lin. ' iPS" 'A e ' THE SCRANTON TRIBUNE-TUESDAY, OCTOBER 23. 1000. h$. SYRUFoJlGS ActrfeafantytmdJivmpty: Cleanses the System Gently and Effectually when bilious or costive. Jbcsents in, the most acceptable form the laxative principles of plants , Jcnown to act most AenenciaHy. , TO GET ITS BENEFICIAL EFFECTS BUY THE GENUINE MANFD. BY CALIFORNIA FIG STRUPCO. SAN FRANCISCO, CAL. lOUISVIUE.KY. NEW YORK, N.Y. for sale hy druggists price SO per bottle. r Ice Cream. BEST IN TOWN. OE Per j)c Quart- LACKAWANNA DAIRY CO 3 elepbone Orders Promptly Delivered 23f,-33J Adam Avenue, Scranton Transfer Co. Baggage Checked Direct to Hotels and Private Residences. Office D., Jj. & W. Passenger Station. Phone 525. DR. H. B. WARE. SPECIALIST. Eye, Ear, Nose and Throat Office Hours . m. to 12.30 p. in.: 5 to . Wllllsuna Building, Opp. Postofflccv -f -t--f- I CITY NOTES : I'.NTKKTAlN.MU.Vr T0X1GIIT. All ccellciit entertainment is to be eiun tuutaht at ', o'clock in the AuiLrm.in .Ucinoiijl dupd cm 1'res.cott avenue. KKYSTOM'. CI.UI1 MIXTI.VC!. 'Hie Keystone Hi publican club will liolil a mcetlmr tonight in 1 low aid Place lull, limine? of iiupoiMucc to be tiansactcd. hKCONl) ANNUM, HAI.U 'Uic secund un nual ball and cutciuitiniciit nf the Cu.iiit.ihlc l'lii'iiils association lll take pl.ico at Music lull '.1'ucsil.iy evening, October U). DATK OV WUKSILIXO IAT(JII. The date of tlie vrcotliiif; nutcli betucen M. .1. Dwjci, of this dty, and 1'rank (icl.le, of I'i(iii, 6 ins been Inioiicctly uiiuouuiiil us Xnwinlur 2. It will take place 'I'huiodjy, N'oieinbcT J, at tba r-cranton llic.sclc club house. bAvr.u.i: is Pri:.-iusc.ii i.aniic, of tin, city, who w.n recently supposed to be the un Known man Mlltd in .1 r.iilroul accident .it Vi. mingion, Del., is safe jml miiiiuI in New Ymk ilty. I'unk II. Hcllly, of Wellington avenue, Jeceiieil 11 letcr fioiu him last wick. Till: TIIIH1) mTUHK.-'Ilih eunlns Mis. Kinma Sluw CoIcKiikIi will dclhcr the thlid Jcituro in the course for the ll.ilinpni.inn bos. pltal at the lioino of Colonel H, M. Hobs, Sin gle tickets may be had at the door. It will bo one of vivid interest and should bo well pition. iud. I'ASSr.D THIRD WIAIHXG.-Oemnion council Jii-lil a nueling last nlcht which lasted Just three minutes and passed on thlid reading the ordi nance proUdlnu for lho appointment of ieveis to nisess the damiues caused by the opening of Poplar ttrcct across the Delawaio and Hudson tiacki. PARTY AT CUKKNSEY UALU-Guernscy lull was last nlsht the 6ceno of a very pleasant re ception glun by Mrs. S. J. I'uhrnun, of ICO Penn aenue, in honor of the flfty-llrst anni versary of her husband's birthday. (ler fifty couples were prcsmt. The music was furnished by Y, 0, OU. Lunih was beru-d at la o'clock-. CHOWUIIB SOCIAL. A clam chowder foclul under auspices of lieutenant torn S, Griflhi Yolnan'l Helicf coips, Xo. M, will bo held at tho homo of Mrs. J, S. Looinis, Vii North Mn. coin acnue, this ceniiiB. 'lho public is cor dially invited to attend this social mid assist a worthy cause. Supper will be tencd fioiu 5.30 throughout the evening. MKS. FKSSVKDKX WH.I, SPKAK.-Tho regular inectinff of the Central Womm's Christian Tim. peranee union will be held this afternoon at .". o'clock In Ouernsey hall. A laive attendance Is requested to hear Mrs. rcsseuden, of lloston, Mass., bpeak on somo (iluscs of temperance and reform work. Mrs. rcssrmlcn is being enter tained by llev, and Mrs. Lansing, 8RHIOIW.Y CII.Mt()i:i).-Tliomas J. llii.ldy, of Pellevue, was Saturday idt,ht cominitte.l to tho county jail In default of $1,000 bail by Aldemun Siillar, Iluddy was accused of ilncitiiig Ids wife n few months ago and of having since then rompicjinltul a )ouiig wouiaii, 'the "an. ml w.ij Issued at fhc Instance of Mis. IV, II. )iggan, ugent for the Auoiidleil ( luillio. mks. n.isi:v Ainu;'n-:i).