"ltUUKT8' PJtf JtOLKUM TORPEDO7.
'TORPEDOES.
TIIF3 HUBERTS
PETECLEUn JFORTEBB 13.
Office at I ho
Ki:n Planing Mill.
Vomer of Pin and Second Httecla,
,'Nar the Itatlroaal.)
TITUS TILLS, FA. Z ,
Owing In the brge and Increasl tin demand for the
w.ioorts Torpedoes, and the tew dccieiou of the
unimWtOBcr of Patant In refusing to Win- K.d
patent. atuUhe dVlaton of .link's e O. Uner sns
aloiiw the Robert' pitent they Tevye LOWHUUU
tha urlae of their Torpedo
TWKNTf PKH, CENT.
an that ty Operator nn aflura n try a Torpedo
ftafur abandoning a Well.
ha Ibllowine la the decision rendered hv Jnrten
Or lor nn the twentv-rceimd ('."') dnv nf September,
wail. In tlx United States Circuit Cmtrt w PlHadel
phi. The cas e was argued three dave by Charles
. Keller of Now York, B. . Loom "and tt. A. Pnr
Mance of Pittsburgh, for drfenrinnte. ami
Harding of Philadelphia, and Usorge U. Christy, of
snwvwrgu, nil piaimiu.
OPINIO OP JUDGE ORIER.
A I write with difficult? f can only state the con
elusions to which my mind baa cooia after a carelu
aaamltnulon of this case. 1
The oomnlalnant hut exhibited a nntent dated
Ktn of April, 1M65. This Is prima facte evidence of
n geoa hub. ana puss no roe respondents tne bur
don of proif that the patent Is Told or worthies.
I need not repeat rov remarks Inthe rase of Good
year vs. imv (3 w all, c. c Hop; a.) bnt
adopt them as affording a rule c
now
soi c
decision wl.ich ap-
lilies clearly to the pressnt caae.
As in
i the infringement of tho eatcnt Is srtmiitM.
nooni7 qumiiuu win wits ro roe vaiiaity of con
ulainante patent of Aoril 25.1858.
"It was after speculation had been rednced to
practice," and atler repeated experiments, that the
eximplainant succeeded in, overcoming -ho prejudice
and Ignorance of tbe people on the subject, and
wnwwiv "iw I'mmc Mint nts invention WHsnsctuI;
after he had established Its great utility and .value'
and "when his genius and patient perseverance, in
piie in sneers ami scons." were tompletelv sue
eeesful, thBt Heed, who had before made 'expert
meats on the same subject, and was nniuccMHf.il.
imstrtned that In, h.l tho limi rl.rhi .ni.ul.
and after purchasing one or more complainant's tor'
iHfljiiw. unaiviiw on lue isi 01 flovenioer, lHtiT,
urapstont for anhetatituily tho nn combina
tions of devices and marhine contAltieU In complain
ant's pateut. On the 16th or the same month the
raspondenla formed themselves Into a company or
corporation culled "The Kced Torpedo Ckunpanv,"
for the purpose of plratlncf the complainani's In
dention, and suppnrtinr the expense nf llrhition,
aiidthus defraud him of the fruits. They have pe.
aevered, even after the prslimtnnrv Injanctiun very
lirojierly (.-ranted br the District .fudge.
U-t a droe lie entered for complainant for a per
petual Injunction. nd a Master appointed to take
em accouut according to the prayer of the bill.
H. O. CiltlCH, Judge.
Koti -The psssnffs refiTred to be .ludgn Orler In
Ms former decis'on, H Wallace, p. 399, adopted as
applicable to this case was as follow-:.
