0 Owl 1.0
/la, and deollei
iitfot 6oein
-- ---, • - atent , Pe. ,
• ''Kfiroc.gi t /fibs" P r 414
vi t i.
l• - i',. -,Omaiing; 04 NI 4
4 0114 ,/..".. 4 .._ "I"ii,u,kir sat: :7
‘4-• -•••••
...,. •
Taw,.
ri.
' , ;4ye11i4 . 40 .
140,1*
.."*410411i
41 1 !1 . ' ll
{' ' ( •
0
V• k !
. 1 ' ' .I' l .
. ••••:,...4.-igo
; l kfin.:,.. •
••• tk: ''"'
. .... : i :
Atia.
; 4 2Jae:.
,tek,V•
4 , 1
,
'
411.1241,.
„-5. t
.teif2l-Ar ..;•
fitAV.4 % :t•WV:ig
AriAtro'2l?, PCi4P•PI:V.C.?:7O.
• •'`..l4' ": 4 04•1ti.:"5• .1 "
• ,t t e..4.,i,?:lls%rreao.*tt.:SPZ'
•
51,4 61- ‘
Mirff i s 6ll ; t °
''4l`6l* Vlinni
WINO" .
-‘illYoffi t Of l O N ', 41 4 0 4 '1
04f.it ' - 54f-s - wP -
‘re ' ' .';#„o " ,tAtlt
1 ' liiriwialt, 8.-.usuT
rlrsi.o4:o l 4 l- 14fng
tlreatipor,tolippratte,
Wgl f ig l itq l *
„,,yak.,., .4 :54'...5.,‘:•..{ 4, .
plinethi r tliga:44l • '•
11011 4444 t cn ..)•: i ti
deteaL-illkinlitettl ie
oiletiPtll*Jeittlo4 tikt
ttiexpliißger;nuAgetit,
11 Prigi*ntiffig,P 4 01 5kihig . it
4 45,0tReatisniikeithlkutire,
litotl,theimie iiiiiipint
' ' 4441 000=V M
,-', •'-e l "9 4)lo l ,ffb ‘ t l ir i ,
Plift4 oll obi4fii*,4 l o*.
..,,„_- ....._ rpit4;iwiathitigto ioLloilv.
• oitll4:olol,coTrti,orglift 6 ;*
4103 u19.Ccoriam r ,a
.rap...ite.bithill 14211
iliiiifTlf 7 :(l*.4 l oY,X4l 4 - 411 0 1 : 06411, or :4 6 '
• .. o
"r . x .#ol ll . e 0
4 0 .6# , t 4. 0 ° :6 4 4 e .. 0,4 1 1 6 1 ,0 4 t
I°l4ttKPt4ltoVr4ltPlM-Pr°l.l4l'B7•'
'
Amintatcty
ma ;the ••prthotple. of f, atilt% NI
W 4 iNilic, , t4 i. , ' kCi e rt t ; i ii f o k t.44i
• on of wrilton instruments." ' And. In
noVA, i:igs . Tik;itti/- viiii:XlMaityii me*
, Terk aid Eris RatfroadzelmtlilaYs (Paths
ziPsi fill Court says 4cl,4l(e i tiniljniony of :six 3 l
pigtop'which was rejected littd.nerqtrvanny to,
kag.:Sgacifi on ,41411C4 ill4lginireee 'ti•lmso; tiiiir
rather to be IntitidtitVW ilistrtletto
11241 'Zi;itinolpi it
t .urt on eomenteohanloak , 4 ., ,,
6 i*1 3 i 0 4 444 1 4 t.rt le ffKl i t 4.2"°44, by.
,k , -tooefi-filitigii4ClVid;tio.tritli aiiiitruoi or/.
, iateliesiits*di: iwibiVitefigpea 'to
_ tcriih*R 1 ,11..20 , 11,•`,..?*: , 4C
' ' 't. i a t,4*,* ,'4/49 7, . Pli:OtP ,4 1 4;16, the
+
pftis#o7aeu*Gbilier, triootat;.irr arm.
Og i rf:l lo _ , , TWAW,II4'Ii4 paint 'otiCtifo:dW
011;136110 IN vehukr of the modololoii4 (123 , y1001i
464104ViegSA/PV‘c.ei, Tgeatkifyipt.,
gi &foe lo skaia , itliOitol 6 jporinftiithilw
to 0444116* telt Akin 4Firi or ea' "
if . tfo4 -4 Kiiii4.l - if iiipAiiikciiili - sfjk
44.01,.,440,1,i t iot:•tmrrreivt4ito
* k . =itillf-e t il l'WCoo
lni~lmnOnt'' Of'
Nt4tliii 5"2..a1, Jiiiliellirifelitle r ikaiiiiim
trare tbilektrbo ;oil:41:41;04 mitten visr.
'.:4:ol.Nimo4li.tfeig+. l 44.ol.- itiwi
4i3.,.(ditt'fi.t.o.).#ol.64l..dthheid.:Ast
g:t - pti.maan#.4:iliv - irw*kaisiiiiwig
~ e ,. ' 6 4,4ol 4 l lo4l " l *P i tti ll ks,, AY
**Ammo st ii wined to -iii witowiti,
''',
_ m lo4 o wAtimir!P th otqw*HmtritatinYllori:
maa weettAredeeentrkmed in - eromexam.
iationa„-toteetAsrldltrr:ka 911 , edgebf i rtilk
i t
Wr i f li, * l k ilikt iOt e ft r A illir 4 9 / 1 /
ini,4sitia gig - 5%120 :gird Yet , ../ 1 4 - , illf4wict
c..l ..
~,,o.M4G:o„.ll4i4oeWtesSfl42,9.lW*AY9*
W r if#,, Ups. Ilme,l"abloarttnEvidertieiiett ll ,
`•
4ti""0%6 caseifniiiicire,tyolta.
;4 Fils4* - 1 10
ita -, brAhrrlittaoi , ii ) filP
. !WAWA: Skeen/444g iviltl4‘; , jaital:
meets:.(o ,9tVek - AM Ali'ljo.P. 2 :) . , „!Fttni tif, e'
• Stif/illO l o* /112 ; s e c` U P• l o ot .
,*,f?t64.,1 - oC4asqeff<iti4;
4a• - hriicii'lfeic. kagsforeeeihe wok
tadkuieiroonti,a - tithirt, that del
1 Aairilitiiivriaji "instrument ;iikti)
- ija l l ( .s.**+. 4lll6 l ll !°lv'es unludtT,
Nlcit4isll4*l#oKilitr
iiiitikiiklft4RoPtillti 44
',: - X4, lq i Vburitnilf.•
'44l2%inagi•WsAii4
s i l kilt4lt, l 4,fillg... •
%
* iaraglicaukiiei tc* Wind 4*i *
net. °;*lig,•
TA
'lf e # 44 4l
inliiirAtigi '
' . 1 1! 0 44.407td.;
.01 , 1 1, 04 1 . 1 4 0
ktottithifiaroV
l' 6ll "47l 2 Matitell
iiiik34.1.44.
- -4 infiktigdairirtlk
47710 giii 4 iii 7- 'IA
.4) c.• ) er t"fl'itr ol4l k 4 . blak stiff'
r- 4:40s he seYs I " /111 , kali leadiiig tl,
, - ~.,15!,;trAtee lostreqesitisAikPei + O ,
r ;bit/Pe/AV! d icoriung ' to 4g e, i r 10 4,
; wiiitwiit,oet!:)%4l4,:twtol or trittb jt s n
,ti'll"")o4.,lte-IY*44 *in iirdeNr
a p
thi t A ‘i niiiifth' 4l4 44o l oo: 4 e:o l ‘. l444s Y ( ft
which the hisnioent t fitilueb-Veldtaitkyrbtair
ta olisbitartee4AßMlVid'o6Sin •10
22 1 1 , 1 44 ligAioeuttillifallfreiafl!kik JoirAck",
terftaiteirlainise. of 'orbit `omamlinietton•
1me94,1t. , ithateveg, therefore, indicatil
00 nAterso2l4alm) tjacCli (Ong tbedltuu ot:
,Interpretattotiakthp i lateguage and meaning A
the,partlia, in ref 66 to it, and Is also aj :. ..
.fonadativi for giving the Irtect•ropent,sso woe.
;Mobil* ;hen cineittired Matt 81 y, ditnii.;
l ento ow that lthith it; wmck meivfla if cf ) P
' ' : • 4 4;;41ir0,wi5c:10:1295
Yt: -W4All4;APftor,tillg to .484143 for. tile
' 40* . iriitiar 100144 4 12:11t4)011b14 pi'
' 1 it Ni.obsery.o:l44ll4mot
41 1 , *(Er nti4;jegllsL k litig
•!,. 0 .0 1 1 1 ,1i,._
./ 11 0 . 0 4 ,* . i11.. r•
.414 imapiarlykkintilina o,
,f4241k---zjiiillidAlli 4 iti 4 Por iiiii,
0 111 14 431 .R . 0ft'0 r- 1i ai1 1m11 110 4 414 004 1 .
Away. ieeetvable, tommorieipwitieK
liesn!iiiim9DlPo ll e wilo, 443 hein , " ' ' • t
Ulf Oragefolitlik`rifigitgiVitirol testi
*s224,lbreti,lookedtbrougii the whole of tlis:
'tiertimolsilii4l o:4alititing read it twi
very eamfallydstttai left this Impression,
upon WiiharlistiaOthe t r eiot;' ,, obitred" eir
‘ litihrwt joolklmitwelt known to the huh
mill,,kTelf IferklrlOO f filt4," and that these
I, itt " were '. oltirattonwsirltida. , 1 , think.
they • 157,-we'ia .4zio witnesses whom .
tz ! iotairtitfeltioi. h
it p,
`..., ,* Ma ",',tt - ,214p15 5 1 used theta
il • - 1' 0 5 4*. r h %/4 1 t a rt' 2 9 , 01rin:
• ... . - litho hid 1 4 ' Wil ; and tbOi;
Aibirtgit*lfiltindi: 47 ill* t iatt Ebel*
, :aritnitlemt WorstAiatit,„ .. in , India .1144sroulif
- Ittme-efera itallitiltiOpind. their testimony elle
pil EA clear, thigligtenn ~ shirred or eq.
P
.. ~.. ,
i • odlll'Araffaltillitnown prior teigtitt
'bero is sorneritondthr4atareen this testimony.
i hnd the taitltututy WOO of the dotentlanta'
iiilleaaceA Ull
l'4Wittii ;AO, in regard 'to
*any of , the `wktoptioi f Yor . ,ltW'rlot:oridapss,.
Mt. rosti4k will apply} ?that they are intimated
to "VA thc f` . t b Ott i P* ll3 , ll *: , o l o l o: ll ,l 6 -tv fq/
(ha
C° o l ' " 31144 IllYilmt 2 12 09' 1 441 1 6 1 11 aro
itimilt*OlikkiAthitOiftoliallo . i 9 - M of
*aloonlie, ntbtierii*ltivriat right, they .
. 1 14 41 ttfft ' t...oo ll 44lti.ii!•` c ia : 260 wP 1 , 3 i1t
6 4 1 0* - :40: 41 36141111rfinti!' - ‘ 4labn' can
- o(iiiiitilia arOnfringlii . All .•
*ln a
' .* 1 4 * tlf 46 ;4oalutior IlhO g ratt r 4-
ri ll osheopip,4 o . o o;,, c iutho r ,•fif not entirely •
',..t144 lattliMMllit.will apply to a large.:pkei
440044**9117-sor, th e defendonte witeasa;
4
tljtth44: l / 4 ,tbat they testify that there tilla
goo 2:1040)41".6i111:06',Woyott olait!e,
• . iltl,4l 2 l l 4ldtilfigie the patent
oliiircii 9th i gitOTkilAilt apparent to the
' - . ' — t , lk 'Pi,. Purtp being
„ altlrroel f' ,Was : well
lble, to', trace.) {
•ont. Ttiii';eternt:
red or corettga i r _•
I bare alreatt
I well in”!
