lW TEvTkS L. I, J.? P? i".J r wyvmT'ssnEw'rt m-wr . ;m !8'Jtl'"i " ' ;," V - - f V f - M V IJIS JW l-C r' Se ! fc4 l.ir w, W JLI I H f rtyWB'' L.. , '" F'L-MMm tlfnrt Dithlit UriWr PURMC LEDGER COilANY j ," ,CtnVS H. K. CURTIS. PamiDBxt & f!SS..' J7!?'!, B'crjtaryt Chariea if. Ludlrar lSS,VrS.'I'pi8, Ce"lP,,:7.,)J.hn " WllUm. Jehn J. mtiSSn 0el'" F' OeM'mltli. David B. 8mlly. PAVID B. SMILEY .EJltet JOHN C. MAnTIX... Otntrat Butln.n ManatT . Publlahed dAllr t Pcbue Ltren Building ' Indeixndtnca Sauare, Philadelphia.. ATLAxtic Citt , . rrtx-Vnlen nullJInc Van Toek Bmeir..,. T. Loet.., Catcioe.,.. n aiaamen Att. 701 Ferd nultdln 013 aiobt-Drmeernt llulldlrg 1303 Tribune Uulldlnc ,. NEWS Dl'flBAVS: .. J?. H. Cor Pennsylvania Ave. and 14th PI. Tw YesK nciKic .... Th Sun HuiMIr aVoscew BcitiC Trafaljar Uulldlna ... SlUSCKtPIlON1 TKHJftt Tha Etbsine 1'oiue Limn is arrtd te ub erlbtra In 1'hllaltlphla, and aurreunllne towns t th rata et twelv (J) ctnu wr wtik. paiablt fe the carreer. Br mall te relnta eutalde of Philadelphia In Tn TTnltrd .states. Canada n- I'Mtrd Stain ri S?,,l?n,,Jp"Ulr8 '"' nJt' (50' nt Per month. Te all fereien .ciri- n- s 1 rtM.ar a innn-h I Nonet Subaertic wlihlng addrtas charred , nuat give old aa wii as nw adJrts. BELL. 3m VAI.SIT KlY'TONE. M 4IN IJ01 j VTAdJrest nil foinmiiitlfiiffe'i fe Evtne P'ibHc Lritgtr, InJepmdiier Square, Phllnilelfihla. Member of the Associated Press THE ASSOCUTED rRKSS is txelutwtlv en titled te the ue or republication e' nil pic ItpafcAr crfditfd fe (f or nor efnfnru crditfrf n tMs vaver, and alia ln local nnrj pne.uhed ficrcln. XII riehft nt rfpubricafien of svectal Jjpafci herein art nlu rirvd. I'hilnltlphu UrdnrxUt. Auuil 16. !:: GOOD TRANSIT NEWS TVTAYOK MOOUC'S uiiiieunct'iiieiit iLnt lu Intpiitl te l)Ut.li plnnv for n prnrnm i cemprelienilvtf rapid tran-lt tUnnlopinent In tlie hope of havins !t adopted with the "iane. tlen of Council and in ngrcHment with the P II. T. hefore his ndinliiltratien mis H feed news and bis new. It Is plain that Mr Meer new i '.early perrelves the unwisdem of the nnre te whleli the !t wus leininitud and te which his Administration fell heir when for sec tional political reasons crandkwe but In ninny respects Impracticable networks of ubways and flevated -trueture!' were ordered constructed with huse lenn earmarked for ench. but with the all-Important q.ictlen of hew mid by whom the should be operand left unsettled. That wa a mistake whi.h ought never again te be permitted Since the rehabl'itatinn of the I' II T nd its emancipation from polltice-tinuncial control hate been accomplished under the Mitten management, the Id-al nnd, in fact, the only complete workable plan must lie operation a? a unit of the whole transit sys. teni lu the city The Mayer, therefore, is en the right track when he declares that he Is going te call the 1' It T a well as Council into conference before expending a dollar of the taxpayer' money in further extensions There can be only one reason able result of such a businesslike way of preceedln; and that l an arrnngemnt which will b satisfactory te everybody be cause every factor will be represented It would be the grossest felly te go ahead with the building of llne which an oper ating company would net rind suitable be cause they were erected te suit the voters of particular district and net n a proper ngineering project. The Mayer's plan cannot fail te bring '.he best thought te bear upon the .