It Is nnally the case, when anv vamahle discov
ery la wade, or any new machine of srrent nihity Is
tnvented. flint thesttentloti of the public has been
Mmi'd to that subject previously, and that many
persons hnve been muklnjr researches and experi
ments, rhilosophen and inechanietmis mav have
m ssnie measure nntlcliioted In tiieir snr.u'ntinn
the possibility or probability of snch discovery or
invention! miny experiments hove been sncressful
lv tilnd, coming vory efar. yet railing short of the
i!eslicd rnsnlt. They have prwluced noiliins bene
flHal. The invemlon whon perfected may tmlv be
ald to lie the rnlniinallns point or manv experl
meu s, not only by the Inventor, but bv many oth
rrs. He may havt pnflted indirccily hv the nnsnc
esMsful experiments and failures of other., hnl it
jives thsin no riirht to c.sini a share of the lienor of
Me protlt of the snrenssfnl inventor It Is when
apaculatlonliasheenrediic-dto practice, when ex
periment has resulted in (iiinvery and when that
.ii-cintTry na ow.ii porireieu ny patient ana rontin
ned experiments, when some new cnmpotind. art,
jwaunliictnre, nr maeiilne has lien lhn predticed
which is useful to the p-iblic.tlmt the party liinkinult
keanmes spublln benefactor and entitledtn a aatent.
"And vot when enlns and path nt tx.meveraiirc
fcave at liuieth sncc -d. In spUo of sneers and
sixiir, aomii vslmlile Invention nr disco-ery, how
seldom Is li follnwol by reward ! Knvy robs hlm
f the honor, wlilinapoeatators, swindle' s. nnd pi
rates rob Mm of tho profits. Kverv unsncccsatnl
. exwirihi.aiier who ilid or did ordld tint come very
near making a diseovory now claims it. JBverv one
who can Invent an improvement or vary Its form,
. lilni a right to pirate the n-iirinal discovery We
need not summons Mie-sr, or Hlinchtr.l. or Wond
worth to jirove that this is the usual hijtory of eve
it trreai. discovery or invontmn.
'The present case adds another elmptee to this
sons ami uniform hlslorr.' 2 Wallace, C. C. rle-
lurie p. wa.
rAt'i'iOX.
The pnbllc l e intloneij ncain'i emnlnvlntr any
nt the. regularly nnthori.ed Ammis of tlie.C'ompa
l.sineo the Huberts Patunt cover the usu'of the
'I. 'rne.lo and all explos've materials fir oil wells,
. -and Mie n nt su-'h nmutrlals by other parties is- a
direct InMngement of tho'r rlelita. Anv untiles In-
trlnglnu any of the KOHKUTS PATENTS will he
Jeklt with acsorrfine to law, and as acting willfully
and knnwlocly in defiance of Inw and tho decisions
.if the Courls
ThaCompwv have re organised their bnsiness
with a view to ifcneoimnodaie Oil Men in every part
f the Oil Kecioti. They hare emplnied the most
efficient Acenta and assl'iarts that, can he prornred
,r the hiisiiie.s. Kaith Tonwdo is lahulled Willi
elva af patents, together with the price, or the Tor
pido, and sljned by an officer of tile Company, so
every Operator wishing a Torpedo: may know Its
price and whother It came from our office.
ipotators will BnnCgr a favor by reporting to this
Office any net;ilgencdjif Aeents.
The following named persons have been appoint
A Agent and Assistant Al'-ui for the OH liujjioiui
f l-enusjlvania and West Virginia.
JsIST OP AGEXTS,
TiTrsvirxit, curiicn iicn and. vicini
TY sritVHBM )fF. Offlce, Hamilton's CiR.ir
sitoro, uddn.es Tltnsvllle, Pa- Assistant John Van
TUTTavtLi.K, enrfnen hun anj vicini.
TV II. 11 THOMAS. Office and address, Man
ion House. Iltiisvll'e, Vs. '
SUAMHURO AND VICINITY C.KOHOE II?.
TIN. Ofilcn, Hhamnnni j residence, Tltusville, J'a.
As!slant, A A. West.
BNTEItPltlSB PI,KASANTii-LI.E, PEAN
farm. ani prnioi.-; w. our. van
TtlKT. OtHee and address. Cnail House, Fiona
anivllle. Assistant, 11. '. HuntlnL'ton.
TIDIOUI' AND WKST HICKORY CH AH.
CI, A UK. Offlce and address, Kxp ess Oflleo, T1U1
ante. Pa. Assistant. R. C Bcanlsley.
PETBOIjEUM CKNTHB ANU VICINITY
LEVI MAHON. Office and address, Petroleum Cen
... d a blatant. Charles lFnokford.