KW, Ititireforei
4 140 Ok'
tad ad -, 0 044,
10 1 01031 i:
*0 .
itelbfg n.l 0,
iti h Arl`
ft. !Vil
•i: neiV at'id
' tpli,
14 .*MX/ 414
wee a Aint; ii
,litiOtg r ii*
..-- _olitigir 10 f , 4it'lOOPt a'
W ie g ..
, ,
~, ~. i , ,'; , iiMikif . l . ! when' the wo
•
be.‘t:rireedvitiidreanti , sentbA ! Y:
, , ,' ' 11,10-'Piiii,/ 411 1 1 PIAllif.tOgi : „_' . •
4` f * ll : 4V 4 4 t W .r ill + .4 :P tli fek v - 9 " 1 : - : V .
ice-. , 464:.*hths did-ttiddiearaii,
;- ~ s ol witactiditi o diy„.,-ohrb4ir •
~
~.A. „ , Minn tr. his patent . hr
• .. 9 14 1 540itr0i did he mean all '? 1 abirrid•
4 *,' „I i rl 7.,* , 4 9 4) and then
' • • ~,„0-3 cii:k•••••4; •
I ? 4 , 6ll fi l nit t ,k9 4 .10401 : documentary
44
/54 - 1414 '.:- W if... j `gll t Mei t .il l;i i; i " . .: " -5 t P r•si .'
•"4 , .. , •vntse•pliirrsip, ,, :t;.-50v5.5,•' • . i. .' • ~,, i..•
, ' 4 / 1 . 041;:t". : v.• ,- , , : •-• .., .. - •••
--3:f..:- z- ...111:::: , •
.. , ,:ic•,_, , .441 1 . A4 - ..:,-.- ..,..
.-, -,,,•:',., , ....... 1."‘•
;,!fkk `-',..,AS'' -, -,4•'',1-,:.:!'-'
1 11 :1
11
. of it t
iT,Tutto;')
lyear,_by
' pOkt calk
.. - .
_, , ~ ~
I.
.66.rolteirstliftilt" : any condlet 'tr. , qiittriefit
iitielatiebritrolfirtnlintWertiftifelll'
. ...
;Meg .m 5 1it . 3 9, 0:43 E F.P.0.40 ' i"trtnne :
' .WheroiAntereate • are - :so- conspil4ted - d
• 4 iiiiiitlilic ti A l jhok . ifelli • Okeills,Not . . r .th.4l4dia.
! Vibtiet "menufactiiiii"'"fire; "the'- ' l4:ltt woita
i ftP9"1 4 .% 1 0 i = . , grer 4 er ..ll #P - 4' . ;...Ai . :4..tifilol
: iiffi'-igh-A.C-Ad ' flivii•Ceivil49...t4'..iii`itbn . in.
~.Iyll. l ll#llti thd comae contemperatioons with
',.;1 llatlttii4isidonirstia; or: any dedlideiral:.Ones,'
- 140 ,: ftiiim.:tho:teeilmOisitit; liiiiiiiitiosVdtkt•
ioidliit&thOinottlai.}7'aildllia.,:tidtiti9iithielt
i tlO*Oiffldnie;iihibicilkilo : Nicbir:tgat:
: imtijeaq tg , :tli6ll4 l:
1 1 4 1 1oilstcleeditiiit to
: ) sfo4thsieliqii hiefiat;4! . ritueilcA ; " - to
":.. - .P*;o"t'itist-. l l4o 3 ;;MOPettreafA)titletioi:. ' te ,
IPA' th4.:tiimrliitietitlter tft:'. ikii;il 'volts, to
hikPalent,,ot,:itareh' Iltb, 1844 3 ,:he'.16; it:ie . :lp,
4 nittil it! hy, Weide,. 'ironing . the - gitilit Atr.thai:
', hind7of "s hirred icititie liiiikikigiverk . an'
7 . TaapoMtte-tint:OhOiltitoisttitllied-to.hts oppli-
'• 6.551.,i51r.., wh at ' lt la, f '044:0 fie* his,
t alent o z enee"i6L4l?as,,which ho *settled.
rektiii foliiiiiiiiistidelt Phattrtio :say!, nt
"1f0,116 - ", - ..42o".44:l.iliAtllWaiti• apt:lie:hit spid 'e
.I[r;;llitvidliaitypsn- the: excluslyiltisht UP
' WitiettligniMintik : 64i4 . shiqatiNli f
itik*ipicti" . ",4CiYaSn'k, Pik ii,s,ooo!',4lo"doei
. *eirj ,, !- " the .1 - ight to - inenafseinr6.'stilikrisi l
liii*ft.....#4lt . ...been thet.langettle, .it. would
ba r' . Atli,ii xtV. , .. 1 '.0 031 :3: ,der!;, Ahe . defendant/1!
•NOW:sie'-kopw ehat:that- minlnsive right was
• S.lNcil,ati,f)3lihs'inif to;00,4114•,:-.114weafthe.
.if
tug t . re 4 .'intinufaiterirgOcid it 'it Oder' ihe,pittteit,'
tilc 3 ,ooo.;'A l t , !_ ,v!:‘,Xtioltt,,k: i.. - 01;x4ir . .. -
. Iraids , :ihti appliiiipt..beight '.'thii.,rlght.hittlie
X.00*0.3144 '"? i:r`4' s "' 'Shortly ,aftiir,.
• applicant sold thrritolorliTent.Achiii,,s!lniiiiei
'whirred good,, one to T enn ft - ..ioit, - *.:.
titer to the' , l•lewark :India ollubbor laanefat;
tering OoMpany; "and *a third :to Onderdonkllit
tLetion:: ,, .• ''% *3 :. P, • .. . W hen thosoftlerodut 'of,
4),oo4l44 . isitil.b . r,y,th6.eseliontreit rights
irtkiiptitisfered . ,lhat s thi!.;#o:o4 . griods ; ins:.
'r , r,Ope,/ii..iifiglit ii61,1iVen.444.00.,Dai:”... Ism-
AlfelYigiff..9.7.4_APPP.P -; :.:04. 0 9P Aiggoiii
•., oi, r oh7theidluerent. other raghts.he has •Sold,
16 'l4, V .l f_ —Olt iiii!'e." l . 6 :RlOKO."... ti:9 l .. 4 ; l o " 9'isi
the right SO 'make'. baby-jusspersithe% right to .
make diilir,',Spiloga,"ttie:,iighepto,enthe*Ptleapi,
foe railroad - ears, the right te, eiaito• Clothing,
tho right to Mike baper-hoMen or, bands, the ,
ArAethltriSkS' . .,liiilliag,,.'&o . ...!, ;:xO,-... *kali
Illyi:owtied.tholhii and fibs:At:to tiottopeiiies
lilr t VeitlialiiidiCte....ntake!e)titiiii44)e; no
3414iiiier . tylentrelti . for not a' , dollar.lrfit . r.e.;.
4(ii4l - *:ifilii4 i4O : 1 1 iO '' , a - 1iii,414 , 4046 13 ,..
dietteriihWhYttl Ili, 11 44 12 tYi0. r Il i ftkif",,,.*i n g
• icuiltfi #4 l !..4 deka '6 n
t*lil4ll lLßa * is 'tfk ti ci i d ,:g * o:; aP afetio ';da :P ri oi 'Pt l C'i ,y n :if ; - l the "l4 :i T r r h i l ti rr ir od °:
goids„ arid at this litidifirtligtritamitiflitlinf.
,he i5y5;... 4 05W41,?t5:52 . 40 1 5.0;". 'Now,
if Day:had -roititeiseholemonopoly to. metro 'n:iiiiii kid :sewed, as well as cemented ilootitt,,
no ono' had It. Goodyear: num Ignored it
when he made ,
application for 'the . ettetielow
. .. . ,
4)." ! ipatent-, fA ifiiitmveF,: / s t t.follo . 85, ,alter
ktig of the - goittr.64 - eridas.4:lWeeti himself_
.111f4ft46214143; 1.10fti11*184.4 hi eiyoy,
i. lie" one! at, et* `. agvieniente was 0 .
i+ to t sideflajf:thi.itsitir64lght . Ofifotti:i
• tiOrtinittelSoi thoionsgeilieftelo;:et.::o 'hi* .
iffso &IMO. 30.41F110; WOO. t1i, : r41 0 . - #
..1
el44l4lol4o.l)Eiltit4 , Jft.e.trialtd:.-Yottr , aik . , -
; iiipiqgli;699 I . l,oo:l4KlitintErigli,N"kid:Stre elf .
• ifoil#4.lst..*.ly44.4iee' peiturforVisgolf square
irkiitints4&* 4 , . !Ciiii_Llet ` • We . .Woa ' 1 .„ . % , Re- .
feeringattr f lip; t h e w esmttent„dp.Fillebe:sieen ,
. tithr:,.,_,, IterAlea?,.`iftikk - ilt.ihilloOdgbenitido
stdifittitl:Wiiiiitditid*
.Matin nadoe the eon- .
trj"etir':loo;4l/sal,fifsiedietir,-,tiayli,..nt folio,
*SifilliikAtAiiitilathooB6%.,l7oll: *gide Oli Ol!t,
• CB4-it,71010.., 10.,#348/14021)n.fkinge.
iiiirsttrotne°..rtgutii.tionr% , tppficanti ., !sioV :
itl.4<iiiP.lo4 l l*l'OgifiCtst,' . 9. l o.#._Pii@e 14 . 2 _ ,
iqiral' :151401 ' , a lice ins t ;,fiing"."arsongst others ,, •
Iti'lini"bitenit Ceiredt. tlit7,United ~ itittiSiloi.,
thiptett,retbcNPlV,4 4s *, ii: 0 # 1 6*04 1 .•8 1 4 40, 1 .
other jin.iAititi:, , Heat eleitti.WMre pending, for
•
. * liiistilme,, were severely contested, sad very)
fltilienelTia.!:' , , : ,-. '.. ,-..' : ..• :. ::, , • ~•; i e . - A
i;r›i.f.•. - -.tir , •. i
the'-:,') .: ..%•'"'
4g.lfiatiOt •We. look at billja;pfow-Jorsoy;
' ""
''' .'diti*hat:Petetittlitlvetlfiekiltri*s,
" . ...llefringisgivin , Ifialilllt3tIOII::
: it 4.. 4ii:lWtoith,tile:.74sl4 .4.iietieein : thernV
liftlii , " . infrlngeinent,',:ted. t . ttesl,44 , dont t eeis 'or
1840f,thit; the. billiti&nnetit O'fisiiilott :Geed
fe:oAiitOefittits ititi s Set forth : fi*Moon After .
,i4ti-s#ement and Said iiceute said-fist ",iitii.:.
, - . o;.;iiiiiii.#'o":lES:EifiirStaiiinis 0011101 )4:
•- . *iiitiirOr r AtOkeiteritlionOftrttqittibb`or
`,,ttiflifitinfrAnillig: OtinTkiiiibtiet than - .those
vAlitell4,iiii , .;) l o4o, In itolidooif,iow
kii:i4iikiliirte,ooo l 4o - orodAlioi.; . .
la r it ir0i . 11414/ - ;illitiieisoaOf eciiire4,oiiiiiireo;
I,,iiV ~66,j;10:-.Viiiiiii dot:1,011SO? oil .
0 101.WW;;Z:Ba.kb: 8 :, 5 iif 0314..4...iii.4. large
:1 - Mitillif , :fir. , z 1! Ear-appiori , !piici.ittigi.;heie,
' ri . ..l.l4l4 o o4ii's l 4lo,o B ;;ioCtf:kani4):3' 4 ..':
Jr.,#4;:#lloPfriflig,fll4)!ltl:#4' by ' he,
if
g T.0.P.44011** 4 .itritri440,044•Wit. 6 /: B OPh ii r:, 1
1 . :44 1. 1Niktkile. s .atiftfcilit.h 41 0 .3 ?.. , . A 6 iv , .
