WSEf" -4p , r ,..-.- rr THE FTTTSBtmGr DISPATCH. SATURDAY; & 10 1889. toil Hm , SEPTEMBER' rSl, v J&V. said himself be has not the slightest suspicion who did it." "Whether he has or not makes no differ ence," Mr. Armstrong said decidedly. "It is , quite certain by what you say this poor lady did not kill herself. In that case, who did it? We must make it our business to find out who it was. yon don't suppose 1 am going to have your life spoiled in such a fashion as this. Talk about remaining single all your life, I won't have it: the thing must be set straight." "It's very easy to say "must.' father," Mary said, almost smiling at his earnestness, "but how is it to be set straight?" "Well, by our finding out about it, of course, Mary. Directly I get well enough to move and the doctor said this morning that in a fort night 1 can be taken down to the coast we will follow nut our original plan of going back to England. Then we will go down to this place you speak of Carnesworth, or whatever it is. and take a place there or near there. There are always places to be had. It makes no difference to us nhere we go. I don't suppose I shall find manv people alire in England I know. We will take some little place and cet to know the people and talk to them. Don't tell me about not unding out; of coarse we shall be able to find out if it has been done by any one down there; and as jou say that the burglar or tramp theory is quite disproved by the findingof these trinkets, it must be somebody in the neighbor hood. I know what these danderhcaded police are. Not one in ten of them can put two and two together. The fellow sat once jumped to the conclusion that Mervyn was guilty, and never inquired further." "He sas he had a detective down, father, for some weeks before the trial, and that one has been remaining there until quite lately." "I don't think much of detectives," Mr. Arm strong said; "but, of course, Mary, if you throw cold xatcr on the scheme and don't fancy it, there's an end of it." "Xo, no, father, jou enow I don't mean that, only I was frightened because you seemed to think it so certain that we should succeed. There is nothing I should like better; it will matter nothing to me if we are years about it so that I could but clear him at last." "I have no notion of spending years, my dear. Before now I have proved myself a pretty good hand at tracking the spoor of Kaffirs, and it's card it i cant pick np inis trau somenow. "We will do it between us, father," Mary said, catching his confidence and enthusiasm, and kissing him as he sat propped np with pillows. "Oh, you have made me so happy. Evernhing seemed to dark and hopeless be fore, and now we shall be working for him." "And for yourself, too, Jliss Mary: don't pre tend you have no personal interest in the mat ter." And so, just as the clock struck 12, Mary Armstrong lay down on her bed in the little ante-room next to her father's, feeling infinite ly happier and more hopeful than she would have thought possible when she parted from Ronald Mervyn three hours before. Ronald himself was surprised at the brightness with which she met him, when at 6 o'clock he alighted from his horse at the door of the hos pital. "Come in. Ronald." she said, "we were talking father and 1 for hours last night, and we have quite decided what we are going to do." "So you have come to say goodby, Mervyn for, of course, you are Mervyn to us." Mr. Armstrong said as he entered the room. "Well, my lad, it's a bad business that my little girl was telling me about last night, and has knocked over my castles very effectually, for I own to jou that I have been building. I knew you were fond of my girl. You never would have done for her what you did unless you had been, and I was quite sure that she was fond of you; how could sue help it? And I had been fancying as soon as this war was over for, of course, you could not leave now you would be coming home, and I should be having you both with me in some snug little place. How ever, lad, that's over for the present; but not for alwars. I h ipe. All thi has not changed my opinion of the affair. The fact that you have suffered horribly and unjustly is nothing againstyou personally, and, indeed, vou will make Mary a beltei husband for having gone through such a trial than you would have done had not this come upon you." "I am sure I should," Ronald, said, quietly; "I think 1 could make her happy, but I fear'l shall never have the chance, bue has told you what I said last night. X have been awake all the night thinking it over, and 1 am sure I have decided rightly. My disgrace is bard enough to bear alone; I will never share it w ith her." 'I think you are right. Mervyn at least for the present. If, say in five years hence, you are both of the same mind toward each other, as I do not doubt yon will be," he added, in re- Bly to the look of perfect confidence that passed etween his daughter and Ronald, "we will talk the matter over again. Five years is a long time, and old stories fade out of people's remembrance. In five years, then, one may di'cuss it again: but I don't mean Mary to wait five cars if I can help it, and sue has no incli nation to wait five years either, have you, child?" Mary shook her head. "So I win tell you what we have resolved upon. We have made up our minds. In the first place gome bodv murdered this cousin of yours; that's quite clear, isn't it?" That is quite clear." Ronald replied. "It is absolutely certain that it was not a suicMe." "In the next place, from what she says,iit is quite e'ear also that this was not done by an ordinar burglar. The circumstances of her death and the discovery that her private jewels were hastily thrust into the ground and left there to tpoil, pretty w ell shows that," "I think so," Ronald said. "I am convinced that whoeer did it. the murder was a deliber ate one, and not the work of thieves." "Then it is evident that it was the work of some one in the neighbornood, of some one who cither had a personal hatred of your cousin, or who wished to injure you." "To injure me, Ronald repeated In surprise. "I never thought of it in that way. Why to in jure me ?" "I should say to injure you. because it seems to ine that there was a deliberate attempt to fix the guilt upon you. Some one must have put your glove vhcre it was found, for it seems from what J on told Mary that you certainly could not have dropped it there." "It might seem so," Ronald said thought fully, "and yet I cannot believe it; in fact, 1 had. so far a I know, no quarrel with any one in the neighborhood. I had been away on ser vice for j ears and bad nothing to do with the working of the estate, and had never had an angry word with any man there." "Xever discharged any grooms, or anyone of that sort?" "Well. I did discharge the groom after I got badv." Ronald replied, "and the