ri- compl'lh it. And, (hould the draught of the t'lii itia he inluificient, certainly the Je g'lQa'Ure wii) enable the Executive to raile and mirnta'thi (landing body ot' tones, to lh the "hjert of g veumient. They 'rill come, at d liferent timer., in dil ferent'direftions, and accumulated num ber** for the whole fjrcn"l ths United; State? wilt be d resed agatyfl o*.; f« ''is th.* I! tfideiit, never fpe»k; 'till he has Jetir.ti"iasC';i".d by ln» proclamation. II this count y rejedt the conditions ofkr ■c-d t'.ie svlfri'e cWi;f) willb-confitleied as in'.i :tal" » rebellion ; every man must be emifuk'rei eithei as a citizen, ur as an me inv. 1! Jic fay, he is a citizen, he may be —Lalvd I>y th.- force niidet the JStSgfi ty , 7r-~jpreiirment, to unite i'i inbdroijg its Uiieipiii. IV he ret'ule, he become san ene my, aid as fuel) may be treated. The ar my of government may live among us at fi'V'C (|{i.'.rtei s, and reduce us to obedience bv (ili.nde., fire and (word. Will the Bn'ifh receive us ? tl>e gover r. of Canada da. e not, without authority from Londm. And it "is not to be fuppo'ed, tNat Bri laln w■ il rilk t 1 »e 1 ofs of the triend fn;r> and t'nv?;'of the XJnired State>, for lb p. '- an obj' a" »itr becoming Iter fii'j ,fts. i f
  • JiVifts wnefe are oiit magazines of niilita iy ? Or where can we dbta ti a Alppiy tif ',hyf*e articles, but frohi the Unitvd Str.tes, with whom we ilia 11 he at wji . All cyiiniurdcatioo between Us and our felloo r anlmunitidn, will be hi'lolh ed to us, f- oin that ter. Armv after army will be lent il*. Iti a (late ol opto wai, we (ll f i!l be confitered as any o tl;er enemy, With the additiona. 'rancour attiiched to a civil war. Our ag. iculfcnre sri!! be drft-Oved, our field* laid w»fli,' our houses binnt, and, while we are fighting oui ftllbSv on one fide, th£ Indians, (and God knows soon) will attack us oil the otbc: —The corifciences of mail) among ourfclves will flir.ihk back with horror* at the Mea of 'rawing a ("word againll oui brethren. They Will, call for neunnlity They will,enrer Into mutual defene; Many who how from fear of dan gdr oribfuH, pot on the appearance ot zeal -and violence, will, when it Comes 10 deci frv This is a quclHon Which ought to he fettled; previously to our ta king lip againll government. for to di'obey a government, while, by remaih ingiii it, we atlmit its authority to com mand is too abTuvd, aiid too contrary to the duty of citizen", for any man of re a son and virtue to support : efpecialiy where that like ours, is created and changeable by the people themselves, tlut 13 bv the whole people, or a majority of the whole people. Our appeal io arms is there fore a declaration of independence, and mull iflTue either in Reparation or obedience. Government cannot recede farther than it has done. It has already made facrifices which entitle it to grateful returns, it of fers to so rgive offericej, and confjder its having never erred. It cannotj witu- Out a total extinction of all au hority, re peal thislaw, while wedifobeyit ; Govern ment must either subdue us, or cast us off. For, however, we may flatter ourselves, with the deftruefive hope of deleatiug go vernment, we have no profpeft of subdu ing it ; and compelling the United State*, to retain ui in the Union. Suppose Us then a separate people, what prnPpeiT: have we of being able to fectlre those obj fts, which are eflential to the prosperity \ f this coun try, and cf far more consequence than the repeal of the excise law* Shallwe at tnir own expence, subdue the Indians, een fulucient foi; tile expences of govern ment including thpfepf the Indian war. Hie excise law, therefore, could not be •epealed, unlcte tome ri6w fund was sub- Ritutedin its stead. No sv it is impofliWe to impose any tax whatever, that will operate equslly on all men. Suppose there fore some other tax imposed, in lieu of this, while we continued to refill this. What would be the consequence ? It might by as unpopular he>'e, or in some other place, as riiis exeife ; -the consequence would be, that from an experience of the weajtntis.of governmeht, in failing to en force ekcife, the new tax would be re- Cfted~aJfo» antl no tax would ■ ever be en forced. Suppose a direct tax on a general valuation of property; there would be £ieat funds. Suppose a direst tax on l ads. The amount of all direi!l taxes, in eich state, must )»e in proportion to its number of inhabitants, .now unlet* lands OV other