'die Olignio*.W•lehe'lliißriiliiiiiibe7initiiil
t kiklijirsfti,Det. • • )t"thYtill? . t!kttr.thteil2sen
:iiiiiitteg l . ol,4.lkitre;'"ifs , :ipill . :iii::::Oninfid !
ri - eti - ; ; ;Olit 10 - #40,, :y.i . 4.,z7.601,_iiiii0:-,441,nat
f . 0113i . ; fill tieVirotilt bOtirt efAist:f.slerinsy,":fer.
s ti+oli4l.lo4A!filli.:!4;lo,..ritiH ', s4:o4 ., :t . .*- 6 i , ' - ',
6 ,4 ooo4 : lB46.,l , o7,nwomOrio . cetta.:nsing
. .4nlit4oo . 43lo447to:tilitoi Ottai , eirttellie..tio
kaiiiitrisoOktli, making under 4:pie, con;',
- fro I have,juitt.'eneinerated
-8 1Foib,:. 6 nri - eaokfiiit,itioricit hf0.,, , r,
.„ 0 ... * 0 0 04,0 : 5 00 00. Ilithitt'wkren Ir.
ilieslit elattlfeOplie.,.l , lF rt";? i -t",! ....;:" 1 .••' , ..
0.1... '.r.,cz, t. ...i.,:r. - .....,,,t, 4, , , ... -1 •
, •
L sk. 4.o . %l9li,Visififip*4lY;o6Bribst;" ribs
yVelict,i,ibic r la r aiidifiiii7ii.6o' .. diriraerniii k in.
litisfii:eig Itiol**C4liiriii4a . apy, ip'dteitipi 64'
lii..`•itiiiittilfli4hOt - 'ilii;;i4d dbe general loin'
rAiitifid.„ oe:OtrAg04:ka08;!!-Tn.the Con
.fiii4iof•lB46' iii i l trait. thony.tir; the . artieleit
.144.pedin•Alio.'..pntent....ot: MakoitSt; '1844 7
. 00:11:e . contranyiiiii there.jititiektrything to
sitopititeeitPiionrY4filipiii:Ainlant to InelnAo
liflikiiidnOtk itaieii. .:ii : ttoiii. . gelid
. ; geods 1 In
Anti ilqiii!-,ll,....2l9,t:Or:tierls.ititltuit' tie very ;
lingneio.ofAihp,apkticatitiifor the cxtenSion.
of WA pitentili*.l4lsieri(ehl ; :tinti`•,ir its
"sop' oty , P to hay• , ..i. , ‘l -: y,-1 . : . . -..-- *--..1. ... 1, •
latent of
limit also at , tho . :olasille#Utie tii . .the
gnitet,of Dupont & Ely.att,...lt,ts Teliiiistly itio •
:PT . o l ,,t,l;i i i*t,.4.9'„ , trni , !Fbh - Tot. , ‘ , 3k . ... 4 .;fiiiiid •
igOo l ltrWiiis:iine...that was ISA-kit4n; *arid'
- tlfak - 441Miefere;'thiii•terd'.Was) . ttti j . tivistlciti of
;,.obedyear .ehen lie took out his paten t .- •• ' •
.... .... .... . . .... . .. .. . •
,lint.lia, there anything in. the patent itself of
liiiriikikl4,4 t - , (4; nkidi# l .llie!;tosit of this'tirM
I tillblinill or: 4 3.ooiiiiiiill ' OY.AtiOilyearipiss
'orltiOklike f f,' , ;iili*iinioti*ii,.'ol l # o o l Linider.
its 4 idea t.! its 11iStoIrt remarked, Good
;ear4"dtii'net'",'flivifil' thelitiiid . shiered;, and
surely ~ coiragstedl;;lwnte. g :ivied .. that he
soVll . lnkiie Joao& in tisirjAletiouary lit"' the
sporl,:161014?;;, 5' S p irte d, " the testimony',
ligtyill44iiiit(.4 teriiP-Illiciwri'ond.- applied to. an
.hinterterabie - Warlett , of:goos, - -; :Rossi Cioisa-
Year*etencl,.in:the patent,orAta* ,IY, 184 4,
:that :lie invented. ft i.= ice* jtt: it 11::. :No* let
Its eoustrlie tht patent altokettliiir...:•Xt_ls.tine,
• ;says et "the Cortinioniiiiint,'4ll4 speoifi T
eldiskiii that
.I . itevelnvented a new and useful
iii*iiifecture,
.whieh ,4 I denominate' tOrre
itsts*.o.r shirred 'lndia-Rubber' goods,ii.: , ,Bot
100 ii . ivilat PO reel ly
,patoota.• Moeshe Patent .
d new'reantifeeturo?•Tirtiit does ho call 'tin
hi a . aPpiteatiOn t 6 ittotnienttlitliO'ioren; ei
tension, when ho eimake.of 'baying Sold` it to
Sosdatil 7 :kiiiiv •ii iniirinrenient.": What:
doett hi:VsaytiolOw id: hig_claiiiil • bOoslt read
thus? :‘ --"/ llaviiefor - the ;purtioaci of putting
the -.public in: possneidort ',et thy Invention;
talli,deseritiCd the nature Of toils anufacturci.•
Whicst4,ia/.l. l oymicl or corrugated goods." If
iiiiitiliskticsn . -,9 . 9 istigsago nee‘thoro would
.11 - *Tif*AnP-tl. =rorc. ° - !P': the, . eon!tructiesi
ilihne s d *be defendeits. But the langnago
" ' tilei' .-o •Xlivingi -Scot , fully . describod - the
.I:4liiir%:.li ;V ,i4r, liMil)a . 4t4pl','Cßl:rui-ate'd
4eirtish,s).Tfien'tliero4itif,i. manufa cture be
: lool . ttlik,iketdroidWll.lkciA , lo: ; tlkiiirint. oh
:the .fare :Ol'. : . difi..,.!piteoL.- ; -11e . i.,continues :
• t ? e fA ii4 -2,1/01141, also '06:''!ll 44er tn .
, *llia: 1- manuflesturelthe •Aernei What 'claim!
iiir,:tesi,ilheroin„(rmillitt'...thai:theie . nits
; tOtioktitiitlikelt big . pkt) and . dosii6 to secure •
.)4flitgeji[pittent; ii.:the,f;:i Ming et . suettgoode
mAoV,4*.hiog . or 44, tir.throisacalidia
• 3piiibir,ro...iuo3 - eit:eit as nitrite "deskikim,/
• Vik,o : 4: - . oqing of said, stripe ' Ori.'.."WripOitti, sides
;tett& .t tie '::lenilla93 . of 1 oloth,- , leather; ": or 'any
! Ttoio:ellitatilti malarial Which' la:ninon • t o
: he,nulted "to each other and to Lilo. thresh, or
etilpi or eletii, - lii 'nielins'. of._ Indfit-rubhor
cement, the'ssmo :being effected so as to' pro,
,dote to; manufactured : article.su ch. as . herein
• :Set fortti- , New-what is h is. patent / 1t la a
*** . ,.....ptii66,p , 4.)4oii:.i..iimikoltactiir6 that
'was knoWn before:' Itistead" tif: malting tor
' ilikited 'goods kesaiitilibir . treating, .Ithich
was st- tillatOry grneeeti,,he mokei them more
Ailiiiiky. and 'quickly
.I*. cementing. - - That is
- mist hefistosts,-s new, mankifocturo of cor
-4i1t.141.10041it •It TO . kl.low.:01?(I' niond int
THE eft.ESEC:-PHiLADW.
s'3 g, llttittitiands
er by the law:or 180;
le, i thbVetge:bl'isif; tifitu the laninaie
fiattutt;-Ari/it. the tostimortY t 4 1,34 4 ,,,
and . from the lang r usge of. Gocalvlr 11111041 i
his"..applicatiott"to• thit,looindledikteil
!ratentli,,thitis: he" dik. nee infeitil:tii'lltelt, lit
grantiu'lhe : Oentri,titliffitflNE46 lit:tr goods
:n s tig !cadet. ttio:iatontAirrtvpiticti ! , . •!.
fief ue"noi geed( plsco;laAApitiliia in lice
:Cettateral s thiktlE A:4ood
haViff Veen* Any `ottioel.ititeitilop,to# 'the pill
of F
Gotsi Sc'.sl"4ollo:iiiil 4 l:!ksti
. e.'tf itssiggaimoul,sp'the 28th for
Sept. ln
ut0,438 . 68, to the IndiajtublieK
Company, thy* likAute portitikitlthilt struek
my -Wed, •iiirelby, •drt connectiort•itith this
hitestiel‘,:lter.gties : on to idyl 4 .l.revi, in con =
sideration'of the premises, and of'tho:sum of
tBO,OOO paid to the party Of tiiii , "flMt•part by
the parties of the second;:part; ' the recolpt
;whereof is 'hereby aOthowled, and of the la.
riffs heroin
,epoopled, , the parly ot tho first
pa?C'hse :giapted, hargalned,ssold, and con.
•yoyeci- unto the parties of tho' oocond part
the full, ;ilia ol lite, and `exclusive Deena o,
itight'acid•prlvilogot6m.ke'titetp;:,arid,Vend to
Aiwa: toheitifsed; theinvention ; lOpthanlsed
as the wfme May or
'can be iitied.in the Maisniactnio of Xll brpided,
woven, centeisfed-qr 101064;tabrlie,•or:Snefilas
are or riartiii covered;or r prltteeteton Ohe 'or
both sides,..wknio44iic . tv;idhor than rib
ber:, tindin ail 311100* itaiftelliiryfdgodde."l I
cite this`feill the purpose of 'asking this tines
,unestiont Why,* if theta were neit,„other
shirred goOds Made, than. those under tee pa
tent of March 9,t11d he :lid '1.1100 ( In
hero 1 ilocanae it is admitted that Dar held
the right to. shirred goodi at this thskii. : ;:Does
It, not show that there wore , other- ahliithd
goodghan these made undoitttiCipatitiii,lof
March li t 1844 ' I cite it : let .tilit t .turphile,
iurd'that'atono. 1
tot 119 now look at tho three license . ..attic=
'tarred to in the contract ;,..This first
IS the license' to Hutchinson &"Itounipii:on the
12th of August,, Isls. It aonviyi
‘; free licoriso to manufacture, use and vend
,stiirred or corrugated goodi t of every descriP-
Ilov," In so far as the said' Charles Goodyear
play,have, any rights co,i4iirlviiegos. -Shirred
goods of every descrtpllo4 4 NO% the con
tract of tho 29tti of Otitoher, 1810, between
Goodyear & Day, the language is, to make
ttio, and vendall shirred or corrugated
-goods," 'exempt so far . as Goodyear has parted
with Abe right by three itemisestherefore, It
isimportantto aseertitin what those titre° 11-
conseticontain: Geicitilyearconvois to Hutchin
son .e Runyon the right to use his inventions
In the manufacture or_ shirred. or corrugated
goods of every description, is so 'far' ash
a tjest:to reit. NoT, ie had fhb 40 to sin
tije irivemtloria, underjtkiateatsof March o t h;
1844. Bet.there saresome.thlngs that he had
note right to do. ", Ho. had no monopoly in
woven goods made 61 'common gum,. bat, he
Could seifihdright,iii . cornet:Red goods
of common. rubber. and of , vulcanigedsrubbor,
and lits:eintld9Ktite;:tight, to:sititie woven
goods' iietintigint.sed rubber and ? theired'ore, ho
puts that De)14:1; also, In
hisllntoblihnin,&ll f unithj . ibitt they
shalliieSt biM , at ,ttitOrtitsi 4C:tent:Conte per
isquartiffitiosaii 4 tudd' ahisfelA.:o44<which
'.they ortthigi:damsoi ith imikeihy..or under,
• mot . thicitit_Sistsof nidir any
ithprovementi, or letterspatent
before) Mentioned:" Now, can any One doubt
about that cMmtitiotlenl X 4 . 40 net, a shadow
doubt that Ile . Inietificti,toigbli. to It Whin
son &Runyon, lidensd, f the' right to
manufacturo::Sa kit* Akio :nods,
iviiqttio : . ) ,they: %lice° sionimited, opkTod 'or
woirentand 'to use lit filitilf:mainfacture
_his
thilangnage. !It
could not be plainer; are to pay Good.
yoar ten cents per square yatd 'on all thiried
* goods idilehlbey Cr their aisignkshati nitaho l or
, • U5O to be made (.by or under any of the; in.