TABK AND HL4UU PAKM8 and DMrlct lytng
ui Oil Crook and Cherry Run. train Story Farm to
McCllnto-ikTllle .1 A M bau mn. airress
I arr Farm. Pa. Assistant.. Luther D. Saunders,
,.P1... u f'w.hrnn And WPliaal Host.
vcs:li!.tickvii.i.e, on. city and iipno
A. B. WVST. Address, Oil City or Jteno, Pa
A 'Js,Inffi,,c1 nvn THU AIXFOMKNY HIV.
n!F. ueit.'nic miles end address. Franklin, 1's
soHITBa..ASS, F.isTEH FARM PA.tRKM'8
I rviiiNil HICHAUD W. KHKPIRI.D. Offlc.
... I n irinss Hcruberass. I a Assl.-tant, It.
Per
twflo'il, addrras Kmlenton. Pa.
VK-T HWINU-C 0. AN1FI.. snd T.
0'i .i'M 1'arkenborr. " st lrjlnis
' iZiiU n,. VroIi"tHJ Ton'"! "'"
TJTTJ8VILLE ADVERTISEMENT.
$H), $10, $10
buys
A
A
CookingStov
CookingStoye
WITH FOUR
WITH FOUR
BOILER HOLES V;
BOILER HOLES
AND A
AND A
Lar
Xj a r
Oven.
Oven.
ge
".Call and well Show it
Call and we'll Bell it
FUB TE DOLL V Us
i
A.t Ames'
TITrSVILIiE, PA.
Great Reduction
IN
STOVES AND TINWARE,
- AT
AMES',
THE "PEERLESS"
IS STILL
Wlthnnt n Miviil
lit Um sitove llorket.
-aev loi rednrKfi llie nrice of th-s ftvorilo
stove ten per cent., brliiKicg It within the roach of
'"ffn have also on band tsen'y flre differott vv le
ties of
COOKING STOVES, .
To'wh'.rh wo Invite the a'tentlnn nf purchasers.
Our prices will be fonnd lower than ever.
Kvcry stove warranted. m
Call and see HA ' . . . .
octW-tf t At AMES'S.
WHOLESALE
Liquor Store
ni been reinoverWo No. 20 Spring S,
AMERICAN HOlSfJ BLOCK.
A FULL ASSORTMENT OF FINE
Liquors
and Cigar?
vil be liept and a continuance nf patronage Bought
tor. A eomrortame ana insurious
keadlm; nmm
Has lieon fitted up' in rear of
H. stnm. where mv rumerons fiiends and ac-
qnslntai ces are cordially bulled to spend their
leisure time while stopping In Tltusville.
Remember In the American
HotiM Iinildinc Is w lie re
you will find
ED. SA.IERSO..
Tltusville, Pa,, Oot, 1, 1870. 1
PETROLEUM IRON WORKS
Urfan, OillinKhnm Ac Co.
Machinists!
iron and Brass Founders
FORGERS,
Manufacturers nf
ENGINES, ROILERS, DRILLING
TOOLS, KULLAY AND SASH
SAW MILLS, PUMPING BIGS,
WALKING BEAM AND
BAND WHEEL IRONS, PLOWS.
AND ALL KINDS OF CASTINGS.
WHOLESALE & RETAIL DEALERS NI
ALLISOYS Tl BOG AM)
FOR OIL WELLS,
TitusTllle, Not ,JSth,186B. tt
iC.
M. S. SIMMON, ft .COLUMN.
SllMOMS'
Washmgton-St.
PETK0LE131 CE-liTUE.
The Larjrest and Best- Selected
stock of Goods iu V cstera
Pennsylvania, and
sold at
1M. Y. -..p RICES
THE IXTIIET
-OF
WINES; LIQUORS !
tfcc, for Medicinal Purposes.
ORlCSs CHEMICALS, "&U-s
TURE AND FIRST CLASS.
Yi.mishfs.
aiiil Dye stalr,
and Brushes.
IMPORTED
sita
rOSLET
ARTICLES!
TbeCnost assortment ever before offered on
Oil Creek. . .
WALL PAPERS
AND WINDOVi SHADES 1
LDBurpapRPd tor bpftiity nnu oripinnllty o!
UloljjllSt vLUJOJIUvbb nun uuiauunjfs
Canary Birds,
Ilouso Plants &c.
