Press Them. Mr. Hums did not press tho commis sion for a specific, expression of their position on the really momentous ques tion but turned aside to a discussion of the contingent question of how th non-union man was to bo dealt with "if an agreement" was made. Mr. Mitchell was brought into the discussion by a question from Mr. Burns as to what vested or other right. If any, a miner had in his "job." Mr. Mitchell said tho miner legally had no claim on his job, but morally ho had a right to bo given back his place, after the strike was over, considering the manner iu which It was ended. Chairman Gray suggested that as the operators' proposition contained a con dition precedent that the "men shouhT return to work immediately," it was to be gathered that they should have work to go back to. Later, the chair man took occasion to qualify this by saying- tho non-union men were not to be displaced. Mr. Mitchell dented that tho union was demanding that any non-union, or non-striking men should be discharged. Tho companies should, If It wants to provide for them, move them Into tho places deserted by the thousands ot men who left the region and do not proposo to come back. Then the old men could have their old places. vThat the commissioners were some what impressed with the listof strike "violences" and have come to the con clusion that, even now, tho non-union man Is none too secure in his "life lib erty and pursuit of happiness" Is to. be Inferred from Fomo apprehensions iter ated and reiterated by Chairman Gray, when he announced that tho commis sioners could not comply with tho re quest of Attorneys Lenahan and O'Bri en that the names of their clients, sonic 2,000 non-unionists, be not made public. Some of the Eemarks. Some of his remarks were: "I take it the use of the best of names will bo exercised iu all fairness on both sides." "We, of course, rely upon the discretion of counsel that 110 unfair uso shall bo made of thoso names, or that they be subjected to trouble, reproach or anything of that kind." " "Otherwise, the com missioners would feel they had been u. party to reflecting upon innocent peo ple through this means, and subjecting I hem to Injustice." "We havo felt tho importance of tho suggestion that the nnmes bo kept secret." "V( would feel very much the respon sibility If nny harm should come to tlieso men by reason of the disclosure," "That does not relieve us, though, from the feeling of anxiety and tho hope that there shall come no harm to any person in any way from anything that is done beioro the com mission," Among tho prominent onlookers yes terday wero Rt. Hev. Kthelbert Tul bot, of Bethlehem, and lit. Ilev. Cam eron Mann,, of North Dakota, bishops of tho Episcopal church, and Uev. Rogers Israel, D. D rector of St. Luke's, whom they are visiting. They were Invited to seats on the plaftorm to the right of the commissioners. The three bishops sitting on the same plat form attracted much attention. "Mother" Jones, tho former organ izer of the American Federation of La bor, who liaa devoted so much of her tlmo to the miners' cause, came In during the morning and was warmly welcomed by thoso at the miners' table. Tho crowd of spectators was quite as Continued on Page .1. YESTEBDAY'S WEATHER. Local data for November 19, inoi Highest temperature ,,.,., ,.,,0a degrees Lowest temperaturo ,..,,........4t degrees Ituhitlvo humidity: S a. m. ,..,......,100 per cent. S p. m. ., ,.,...,M per cent. Precipitation, :i hours ended 8 p. ra., ,03 inch. T $, WEATHER POBEOAST . 4- "U'nRlilneton. Nov. . yoreeast -H for Thursday ami Friday: For Eastern Pennsylvania Fair Thurs day und Filday; light northwest winds becoming variaDio. .tt.tt..ttt.tfiu