Sinlions,'lmprevomonts l ; ; l4;lotietillit4 llll )itt
fore montioned.” Thigslts•gaydf Butch
son Runyon mate itrien'iiii*ed:6o6434.ol:
toq]
cents a, beCtinfiligierliro Matt
them under",thirilitent'oThiarAc t ,4B,4l, I
.theycontnititie Ai' eff:aleuth:o o o. Oat)
4 diinltkigalim.#grs.n3',Of
Melinda' isofte::: U - dti net: think the •Thigr
VialtUgultiti*liYiliii l :',. o ° Mktg':
*amber, IMO, :rautehholifin .&. , R ny on.
idinvoi Goodyear.thiti , :l . Conse, in gerieral
s
term, Ibr the manufacture "of ahhtid ;OS,
ittrugated India Robber geode."
•
• ;Vie
,(('tense to Onderdonk & Lots* Wa6
giantiikiti. ; ilieptomber,..lB4s. It is Am a It.;
eel*? piptitimfacture, 11514 ' ; and vend Shined
bi tortugito goods, of , every description, In
..kefft4 011,994 Year may have any rights and'
pill Legge ; relating theroto. It scents to be a.'
,doW`o
:61:theAter; and is substantially the
recionvoyet to Doodyear on
. .
Thii,thfird Rein* to:1401i Cits 4 lifalao In
the samolpnpirella intagei!:.theirall.seom to
coool . . : Orioott.ogiot:';',Vor Feson
voyed to:bogged:On:WS Bd-or December,
' ' 7 - •
• - There Vic I.rellirence made by the•COSISOI
for the'defendiiiite (Mf. Marshall) in Viiiefsin-
ment,:to the release °Eerie of those licenses
by the Noialk Rubber Oe.s—the Hntchinsoni &
.. ,
Runyon license—which professes to
make release,
only the right to ake the ; goods under, the
patent of March Oth. The.,rolease bears ne'
ditto, but WAS reeOrdedXSiGke. 9th of Deisoni
li 1f46) - i ittrtiite, "eoPiritlit •en the Part of
' O l CoP:i9illiyikittilil , ":" And the said Com;
pisetcovenantii:,iaisCagroier. to :and with the
eidtkilharies dooditelis, Giat•griy will not ma
rinfaceure ahliriWpi t ititicubted, India Rubber
goCds, hi violatiOnN ( 'Gil patent for Said ma
nufacture, leined'ikdarlos G,oodyear 'cm the
Oth day of Maroh,;lB44:" The granting part
hrz,-;gt Know all : ** by these prottenle, that
tie; Newark. India': R übbor Manufacturing
1:101X1011,114 iii delielderation of One dollar to
likelepaid bYoharies Goodyear, has aesigned
fit thegidtharles Geodyeatiand his assigns,
all their:lnterest in the Within, instrument,
and ovory.::elause, articlo,''Sie..Abig therein
ftiontained." The assignment"; is t .therefore;
genera; tilt Merely. the covenant, that they
will-not manufacture ebirred or Corrugated
goods, that refers ,to the patent•Of *Arch 9.
But Wis something remarkable that-on - the
edam day they made a general release and a
general covenant, as follows: 4 4 For and in
consideration, cif 'ono dollar, to las in hand
paid, by (Bnten Goodyear, end in considera
tion 'of other good catiees us therounto mo
ving, wo hereby assign, transfer, and sot over
to said Oharltil'peodyear, hie executors, ad.
ministrsiersoinirwisigne, the' within license,
right andlirivillegicand the assignment there.
of to us, entreat rights granted or lotended to
be'granted thereby or, incidental thereto, in
as - fall and' - ample a manner as we now hold
and possess the setae. And we also stipulate,
covenant and agree that' we will not, after the
Ist day of January,. one thousand eight hue
dred and `'forty-seven; . directly or indirectly
manufacture, or he concerned in the menu
fichire, of shirred or `corrugated India Rub
ber, goods:" ' So it appears that, finding their
error, they correeted ' R." One release Is en
dorsed on the assignment, and ,the other. on
the original license. ' :
I think, 00,far as I have been. able to draw
Itiinforence from those licensee; that they
tlitrongthon the conclusion to:which I have
arriiiidtbat in the jaentracC-of October, 29,
1848 i the ceablrred or corrugated geode"
Meant ALL RINDS OP swum) Oa' 0011.V.170ATHD
a001113;140EPOISO OEHRIPPPD, WOVEN, Oft saweD,
and is not limited to the goods made under
the Patent of Mira 0th;1844.. : - -
And, this is further - apparent *hen we look
at the license to Suydam : . The argument for
the - defendants Is, that Goodyear, when he
used these words In the instrument of Octo
ber 29, intended only•the goods made under
the' patent of , March ; 4 l .4l4:'*:o# As '2lth' of
May,. 1844; GoOdyear sold iolloydares the
right to manufacture shirred itoode under, the
patent of Match 9th. The 'tromp exProse
ly limits his right to those goods alone. • It Is
not, 4. I sell the right to make shirred or cor
rugated goods," but it ieciteii • 44 All My
right, title; mid intirUit in andth two certain
patents granted to rue by the United States
of America, both dated the 9th day of March,
1844, for an, improvement in India Rubber
fabrics." Now, I hold it to be very clear that
If a man owns typo rights , to manefhature goods
by patents of different dates, ensile sells to ,a:
his right under ono specifically; and' to B ttio
right to manufacture the geode generally, as a
matter of course the fair construction of the
latter grant will be held to be a conveyance of
the right, to manufacture, under both patents ;
because In file first grant, when ho Intended
MErY - URPA,Ire . 3131 - 31 , o°. 1859.
Wt.. )(inertia rto eealtda ori-tho.fses-Of itie .
g ,tinit,.N..,„.„o4,Li-84413kp0;
be nee 000,orine id go over alit
gronintio very ablyoectlpled by the learn
ceanaetiortritotb - dfdee; nbt ab o
to do justice to lip, not r LIOLD TOE TITLE P.
I) A.T! ft 9 : . OLll.lt TIES OrIETRAGV
TUE 2Oru OF OOTOBEfti /041 J, TO WE VULOA
17,61 •RullOsf. 41, Tl 4 lust:victims ..oiVatt
BfilitßlLD GOODH, .oupgays THEY DB OEDIESTSt,
altiVID) 0 / 1 4 4 9.V.44....10 :•
BM I wintry cwor4 or tstoOn tho deed tt
the 240. or Atity, 1808.,1r Ookratmor zmuniois
ALL THE magliass. 0011081ININ0. wlitall tllllB
002p4OVARII,Y RAO.AItIOVIUBX XXPItROS *LULL
ROT /SRARTF,O tO DAY BY THE OONTRAOTII OD,
TLIEr PABBED Olt TUB TERMS OF I'll 6 DERR
Of:1808: I do rfotspoak nowabout the valtdrly
of itr--whether it operates in piesinli orlfffo
loro—bu4ufttf roue stt . uses,terfus whfUh . will
embracellieso articles'. It grants to pay ,tho
right to usa :Ctoodyear.'s-tuvention of vulcia•
nized rubber for the present and all eaten*
or renewed teirris'of said 014 . 6; as the ,satne
mayor s ian ho" used the manufacture of It
,(( ;. ttrividod, woven; cemented,' or sowed fabrics,
or such as aro or eau be covered or protect 4;
on one or ;both sides...with eubetances oth:er"
than rithbor, and in all articiath,elantic, shirred
geode." ' , NOW, if Goodyear htid tho riiht,
make ~ f, b li' g entit when ' lie made . It, the title
, would Cobiso pass underit,'„ . Is it not a.
perfect deed in itself ' ? Tble4eed 'was , 'pt.::
tacked on the ground 'that it^wati nnt valid. ,
But it fa a deed under 'sealiletlitur giveft for
a consideratiOn;and it speattftgn presepti.
deed conveys a : title , althongb it maytts;vo.
covenantsin it which have not bedn perthrtnd4
There, aro thing's wilier rest , in grantfled
things Whit% ' rest ' in covenant. in Rican, at'
every lease,or deed,„if not quite every oh!,
(hero Is tiOthothing that rests in grant andtiotticr
thing.that rests in Covenant. The words lid
this grant aro, et I hereby
_license, and:
Comfit" There it hi,: ; it operates
sa a grant. , Then it says, (.4 I ngroo to can.
fine." That Is a covenant for farther an.
scrum., , Than it ssys;.(f I hereby authorize
and empower the said Day to use my name:to
premectite and defend the rights and Privilege's
hereby granted." , Then it provides : < «And.
the terms and conditions Upon which this•
license shall iield and enjoyed,. as 'to
bonuses; not exceeding in tiro 'whole the stlni :
of: thirty theunand 'dollars, and Bit I.olifi,,rit
exceeding ?lie cents a pound on the :piddne.t.,
aball be fixed-and determined by Nathaniel
Hayward and, Thos. A. Jouckon, vvitoso award
in the promises shall be final, and shall be trtiple.
within throe months from tho 18th dnY' orb%)
next."'
Now, I am not called upon' to give a con
struction to this Covenant in this deed, as to
Whit might be its °tract. , But.Goodyoar made
It, and with It be made a grant in presenn.
If the covenant falls by hls the grant'
nevertheless stands.: The covenant does not
effect the, grant ; the . great' passes the title
and operates isPresenti. The covenant may ,
have beeense Impossible, ity'the expiration )of
the time, but yet the grant stands. • Is not that
well known principle In the :'common law ?
If by the expiration of time. such a covenant
becomes irriposalble, the pint' kends.
tint, bititioedyear this 'flight on the 24th ' of
May, 188E4? ,Thst . depends ,upon the con
struction Which you give to ~ the . licento rof
Goodyear to the Naugatuck Company on the
18th of July, 1844. Dtd that license catiry
the right of the , Naugatuck Company into
the . eitonded term of the, patent of Juno 15,
1&14? .. . •
' Now, If the Supremo Coed Jiiie decided
that, question there, wocid be mai of it. Beit I
do not consider that question al decided In 20
' Howard. Courts are i Called -# h only 'to
decide questions that , sea 'lan Illiem. I A
ilm ile
Judge sometimes, 'ha' giving iiiil.V ibion, uses
, language which, although It ler alwaym entitled
' *consideration and reaped, yet)n reforedco
trhquestions thaeiiiitio riot before the Co4rt,
it* the deoldonorialitch was noFnecessa .to
ite docislotiiilke,questions bade it, is 401 , "
of bindin2 authority.:-' The' doe in 10 Howdrd
was thie i 'Lleiaittophiliiiel of the violation of'
theChattee Patent by: the, Upton Clompally.
Of.conree,'be could not- recover unless be
could satisfy the Churl that he was the °wrier
. .ottiitipaierit,• 'The Court decided that. hew*
:64ke D inn l er,..• , •+: :••:,. e.'•: la, s,) , -, • v... : s
s ,
.F ThaVWpoitits in lbeitliiiiii% Vilittill i
gilltreititrelerencl to the •Tiestion of the
+filidifiNittti deed'O . 1868. In the7oiso of
n .
: //koiol44o'rit t the . Court 'had' decided
thifthe Chaffee Patent was in Judson for Hine'
benent or Goodieitr. 1 They speak of two odn
*tracts that J colon made, hut the decision reets
upon the last contract of the 12ttiof;NOVitu.
bet. In 'that *case of Day . es. Hariaßirsi,llt
will be foand that. Chaffee attempted ` , to' set
iesido Ids contracts with . Jaded+, ' because, the
contracts bad not boon , perfornied: I read'
ftorn IP Howard, 222, in reference to my,
la 4 statement in regard to the operation of the
deed 00858 : " From.the awing and ;Wet,
of the agreement the remedy for' tho ' breach.