THE CHOICEST BRANDS,
ALL KINDS
PATENT MEDICINES.
PRESCRIPTIONS ARE PUNCTUALLY
COMPOUNDED AT ALL HOURS.
t-ICE COOL SODA WATER FRESn
FROM TnE FOUNTAIK,
At I3FMO.
OWEN GAFFNEY a COLUMN.
j Old Establisiilii
LiuosHouse
ICO. 25 WAEHINBTDN STREET.
QVEN GAFFNEY, PROP'R,
s
BOURBON WHISKIES!
From f . T. fault 4 fo.'s. F. I!. Chsse A Co , and i.
W. Uuim l Co., an ot ixiumvuie, ny.
Rye , Whisky
'.'.
TlnclrbmtM OwMrfilt nntl ot!M Fin Bmndi
from PUtHburuh tuiJ W e.itinortiiiisO cuoiy.
Domestic Groods
RUMS. GINS, AND ER.VNP1ES
PIE WW. of 3PiaKT8.n
JAMAICA' TITtf. '
ST. I KOIX RUM.
HENNE-isEY r..wnr.
CO"JNIAC HKXNDY,
1I0LL .ND (JIN.
y FRENCH KIMilEL,
Ail direct ifroa the Ca.tom Home.
nes-
Port and Sherry watr intcd pare for medicinal use.
1.
IMTiVE WINE;
SWEET CATAWBA, f .. DRY W!NI2,
HI I INK WINE, rfAMxOND J fOUT WWII
and HKBSIUKK Vi ISE: -
lampaign. r'ints.
l(;iquot1
f.
-Jlnmin,
lleilick,
Jiitmoud "WeddliiKj
. ; ; Carle Blanehe.
$uit li Siioro Ac
Numerous other 'brands.
large stuck eonstanly on
Hand. 1 '
ALWAYS ON HAND A LARGE STOCK
i OF
"SUNDAY CBFtlFGHT
TO BE HAD AT ALL TIMES.
IW GIVE ME A CM L.
OWEN GAFFNEY.
Yrtretata Ceotte, Pa ley' IS
WINSOB BROS. COLUMN."
WiBSSOR BROS
HARDWARE
STOEK.
.ESTABLISHED 1859.
Win sor ' 33 ros.1
BIAIW STREET,
IETh0LEIH ETltE,
PCALKR9 IX Olb WELL 3
TUBING AND CASING!
ALSO,
WORKING BARRELS & VALVES,
STUFFING BOXES,
CLAMPS, TO NO."?,
' INN IS SUCKER RODS.
RIVETED JOINT SUCKER ROD1
BOILER rUMP.
CISTERN A WELL PUMPS,
very. SeKrtpf.aa of supplies br
OIL SWELL "mu ..IB
REilNKRIKS. 4
STEAM & GAS FITTINGS
BELTING1. PACKING AND HOSTf
KlKBY'SCOJIPKESSEDBl'NGi,
Uoiteo Trimming,
Carpeoleia' Tools,
DrilMnK and Plnin Laid Rupr,
Oakum, Nail!, AX'S,
Table anU Pucket CM'TJ,
A fall astortueat of eve-vtiiliy la the Ilirdstir
l-ibs.
House Furnishing M$,
VENTILATOB
; AND
a. '
Mornine: Glory
BASK BIKAEKS.
HOME COMPANION, -
1R0 GATE, Mil
WHEAT SHEA?
Cook StoveSr
' s '.;!'
Lampa, Lanternt ate Clilmn'ri'
' Ao. 1 Winter rain"
Lard Oil)
NO. 1 REFIaEW uiii
( IIAMHOV CX0TIIES WBIXCES
Vtuafacturcrs af
TIN.
SHEET IRON
' , . IrVABI.
SMOKE STACKS,
Stemn andr Cas
Ih.tehaalngwimea.h'offly ;J "",, j, jj
lushing everything In out lit
ctlrhclllrt
oilier establlahuieui m tu v..
11, at class.
TIN AND REPAIR S
llhsnil
Thank ng oar rrlonos - rv.. -gjrts J? Ts-
lnU..ltt,waihsl ' " ittr!
tts etnrlt.nasiiNr.
-, t3" Q vt ins caU