-Mrs. midcoi Balucy, of f.uzmic lret, was hehl in svm lull Hit mirnt by Aldcriiiun Millar on he cluii.es ft disorcli 1 1 onduct ami bilug .1 coiuuioii scold. Mrs. Iluiy Jcudan, a mlsUmr nf Ihe defriidaiil, preferrc"! the tlurire. .i)ing tliat Mrs. Haluey vn various oieasious railed her a (uic-ei, because he wa V"f arrettfil on that chargr, alllioiiKJs ..l..........ll.r n,.f.,,IHlil II III.. (...,..,..... r.t VIj -04rIn 1'atrick Italucy, (lie 15-year-old uu of Mrs. ltalney, was Rhen a bearing fn the charge of assaulting Frank, the ll-jcar-old son of Mrs. .Ionian. U m discharged. ltl'.fi:li:t S10M:N (IOODS.-Tony 1'acc m! Ccimlo Maltuttl, of Ulakcly street, Duiiniote, wcro )clerluy arrested on a warrant liaiied t'y Ahlerman Kasson, ot Hie Instance id .lolin .t, Colcmiiii, nt Dnnmorc. Hie kilter aciusttl them of reichlng lJ5 wotlli of llgan and lobicco stolen from tlio Kc)tone hotrl. Ihey wnlect a Inuring and entered ball before a Uunmorc Jus UNION T.nAtmi: Mi:KTISfl. Tltcrc wilt lie' a meeting of lho Union League tonlnht In the looiiia ot tho Central Uepubllean club .to make arrniiscmcnls for the big meeting to be held In the nrmory oil October ml tinder the nmplu-i of Ihe league Congressman Lllltcllcld and other i.enl,en of note will addrei this meellng. The miltorins for the league hac nrrlird and will be dlnlilhuted at tonight's meeting. ITU.tAX SOCIl'.TVS HAI,t,.-Tlie tclllli an nual lull of the Italian Society diMrdla Vlltorlo IhiMiiiiele It, waa last night held nt Music lull. lhu hall was hindsoniely decorated, the Itallmi and American flags being In rldcnce on tho Mage. The Union orchestra furnished the ern. ing's music 11 ml the gumil tnaicli was led by Mr. and Mrs. 1'rank Carlucel. Ihe committee In charge last night consisted of tircsldenl, J. A, f'asiCsel lce president, I', Ilk cm; (J. Dcinarcu, N. Masl, S, Dl Martlno, N. Carlucel. CIIVSTAIj I10SU COMPANY MAI.L.-Muslc hall will ha a scene of great beauty tomorrow night when the Crystal Hose company No. i will run Its last nnnual ball. Tho Crystal bo) will bac for their guests nil the fire companies up and down the valley, also from the different companies in this city. Lawrence's orchestra of twihe pieces will furnish the dancing music, lho Lawrence band of thlrly-fhe pieces will gle an open air concert In front of the hall at 7."0 on Wednesday evening before the ball, At midnight a tire laddies cuke walk will be (then, rnemen In full uniform will be ad mitted ficc. AGI'.NT TIUCHOX AHIIKSTKD. C. Trachon, an agent In the employ of .Toms It Hall, sewing machine dealers, was )csterday arrested on .1 warrant lvuod bv Alderman Millar, charged with nsiault and battery by Mrs. ftlwaiit Tarr, of Snell's court. The latter alleges tint some time ago the bought a machine from the firm on the instalment plan. She became In ar le.ns In the September and October pa)menti and Saturday, she sa)s, Trachon lsitcd her home and atempted to remove the machine. On her objecting ho became very disorderly and stiuck her. She also claims that he picked up the top pirt of the sewing machine iml threw it across the room, breaking it. There will be a heating In tho case at 7 o'clock Wednesday evening. CHANGES IN THE ROUTE AND COLUMN Firemen's Parade Will Be larger Than Was at First Intended. Will Start Promptly at 2 O'Clock. Seveial chantres have been made In the formation and line of march of to morrow afternoon's firemen's parade from the original arrangements, and the procession Is now anticipated to bu given on a considerably larger scale than at first contemplated. The parade will form on Washing ton avenue, right resting on Lackt wanna, and the line of march will he ns follows: Down Lackawanna to Wyo ming, to Mulberry, to Penn, to Lacka wanna, to Eighth; countermarch to Adams avenue, to Olive street, to Washington. The inspection by Mayor Molr aid councils will take place before the riarade and will be held on Washing ton avenue. The wagons and earringf'S will form on Mulberry street, betweci Adams and Washington, and will there bo reviewed, At the conclusion of the parade the life-saving corps of thft William Connell Hose , company will give its exhibition on the Raub build ing on Spruce street. Bauer's band, followed by the police force, will lead the procession. Then will come the carriages with tho city officials and members of councils. The chief and his assistants follow, and next In line