Could rest only upon the personal obligation
of Judson, as by the previous one of the oth
of September, the interest In the patent . bad
leveed,
,to Goodyear and his licensees, and
'ikoddeult or act of Judaon could affect them.
'Chaffee chose to be satisfied with the covenant
, of Judson, without stipulation or condition as
ii, respected the other, parties, and be must be
consent with It." So the Court .decided in
Oat ease that the Chaffee patent williii/08011,
liftlielbeneflt of. Goodyear.
:. - • ,
" .:... ffil,:yoigain complains o r the Union Company
fey terplation of the same patent; cleimlni
41t161titinself by tho same Instrument. Tho
Court say, In this case•of Day vs. The Unioil.
Company, (20 Howard, 211:,) " Tho Court held
lu the case of liar/shorn 'et. al. es: Day, that
under the agreement of the,sth ot September,
1850, between Judson and Chance, the paten
tee, the entire ownership in the. patent, legal
and 'equitable passed to Judson for the Murat
of Goodyear, and those holdiag rights ; urter
him, and on that grouud decided in favor of
the liedisees• Now, in this case, thelicenses
under:Goodyear to manufacturheloth, Of the
description 'claimed are 'tut broad and aniple as
were thobta - of the delondaeits in the ease jdst
mentioned. Goodyear became the sole owner
of the Chaffee patent as early as 'the 28t1i Juni),
184 t, and on this 18th July following gave a
linenpo to the NaugateCk Company .to reedit
fadure cloths, with certain exceptions, neater
all his patents—those in which he 'Was thou in
terested, or in which lie .rulght thereafter be
Interested, Issued or to be issued, &dialer, In
all, renewal or pstente. Ho also gave a like'
extensive license; on the 18tii of Barth, 1817,
to W. E. & John Rider, for' manufacturing
ships!, letter and mall , bags."
Now, I have a most profound respect for
the learned Judge who delivered this opinion;
:but-air the case turned not upon this question,
but upon other points; these licensee have to
be :Critically examined ; beeriuse it will be ,
found, on looking at the licenses referred to'
by the , Court, that, they aro .different la
a lap- ,
guage . and: in terms from ' the Naugatuck
time°. But what does the Judge say, when
ho dimes to the point on which the *owes
deckled I " All Those various licensee after-
Wilfil.became consolidated i n the Unionl
, n.
.
die Rubber Company,the defendants In Ude
suit ; ;and present, therefore, a compliki de
fence. to the suit, If Goodyear was the trio
owner of the Chaffee renewed patent." .'(And
thoy decided, as they say, a little below,thid .
r ho alas.) " The Mouse of tho dottandid#s
- in this ease atands upon two gronside,
oithei of which would seem to constitute !a
sufficient defence to the suit for infriegemenii
First, authority from Goodyear, tho Oireor 4.1.
the Towed term of the patent ;.andoiecend,
the express recognition of Chail'ee, the Paton;
tee; of the right of these parties, as licenseei
of GiOdyear, to use the improvement. And
we.miry add to , these grounderof defence,' that '
. uponztlie" interpretation of the Cieutt, id thou
steise of !Hartshorn: vs. Day, .of the several.
:igrodments relating to able patent, and esPO
i olaliy; that of the sth of September, 1850, Day
took no interest in It uedor the asslinment Of
Chaffee, of-let of July, 1863, he .having, pre-'
vide to that time, parted with all hie Intordst
tenths benefit of Goodyear and his licensees."
Those aro the grounds upon which tho
Code put , it. 'There was no question before
them :About the renewed or extended. term .of
the Patent of 'June:l4lB4l grill I presume it
was never argued. ' It was another patent, en
tirely;rthe, Chaffee patent 7 -and the decision
is pet upon the ground that the complainant,
Day, had no right whatever, if the patent ilea
violated, to recover ; and that wee sufficient to
decide that case. But the Court wont on and
decided that the defendants had a right to the
extended tair "of the Chaffee patent, under
the license from the Naugatuck Company.
Ifoiv r iehat Is that license'' - "That the bald
:10,f,Y4PrObleAnict -ftliPtlighownbendrtiPriNOßdz
halhliginetr 'and ?granted * " IPt
Ifitglit9,'o44Vglibber ra'jfAff
absolute liconan pito anj ant filth!.170011- =
biern l „' 6 l'lo4 _glibber, and 1 41Tiyitbittinleltt
tli Vrapatatlan , of.rndia 'l4,ol:diet . fer
Ilitl.p.ealtsitui4i:aiey nth& *Melo ;if theretiaa-
dtsei:prank maple ter,blettltie,'aanie,inefr:lie
apillaable;f6rind during the nnaiplretl : tepbi .
of all , „l.)atchle:leatfeil to hint110404107:00,
ohatsciiivei.i . 'here la a full sentence. He
giros It to the* dtirlorthlWeiii - r 7 i;t 7 ;ll 7 Pititeila.
Isai to'hinar_lio4lng arty .. ~fste ;,►eifatsuo+reri
: , ':And for- and' during the lineal:46'4 tot* er
tit* of any otherPatont, it:at:anti, -renewid
of patenta, owned_by him'Matla - that he then
~ o wa)4,).or•in which he may'haYo att intoiea4 .
11411(4 Or to' be ;hatted." Thikiltiktil:' - cOyer
eases-islietn-be might- have hid in hitereat hit
efiatent,whiett hart ntitheenz larded ;npfoo'
Courts have.decided that you cart sell in Wee!"
eat in a patent that is to beiartnad:
'Now read it the other say',-'as the 'coutisof
foi. 'the de fendittte
and during the' unexpired term ofjall patents
: latiOd'.to hint", bearing; sii date Whatioeier,,
andlreneivala ofqiistente b*ned by hiiii;:nr in
wlitchheotaX4VO,,WlnfOriat, laanedier,to be
issued;" 'tau would have Mixt Using the woid
issued twice, heetinie luta - granted, atioie.,l
the rigliCto than:lie, of his - patents •issued to
him , bearing 'any date-whatsoeVer, thleti a
full grant )" , litid 'then" lie gifants•to
.theidin a
differeitfiente±neeihe id it for 'ild . dirirg the
unexplied term„or. terns of:sany-other patent
or patents or renewals of - patents, owned by
" Does not the : Wont "reiievtale, ' *44B
sentence; rOet't , P4enfa,tili 4 erefili*‘o4 by
him but not batted to hlin:Lbecanae,therta waa
the Ohaffae , patent which"' was &tined , by but
net issued 'to hlnfi . -Or' to tficiie 01 . 9 :k lie
ririQirt'hhvo en; in4restcfni the invention fo be
patented I , -
,-, t ,,„lkTow,let Os look' at - the license-to Trotter.
Soe the difibronee in' the language. It la a
licenaa6 use any Of the' ,, mach/lie', 0 9i??0 0 7:
shlons and 'Methods: rtirnifinituring and
.preparing: India itubber ",.,*.-!t- which the:said
.parti or: the, first part now has -or may bow
after have; by virtue of any patent or Patents,
oi ;Otherwise,' fer.and during thri tineipired
term or : farina of ; aim slic)i patoptt or. patents,
,or,ropewal or renewals_thoreof, which ,are or .
may be -owned' by him, or In tihieh 'ho may
have'atfinforeat, or' f which heniai:tieae . tne,
poisessed.'„ )
,That is tiillbront.language tin ;
'holy.
:The licit is the license to Riders ,% TrOtter: -
This'non tains on expresti'proidslotithatftelialf
tarsi _pr qrina
of said patents, or any of them, or the renew
als .thereof.”. .That, therefore;-Is very clear. ,
He intended to convey Whatever ho did con'.
voy to them during the, renewal or, all patentsM r ho Says BO in express language. , It Is to
,nontiano.daring the.unexpked term or torme,
of said patents, any of them, or the renewals
lherecif;"
In the agriernent - pf - Goodyear with ihe
Union Company
,April 23, 1868, he speltkii`
of the patent about-to expire, and this is eito'd
by the counsel for the'defendards to shot that;
the Nabgathcli lleasetiesintendini 0 ; 4140
into, the exter 1 4941 0113 4 o s f , the;Paterit of 13nne
:16, 181-1, ,by -this •sigreementi , , Now, Vet
look at this a - moment: It says That_
ithere,as the', tiarttee tfiti:nentind part hit've
certain rights ind:interoisfi • s in:: the pittenta. of
the
,partr of, thw:first,part,..*_, !f.* under lair
agreement made by the party or the first pitrt
With the Naugatuck Indid:Rith,ber tioniPany,
Trotter;:*
t ifittient Rider & Brothers, , ',' and an agree:
moot made with Rider & Brotherly
and Jonathan Trotter ; " I rte' and ‘' , lteriiiis - the;
patent (if 'the party of, the first Iphit,'Allitea'
Ji4el6,th, 1844,..„ about to expire, find i
application, has_ boew made loran 'extension
thereof.. licriv,•,'.inT erdi3r-le fiX, deflne;2and:
render O'ortnlii thetindebligidiens'el the;
ifaitiOn,,ig,;44y,p . receed tq arraago,tho tarilr
.reapeeting.; eloth . when made-into. clothlkti
Now, 'was - that:WOO :under the Naugattick
license, fiet'ac_ r iill ;,;hut,,,upder thoTr4nr
ikenee: Theyare to pay two cents per:lnner*,
yard of-clotitiwthe plena - or Whewmade
one and a half On§ allontill on India Rubber',
sold Ir9ihnots,er etherwisaandtwo'and-a half'
cents 'a wand for other artielea_triothernin.
the , ReensW•tw;Riderd, and!H r Trtit*:Aind?„-net"
ifti : 4o . op IbitigrakeOlceiViti thetthere
no ' aTs.li4l-9nt to
:that agreeinont efßotiodyearAo than; that the'
, Naugatuck Meese doverid the'nxtendo term
of that,pittonti:.! - ", - .. , , -
A-1 ant 'thdefore'disloised to' think from this"
Inetituran4,- ; and4`of the'deed
May,F4,lB6B,;o4;'ikey„ deo n 4120:
conveyed en interest to,Dastin:ttie , ariefes; the..
ifr:friligeiliet.O.l wMch 141.1 ir`nt . spfateedni.
Bar rr IS NOT NEOESNAILY TO DO So pi! Tilta‘..4ll4C
tne title; of -Day-ori the cents:act lid
1846; and from thtfbetstattention been,
ablesto give to ; 14 1-beve beard nothing bi•the‘
argument; an, aree.: . rietirik lel, the
r dbeinnentari 6r parol evidenea; to-convince
nieihafthi'iiiinia"it'shiered",efeciri*ted,"
bithe contrsot of October29,4B46;ahotildle,
:limited aid riot - 140rd to the goods mode,inder
thavatant of March 9, .1844. r: -
ruzaasonajwrm, SIGN A DECREE AoAirier
TUE; DaTERDANTS, ILEsTitelltiNO MHO!, ' 4.11 :
TBATIW FOR IN THE DILL.;
The „canoe was argued, on the pert of the
pernplairutria, by',llen.' J. M. - B.,,Latiehe ;of
Maryland, T. it. Janeiro, of Rhodelsland, and
4. - ',Selward MOW Toile, with whore itin.