coachman, too. for I f onnd upon looking into the accounts that they had been swindling my mother right and left, but that can surely have nothing to do with it. The glove alone would have been nothing, had it not been for my previous quar rel with my cousin, which no one outside the house can have known of.Tind that unfortunate ride of mine." "Well, that may or may not bo," Mr. Arm strong said; "anyhow, we have it that the mur der must hat e been committed by someone in the neighborhood who had a grudge against your cousin or against yourself. Iow, the de tective that you have had down there, my daughter tells me, has altogether failed in finding the clew; but after all that shows that he is a fool rather than that there is no clew to be found. Now, what Mary and I have settled upon is this: di rectly we get back we shall take a pretty little cottage, if we can get ona, down at the village." "What, at Carnesford?" "Yes, Carnesford; we shall be two simple colonists, who have made enough money to live upon, and have fixed upon the place accident ally. And then we shall set to work to get to the bottom of this affair. "We know it is to be done if we can but get hold of the right way, and Mary and I flatter ourselves that between us we shall do it. Now that's our plan. It's no use your saying yes or no, because that's what we have hxed upon.'- "It's very good of you, sir " Mervyn be gan. "It's not good at all," Mr. Armstrong inter runted. "Mary wants to get married, and I want her to get married, and so we have noth ing to do but to set about the right way of bringing this about. And now, my boy, I know we must not keep you. God bless you. and bring you safely through this war, and I tell you it will be a more troublesome one than your people think. You will write often, and Mary will let you know regularly how we are getting on." He Leld out his hand to Mervyn, who grasped it silently, then held Mary to him in a close em brace for a minute, and then galloped away to take his place in the ranks of his corps. The troop to which Ronald belonged was not, it was found, intended to start at once to the front, but was to serve as an escort to Colonel Somerset, who had now been appointed as Brig adier General to command a column that was to start from Grabamstown. At 8 o'clock they started, and arrived late in the afternoon at that place, where they found the Seventy fourth Uigh'andcrs, who had just marched up from Port Elizabeth. They had prepared for active service oy laying asiae tneir bonnets and plaids.adopting a short dark canvas blouse and fixing broad leather peaks to their forage caps. On the following morning the Seventy-fourth, a troop of Colonial Horse, the Cape Rifles and come native levies, marched to attack the Hot tentots on the station of the London Mission ary Society, Joined by a body of Kaffirs they had murdered in cold blood the Fingoes at the station and were now holding it. After a marcn of 20 miles across the plain, the troops reached the edge of the Kat river, when the main body halted for a conple of hours, the advance guard having in the course of the day had a skirmish with the natives and captured several wagons. One officer of the native levies had been killed and two others wounded. A further march of five miles was made before morning, and then the troops halted in order to march under cover of night against the position of the enemy, 12 miles dis tant At 1:50 at night the infantry advanced, the cavalry followed two hours later. The road was a most difficult one, full of deep holes and innumerable ant hills; and after passing through a narrow defile, thickly strewn with loose stones and large rocks, over which in the darkness men stumbled and fell continually, the cavalry overtook the infantry at tfae ford of the Karelga river, and went on ahead. In the darkness several companies of the infantry lost their way, and daylight was breaking be- , fore the force was collected and in readiness for the assault. f Tbe huts occupied by the enemy stood oa HHWie .-r .. .-.- ... -.j'ji ,. n-int- ,. ..,.. ?.,, 1 &.. r- , , joBBBaasgi. -v. . . . .. ... ... ...iu.. j--,-i .5 - '1 -r if-ffri'frT;nr'-iirii-ffin,ntT-K- - ''irifi - htmi . n r 1 rutin ,v ,r - , , rn tar inr w r ,i- nm. 1 , 1 HKWKifiit . . lilliPPfc Hi HIIil i IF 1111I11 iFrMlililTiWIMi Tri11iiy,TiAlm,WMMMMIiiMMgMiMrMfcaMHMMMraMB1MrMg';r duiHHHHMBS4TC!&2HKVlHKi3SSMlMHEMl one side of a grassy plain, three-quarters of a mile In diameter and surrounded by a deep belt of forest. The Fingo levies were sent round through the bush to the rear of the huts, and the cavalrv and infantry then ad vanced to the attack! "The enemy skirmished in the plain, but the cavalry dashed down upon them and drove them into a wooded ravine, from which they kept up a fire some time, until silenced by two or three volleys from the in fantry. The mam body of the rebels was drawn np in front of their huts, and as soon as the Infantry approached, and the cavalry charged down, they took to flight, bnt a volley from the Fingoes In the bush killed several of them. The rest, however, succeeded in gaining the forest. The village was then burnt, and 650 cattle and Borne horses and goats, all stolen from neighboring settlers were recovered. The column then marched back to their bivouac of the night before, and the following day returned to Grabamstown. There was no halt here, for the next morning tliev marched to join the column from King Williamstown. passing through the Ecca Pass, where constant attacks had been made by natives npon wagons and convoys going down the road. They crossed the Koonap river, and at the end of two days' march encamped on a ridge where the Amatola range could be seen, and finally joined the column composed of the Ninety-first Regiment and the rest nf the Cape Mounted Rifles, encamped near Fort Hare, Two days later the whole force, amounting to 000 men, advanced to the base of the Amatolas and encamped on the plains at a short distance from the hills. The attack was made in two columns; the Seventy lourth, a portion of the native levies, and of the Mounted Rifles, were to attack a formidable position in front, while the Ninety-first were to march round, and, driving the enemy before them, to effect a junction at the end of the day with the others. The cavalry.could take no part in the attack of the strong position held bvthe Kaffirs, which was a line of per pendicular cliffs, the only approach to which was up the smooth, grassy incline that touched the summit of the chit at one point only. The Seventy-fourth moved directly to the attack, the native levies skir mishing on both flanks. The enemy, who could be seen in large numbers on the height, waited until the Highlanders were well within range before they opened fire. Tho cavalry below watched the progress of the troops with anxiety. They replied with