is the Citizens' band, of North Bcranton, followed by tho Frank lin Engine company. The Nay Auf; Drum corps Is to be followed by th Nay Aug Hose company, the Liberty Hose company and the Crystal Hose company. Ringgold's band will he next, and behind will come tho Nep tune Engine company, the Niagara Hose company, tho Relief Engine com pany and the Phoenix Chemical com pany. St. Peter's Dium corps will precede the Eagle Engine company and the Co lumbia Chemical and Hose company. The Sons of Veterans' Drum corps Is to be followed by the General Phlnney Englno company and the Excelsior Hose company. Tho Hook and Ladder company comes next, and will probably be led by the Ninth Regiment band, ot Wllkos-Unrre. Lawrence's band will lead the Will iam Connell Hoso company, and the P. O. H. of A. Dium coips, followed by the Ccntuiy and Cumberland Hose companies, will bring up the rear of the procession. The parade will start promptly at li o'clock, and the exhibi tion given by the life-saving corps will tako place about 3.43 o'elouk. REPUBLICAN MASS MEETINGS. THURSDAY UVUSIVG, OCT. 2 j-fci .niton, Athletic Hall, Spcakeis, Dr, I'lntl Schneider, of New Jersey, address in German; . J. Col born, Jr, TIIUliSDAY KVI-'.NI.N'tl, OCT. liJ-Dunmorc, Odd Fellows Hall, Speakeis, Major A. M. Han cock, of lialttmorc; Hon, John H, Furr. FHI1UY HVnXING, OOT. M-Jcrmjii, Knter prise ball. Speakers, Mijor A, 31, Hancock, of Baltimore; A. .1, (,'olbom, Jr, SATURDAY KVHNIXO, OCT. 27-Moscow, Odd Fellows lull, Speakers, Major A. M, Hancock, of Ilaltlmorc; V. Ga.Word Thomas, Ksrj. SATURDAY AFTCRKOOX, OCT, ' 27 Dalton, Old Church. Speaker, Hon. Qalusha A. Glow, MONDAY EVENING, OOT. 2scranton, Ar mory, Speakers, Hon, Clias. E. Llttlcfteld and others. TUESDAY EVENING, OOT. E0-Hyd Park, St, David's hall. Speakers, Hon. Hugh Gordon, Miller, of Virginia; W. Oaylord Thomas, Esq. TUESDAY F.VEN1NO, OOiV SO-Carbondalc, Oeeia house. Speakers, Hon. Chas, E. Little field and others. WEDNESDAY EVENING, OOT. 31-Tompkiiu-villc. Speakers. Hon. John It. Farr; W. R. Lewis, Oeorge M. Watson. THURSDAY EVENING, NOV. X-Ncwlon Cn. tcr, Van Sickle's ball. Speakers, Hon, John It. Farr, A. J. I'nlborn, Jr, FRIDAY EVENING, NOV, 2-OId Forgo, Law. renco Republican hall. Speakers, Chailcs E. Daniels, II. It. Van Dusen, II. O. llublir, FRIDAY EVENING, NOV, 2-East Denton, Odd Fellows' hall. Speakers, Lewis 11. Carter, W. J. Douglass, II, 6. Alworth, SATURDAY EVENING, NOV, n Justus, Alll. ance Hall. Speakers, Hon. John It. Farr, W, R, Lewis, George M. Watson. Western Bates Reduced, Greatly reduced one-way and round trip second class rates will bo In effect from Chlcatjo via Wisconsin Central Railway, to points In Minne sota, North Dakota, Montana, Idaho, Oregon, Washington and British Col umbia each Tuesday during October and November. For detailed Information Inquire of nearest ticket agent, or address JAH. C. POND, Uen'l Pass. Agent, POSITION OF MEN'S UNION DEFINED BY E. B. STUROES BE FORE THE COURT. Wholesale Suspension of Sentences Where Convictions Are Secured or Pleas of Guilty Entered Are Caus ing the Movement They Are En gaged in to Begcncrato Into a Farce Same CauscB for Leniency Do Not Exist Now ns at the Be ginning of the Movement. After the drier caso went to the Jury yesterday, court took up the task of Iniposlnc sentences In a number of cases In which convictions were se cured during tho term of quarter ses sions, which closed on Saturday, or In which pleas of guilty were entered. When the first case was called, E. B. Sturgcs, of the Men's union, came be fore the court nnd made a atutemnt with reference to the policy of the union concerning the suspension of sentences In cases in which it is In terested. The mutter came up when Mrs. Philip Graff was called for sentence. She kept a speakeasy on Cedar avenue, and her attorney, M. J. Donahoe, start ed to make a plea fo'r the suspension of sentence, stating that the plea of guilty had been entered with that understand ing. Judge Edwards wanted to know what the commonwealth had to uy about the mutter, and District Attorney Jones turned to Attorney Fred 