-ubjeet and If carried through In the desired spirit of civic pride and unselfishness it will be an achievement upon which, when the time comes for him te lay down the heavy duties and responsibilities f his difficult emVe. Mr Moere can leek ba. k with real personal satisfaction as a monument te his Adminis tration. FRANCIS B. REEVES FRANCIS B. REEVHS was n type of re former who invested that term some times mistrusted with honorable distinction nnd wen for it a large measure of popular respect. His career in Philadelphia Is a idgnal instance of the r.ght conception of public spirit. Mr. Heeves labored unceasingly nnd un selfishly for the geed of the community, nnd there were fen humanitarian enterpris.es of note Tith which hu name was net con nected. In polities his aim was the reverse of self-aggrandizement. It was the welfare of the city which he had sincerely at heart. and It Is pleasant te recnll that his con sistent espousal of the cause of clean gov ernment played no inconsiderable part in the elevation of that affectionately remembered "old war-horse," Rudelph Blankenburg, te the mayoralty. Philadelphlans after the mannr of Fran cis H Reeves, men peeed uf his quiet fewer of genuine constructive accomplish ment, are net tee common. His pas.-lng leaves a regrettable gap in the ranks of riti aens of whom this community i.js the right te be proud. Ills was a life of fine ideals unflaggingly pursued, without vanity and without the least insistence upon the spectacular. MARVELS OF PSYCHOANALYSIS CHARLES HATES VEISP,ER;. stu dent at the Iniversity of Pennsylvania, has passed a national psycheanal ticul tes with flying colors and is declared by ex perts te have the finest all-round rntch-.ii-catch-can mentality in anv college in the country. Ills Is the champion heavy weight brain ; science has proved It. Charles, In telling of the infnllible meth ods by which this was discovered, i-ays : "There were some questions calculated te teet the students' powers of observation, among which I remember one as te whether the figures en City Hall clock were Arable or Reman. Luckily. I hail noticed them and remembered they were of the latter type." The only observation allowable te a mere editorial commentator Is that there are no figures nt all en the City Hall deck , there Is merely a straight line te indicate the di visions of the face Inte fie-mlnute periods. THE TRUTHFUL CAMERA r' IS en old axiom lu newspaper work that u murder story in tripled In news Tnlua If a love tangle is woven Inte it. Sordid details of crime ure lightened and rlghtened and made pnlatable te the public ' the atmosphere of romance nnd the rtlc thought of a love that stepped at Vhlng. f'e rrnd of u husband Main and n wife nil mIiose effects are found hundreds of donate love letters from another man. i de net, en this account, overlook the neutneb)i of murder, but we find our- tia Inclined te view with added interest f i J. aMbUK. K e mental picture of n beautiful wemnu ff- vauiht u tue web ei a tangled heart ir-MtmCiiy. '.'B 'And then comes the cruel and heartless ,iMi,'''unreinnntlc newspaper photographer, "' ' ---- f-niii lila fifixlvnmtnt in "mve," ,'3i7rM, 1,u ,ll,Ies nlmsclf uml utN Plates 'aWtfckta darkroom, for ten minute and t emerges" with what? An nll-toe-trup like ness of the heroine I And nhe is dowdy nnd ordinary, and her bet friends would hnvc te admit that she wns fat nnd she herself would have te ndmlt te forty. And she wears the spectacles of frank near-sighted-nes nnd her beets ere eminently of the "sensible"' variety. All nt once the whole case descends once mere te what It really Is n drab and ferdid story of erdlnnry people without n hint of real romance te color Its stark ghnstliness nnd unleveliness. MONAGHAN'S GOOD EXAMPLE TO JUDICIAL ROUTINEERS One Court In Which Courageous Initia tive Is Brought te the Aid of the Law QROANIZATION polities has had a great deal te de with giving te some Phlln de'phla Judges the aspect of casual nnd rather bored spectators in the courts where the preside Elsewhere particularly in Ene'nnd, sometimes In New Yerk mid often In the West Judges feel bound te make geed use of knowledge gained by direct oh eh oh tervatien and experience and te utilize cvl dence discovered through the questioning of witnesses as ground for rresh initiative In action against criminals or In the Interest of the unfertunnte. There Is no reason why indignation or compassion or an Intelligent sense of re sentment should be forever absent fiem the hem h or why the humane inucern of n Judge should net find expression In methods of procedure devised te