steady volleys to the incessant Bring ot tne enemy, advancing steadily up the slope, but occasion ally leaving a wounded man behind them. Two companies went ahead in skirmishing order,, and climbing from rock to rock exchanged shots with the enemy as they went. They suc ceeded in winning a foothold at the top of the cliff and drove off the defenders, who took refuge in a dim forest a few hundred yards in the rear. As soon as the rest of the regiment had got up they advanced against the wood, from which the enemy kept up a constant fire, and pouring in steady volleys, entered tho forest and drove the enemy before them foot by foot, until the Kaffirs retreated into a thick bush absolutely impenetrable to the soldiers. On emerging from the forest the troops were joined by the other column, which had driven .the enemy from their position on the Victoria neignts ana naa uurnea two or tneir villages. While the fighting was going on between the first division and the enemy, the second di vision had been engaged in another portion of the lulls and had penetrated some distance. Skirmishing went on during the rest of the day, but at nightfall the troops returned to the camp that they had left in the morning. Tho Kaffirs had suffered considerable loss during the day, two of their leading chiefs being among the slain, and Sandilli himself narrowly escaned being taken prisoner. The Cape Mounted Rifles attached to the Seventy-fourth had taken no part in the affair, for the ground had been altogether impractica ble for cavalry. The troops when thev re turned, were utterly exhausted with the fa tigues that thev bad undergone, but were well satisnea witn tne events ot tne day. It is well euough for a beginning," Ronald said to Sergeant Menzies. "but what is it? These hills extend 20 or SO miles either way at the least; twice as far, for anything I know. They contain scores of kraals; I don't suppose I am far out when I say hundreds. We have burnt three or four, have marched a mile or two into the woods, have killed perhaps 100 Kaffirs at the outside, and have lost in killed and wounded about 50 of our own men. I sup. pose altogether there are 15,000 or 20,000 Kaffirs there. Thev have no end of places where our fellows can't possibly penetrate. There's no holding such a position as that. The columns may toil on through the woods, skirmishing all the day, but they only hold the ground they stand on. Why, Sergeant, it will take a dozen expeditions, each made with a force three or four times larger than we have now, before we can prodnce much effect on the Amatolas." "I am afraid it will. Blunt," the Sergeant said, "before we break down the rebellion. There is one thing, they say that the Kaffirs have got 20,000 or 30,000 cattle among the hills. If we can drive them off we shall do more good than by killing Kaffirs: the chiefs care but little how much their followers are shot down, but they do care mightily for the loss of their wealth. Cattle are the one valuable possession of the Kaffirs. Shooting them has very little effect on those who are not shot; as for driving them out of one part of -tho country, it makes no difference to them one way or another. They can put up their kraals anywhere. The one point on which you can bit them is their cattle. A chiefs consequence depends on the number of bullocks he owns. A young Kaffir cannot marry unless he has cattle to buy a wife with. Putting aside their arms and their trumpery necklaces and bracelets cattlo are the sole valuables ot the Kaffirs. You will see if we can capture their cattle we shall put an end to the war, but any amount of marching and fighting will make but little impression upon them." The prognostications of, the two soldiers proved correct; it was only after six invasions of the Amatolas by very much larger forces, after hard fighting, in which the troops did not always have the best of it, after very heavy losses, and after capturing some 14,000 cattle, that the conquest of the Amatolas was finally achieved. So far, Ronald bad heard nothing more as to the discovery of his Identity by one of the men of bis troop. He thought that the man could not have mentioned it to anyone else. He felt sure that had it become at all known Le must have beard of it. He would have noticed some change in the manner of the men. and it would certainly have come to the ears of Menzies or one other of the non commissioned officers, who would, of course, come to him to inquire whether there was any truth in the report; beside.he must have known him from the time he joined the troop, and conld have mentioned it before if he had wanted to do so. Ronald snpposed, then, that he had kept silence either because he thought that by originating the report to the disad vantage of a popular man in the corps he might, though it proved to be true, be re garded with general hostility, or, that the man nrTght have intended to keep his secret, think ing that some day or other he might make it useful to him. o doubt he never would have said what he did had he not been excited by liquor. Ronald hardly knew whether to be glad or sorry that the secret was still kept. It would, he felt sure, come out sooner or later, and in some respects he would rather have an end of the suspense, and face it at once. His position was a strong one, his offigers were all markedly kind to him, and his expedition to the Amatolas had rendered him the most popnlar man in the corps among his comrades The fact, too, as told by Colonel Somerset to his officers, and as picked np by others from their talk, that he had refused a commission, added to his popu larity; the men were glad to think that their comrade preferred being one of them to be coming an officer, and that the brave deed they were all proud of had not been done to win promotion, but simply to save women in distress. There had been sly laughter among tho men when their comrades told them how pretty was the girl Ronald had brought back; and there had been keen wagering in the regiment that there would be a weddjng before theymarched, or at any rate that they should hear that there would be one on their return from the war. The one contingency had not occurred. The other, it seemed, was not to take place, for. in answer to a question as to how the wounded colonist was going on, Ronald had said care lessly that he was mending fast, and wonld be well enough to be taken down to the coast in a fortnight, and that the doctor thought by the time he reached England he would be com pletely set up again. So the bets were paid, but fie men wondered that their sergeant had not made a better use of his opportunities, for all agreed that a girl could hardly refuse a man who had done so much for her. even 11 her father were a wealthy colonist and he only a trooper in the Mounted Rifles. . (7b be Continued.) Weak stomach.Beecnam'sPills act like mage Pears' Soap secures a beautiful complexion Knnblo & Shuster. 