13. Beers, of the Men's union, for a state ment as to what the union had to soy about the case. Mr. Beers started to say that tho union Is prepnred to recommend tho suspension of sentence only In special cases. Just then Mr. Sturges appeared with in the bar enclosure and, learning of the desire of the court to know If there was any objection to the suspension of sentence, stepped before the court nnd said: WHAT STURGES SAID. I want to siy a word in general as to lho policy of this prosecution once and for all. When we began this mocment vrn came upon many law breakers by surprise, for the breaking of the law had been 90 common as to be a matter of couise. The law was bo gencially ills obe.ved that nt first we had no desire to be un duly seu're with these people, believing their arrest would be a warning tc them. Alter a laige number of arrests were made, ii. jour ho-irs know. In nearly all cases where these was any lc-ason why clemency should be extended we joined with the defendants In nsk irg that clemency be extended. Me arc not here for punishment but lor purification and obedience of the law. This mou'incnt has been, going on for about six months and .ill of fenders hao had ample notice and warning that this means business; that the laws must bo obc)l; that the courts do not tit here to be tiifled with. We luc recently been solicited by almost everybody who has been convicted. We Ime declined to interfere except in special esses. I hate no peace at my house, I liae no peace in my office, I almost had to stiy out of town on account of petitions and begging Ut ters and applicatljns fiotn personal friends and fiom brother attorneys, whose friendship I still (ocl, to hac sentence suspended In certain taes. So my life has been made miserable I may My. Generally the appeals hac come fiom those against whom it has been most ditfteult to get testimony. Now tills has begiili it be rather .1 laice, and that f.uce culminated a week aso last Friday. None of jour honors were interested and the judges who were hire had undoubtedly been decehed by our conduct in other cries when two of the most notorious end persist ent law breakers escaped just as if they had not been acused or comieted. These wcro Anthony Iinnleavy, whose petition for a suspension scs signed by tome of the most reputable cttirons, who should huxe known betlcr, or should hace, at least, tried to ascertain more fully as to the facts, and .Mrs. Catheiinc Crane, two of the most notorious and persistent offenders and against whuin we have bad the greatest difficulty In se curing testimony. HAS UEEN EXPENSIVE. This whole proceeding, which has been extreme ly cxpensiic to a few, seems to be in danger of degenerating Into a farce. These law breakeis make it troublesome., for us to get testimony, and then they h.io the benefit of the doubt be fore the giand jury, and a, must soious de. fense in this court, and, then If comiitfd, time is Muiges and the piosecution to fall luck on. Now, we want to sav tint they have not the pioserutlon to fall back 011 any more. 1 am not talking about tills lady, but I say lids prosecu tlnn should mean something. After we lue hid all this trouble they should be dealt with ns lawbreakers and renlenced accordingly, except there be some special reasons. Wo have found in some cases where- they leeched extreme clem ency they lue gone right back in business again, and it Is almost utterly impossible to get the tes. timony tho second time. With this statement, which I simply make as one of the leaders In this nntter to define our position at this time I eac tho whole nntter ill jour honr.is bands. We want to put ouisehes on rceoid that we are not after punKhnunt or rcienge, but the publication of this city and the lalslng of it to 11 higher standard of obedience to existing la, whcthci these laws b light or wiong. If they are wrong they should be le pealed. We feel It is necessary where offenders aie romicted to iccehe punishment. About tills lady I want to say that Mr. Ileers Informs me that some promiso was made in our indulgent d.i)s that if she should plead guilty we would make