property, in (fiiantify or value, bore the finfe prcportkm iu each state with the number of inhabitants to the whole ; tiit? dire ft tax would infbine flatr* Ik- un constitutional, and of courfc- refilled. I am ir.forihSd, tluit, in New-England, a diredt t ; tx would be is unpopular, as the excifc i here. Government: therefore cs uki not, with fafety, substitute any other tax, in iiiad of the excite, till it had tirfl (hewn, that itfc auJJ»oi ity was iufiieient to enforce , tlie excite. Attend efpeciallv to the situation of the tTnited States during the last session of Congress, and judge for yourselves was that a time to release any eitabliflied fub je)lindnefs and passion, and five this coun try from becoming a field of blood. For fit Gazette of the United States. Mr. Fenno, I observe that the Insurgents in the weflern parts of this (late object against an Excif., and call/or Direß Taxes ; and forae of their friends have intimat ed that it will be bell to let then go on in their opposition to the exilling laws until the next feffiou of Congress, when the act will probably be repealed, or if not, it will then appear that the sense of the majority is in favor of it, and " our western brethren," finding this to be the cafe, will fiibmit. It is not my intention to expose the abfurdily of a proposal to fufferany man, or any body of men, to oppose the laws, bum and destroy the hejufes and other property of their neighbors bccaufe they are fup poigen of the laws, and for the fame reason proscribe their fellow-citizens, for months, with impunity ; nor to shew the folly of expecting that our " west ern brethren" (now, tQ be sure, acting a veiy uiibrotherly part) ever be willing to pay taxes of any kind ; but my deGgn is to shew the impropriety of a repeal of the excise law, and that the voice of the Union is in favor of its continuance. For this purpose I (hall refer to official documents. It wili be recollected (but perhaps not by some of our "wtjftern brethren") ( that the weight of direst taxes were ve ! 1 y severely felt about tlie time of form | ing the present Constitution of the li nked States; —complaints against them were loud ; and hence the Convention which formed that constitution (con fiding of confidential characters ap pointed by the States for that purpose) in defining the powers of Congress, provided, Art. i, Sec. 8. That "Congress (liall have power to lay and collect du ties, imports and excifts," in addition to taxes—"but all duties, imports, and efcetfes {hall be uniform throughout the United Stales This clause forms the foundation of present Excise Law. The ConftU tution containing it, was fuhmitted to the thbii exilting Congress, and to the Convention* chosen in each date * by the people, who a [Tented to, and rati fied it, but some proposed what they tliought aiuer.dnr.CQts relative to clirefi taxes and excise—they are fellows : Amendments Proposed. By Maffachiifi its. " That Congress c]o riot lay divcil taxes, but when the monies arising from the impost B id c:;c:fe are infufficient for the public exigencies." S. Carolina. " That the General Government of the United States ought never to im pose direst taxes, but where the monies arising from the duties, imposts and ex cise, are infufficient for the public exi gencies." N. Hampjhire, " That Congress do not : jay direct taxes, but when the money arising frojn impost, excise, and their other resour ces, are infuilicient for the public exi gence." Virginia, " When Congvef* fliall lay direst taxes' or excises, they /hall immediately inform the llixecutive power of each state, of the quota of such state, and if the Legislature of any state fnall pass a la\y which lhall be effectual for raising such quota at the time required by Con gtefs, the taxes and excises laid by Congress fliall not be collected in such state." Neiu-Tori. " That Congress do * not impose any excise on any article (ardent spirits excepted) of the growth, produ&ion or manufa&ure of the United States, or any of them. " That Congress do not lay direst taxes, but when the monies arising from; the impoit and excise shall fee infuffici i ent for the public exigencies." iV. Carolina. " When Congrefs'fhall lay direst tax es or exciles, they (ball immediately in form the Executive power of each fate," &c.