20 doz. flannel shirts, regular $2 50 qual ity, all to go at SI each, Friday and Satur day. Store open Saturday evening until 9:30. Enable & Shtjsteb, 35 Fifth avenue. OVEBHOLT. Golden Wedding, Large, Gibson and Dillinger whisky for sale in large quantities by Geo. H. Bennett & Bro., 135 First avenue, second door below "Wood street Ladles! John S. Roberts, 414 "Wood street, has the largest and most complete stock of wall paper in the city, tis Ail the best stocked bars keep Frauen heim & Vilsack's celebrated Pilsner beer 09 draught. Ask for it, or order it direct. Telephone 1186. The oldest and best, "Holmes' whiskies." ws TIIE LIFE0FlRACER-nr& ton, in to-mM-rottr" DESPATCH, dejcrfoei Mie ca reer of a king of the turf. AS SEEN IN THE EAST. How a Trade Journal Discusses the Katural Fuel Problem. GAS YET A FINANCIAL CONUNDRUM Genuine Mushroom Methods of Ohio Municipalities Shown Up. AN INTERESTING QUESTION OF LAW rCOBBESPONDENCB Or THE DISPi.TCn.1 New York, September 20. The -Financial and Mining Record will print the iol lowing to-morrow: Although the natural gas industry is in its infancy, being bnt seven years of age in Pittsburg, the pioneer city, it has had an im portant effect on commercial enterprise and economic conditions. Thronghont the whole area of natural gas production, from Western Pennsylvania to the fields of Indiana, manufacturing has been stimula ted, the prodnction of manufactured com modities and the consumption of raw mater ials vastly increased, the effect of which is not limited to the gas-producing territory, but is diffused throughout the nation. The purely financial considerations attend ing this new industry and enterprise have as yet taken form so little removed from the speculative and experimental, as to make definite conclusions nearly impossible. Financiers have nevertheless HAD CONSIDEBABLE EXPERIENCE with the stocks of corporations engaged in the'industrv; bonds issued in furtherance of such enterprises are occasionally offered, and order is so gradually emerging from chaos that indications of permanent truth and re liable principles are making their appear ance. At present, to find a natural gas stock on the uarket worth par is a decided exception, notwithstanding the fact that several have been paying dividends from 9 to 12 per cent per annum regularly for a term ot years and are still in a position to continue them. All natural gas stocks are speculative and sub jected to so many influences against which no human foresight can attora protection, that however valuable they may be as im mediate profit payers, they have never risen to the dignity of investments. They cannot, for many years at least, from the fact that the sources ot supply are beneath the earth where the human eye can never penetrate, and nnlike many otber mining operations, the extent ol the "vein" or "lode" cannot be even surmised, much less surveyed. TWO WAYp OP LOOKING AT IT. That several of the companies have been successful in finding new and prolific terri tory is matter for congratulation to stock holders: but such extensions involve expen diture not contemplated in the earlier days of the enterprise. It is evident that the wells cannot be brought to the pipes. The pipes must be extended to the wells. Every new well drilled and every foot of pipe laid to make its production available (if, indeed, there be any production) causes an additional outlay of capital which wonld not have been the case bad the wells been originally inexhaustible, as contended. Natural gas may be inexhanstible in the aggregate; the supply may be all that is claimed for it by the most sanguine of those engaged in the industry; bnt the extension of lines and additional expense on account of the exhaustion of wells in all known fields is a truth too well established to be successfully refnted. How far this may have to be continued, with what rapidity it may be required to supply the demand in the future, cannot be known. The petroleum industry was long recog nized as being the most uncertain and specu lative of mining operations, but natural gas is even more speculative than petroleum. All the uncertainty in production of oil is present in the production of natural gas, bnt in oil the uncertainty ends. Petroleum has a market thronghont the world. Gas has no market except at the end of the pipe. EIGHT DOWJf TO MUSHBOOM3. In Northwestern Ohio, widely different conditions exist from those in Western Pennsylvania, There, municipalities have engaged in the'natural gas business, issued bonds to enable them to construct and ope rate natural gas plants, and, like other mu nicipal securities are accompanied by no tangible collateral whatever, but are based entirely on the pnblic credit. In the way of bond issuing, these afford the most interest ing financial considerations in connection with the natural gas industry. The exhaustibility of supply and con stant search for new territory applies there as elsewhere. The business risks and ex penses of a municipality are at least as great as those of a business corporation, and are liable to be much more. Natural gas trustees are generally gentlemen of success in their vocations, but Without practical knowledge of the details of production or distribution of natural gas. Practical affairs inevitably become more risky nnder inexperienced management than under the direction of experienced men. Bonds issued by a municipality un der such management, and having nothing but public credit behind them, cannot be so desirable as those issued by bnsiness corporations, whose affairs are conducted by persons of experience in every department, and which give collateral on their tangible plants as well as the seenrity of experience and actually invested capital. Municipalities invest no capital in their natural gas plants. The capital is bor rowed on bonds sold. Tbey h ive been uni formly induced by a class of persons who desire to "boom the town;" who desire to induce 'manufacturers to locate in the citv or in its suburbs under the proclaimed ad' vantages of "lree gas" or "cheap fuel" at least, provided largely at public expense. To borrow money wherewith to erect a charitable institution, or one to be conducted without profit, cannot enhance the value of bonds upon which such capital is bor rowed. WHEEE THE TAXPATEE FEELS IT. Experiment has shown in a number of cases the effects of municipalities entering upon the natural gas bnsiness. Besides the creation of a bonded indebtedness for the construction of the plant and setting it in operation, .the expense of operating has caused a deficit to be supplied by taxation. At first, prices to consumers are reduced so that business corporations are forced out of business, and the price is then advanced often to twice the rates charged by