no objection to supension of sentence. Judge Archbald In speaking for the court with referenco to these cases said; In the matter of these piosecutlons as In every other, the natural result of cnniicllon is a bcntcncc. There must be- something cxtiaor-dinar)- or tpccial reason to have sentence sus pended or defened, that Is to say, to lue (lis hand of tho law arrested. In many rases we hae taken fiom the Men's union suggestions as to whether the sentence should he suspended and hac many times rifcrred and deferred to their judgment In the matter. We do not mean to put an uudue burden upon the Mien's union or to make them a loard of pardons, simply to know from them whether there Is occasion of suspending or whether th sentence of the law- should be imposed. MRS. GRAFF ESCAPED. Mr. Donuhoe then made a plea for Mrs. Graff, Ho said her husband con ducted a licensed hotel on Cedar ave nue for a number of years, but last year failed to take out a license. Ho became 111, and Mrs. Graff sold for a time to support her husband and chil dren. She has retired from tho busi ness and Is about to move from tho place. Court decided to suspend sen tence on payment of the costs. Mrs. Ann Lally, who came Into court with her crippled son to bo sentenced for keeping u speakeasy, also had sen tence suspended on payment of the costs. Shu lives In "North Scranton and Is a widow with a number of children. John A. Winters, who pleaded guilty to selling without u license at Cnpouse avenuo and New street, was sentenced to pay a line of 500, costs-, utiet soend three months in the county Jail. At torney D. J, Reedy madu a stirring plea for Winters and presented a peti tion signed by nil of the nnem ner.s of the school board, by whom ho Is now employed. Judge Edwards said they appreciated the strength of the petition In Winters' cquld interfere "We can seo our way clear to suspend sentence in the caso of 'some widows who have children to support, but here is a man who was able to earn 11 living, and wo can seo nothing In this case to move tho dis cretion of the court." He then Imposed sentence. CASE OF TUB FLANAUMANS. Stephen Flanagan n and Thomas Flannghnti, father and son, who live on Luzerne sttect, wcro convicted last week of keeping 11 speakeasy. They had a plea made lit their behalf by Attorneys Frank Lynch and Ralph Levy. Colonel Hitchcock und Mr. Beers, attorneys for thu Men's union, opposed vigorously a suspension of sen tence In these! cases, suylng thu inott on trial had added perjury to their other offenses by the testimony during the trial. The tittortioys said tho Flanaghans have been selling since they were In dicted, and they had evidence that us late us si week ago lust Saturday father and son were behind the bar In the place. Owing to the youthfulness of thu boy, ho being but sixteen years, tho court decided to suspend sentences In his case, but sentenced the father to pay a line of $500, costs, nnd three months In the county jail. Michael Horan, who pleaded guilty to selling without a license in North Scranton, got three months, a fine of $500 and costs, notwithstanding strong pleas by Attorneys John F. Murphy and R. H. Holgate in his behalf. He Is a married man with four children and several dependent relatives. Mr.. Mary Visoll, who pleaded guilty to shoplifting, escaped with thirty days. She has been in jail for six months awaiting trial. Her attorney, C. S. Olver, urgently pleaded with tho court for clemency in her case. Ho said her husband, who has escaped ar rest, was the real culprit. DR. KNAPP'S CASE. Dr. C. R. Knapp, of Forest City, was not present when his name was called for sentence, but his attorney promised that he will be in court today. Sen tence in the case of Attorney George Beale, convicted some time ago of em bezzlement, was postponed until the next term. Harry- Obllnger, who pleaded guilty to keeping a gambling house, wns fined $10 and costs, and the same sentence was Imposed upon Francis Treon. Llbble Young, one of the famous family of that name, of Carbondale, who are so frequently seen In criminal court, and who has been detained in the