8.-R. Curtis of bluest dins etto and - other's were
associated. . , , • ' • i
Attail
s
.AND
pkyiitchiniprigents totbi Attention of mothers bet
. . SOOTEItNGfSYKUP - •
FOR , 011ILDREN - TEBVEITNO'
'Alai pest], fsellitaton prosees of teething, by
ifOrttning tht eons, reducing all Intlammitloe ; wlr
All 4 ALL PAIN and simemodle sattanT sind 1N
Firkrii
itape ivtpt!n Itimitthers It wllt 'eta .. tett:le:y."or
11,BLIRP AND lIIIALTH TO Yong INPANTit:
We ha's pnt up and gold ;,,4thle allele for over ten
years, and gen say,- la eonOdenee 'and' tru h' of it,
what we have never been" able to say_oracy Whir
medloine, WINYAH, • HASP IT BAILED.' In A 81N
.61, TO NYO.I PHUT , p 1131113, when
timely used. Instance of
'fllasatinfaotlon by nay one Who wed- it. On the con
teary, all are dellghteda with dts 'oPeliallonol. and
speak In-terms of highest. ' , commendation Mita Mae
catefflottemd medical tune r ..We speak, in, this
wittier 'de:o ktiow,,wOtter ten, yearn ,
hiPerlefitlejandplisldeourl4 eipatathon for the 1•141-
scout of what„we here, de l .. t otem , In IlitpOS every
iiptill#WWhirre the, Infant" Ia aulPiong Iron& pal - nand
ealumetton
,iellef Nbe ell found In atteen or Alfen,ty
nil°hlo° af ter -
ThlNVelnabli repave on . ° fe thh preecrlptlon of cue
' triQat xemai X VOBD sod
Nl7llBlB In New itndland, 0 as; has...been need with
never7fallina cocoons In, ID'
-"' •-' .141.01711AND8 .OP 0611E8.
Cot only relieves. Ike otilld nom pain. but In
vlscieNei the Stmosob and `e` bowels, corrects acidit,
and Wee tone and energy to the whole -system. lt •
will almost dnetantly Rave oitteiNttlN TUB
pow,EmsArip...w Da 130.41Chandeverporne eon
valgons, ~.whlsh, -If . not speedily remedied, end In
death... , Ws believe it the H beet and 1112011 C remedy n
the worid e ln all Wes •of GO DYtINTINY end DIAN
ft/faikt, IN 0111hDREN,4,4 whether-it , art Os from
4tiethieg or from any ether 7, cause. We.woOld ear to
every- mother, who - has .a child entrerloctrain any pt
the forakolnd'oompleints,ls do not letloer priludlces,
the- prelnabies 'ef ;others; stand between
rine angering child and the - -tellitit that - will be
llliTilti—ytit;'•4lßBol.ll3TlO L'Y 8171t1I—to' fellow 'the
- use,. of this medicine, Wel timely 'Med. -Volt dire°.
Nona fop piing plli sitoOnit 14 Piny a each: battle. None
Zealand Ilnlese'lhei _fact kt of MINT 18 & Pint-
NI08; Nett' York , is on ell the eatable wrapper.
17 Bold by Drudelata'tli.oakhout the world., Prin
lateLetdee, 1 1 0. 18 ONDAIL Street, New York.
. - s -
AL HOWLER PROOF OF,,T4E WON.DER
11L PW zuners OP NituRALGIA
SALVE
-Pinta.; July 7th ,
Mr; E. W. Tnoisit —Dear air: 4 bays been tronialCd
with the tor the last -I4 retire, and
hove outfoxed the moat exoruclating polo, compelling
meet times to give tap my bueineas entirely. Locale
not oat, and , 'leap was a atimiger 'to my elee rgur.
feted morn thou tongue canton I badliovadvieft and
old of Varlotta phyatoistre, and tiebd Other, remedlee; bit
all of no avail. having noticed •r 3 oar adiertliententin
the pagers, I concluded tooth on a perm whom
learned Rae enrol of & 439119 of .20 'erg etanding, Re'
applied the, , I.SALVIII , but onto, rood I felt fuunoui:
ate rollefr,et secondrapplication removed the Vein en.
array, mart now feel like a diffeiectuien. Since then'
plmaloptwaa—aomething that I have nor done for
months, bang obliged to alt up all' night ins theig
My appotltahoe remark/4g and X foal gratilla to yOu for
the reetprotion Of MI himitly
CHARLES B • MOOR, Tobseooristi
OABROL Street, shove WOOD, Kenainaton.L
Der mac wholeoole mut letal, ate. W earner SIXTH
and .PABBISH stmots t took
C 0.% oorner-notit*HOJWatnut eta, &00.tfl
WESTOOTT'D OELSBRATZII-TAR
...NIA" CORDIAL " H "
- WestooWs Tar Cotdierecra, Coortnnplion
WegnerPc Tar Cordial cures Bronchitis.- - , •
• Westoott's Tar Cordial Curti Cotighe arid Colds.
• We etoott'a Tar Cordial orirea Bore Throat
. westeettie Tar' Obrdlal iturea r l'alpltailort of the
Heart. • • • •
-
Walloon's Tar Cordial acres Ha - rialto Debility. '
Wtstoottls Tar Cordial curea fialtenti Debility.
Westott'aVer Cordial eines Diseases ,of }Mom
'Otraolilltli and Gravel.
Weatcolt's Tar Cordial eons Blind and Heeling
vienteiritla Tel; Cordial Caret Ferutle Weal sea
Br- Winteotpe Tqr Cordial' Depot, No. 6:9 ARCH
Kraal -
Also; Principal Depot for Dr. Weatoott'e Antl.l3croin.
lone Syrup and Cholera Mixture.
Dr,;= - 11., It. Pi'llaTCO IT:o an be "ooniulted on the
'thole dinettes,. free at: charge. et hie Consultation
Hotting, No: S et, (tempi. M:,.10
DAM' MOOSE, Ur eli*-
MEM mix, xt. tip vinit Bono. tiumsell
, , I
_ .
t TitaltAgacßiONSe '
ate Nok Isciital4t,Bouturtookuriptivi
ArdietteivNei: arivo '''`"
tßi a l; . l3 tATV:Vrooßik4.le . " , -
Pnblie Base -at theF,Phifedelehtaltgolatigf
Turaley blerit*totthitql the huidarfeeseabbal.
frje. dlsodblite rot ettelfrroperty_ lateplater7o
tttedditlitteetidol erepubliah en - the , Pitsedity Prer
TIM to earth sale, oaelhougand 4:dialogue to pasOlet
form, giving full deaoription of all the Property to be
eold on thb folloTpvellajr 1
Arive ItillNlMNfraglatt AT TUN AUCTION
ItTtNtillsrerfTentrilaglactening• ' 4 - 'F.: 'F , r . y!'-1 •
AlivAt ISTATIVAW.PkIPAVN PAM , .
'We have a terseltdsointof /NM RAMO at Pri
vate` Sale; Itneldithrg e v ery. dendlitibu of Mfr . Ind'
eonotry property. .Prfhted- lilts may be had at :the
anotton'etere. '
SALIN 11.10IMIR.! r •
Real llstateasitatod on Our Prt4 Sato Ree
ter, and adrotitepd- 'occasionally lu our Public' ls
Abelniots,ol" whloki I,tMJO cioia•s are private!: iNeklyi).._
tree ot
- ::,0 - 440.......MhO,Tgodi Halo. to Bookse will-Qom-
Itoptember - -13.: I Catalogue
OAR - 13.--' July . : aid: Angnat oal7 onnaaloiud.aatga4
aalniatatafolo.-ndt envy wank, u in •th,* ;tandem!
Theliniiii 1346fii intai, 11 and 300 3)111
. 4_14 lota,
-ATIANTIC-13.1,Tri OTh aanddt.:' PI" nwbillS "
'ilitog-.-011 the jmiuttsee - ,` Athettel
" Ci r olt 44 F4t 40 ,440, 3 011 1 ?„ sad about 100 6nB
•
" • itaTATEI „
- Ob Tuesday Morning',
dualist 10111 ; 95 9 .tioak at the Phtledet ,
Ixobabgs— - - " •
Nine* 00047 seat' 189 sitesslei
,praraote n ts, - A49. - alhade Neer, superior fruit
ardeMerles, variety, Eao„ Au op the, Nbsellolo Z.
Dello/10a Soutar. trltfile'llalf.i'litlWof - 111.0:depaUel
the elttledelrhti- 3 Dartiy - Taseeitiet:liellway, At.
si t colle [mot,* alatlah
lifid•Wiet "Oh,rek•ritil aplls - 011 *S
weat of reinoitslrittlm the 0 tate. • 11111'..Stbak,'"&0 .9
will be sold a der, of twq alter the sale of the place:,
TWO ,EltOrthite AND' DA1DL1.4.11E18...4w0 three;
stag bilik'steptes 'and dwelltagei Noe. 'lOOO and 100 E,
Beech street. &arab of ,Learel "treat .Terms emit,
*lmmedlate4statesaion,,Tutr,r 1104
t 4 e l 9•
"7.
Ails at Nor. lairsio lit Boats' toittb
BpEEBIOB DUENITURS .41tENOEVS L lNS.Snilltr.,
KOBE, 1.141.21040_ 'Mumma oAltrirro; -
, •••-•oir.nrvoids k r ItratillAt;-
At 9 Wilook a at tie - Inetlistatotir totortitioal•
of ezeilleotnitebrit-hiod AlLMltttre r tettipArriao:
fortes, !ie carrots, carpels, stal l tram :millet Soi , i
'olffiltitirrarikaiSf•Spateitiolto fitorillbt "sto,
TrinltneS eale-4n the
11111TID ATARI& BOTAL AhIy.MILIT 100 11011.11-
LW- LOTS, ATLAB SIC
_ClTY . ,%.l. pi Ettr.
; teniteßsidey MOrahari: • •'•
• Abettet 0,1860 i at 11 "obt'ook, wilt be eobt rat pat.:
Ito eabloter-the proadeos, the United-States Hotel and
about 100 Ibutattag lots, - Atlantic Otte, Newlereee.
- -Itali dbioriptioss. ant llthmaphta plane eas/
be zaa at the antlett toonid.• - - t• - •
ROOKS ON NANMORT‘ . ..nousr TO
Ay at the • •
aT PRIVANN - latil:.-41karra in limrlidia:Otlplida
inst-lderonatila-.l.okraried and atbsaanni: •
•-- PNIVAINIIAIN,—Ihii ',Addable 'p_rayertrial . g.
tier or 711th and Ablinid atesetlif Was Wain*. urge
blink building dad !Alt OfdiXdaat , ,i , -Tiro"-froater. -
z iiiiineos , • •
'--
•
-.IOEIN'BINNE4 A .
'z ' - : 1 -1 1 f riat'ovrlcri, ',"
No; MiltiotteMLlCrilltotet,' -
(Neatly op the dloiulty'Ocitttlfiniee'd
" -
= hei,:b7 lair; relll poirectoodmfehitelOithsind
delesistiose;eid toke'Teettoseirfio herteed" la ltvi--
'deooe Ia $u Court of , Maio OotantoOwealth Peardyl
youte.,,
tie tdmodeiloher 0104 United fitsteeVisa..*
• Commissioner of Deeds amd for, the Probate- of Alf,
eounto, for nearly all tile 'Motet In Ike;:onlorr -
00nrurtiolons to fakir Testimony, Mat Any ,
the Marta, 10. thiSilltate;of soy of 'the Cottle In the
'COCO& atm.? or Territortee; qinntiptly•Anit earetnn,
expooted: - - „ - 771541,:.
'q,TEILIITEENTEL -AND
1 4!:citrf11trraMtniirn .pAsimacss RAM=
WAY- 00 Wyoxor. PaIIADJILPHICI. • .
" ROOM 14i tirkttobitascatanpop,42o Wilmot
tf
Armats.EXl'REss.,ao:;orraom
,4119,(11051141:IT fittest, totereris..Piiroelle,,Peek
eget, Ittetthdiee, Ilaak Notes; anlPAlpeete, eltketi iby
Itteentlteeli,ol , l4-,ooaseetkoit arttit,etherLixpms
oexepeelee9 te Myth* Ftletcdpel ttYWlli.ateteettee of the
. ; 3,IIIILIMND3OND,
Sul, tt; - r.,1- 6htiat*4ll•Poriatendent.