the busi ness concerns. Excitement has run not for a time, values of real estate advanced, and tracts have been unloaded at high prices on favorable terms to taking it back on the mortgage. Manufacturers have been led to locate there merely to find the gilded prom ises but empty bubbles from the natural cause of failure of supply. Cities claim ing to have "gas enough for all the world" a couple of years ago, were chilly last winter for want of fuel, and Councils are called upon for further appropriations for funds to put the plants in order for the coming winter. The whole subject has been brought up in the form of legal proceedings in the city qf Toledo, where it is proposed to construct and operate a natural gas plant by the municipality. The litigations promise to be the most'interesting and important that have arisen since the famous Dartmouth College cases, involving, as they do, con siderations of vital importance to the busi ness interests of corporations in munici palities in all parts of the nation. In Jan uary, 1889, the Legislature of Ohio passed an act entitled "an act to authorize cities of the third grade of, the first class to bor row money and issue bonds therefor, for the purpose of procuring territory and right ot tray, sinking wells for natural gas, purchas ing'wells and natural gas works, purchas ing and laying pipes and supplying such city with natural gas for public and private consumption." Under tbe provisions of this act an election was held April 1, 1889, and a majority of the voters voted in favor of the bonding, a Ward of trustees was ap- & pointed and organized, some of the bonds were issued and $67fi,000 more are about to be. SAID TO BE UNCONSTITUTIONAL. The suit was brought in the United States Circuit Court by James W. Fellows and others, of the cities of New York, Brooklyn and Chicago, all being taxpayers of the city of Toledo, acrainst the citv. its offi cers and natural gas trustees, alleging that I tne act unaer which these oonds are pro posed to be issued is unconstitutional, for a number of reasons; but thoe of chief inter est are that this act authorizes the taking of private property, for other than public use; that it impairs the obligation of contracts; and that it authorizes the mingling of muni cipal funds With those of otber .persons, and applies public money to private enterprise or purpose. The leading question is whether the sup plying of natural gas is a "public BSe" within the meaning of the law. There can be no question that the taking by taxation of the property of a citizen is a taking of private property, and therefore can be taken for public use only. What constitutes a public use? If the furnishing of iuel be a public duty or use, municipalities may be permitted to borrow money, issue bonds therefor, and purchase coal lands, provide for transportation and distribntion ot coal to the citizens, conduct a coal business; but without profit, and tax all other coal deal ers to supply the deficiencies arising from lack of paying expenses other wise. If it be a jiublio use to provide fuel for heat in winter why not ice to keep the people cool in summer? If it"be a public use to supply the people with fuel why not with clotbing.shelter and food? The broad question is presented whether a city has a right to provide agencies by taxation upon its people includ ing its merchants and busi ness people to pro vide consumers with the necessities or com forts of life at cost or for nothing if it pleases; crowd the business, interests of all merchants and people making supplies out of trade and tax them for the support of their successful competitor,. The question involves A PEINCIPLE THAT GBOVfS the more it is reflected upon. It has been held in many States, that taxes cannot be imposed to aid persons suffering from a great fire or flood, either by providing them with money, food, seed or otherwise. It under such conditions ol disaster pnblic moneys rannot be applied to such uses, by what process of reasoning can individuals be en titled to like aid for fuel in the absence of disaster? But the citizens of Toledo are supplied with natural gas fuel through the agency of two companies already existing, and which have been in operation for three years. These companies were chartered by the same authority that assumes to authorize the issue of these bonds. They have been act ing under ordinances passed by the same city which now proposes to issue the bonds for the purpose of depriving them ot profits. These ordinances provide inter alia that the city may fix the maximum price at which natural gas shall be sold to the citizens and has acted on 'the authority. These com panies have been charging no more than the price fixed by the city itself. The charter and ordinances being a contract between the parties is this issue of bonds and setting up a plant which will act as a confiscation of profits at least a violation of that contract? If not, the property of no business corpora tion is safe in any municipality; the pro tection of business is broken down. A OEAVE QUESTION OP FEAUD. The bonds have been issued of bo many neighboring municipalities under taint of fraud as to give suspicion to the whole. The experiment of furnishing natural gas eco nomically by a municipality having proved a failure in many instances; all bonds hav ing been issued pursuant to momentary ex citement and popular clamor induced by professional boomers of real estate, which all experience show runs its course within a short time and leaves depression in its stead; the question of the real value of municipal bonds issued lor natural gas pur poses would seem to be answered. Further, if this act be declared unconsti tutional on the grounds stated, it will in validate nearly all the bonds issued for like purposes by all municipalities in the Sjate; a result greatly to be desired by tbe tax payers in those municipalities in which the gas has already failed, and during the pendency of the act on every person who buys a city of Toledo bond issued under the authority of the above recited act, buys a lawsuit. Whether the city does or does not repu diate these bonds at maturity, and whatever the result of the present action may be, the taxpayer not joined may still have his remedy against the taxation after it is levied to meet them. Such bonds cannot be considered as having any considerable financial value until the litigations are de cided and the constitutionality of the act is finally' passed upon. C. Habbison. HANGED IN TflE EARLY DAWN. Minnesota Newspapers Do Not Obey the New Law Recording Executions. Mooeehead, JIlNir., September 20. Thomas Brown was hanged here this morn ing for the murder of Policeman Poull, on the night of October 17, 1888. The drop fell at a few minutes after 4. Brown faced death bravely, and died without a struggle. This was the second