county jail as a witness, was te leased yesterday on $200 ball, furnished by her mother, Harriet Young. Capiases were Issued for Andrew Oram and Warren Tappan. WANTED TO HAVE CASE TRANSFERRED Attorney C. Smith Made One of His Characteristic Moves in Argu ment Court Yesterday Many Cases Continued. On account of tho Grler case taking up the main court room until late In tho afternoon, argument court did not begin until 4 o'clock. Between that and adjourning hour, however, the list was read by Judge Archbald and the cases marked either for u. hearing or con tinuance. When the case of tho Scranton G.is and Water company against C. Smith nnd others, exceptions to affidavit of defense and rule for judgment, was called, Mr. Smith made one of his chat acterlstlc moves-. The action, as oriff lnally instituted, was to collect for water furnished to certain housps owned by Mr. Smith or his wife. He said yesterday, after Judge Arch bald called the number of the case, that he thought ho could not got sub stantial Justice In the local courts and wanted the case heard elsewhere. Judge Edwards told him to present affidavits, as is the practice of the court In such cases, and the matter will then bu heard. Rules to set aside executions against Brink, Evans & Co., obtained by Otto. Stender, Fred Rempe, B. O. Ott, John J. Schneider, Julius Smith and C. C. Tripp, were reported as having been amicably arranged and were stricken off the list. Rules absolute by agreement weio allowed In lho cases of Annette Rey nolds against Thomas Brooks and others, rule to strike off nils to take depositions; E. C. Newcomb. trustee, against George W. Beale and Amos Scott, rule to strike off judgment as U Amos Scott: James B. Gorden against D. B. Hand and others, rule for secur ity for costs; William H. Merrltt ugnlnst C. J. Grosvenor and otheis. rule to strike off judgment. In tue case of It. N. La Bar and others ugalnst Speedway Land company, 11 rule to open Judgment was discharged by agreement, A large number of cases wetc continued. Yesterday's Marriage Licenses, Hugh Wilkinson Wilkesdlarre Maty Ho)h Scranton Anthony McNulty Scranton Mary WaUsh Scranton Dr. Henry llalpcrt Scranton Eel)n Mortis Scranton Wintield II. Fellows Philadelphia Frances II. Kennedy Scranton Arthur Estell Scranton Hamuli llowcn Scranton Court House News Notes. The report of the Wcwcis in the matter of the extension to sewers of the First sewer dis trict of 01) pliant wus )csteidiy tiled with the court by Attorney Frank M, L)iich. Court yesterday fixed Wednesday morning at 0 o'clock as the time for the hearing' in tho matter of (fie objections' of Fred W, Warlike to John J, Flanaghau's papers as an. independent candidate for recorder of deeds. A petition containing eighty-eight signatures was )estcrday filed with the court asking tint the portion of the I'roUdento and Ablngton turn plko within the limits ot the city ot Scranton be condemned and madu a freo road. On Nov. 12 an application will be made for the appoint ment of a master to tike testimony nnd of a Jury to iew tho load. Mlchlele Latnonea yectcrdiy began proceedings to secuie a dhorre from his wife, LucU La liionea, to whom he was mauled May 8, 1SS9, They lived together until Nov, J, hot, when Mis. Lamonea, It Is cluigid, ihseitcd her hus band, it is further alleged that she wuj un faithful to her husband and was guilty ot un lawful lelatlons with Yinuctuo Sarlo ami otheis. 'In closing his petition Lamonea sajs his wife has now given herself up to a Ufa of prostitu tion. Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup Has been used for our FIFTY YE IIS by MILLIONS of MOTHERS for their CHILDREN WHILE TEETHING, with PERFECT SUCCESS. 