.4 Lzroktorris-K;
,i, , ':IIiTTOILIVRY:. AT. LAW,
pmethisla Woitmorttsadi Aranstrarg i , sad la.
divas aolmtlier.,,4 • • •!: - 40.1-11-
; •
t A 3y-,,DAturna,:re , BEATza 1114111 T ), •
iaknas Lettamat Credit far Travalleva, avaltabls la,
all parts at tlat.worldi throserthe Mandy. Ratlialiilaa,
af•rads, Lomb Atisaktertillaplesi aa4•Vianuat l *ad
Abala la. • - -ry •-,101.40,
..,, ; ~cricas
- 2(OTX% ,TO r 8 Rik" 4 0 ,
, ' , -
MiIIINIE
: -, - 'tit tOtlAriinElolol44,-iiAsiv
';Wr 4i - 7441/ 41 "ftWat i t. 4 418)st. to tit 6
.1 " RP 44 /r ' Pa '"lfi al ' 60004 VANTRA,
tali:tg . fl :. - ,f- kt 3t , 2.. ..,
~, ,, ,Nopqiiikiiii.,
44 4 4 4 , 1 p 1 i.,4,,:,,3 ;. , - 140 , 47; Fli4i ;,,,
: 4 144101 ',
- . l 4 , irbusar - ; , -" , - ,- , A, ~--"- - __ l4 - it - 4,t 0w .,: -..••••-• -
f:f , w4tilizr ~4*,_ Y! ":;•-.' ' -, - sair62r `, -• , • • • - •
5'..L44_054..„••, : ,.., -,,:i ~,,-; •, • :--;11 - 4 0, ,,,,,, - .- ~ ,
-;- ='•r- I T , '° A, ''' - ''''',,' aniotiaiiiim. .-, .;
,
~.: .. , ,i , , ,
_, , , , ,
~
,A.T.SO6-tirkits'iiiiiiii(CTllf
--. ttiotiA 44 1 4 j i 0"" . '
...... ;„.' '-''-"- ' "."
'AA
0.1. -I %lleo - . ' lopiett Station-, Ta.....-JOANTAI,
- AIMS- -- 4 4° ' - iii tiprompity I/of/ludo!.
~. ,
int It Ci a gn. ll 4 l.4, r pis, frOhlkt Agen!.
- , .- - , 1 ,31 1 ; 4 1 , : - IJ'iA = . 11 ,t -' 4, - '
1111011(1E-Nrticiite. having'
km'-the YVIUX , lABBMIOTOM.i. vall.
'VITqI atr.et, blittgiewthoi hounrise-LoYeloalv!ied
R. liciehere tkey,"irklittod , thelawpator wilts Dersty t
_4411(..1417111it1i •-.
, - • clarpeetor.
ECRAl:NOTlOlL,D,ealeiilgithodyear'i
N'lifonitroCtlittildsoa Rabbai:supwadow•Dratt*
•DawAlioffikorgAbz44.om.muablimadavarnabln:
inienereassoestasoes with Weidner eheeteet mime
hiekkebberarenotilledtheteielesetheemehreletoperly
etato . pol e* g acme ; end by Er/ adman;
t7l USW diepoieVot fa the United
Itatei brie,* to emi.deelere are Ineltel to moans
.1111padmongkpot Atom tad to gay" thole Osten for the
umerogoed,..axoLusnrs avow.
It wr'tfla"Vms ANLlxq.zzotTa Itatiret:
nt /Mt' RAT V* OM* goe4 ll, ol9 l ClMbride
the4l o l4l *" 2/6 K a tte
be ebUanee - et heppetheeter!
tieeht 119.116 09,111/90 _
r . , v
- B 1 9. 11 . (1 , 311 :Ar Pa.4l:
fipplldOfjoif, wilt be" patfle:
I. If 'Os mitt jitailoa Of -the r Lsilifshiat of Pennsylva:,
ohs 'fosjtliatiouriaaatioa of o,llsuk; _ with: Oasis'
boubligrielo, -filth capitsVof,TWO IftrffDßllD,
*AD "MUSD DOLLARS, ;to to salad the
hthaftirsOnflatiar BANE, tC be lodated io tke city'
. 1;2.o8to
Vaiiisoluttons,anb fillopartneroliipe
0/01'illetlfiEREBY GiVEI;II, ih at
'homer 'WARRICK- CHADWICK ,
thte4ar dblietredc,: The Hester ; liege; tuidt'Vtvelnu.
need etillhaileathined 'dada the tame 2 of 'COXIJIWICK
ar. - - ARC ,el 7 :the B earner •13110OND - MA RAOI,
Meet!. • • JOHN K. CHADWICK;
- - • -• BR eNOLIIA: CHADWIICK.!
,PhlllialpiCe - /ply 11, 11/69. . •-:. • • 'OI2AI
IP 2I VQE!at aiTILERSHIP heretofOre
anbaoribtra is thu day dlasolied
b$ mutual eons-rut -The business or the firm - will -be
settled by,/91110PAI H.:HANSON, who iratitherlseil %to
loathe parni:oS,the Om in liquhlation. ' • " "
• ' JOSNPIL-B.HANSON, '
Jul/ ht,l B lo - , NORWOOD PRIMROSE, ;
• dOatIPH o.AffBP.lf will continue the Tobaroo
Cloattateaton bateteesa, and ageney for the gale. of Bow
bytire Geario, is heretofore.
• -; No.-104 Perth PIATIR Street,
- N0..10 North DBLAWARI Avenue.
GEORGE .ROLDINi
JOS North WATER Street
404 WPOD rpfROSN,
DES North DELAWARE Avenue
111MWOODRENTip87, (late of the ilnoot ionaph):l
Mimi fr.. flci„) . 10 tike d,sy iasoelated with 00/198,
A01,1:4.1N . , -wider Ake stsle and acin:of=llOLDlN
PAtIROSII, for the'pOipose of 000duittng a Tobacco
Oilw and tio - nerai omin:fission busonat
July 1, 1859.
O T MM. —THE ' 00P4RT.NERSEIP
herekifore existing between the entreeribeie,
under the Firm of HM. U. Ititovm & co., Is this
derdieeoiret by ; mutual pqnsent—, - „ '-
The - ballnere ofthe firm wilt be settled by 0011,Np:
1.41.14 I. IiRADYPRRoand Nati:FEL Linz, who, ere
entheitsed to pee the-acme of the Arm for thlt
-
pur-
Me: . „ - 11,13110WN, - , ;
J. BitaDIVRDi
8.itd13116
Ptritstattreibt, 7th month let 1869. • jy1.1114
, Coal.
qpilEo. - ,p: EMORY 00.
%IL ornos tr0.:149 Bout FOURTH Ft, VOW .
- i3ole Agents of - - -
OHO. C. rbrra & cO., - •
bl!norg end 13h3pRere t L h o l zarr -
mu
La -
0 - 617,,
From the LoOlidi ittOututatn'. „ A
• Near Ashland,
aplAns] BOWEIpTAILL 001:110TY. Pa,
Q, • Wz--GROOME & 09,
ky. = Dealeri/ and' Oilppertr of' .
ranneu,', , BOHOTIACILL, sad BROAD Tor SIMI
• , DITUMI*OIIB COAL. ' . -
- • ONLo• - --_No." 146 b oth YOURTII lirest. ,
- , aaost• Pelcrtw nue.
apleat- , ;- • ' .;"• • -4.II3.LADELPItIA
vivo OD, ORAL, AND' KINDLINg -
Iry _
-• & TAIG]fRy
IL
"00Arld4TIIIXT W HARF,
• Bali conelentlyaa ands & large arid fraperlor &Mole
of tOaKiaad , BlolEoill WOOD; tnri
completed our arraniternentit, are now prepared . Caw
the - WOOD-BYITIIII.II-.FOW3R. ' ham ilea Cu
hand a eoperlot 'quality of LERIGH. 'COAT, ' or all
sizes; aelected withaare. Dialers and Conimmere will.
&Alt grentirto'.their adiantage to purchase Aiodtlug
Wood2rif:tui.. t-- seater,
_ .
reHE CHEAPEST BRUSH 11017§E
PEIR , 64I9I,VitIA..;—Look at the .folteritig' of.
PrieetrrOTAfeedeentbe tied, compare thenS •trith these
ow:l4M pmetntrekr. s. , -
p4ossa.
No. 9, , 132 knot", 7.? .4'
• --
No: 88 knot+ . 8? 4 ,. ' 44-
• No. 4, 80 knot4l l 3o 14
No. 5, 88 knots, 112 44
No. 0,100 knots, 125 $ 4
No. 7,1043;n0te, 350 44 .•, ,
No. 8,
_I6Q khoti. X 75 44 -
-
81NRY diIIOROXIN,
03 t iforth THIRD Street, below &rob,
„ ,
itittiTOs' ls ENOAUSTIO TILES. for
Otaluiesitai Oblaniey,Tope fir cottages. '
-`9llcdest Vallee luid lonntelac.
' Vitrigea, Pipe ibr.dreino end water Coadsleics#
Ymptltttdknd far We bp,'
reat6•U'
DIE
,lINIitibT;AROH:ST,REET, ki3OVP
frtiabi RUILADEItIinfO. -Url'Orl, a Mt,
intueiion of•thin HOTDtLissuperiorly,
r edspted,to the wantet,uf the Duelness,Publia v. and to
those In install' or Pleinutre:reasenger Italiroads, whinh
now min pest, and in elonurproxlmiti, Afford It ahedy"
and' pleikSent ride 'to all "ploreo of Intoroot in or alma
tlto 01W - * .;#4.6t0
4 14/r
an inn#4 44:ork
inibilaingalfirki'andletietql las
befit eitylkiniPauttnii iisektirkittitiritidevtittrilla -
Otentlen teV4DlVAradi oblate" Austio.o l6l k***-1 1 P, 1 1 1 -
1 "" o°4ll/TA -
fri!' Goods may to•exani 7/4144110tfogpmmly
on Cgs Denting uf - iiitiV 4 • 'L., , - • -
l i le-Uch7 "- aft(i '
'climiltuT a Qom
botiteest Irom tr
mg ga m.
ati.:
Ipprziktu
It, Atop:,
•'
' ;•• _"" ' 4 116:180 wAsararalramr.
vAnD • 1101 64hur asolkittgaik -1011
iota tor. girl/Mk of .ffittouney
bettishotA Minn:ire daythitp.-7 -
..• • • - - -
• ,fl:7",on,eac,,RXiv a i e. : Mdc - Anidnllitir - iaift be
total a very jam. ousuipt of 044..mai14e,
deigrlP,°l at-7:l"4"viartrar'
- • - t--"-%11400-
• , rot izi*Asaurt
o,s
-s preip Oa
I t R
sOArT liil!h At 7
tt-Ta' s:.
Atmeoultuta e tips • 04 .,.L
! , 7 , - .
-- ~—.-- -
(,--mingey itipleani-vit Warrior sfacai4itiorft, eit-noi;
ahapo.l, sonallyontli as; ia/Aggclost st,N"
tasti over ise - assgrict..464/Oi, n tOs_:_sgri. ... Pe
"Oak, Isrlsearatotagg,4,a 4 a monist
istabilikalsat-13- II rotser;4loll •
W
_ , ..,sio t iq t ityinda, Axiamiw7t: .
L ' UPNAV —4 IO OTII -- -r
-- 'Vasil libiralii- fair litisidlitianiany
frObeene'lialli? Itranclis*pliiiiiiik iimitathirjOSW
Catnauti, 111,06111 W. tam eftrafferAdkiT 9
ladituneati ftrik ai iiK44 6 o= 2
algae'', Ineggair eatry, , _ - , i .
on, NO all - ' arvalosior lfttlan.Oni
myna asiol rThisindl,NiiiiWnissent,
isialand °moot aid Min insdi...:
raom wow N an'tonVaial_ i'lloanc:il,- .
fit.
ilialawartirumilit •1 1 :7 -- `4Nb l ii. ---
='.,- -
4 48 #4 '41 4CM911 1:111 41 4 . - i
WAD , j S., 4 ungai iiiiirrialrl
Stisigitei Ottani alibi on Inelasalus
lislf the _gissE aterepriaaa vglar oak/ 4 0* Oka%
lo3l4olieleltaila 14O,S,dAcksisit a_ iii i i mat-bao
Inught
saki; la s am *MAO% ..;;Plas
gallineapament IWO sad 'was linget_biLkinglige
use trat op,* fra6aostisetriliifisrAtatrikniUalindoll sae
beat malut: • Silver-lbenh lagar likin: Pad** Ol•
arid IslaijgalLigh# P. , wi l iriat - Ve
Oar =Mae ; ' • ;:,,Arroaq sall.
altildru'd *bang ; , -11nalpalligig=INSCliasi
braolen,Priastriot Ilivi WOW=
*los 'el adokuto4tri ssanstif,6l
1 lifel.
lj sAlls- ntiv-Sr'qtaial,Milrn_ ..44-
tur .---Ns.