legal execution under the new State law, which prescribes that the condemned shall be hanged at night, that no newspaper representatives shall be present, and that the newspapers shall not publish the details of a hanging. All the Twin City papers published full accounts of Brown's execution. Brown killed Poull while the latter was trying to arrest him in the performance of his duty. Brown had participated in a drunken row near Hilisboro, Dak., in which a man was fatally wounded. m He was seen in Moorehead and a Fargoipoliceman was sent after him. He found him. at a dance ball, and Brown got the drop on the officer when Poull, who was a Moorehead police man, came to the rescne. Brown fired at Poull, who fell dead. Brown made a sale of hisjjody some time ago to a doctor of this city, the purchase price being $10, to be given to a certain young lady for whom he seems to hold a high regard. Brown was in his 24th year, and a very hard character. TflE COLD SNAP ABOUT OYER. Tho Weather Clerk Predicts Warmer Tem perature for To-Dot. ' Sergeant Stewart, in charge of the local signal station, is of the opinion that the chilly and wet season will be dissipated this afternoon. The present .ugly spell of weather has come from the Atlantic coast, where it was still raining yesterday. The Sergeant is confident that the weather will be warmer to-day unless a new cold wave comes np from the Gnlf. That is an un likely origin for a cold wave. Meanwhile the clothiers and pawnbrokers are doing a lively business in fall overcoats. That remedy is cheapest that proves most effective, irrespective of price. Jndged by this standard as a worm remedy and child's tonic Dr. D. Jayne's Tonic Vermi fuge is unequalled. It rids the child of worms, and by its tonic powers restores strength and vigor to the young and old; the latter a quality not usually possessed by worm remedies. Sold by ail druggists. Modeeate drinkers are the best con noiseurs of whisky. They will find it to their advantage to call at tbe establishment of T. D. Casey & Co., 971 Liberty st, where a complete stock offine old ryes is always on hand. Jackets, jackets, jackets, jackets, wraps, wraps at Enable & Shuster's, 35 Fifth ave. "Holmes' Best" second to none. "ws Men's kid walking gloves at James H. Aiken & Co-V, 100 Fifth ave. SOLDIERS' BRIDES morrow Dispatch, contributed by the widow of thegallanl Cutler. w Ap THE CITY TO BLAME. Col. Roberts Says the River Was Pilled Up for tbe Point Bridge. THAT RIVER COMMITTEE AT WORK. Arthur Kirk Denies Uncle Sam's Bights to fix the Boundaries. NAEE0WISG MAKES A SWIFT CURRENT At a late meeting of the Chamber of Com merce the very important matter of tbe con stant encroachments on tbe river channels by manufacturers and railroad corporations received some attention. ' Captain Dravo mentioned that the subjectbadbeen agitated before the convention of river men at Cin cinnati, and he characterized the filling-in that was in daily progress as an outrage that should be at once seen to. It was stated that in 1858 the State bad estab lished high and low water lines for this city and Allegheny, and a map prepared and filed in the Court of Common Pleas, by which it could be seen how far encroach ments had already extended. While it was contended on one side that the power of the State to establish such lines had never been questioned and that therefore the Courts could deal with the matter; IT WAS AEGUED by Colonel. Bay ne that the State had no legal status in the question and that the work of laying down such lines belonged distinctly and exclusively to the Federal Government. Tbe constant encroachment, inch by inch, along the channel of the river, is a matter so notorious that frequent sur prise is expressed that action of some sort is not taken in the proper quarter to have the nuisance either abated!, or if possible remedied. Colonel Thomas P. Koberts was spoken to about the encroachments on the water channels last night, and he said: "This is a matter about which I am not at liberty to express any opinion, because, in addition to being a member of the Cham ber of Commerce, I am on the Biver and Harbor Committee, and this committee will make an examination and report to the Chamber. It is just possible that our re port may be presented at the next meeting, out that depends on the Chairman, Captain John F. Dravo. STIBBINO UP PUBLIC OPINION. "I think,however,that what we shall have to say will have the effect of producing some action which will tend to influence public opinion, and that verv speedily, toward the gradual narrowing of the water way. I am chairman of a committee ap pointed some years ago by the Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania to report on this very matter, bnt nothing was done about it. "Some people think that the narrowing ot the river's limits will result in a flood dur ing some unusual rising of the waterr, but It should be remembered that the curtail ment of the channel has the effect ot in creasing the velocity of the stream, and just in proportion to the increased velocity is its force exerted in cutting away the bed and banks. There are some parts of the river where it is so wide that the filling in would be rather beneficial than otherwise, bnt then, on the other hand, there are narrower points which should not be interfered with. "The question of the gradual encroach ment on the water channel of our rivers has exercised the minds of rivermen tor a con siderable time past, and I remember allusions being made to the increased current by them at the time of tbe flood of the 11th of July. The lines of high and low water are clearly laid down on the map prepared by the State in 1858, but without a full and expensive snrvey it cannot oe ascertained, precisely, how much has been taken from the river. THE CITY AN OFPENDEB. "I don't think the public is aware how much land has been appropriated in this way, not only by manufacturing firms and others, but even by the city itself, for the Point bridge is constructed on the river side of the line. The importance of the free navigation of the Honongahela cannot be over-estimated when it is considered that its tonnage is equal to that of the whole of the Mississippi valley." Mr. Arthur Kirk, referring to the legal aspect of the matter yesterday, said: '! have long sought for a law giving the United States Government the right to establish such lines, bnt have not fonnd it Away back in the '70's the Chamber of Commerce had a law passed giving the United States Government the right to build the Davis Island dam, and during the session of 1888 the Western Pennsvlvania Kiver Improve ment Association had difficulty in obtain ing the passage of an act granting the Gov ernment the right to construct and main tain a dam at -Herr's Island, and had that act made a general act granting the Federal Government the right to place dams in any stream in the State. But I have not been able to find that the Federal Government has any legal right to establish water lines, and will be much obliged to Colonel Bayne if he will tell us where such authority can be fonnd." Rogers' Royal Nervine Tonic Allays nervousness, gives rest and refreshment to the tired brain. Invigorates the vre&ry body, and not only soothes, bnt permanently removes all Ir ritation dI tbe nerves. Tour KOTAL NERVINE TONIO has done me more cood than any medicine 1 ever took. It has been a sovereign remedy In ray case. Please send me another bottle. MUSES F. l'EASLEE, ilarshHeld, Mass. I have suffered -with my head from hard mental work, and can certify that your EOXAL N EKV INE TONIU has plven me new life and strength, so that I am practlcallv cured. 