1 SOOTHES the CHILD, SOFTENS the GUMS. CRIER JURY NOT AGREED AT MIDNIGHT WERE ENGAGED IN A BRISK ARGUMENT, Case Was Given Into Their Hands at 2.45 Yesterday Afternoon After Three Hours of Summing Up by the Attorneys and an Hour's Ad dress by Judgo Edwards Mr. O'Brien for the Defense and Mr. Torrey for the Prosecution Make Able Speeches. At 2. tr, o'clock yesterday afternoon lite case of the commonwealth against Common Councilman James .1. drier was submitted to tho Jury. At mid night they were still out and seemingly engaged in a very brisk argument. The whole day up to the hour of the Jury's retirement wns consumed by the summing up of the attorneys and tho charge of the court. Mr. O'Brien and Mr. Torrey divided three hours of the morning session between them, and Judge Edwards took tho first hour of the afternoon session to deliver his charge and pass upon tho law points submitted by the defense. Mr. O'Brien opened tho summing up for the defense by cnlltng attention to the Importance of the case and tho great responsibility the law places upon a Juror. He reminded them that they had taken an oath to be guided alone by the law and the evidence and cautioned them against framing their judgment on anything other than what came from the witness stand. He read the law on bribery and showed how It was possible for a councilman convicted of this crime to be sentenced to pay a fine of $10,000, spend five years In jail nnd be forever barred from holding public office. The defendant was being tried on the charge of receiving a bribe of $40, Mr. O'Brien went on to say. He did receive the money nnd it was proffered to him as a bribp, but It was no trans gression of the law. He took the money, turned it over to his attorney with a view of having the briber ar rested, and now he brings the money into court. Tho reference to the sum of $1,400 must be lost sight of In framing the verdict, Mr. O'Brien ex plained. All that Grler -was charged with in the case at bar was accepting a bribe of $40. Mr. O'Brien severely criticized the kind of reform that "debauched" of ficials, and referring to the men who were behind the prosecution said they must have forgotten the words of the master, "Lead us not into temptation." CRITICIZED DETECTIVES. Then ho proceeded to pay his respects to the detectives and detective evi dence, and pointed out how they wpre contradicted at almost every turn bv the defendant's witnesses. Their story was a concocted one, Mr. O'Brien con tended, and as an evidence of this he pointed out that not one of them would attempt to give a fact without ilrst digging it out of his memoranda book. The statement that Harris laid $50 on a table at Rohrwasser's for Grler was characterized as unreasonable, and that It was not true was evidenced by the failure of the prosecution to make any effort to contradict the testimony of Coleman that there Is not now, and was not then, any table in the room in question. As to the $1,400, Mr. O'Brien said the detectives divided it among themselves and then arranged a story to make the Municipal league believe they had given it to Grler. "Why," asked Mr. O'Brien, "did not some member of the league go down and see that the money was paid ? There was plenty of room where the detectives were In that room In the Rudolph. The truth of the matter is, they found soft picking In tho Munici pal league. They will lose a soft thing when they lose this league." Further, in relation to the detectives, he said that their evidence was uncor roborated and that detective evidence was always to be taken with a grain of allowance. Harris' emphatic declar ation that he ne-er wrote Grler a let ter, nnd his later acknowledgement that ho had written such a letter, when one from him to Grler was produced, was dwelt upon extensively by Mr, O.'Brlen. The action of Grler in turning over the money to his attorney within the hour that Harris gave it to him, and his declarations to five different per sons that he had taken the money, was, when corroborated by these live persons, sufficient, Mr. O'Brien argued, to convince any fair-minded man that there was a total absence of guilty in tent on Mr, Grier's part. The failure of the prosecution to attempt to rebut Grier's character witnesses and the law on reasonable doubt were tho concluding topics of Mr. O'Brien's address. MR. TORREY'S STRONG ADDRESS. At the! outset of his closing nd dress for the prosecution, Mr. Torrey took occasion to say in reply to Mr. O'Brien's comment about character testimony that the testimony