Ar: !,..2 1 ihril,eitalikei_444. 7 te.A4 q 1if7 , . - - - `1"
1191COt it *A3r. 1 0
Ala, Vast Gins Anaftiiiingplia
.
Ont i rg-.
ViratliitrAVOOVlAl/107`.- Mitt'
WALNUT sii•t, Siniunriit akin sf OEM s
Iseeetes444 er oft Eteoevioeloceeftftetth.
Menelle keeel4o4.thealse44ol44lo4ftolkeol
tette: :614 Mite the ft: 40'4440t ti•As• - .110,7 with-
• -
sr-- The Mai is Opm sistyltir trasSitsMisett ths
tssitstsg till to'skpoltjaths moist. soksat ,
is,dlltsrfitlfir Slashes. WI It.. delaoic
' • BOA -7ElMltsestlesi t
at 411/tsso,lteoretsty:Ti't': ,,,,
, - -
I
* Hon. Hoary V. - Beanwri - - - IniNterillilheseSeh
, Edward L. Cartept,e , , ,, , - • 1 Vroimybelloblirti 4 ) -
luall ,
UWEIC Ilelfri4m. - ~ . •
.-,-,:
:Ailitoire_ . ~,,
—• ', faitlirrepori,; • ._ ,
!PO. JAPthia_lituumi;, , L ! , f•itvgabliaisiikt, ' 7
It4mayiarieelsod,sai barmrente inadiii. disllt t e‘-', - -
` lb* taieetmati lietiViosifetiatrlith. Iti
siravidowitAtiathistkill*MoVlONArrige.,
OiosikAlkale, satlonie.„4looo6oll l l3loMidn
reliriktifilaiiiiperrect - ty. Ao - _ tl¢ _ - _ sad
IrklaCeihroOt ‘4lll.td - 64- - to
QUI.: Potitotilm. t,--,, ,, , ,,,, f - • ~ - r vr,-...:... - 5 1, ookly
$
A AVLbte. FUND-41147111W-qtrA f fill
, Tim IXOWANT; Myttabz . istv:44gion
iiimit4•l6 -
snit 6461A11144 41'444 ,
_43 MAL cot &a
mandi.iiiihOtt; seittoi.'l66l4f/Vi i' p IZVIIIO7zIII-
rum fm0,4104.0 4, 4o ooo l F:W;uttillw4rb'
caws vot*friii 0 iibutioWarilignala.
EVllllNGlityptt IMMO on; -
.-P4Arra for milikip -110#4.0451,411 4-* .1 10 0gmali
ftore.gt - •
rieslekint-41TIPMROV OICLIVPOIV_
Tlimearer—, PUN
.241,Usr t -0111.11111
.
QPRlNtreAltuitif 81iTINGTUNTLOtfr
P., MATT OP FSILADBLF IA:
(Mae . , Igo. 861 Ntalh'XlMlD"llree6,
oaisTi.4Ucatottdition Salltitar I
i! ' • ;1111. 1 (41/1-4 ~1; •
*rifts jeoitioig:iiiOßSTsipitsiiniiiiimi Fistl4
41 1 1 d 000 1 00::411600 ,sattoeiyitk.fillXZES
vaitt.11F1:210001!0!;60000,61010di
~- /Vroordsoolo.4oli-iollikitki,l6o44ijoiollololilme
btoliamitod fa the NaMicia•patt ths- oity;ao4
Tioreprh, Goofs* tiavfok-rind Sodot, JPIL ism Qat ,
I•7 4 o74llo lo 4 ol o o oroorttriumloaidsiCNlZlZ
JcePtiG/- - 41kir,R 1 Ou ennialbeat4--
it; My.. Masi "tays !holly by,a-AsOn3o_adteesuse•
date - Aotoithtelt, l o l oo l 4oVoo l ol- 0 0 , -. o =
)1210 oikt9ileVonotlikUoti 10*.014011.1 :110
001
From 0 to sjeolatoaksloo,4iiiiiromakesse maw
DAY from 6 auttl Veto& fa 1,14
- • • - - - imimmaa, _
Arredtoiok • Btopheialimitit,
' Tack lolllosl.ll6ooa 11. It -Strong,. •
0. 406101 4 0 1 0 1 0-1
, 1 1 111 :0 1 -
•
TAW. - •-'460:g0 -
• ZoolgiiiI:Oolv011;
0 00 x0 W 6 4 00000, 'rthe:Ti !Uri, -
C. Robert flomblion:
~" iaauto 11.:PENIMI; .0046114.
ton:, JOICLet
RAVE BACIONi & CF;Ei"
lilateile Oink% galletf, Ihvbi; k 09.4,
Sad MOM Cle)ii tuft:liar TIANOIL Also, Mo
ttos do RezeLte , * %drivelled 11110.0LINONS 101'1C16.
MORTON!, in- dealrable Ckareliew end 'lmetare
MP- SUPERIOR - PIANOS. a - •
, - W/ILIAX
- PLaNO.TOBtIit MANMPAO2II2.I.IIB;
VOL - LB, 6, ind.7-Nortli- lIITAW, titres - 4 and Ito.' SIOt
• BALTlRlOltEtitrott% Wilma Charlet at4,-,
Light streistaßaltimore,
HIM liW67ll'oll - k9lldni 'lle assortment of their
eapenoartanosirettoomended y eersißoatee hem B.
Tkalberg, Btrakosoh, and. ether celebrated performer'
to be equal, itnotanyerior, to any made tortirlo nnintry.
The durability or Taal; Pianos will bawarrantaajor
Dv. yeast, and a irluilesd of-rcrkajUrirri illCrt e Xatira
ats .mentbs, boald - tber notal'Hra Intim
Manathetarin; lvitray,44-‘lll=, dalltrialineiltrant Mt
tall, at the most reasonable West.- - • .'
, WILLIAII , I6 NAB* r 00 -
Meanta- No:r ,ircomETEur
Street, Pllhatelphliy'artr oar aathotieed 'AgenttiOard
will koep7.atmetaatly on:hamt andfiell'etifilaran at
tnanufaftaterla prieea.. _ agaf_tA
' - 'oBIQSERiNN,bi SONS I ',:
4 114130/4.C702111111 ON V M' •
eqtaas, - .l4w..unilear-.
- MAW-ROMS.
10118fITA:81118TNOT
Constantly fa facie a lango steak of oar BRatillillt,
and 1311.11QUALLID INBTBIGILNNTO. • We - hare beam
SI, At the efferent lizhibitteu la this scants; sad
Inrope
38 G AND ItlLlElpi PAIitatOI4O,IIIIPAUL
PLSBOB TO
-12CARDWARZ 'ITRADE •-1--1 4 h9
- -AL"Seibecaltrize,AGlNTS SVP-THIELIALH -OP -PO.
11100Nr - S_ND'. Domnrto WOW WANE; Offer' efor
male the following geode allowed Wes .-Lewls' infe
rior - 01;elns of all %lOC brawlingArtoe;_ 14; hater,
fifth, breeikeragon,lonete;_oolloshig; mlne, and other
Chains ; "P; Wr i ght*, patent :end,othat denrile and
hoes ; L Horse Palle; round -- and near Bake Pone;
short and -long handle Wry Pane, lizaelnior Safety puss
for blasting rbektr, 'Bed Betewl; AnnerlcouiSlatee; Black
board Oregon" andtheepenteret Chalk 1-Peble and Pocket
Ontlery ; Oast 13440411teland Beeps; Oast and Wrought
Data Hinges ; Strap and . 4 "D "3.lingie; Alinlet t Sirava;
Hmereoll'e Minor" Stros,e ; Hodges"- •11: _Knobs ;
Whites' Drat*, Shovels. and_snades,all - kinds OW
and Manure Porta, liatem,,,autt - Aluse 1. Sonthgste's
ritent , Wrenches; Loki as& Latches;- --Door and
Shutter Bone ; HandoSleego, and Stone Hammers ;
Haas and AMON goets,: , Undff, - Shoe, -Olont, and
Plolehlog Nallei:Hoseghr Pant; Hires Flocks and
Dies; Hatole's Snarled: Donn:m.B(We'; Ourry:Otunbe,
American nial,,Sagllali Soyiltse,_ Scythe Stones. an d
Dlfieekti/eWans'. Pumps and Name; _Moleenes_ Dates ;
Faun .11swe_of all kinds ;-,4tnet,Hatehoteplanuners,
ae.,Di gene* assortment of. Hardware-
" - _ - W.- Gl ' LEM& e SON.,
41100Kbill401I Street.
Mir SALAMANDER' RAPES,
A large akasektmetat ;;t ---
- aNTANB "It 11
WAT '
ILADTIL'PHI A. , DIAWILVAOT
AILD
datAAMANDAR - SATEB, • (11 ---•% ,
- VAX - LT:- Dechtly
Z flank* and
DANE LOOKS, '
-
Oat MtOrdidad. any ealker,= -W)-
maw
A. - WATBO4 2
Vatonak SOLTETEI 8 -
GIVILui-a `eAt4,.
II winos,
10ID CIINFITWOT Brraat.
tisk.(4llg - ,•4liWi 4is:iol3oiinitroct, to_wAre
'-F Wahint, STOOK BB.Oltgit 8;4mill - dealers lailffer
oarktilerPererluel, keouriftreginetellp — latent( - the
/Brokers' /hard -dsilroterd . 11l AIL orders: for -, the per.
*hue or sole of STOOKS. -
ILLUMINATING COAL OIL--Warranted'
-411.u.equal -;ant fire brallitiog and - 4niabillt44:lll
tg
imon4A-ploatirs. Alad !Abel:toting Coed on.
• • - ; II; 13liAlis
AJO. ' • Pa
110 ali***oll4
MEI
willittrikiiiiattislirtileibt — riiiscif
VRANKIJItirri SAVINOE;',IIIS
'' , /ifct: leertentet SODWID- Dereekkbetifee•
ObeeteeN:
4
teeek mew sibrue,lN
getsiriad 'Mr leeemei. fleeiieDieree
XjaßOOMP in taeenCOS.Wi t. 4 .6 =
Prides; colkootnotitly via res'Seileic
peters , moierf,'bet bin% - atiaulissimmi
to retara with fume oetat.lactozositotbootatiti
lua_ . ...* awal,A o alk,'Sbliqhmspoy
debeeit'W tbbleraihs' Atike;: too beeblielibdie
can be vitithAeneent bpagikieraseaVi
W airtu r sts4l = , 44o o 9 o l4o4Netklo%4Nbite
a-Nem! ilibbl. -
INV e t a tetigkebjek
eettibm treibeialdee DAC—
DAWN AND BINALDNUMNIUMNIMD:
01005tti gt,eft , 9 1 3 9 1 1 ,1 , 2 1 !tt..
Waiadedarmamanaritesolp,
- • -,, amuivso . -.
/No
'oe*Sstli
rtirm linierea aim
4 4 -
urea ,-411 4- 16/mrp
Bittaiumukl
[ Og
3 Ef: ,, l rtV t ;Vir=w fo,•
L. - hAARLIWITI'sI4O I'
waulio l - 41 44 1 P, ,•
, ,
1, Dollaillive4 trtentearaibilPs;','
4110mr.
MP` PIMP" sad Welottome to Stoat.
. J: Z. eouLn,
cat ousaroi.
44atiiweirj. ,
liiilo4koo.4"gfeeit';