1 H. C. BEOCK, 73 Rotland st , Boston, Mass. It it an unfailing Cure for Sleeplessness. It corrects the Digestive organs. 15 DOCTORS FAILED To cure Mrs. Thomas Hatton, and she suffered on for IS years. The aches and pains which she experienced in almost every part of her body were simply terrible. Those sharp, cutting pains across the small of her back and lower part of her body were almost unbearable. In fact, she suffered with all those diseases and conditions peculiar to women. For three months her mind was unbalanced, and for months she was confined to her bed. She be came very weak and emaciated, so that she only weighed 98 pounds. No one expected her to live, much less get entirely cured. After re ceiving three months treatment from the phy sicians of the Catarrh and Dyspepsia Institute, 823Penn avenue, she says: "The condition of my case was much worse than has been de scribed. It is over five months since I became enred, and no trace of the disease has since ap peared. I now enjoy good health and am very glad to testify to my permanent enrebythe physicians ot the Catarrh and Dyspepsia In stitute.' MBS. THOMAS HATTON, Putnam, Pa. V V .! sVWSWSW MRS. DR. CROSSLET. ladies' consulting physician at the Catarrh and Dyspepsia Insti tute, 323 Penn stye. They cure Catarrh, Dys pepsia and Diseases of women. Consultation free to all. Office hours, 10 A. H. to 4 P.M., and 6 to 8 p.m. Sundays, 12 to! P.M. M15-l55-ns 'XXVNYV.V.'-L.lr3!-. WWW" DT THE COAL HOTS. Dangers That Surround the Under ground Toilers. INTERVIEW WITH A MINER. To thej majority of the public of this country coal mines and coal miners have al ways been, a source of interest. When a traveler, out for a pleasure trip,,strlkes a town where coal mines are located, his first object Is to get a permit to visit them. There is a charm of novelty and excitement at tached to the trip. To step into the car and be lowered swiftly down the long, dark shaft into the very bowels of the earth. A feeling of exhilaration, not unmixed with nervous dread, as one shoots downward through space. The visitor sees only the wonderful portions of the work, and gains only a slight idea of the dangers of the mines. Not so with the hardy, smoke-begrimed miner. He is fully alive to the con' stant peril of his position. Explosions from fire dampf falling lumps of coal, loosened by a blast, and, as is often the case, a cave in of the entire innnel. These are a few of the worst enemies of the underground toil ers. Mr. David H. Brown, who 'resides iu Stowe township, directly back of Chartiers, formerly of Tom's Bun, is an overseer in the coal mines of the Pennsylvania Hailroad Company, and gave the writer an interest ing account of his experiences: as a miner. "My trouble began about 13 years ago. It came on me gradually, and was caused j by colds, contracted from exposure to the dampness in the mines. My nostrils be came clogged up, and I could not breathe through my nose. My head was stopped up, and I had a dull, heavy pain across my forehead and in my temples all the time. There was a buzzing and roaring sound in my ears. This condition continued or a long time. Finally my trouble began to ex tend," and I soon found myself in a very seri ous condition. David S. Brown, Stowe TovmsMp. "A dry, hacking cough set in, and I (had a constant tickling sensation in my throat. I could feel the mucus dropping back into my throat, and would wake up during the pight feeling as thoneh I was choking. I was continually hawking and raising large quantities of phlegm ot a greenish yellow color. My eyes became yery much in flamed. My throat and tongne were always sore. "Sharp shooting pains would go through my chest, extending to the shoulder blade. They were so) severe on the left side, that-' ior tne last tnree years J. could not lie on that side at all. My limbs became swollen. Night sweats weakened me, and I lost flesh rapidly. I could not sleep. "When I got up in the morning I -was more tired than' when I went io bed, and had a dizzy and faint feeling that would last for several hours. "I felt hungry, but when I went to the table the very sight of food took away my appetite. I grew weaker and weaker, and finally had to stop work. Whenever I at tempted to do 'anything I became short of breath and had to sit down. It was when in tbe condition described above, that I first beard of Drs. Copeland A Blair. I had tried so many physicians that I had lost faith, but deter mined to see them. Tbey did not promise to perform any miracles, but I felt they could do me good, so placed myself under their care. "t soon fonnd a decided improvement in my condition. My head and chest ceased to pain me. My eyes became strong and clear and I have no more trouble with my ears. The Dain in my left side has disappeared, and my throat is no longer sore. Tho cough has left me. I sleep well and feel rested in the mornings, and can relish my food. I have grown strong and cameu in weignr. i oreatne ireeiy, ana can do a good day's work. I owe my recovery to Doc tors Copeland &. Blair, and am gratefnl to them for making me a perfectly well man once more. Mr. Brown lives, as stated,in Stowe township, back of Chartiers, and his. statement can be easily verified. t Additional Evidence by Mall. A short time ago Mr. tahn Wright, of Chica go Junction, Ohio, placed himself nnder treat ment by mail with Drs. Copeland & Blair. In writing about his trouble be said: "Two years ago I was HI with lung fever and never fully recovered from it. I could not sleep at night. Tbe mucus would drop back into my throat, and I would wake up feeling as though I was choking:. Large scabs would come from my nostrils whenever I used my handkerchief. Thev would often be streaked with blood. My eyes were affected and were continually "running a watery substance. I was unable to attend to my duties, feeling weakand tired all tbe time. I bad a hacking cough and ringing noises in my ears. Graduajly I noticed I was becoming deaf. I .would have dizzy spells and my mem ory failed me. I had pains in my chest and