—as propdfed by Virginia. It hus been observed before, that the states had ratified the Constitution in cluding the excise, and from the above amendments it appear* that it was not obnoxious to either of them. New- York, indeed, objected againlt it so far as articles of the growth, produ&ifcn or manufacture of the United States (ar- * Except Rhadt-ljlaud. dent f spirits excepted) might t : af joined with Maflachufeets, S. Carolina, and N. Hampshire, in giving it a decid ' cd preference to direß taxes, which with them, she fays, ought not to be laid, ! " but when the monies arising from the impost and excise (hall be inefficient," See. Hence, then, it is evident that the voice of the Union was in favor of au excise at the time of pafling the Conili tution : that it has been so ever fmte, appears from the law's remaining unre pealed to this day, notwithftandiiig' the obje&ions that have been made again ft it, and its having been frequen;'v"i evil'- , ed by Congress. It is therefore aTto gither improbable that the law will be repealed in the next fefiion ; but were it otherwile, it is the duty of our " wefttm brethren," quietly and peace ably tofubmit to it duiing its existence, and to remember that there is no law which will juitify their burning houses, destroying official books and gapers, ba nishing their fellow-citizens, and rob bing the public mails. -)■ Perhaps this exception -would have been omitted had the Convention of Neiv- Tork known that " ardent spirits" are the " common drink of the country," as appeared afterwards from the Resolutions of a meeting of our " tuejlern brethren and that they have since been found to be " the Cash" of the country. Legislature of Pennsylvania. In senate. Wednejday September 10, 1794. WHEREAS the difaffeftion of some of the Brigades of the City Mi litia of Pennsylvania, to the service which they are conllitutionally required to perform, by the Pretideut of the United States, as communicated in the : message of the Governor of tht 10th intt. (involving circumstances highly de rogatory to the reputation and injurious I to the interests ot the Commonwealth) j demands the mod serious attention of ! the Legifiature, to the investigation of the causes that haxe produced such a dereliction of duty. Such enquiriei are more peculiarly necessary in the pre sent inflance, confide.ing the objefk of this armament is to quell an infurreAi oa of a deluded people in our own state, who have daringly avowed an open re finance to the operation of the laws— and further coniidering there is reason to believe, that our fitter states, who aie more remotely affeited by the con sequences, have with lingular alacrity ftirnifhed their refpedtive quotas—there fore, in order to obtain the necessary information on the fubjedt. Resolve d, That the Secretary of the Common wealth be, forthwith,, required to lay before the Senate, copies of aH official acts and proceedings of the Executive, as well as the retnrns that have been made by the Militia Officers, that have relation to tire calling out the apporti oned Militia of this state, iu compli ance with the requisition of the President ot the United States, dated the 7th Ext raft from the Journal, T. MATLACK, Clerk, of the Senate. A.J.DALLAS, Secretary of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. In obedience to the resolution of th« Senate pafled this day, requiring " the Secretary of the Commonwealth forth with to lay before the Senate, copies of all official acts and procetdings of the Executive, as well as the returns that have been made by the militia officers, that have relation to the calling out the apportioned militia of this (late, in compliance with the requisition of the President of the United States, dated the 7th ult." The Secretary of the Commonwealth refpeftfully reports : That copies of all official acts and proceeding* of the State Executive, in relation to the Prefulent's requisition of the 7th ult. were laid before each branch of the Legislature, together with the other documents referred to in the Go vernor's address, at the opening of the present session. That besides the written documents, parole inltru&ions were repeatedly given to the Adjutant General, and other militia officers, for the exertion of e»evy lawful means, to ensure a punctual com, pliance with the requisition, and it ap pears that in confequcnce of inch i'r itru&ions, the Adjutant General has, at several times, renewed his applicati ons to the Brigade Infpe&ors. That the lnfpcftor of the crty of Phi ladephia Brigade, has, almost daily call ed at the Secretary's Office, with r% A t* r* G. D.