was not worth rebutting. Those of tho char acter witnesses who had weight could give only their personal opinion. Ho then went on to say that tho men who are behind these prosecu tions have only the Idea of cleaning out the vlclousness In this commu nity; theso men, who might spend (Continued oil l'age B, Late Arrivals Here Some goods we expected in time for the opening but which failed to arrive in time are now here. We wish to call particular atten tion to the immense line of Jar dlnlers, which were opened yes terday, The largest line ever ohown in Scranton nt the lowest prices ever quoted. Look them over. Gruener & Co., 205 Wyoming; Avenue. tVWMWWMWM It Would Be 1 Of inexcusable indifference for a prudent woman in search of a wedding gift, or goods for her own Use, to overtook such values as we offer in really choice wares. Llbbey's Cut Glass, for instance, less than the price of acid polished glass. Our di rect importations with all manufacturers of foreigh wares gives us prices nnd discounts that none of our competitors get. These are facts, When we say "Facts" we mean "Facts" not Fairy Tales. CVutvasMaAX. Geo. V. Millar & Co. "JMS2 :WWWWWrWlWRWWWrWWr HHnHrTB l. - 7ji JJKyr" We make teeth to suit you and your friends. We guarantee to please you or no pay. We keep work in repair free of charge. We examine and extract teeth freo of charge. Our Crown and ? Bridge Work... V Per Tooth All work guaranteed for 10 years. Call and have your tscth examined. Satisfaction ornopayj Jap Aare Sort of an odd name, but the maker had no other for it so "Jap" we'll call it. It's made up into any variety of useful articles, such as Money Boxes. Trays, Bath Tubs, Foot Tubs, Bread Boxes, Cake Boxes well, we can't take a census of them here. But if you can think of anything of this naturo that you've "Looked all over Scranton for and couldn't find, just try us. That's all. In the Basement. Step down and look around after your lunch here today. J. D. WILLIAMS & BRO. .312 and 314 Lackawanna Avenue. KnMKKMKKUKKn5IM5KKKKSKHKUK if About Rubber Tires Q Of course all rubber tires look alike, but don't you know 25 there is a great difference in the wear and quality of vehicle tires, due to the different methods ol putting on, etc. 5 We have a very expensive plant for putting on Kelly- 54 Springfield Tires on' all classes ot vehicles. It is the only per- V feet rubber tire manu-factured, being made of pure rubber 5 and not composition. These tires are put on to stay held in the channel by two wires electrically welded, Cannot posi- bly roll off or tear out, H BITTENBENDER & Prices on KKUKUKJHnun)rIKHKKKOKKKK??K In Our New Store , We are now located in our new storq. 406 Lackawanna Avenue, formerly oc cupied by Siebecker & Watkins. We are showing a superior line of Furniture and Carpets, andinvite inspection Scranton Carpet and Furniture Company REGISTERED. an Act TEETH $5 SET 5$ Better come In and talk to u bout jour teeth. We believe you will appreciate the work and our low prices. Wa will ae you nearly cne-hill on ill dental work. We make a specialty of Crown and Bridge work and if you have any old or decayed teeth, come to us and we will make new ones out of them for you. Dr. Reyer, Dentist gi4 Spruce St., Opp. Court House. Scerl Heaters reduce the coal bill one fourth to one half. The grate, boiler, fittings and magazine feed are constructed for fuel economy. With a tsi SPERL HotWater) HEATER great heat is produced with a small amount of coal; automatic dampers regulate the heat and prevent sudden changes of temperature. It is an econ omy of both fuel and heat. One purchaser heated 13 larre rooms from December I to April I with seven tons of chestnut coal. Send for booklet civing the experiences of other purchaser?. THE SPERL HEATER CO., CARBONDALE, PA. onnHBMaMHHi CO., 126 and 128 Franklin Ayo. Application. t(4-av MM 1 - Nf -OW I z 4 iusioii of -r. .w,u M-w.rtBom "'"7""' re .f"1" " "" d t k e no other Mini. Twenty-live tents a "20S WvominO' Ave ir-old uu I Milwaukee, Wis. I behalf, but did not see how the court I bottle. Xio wy timing Vp 1 J. UMri ; .'1 r -V., ?, A - ".; ?