bad no appetite. "A short time after I commenced, treatinz with Drs. Copeland A Blair I noticed an im provement. The dropping in my throat stopped, my cough and the pains in my chest left me. I can now sleep and eat well. The result has been a great surprise to me, as I had given up all hope of ever getting well again." Abont the middle of last May Miss Lottie J. Forker, of 299 Arch street, Meadville, Pa placed herself under treatment by mail With Drs. Copeland & Blair. In stating her case by letter just previous to tbe date above men tioned she complained of terrible headaches, followed by spills of vomiting, whleb would compel ber to lie in bed for 24 hours, after which she would be completely worn out. Bharn pain in the breast, extending through to the shoulder blades, and followed oy others in her RtnmAeh and side- On June 9 she wrote: "Your medicine is do ing me cood, 1 do not feel so tired, and my head has only ached twice, and that was caused by a fresh cold I caught" Qn July 2 her letter stated that she was feel ing very welL ' Aueust 26 she wrote: "I feel quite like a different woman from the one I was when I commenced yonrtreatment." Some time ago Mr. M. C Wilson, of Canons burg, Pa., placed himself under treatment, by mall, with Drs. Copeland 4 Blair- In stating his case by letter early in July, he complained of a full, heavy feeling in his head over the eyes, a bad taste in the month, conghlng and raising phlegm, dimness of sight, sharp pains in the chest, with a tight, pinched feeling and soreness in the lungs, and a weak and shaky condition ot the limbs. July 25 he wrote: "lam improving steadily; feel ever so much better than I have in years." August IS he wrote: "I feel like a different being from the one! was when I commenced your treatment, and I am quite willing that a short statement of what your treatment has done for me should be made in the papers." DOCTORS s Are located permanently at 66 SIXTH Ml,, Where they 'treat with success all curableeages. Office bonrs-9 to 11 A. Jf.:2 to 5 p. Jr.; 7 to 9 p. st. (Sunday included). . , ,. Specialties CATARRH, and ALL DIS EASES ot the EYE, EAR, THROAT and LUNGS Consultation, M Address all mall to DBS. COPELAND 4 BLAIR, ' gWixttftYs.PittthurftPa, j- "" " CttllMUlR j'fV-' - f - , -3. i A.,, SHKKftbBtaSBta! " L""fft mew . KB rWTMFKMMRJP! ' t, ' rVJ . AiFINEPIECEOF Chewing n i ""IK! Toba&o:l IS INDEED A LTISUKr. ( FINZER'S Comes as near betes; a Sae piece ot PLUG TOBACCO as H is posetMel to make it; and la kaeWB as a STANDARD BRAND; AMONG DEALERS. -3f We are sure that ONE TRTAT?: convince you of its merits.' -A Ma-Loci, for tha red H Ma tag oa eaeh JNO. PINZER & BROS., LOUiaVliiTYB, KY. mhM&flem ALLEGHENY. TWO' DA7S OJTLTT, Monday and Tuesday, Sept 23 and 24 AT EXPOSITION PARK P. T. BARNUtfliS -'GREATEST SHOW ON EARtB$ Great London Circus ,..., , ,. "a mia moorisn varivair. Paris Olvmnla Hinnadroma. .. c Black Wizards Test of Wottoss. $ "APEBFECTBEVELAXIONOF8URPBtSESJ Amazement, Astonishment and Mystlfleatiea Depicted on the faces of all Visitors. Children delighted with Fairyland Wonders. BARNUM & BAILEY'S GBEATEST EFFORTS REALIZED. A Sumptuous Feast ot Dazzling Splendors.. Rich Costumes. Wonderful Features. High Class Equestrianism. Beautiful Displays. Remarkable Feats. Perfect Performances. Marvellous Attractions. Magnificent Exhibi tions. Fifteen enormous exhibitions Combined la one. 3 Full Circus Companies in 3 Rings. Special Elevated Stage Performances. 2 Monster Museums of Wonders and Cariosities 2 Herds of Performing Elephants.. -.- - 2 Droves of Arabian Desert Camels. 2 Troupes of Trained Imported Stallioes. Great Mid-Air Displays of RsalBarloj.i Hosts or trt ariess tu en-ciass toreien hiiubih '20 Pantomimic Clowns. 20 Animal Clowns." A whole Menagerie of Trained Beasts 125 Breath- taking and liattnz Acts. JsTi , Old Honest! " -s,iJrrjP'iiJJ-My fflpj Everything New, Novel and Wonderful. -Two Performances every day, st 2 and 3 P. X. Doors open an hour earlier. 1 Admission SOcts. Children under 9 years, 25 cts. . Great Street Parade Morning of Arrival of.'l Show. Route as follows: South ave, to Allegheny ave., to Western ave., to Ohio st, to Federal st, to Isabella st. across Seventh at bridge, to Liberty st, to Smithneld st, to Water st, to Wood at., to Third ave., to Market st. to Sixth st, across bridge to Robinson st, to Anderson st, to Church ave.. to Union ave.. to Ohio st, to Federal st, to LacocK st, to Exposition Park. As an accommodation Reserved Seat Tickets will be sold at the regular price and Admission Tickets attbe usual slight advance .at E. O. Hays & Co.' Piano store, 73 Fifth ave. i sel4-31-15,17J9.21,22,2B . URATEFTJL COMFORTINU. EPPS'S eocnL BREAKFAST. By a thorough knowledge ot the natural laws which govern the operations of digestion 'sad nutrition, and and by acarefulappllcatlonoftha fine properties of well-selected Cocoa, Mr. Epos has pro tided our breakfast tables with a deli cately flavored beverage which may save us many heavy doctors' bills. Itis by the judicious use of such articles of diet that a constitution may be gradually built up until strong, enough, to resist every tendency to disease. Hundreds of subtle maladies are floating around us ready to attack wherever there is a weak point .We may escape many a fatal shaft by keeping our selves well fortified with pure blood and a prop erly nourished frame." Civil Service OcueUe. Made simply with ooilingwater or mftf. Held only in half pound tins by Grocers, labdedthss: Jas.Epps&Co. omaLV$?S& noS-h-Wros aOLD KEDAL, PARIS, 1878. "XV. BAKER & CO.'S El It absolutely pure and it it soluble. No Chemicals are used in its preparation. It his eure am Orw Hata OU wtrmgtk of Cocoa mixed wUh Starch, Arrowroot or fingir, and is therefore fir moze economical, corf? tw Oo ette enf a cup. It is delieiooj, nourishing, ttr-ntfhenisg, Xasav DtesesTZO, and admirably adapted ftr hrralklf as veil as for persons hi health. Sold by Grocers everywhere. W.BAKEE & CO.,Dorctifister, Mass. JOEOFLOCKER & CO!3 lUOTTACTU-gEBS Ot - M Rocker's Lubricating Hemp Packing! FOR RAILROAD USE. Italian and American Hemp Paeitefcu Clothes Lines, Twines, Bell Cord, Ftoh Lhses, 4 Chalk Lines, Night Lines, Sisal Bale and Hlas Rope, Tarred Lath Yarn, Spun Yarn, etc "WORKS East street. Alletrhenv Citv. P OFFICE AND SALESROOM-8B Water' utj .UUUi lUVUUVUOi.V.ldU. lUJtf-JlWtri Do You Know It? To perfect a enre, you must remove the cause. WINCHESTER'S HYPOPHOSPHITE OF LIME ANP SODA supplies the system with Oxl dlzable Phosphortu, tie deficiency of wMefe is tbe proximate cause of ConiBmBnHi, For Coughs, Bronchitis, Weak Lnn, Night Sweats-and all Throat Diseases, it Is m as equaled remedy. Sold by Drne'Hts.,.ijper bottle. Recommended b phy;4oiiJ Send lorrarcarar. ninunsaisinsuv,. jibs wiwwovjtes rtsw w HmmmmF BBHaCTSJaBBaHnrXHHi i.aBBBn7zr. . -mil Pi-ay-.' -t-a i. 1