realie the sji.rit as we'l as te Interpret the letter of the low Hut for eme sorts of men there is an ad vantage In the ether method. The Judge, who Is merely n cool nnd disinterested and unmoved interpreter, n ort of umpire nt the game of the courts, will seldom tread un wittingly en the tees of his political friends. Hy leaving the whole business of fact -finding nnd prosecution te the District Attorney's office he can remain safe and respectable within the narrowing circle of his traditional responsibilities, even if he never does any thing te advance the spirit of justice and decency and humanity whldi the lnw is sup sup pes'd te fester. It I- te the great credit of Judge Jehn Mennghnii that he displays, particularly in the d.rectien of the inquiry into Illicit drug cases, nothing of the aloofness and lazy tolerance that se often confuses nnd re tards In the courts the processes of justice and enlightenment. He evidently has what a'.l Judges are supposed te have, a desire te be right rather than merely literal in the presence of problems complicated by misery nnd ignorance and misfortune. And he has imagination nnd courage In groping te the bottom of the general mess that had the Ginsberg parole as one of it outward signs. Judge Menaghnn has been making use of hints and implications con tained In the evidence te ftnd n way grad ually te th higher-ups who profit by the dope traffic. Clearly. It is futile and cruel te send victims of the drug habit te .mil and ask no questions about the people who prof ited and continue te profit deliberately by their degradation That is what a geed man magistrates and Judges In the courts of record have been entent te de It I net hard te find an ex planation for this startling lack of curiosity In some of the mi:rt The drug traffic is linked up rather 'eely nith the underworld outposts of ward politics. And In a pinch that threatens exposure of this incredible alliance the dope peddler- can always he as sured of th help of well-paid lawyers with political influence great enough te awe even a Quarter Se ions Judge Judge Menachal! has be-n proceeding ie. lntlesly in hu efforts te let light In through the veil that pehticul thugs have managed te draw around the sources from which dope is isued in increasing quanti ties and with increasing profit te the groups that -upply the peddlers. He ba presented the udd spec-tai Ie of a Judge telling the Di--trh t Attorney's office and the chief of the county detectives things which the should have known long age. It is almost tee much te hope that one Judge con expose and break up the drug distribution system. That Is. a job which requires persistent investigation unhampered by political influence of any sort. Yet the Inquiry In Judge Mennghan's court has al ready gene far enough te make mere than one political heeler think seriously of a term in one of the jail- that holds the add.cts he helped te make. Here then :- a Judge who ebv.mi-!y ha an Intellectual, rathe.- than a political, con ceptien w h.s function aim nis relation te society. There i- no reason, one might sa. why a spirit similar te that revtaled in Judge Mennghan's attitude in drug cases should net be present every day in ull the criminal courts Hut there is n reason. There are two reasons. One is political, for self. interested politicians have tee much te de with the appointment of Judges. The ether reason Is temperamental. Net every man i capable of pity or able te ee the social casualty behind the battered exterior of a drug vic tim or se constituted as te hate the in justices which perversions of the legal cede sometimes make possible even in the courts. Any one who has net forgotten hew te think ought te be able te see by this time that the courts, like the Congress of the United States, have suffered through the power of debased and unenlightened political factions and that they need u new baptism of the American spirit. Dull reutineers en the bench have done a geed deal In recent years te diminish the prestige of the bench and 'e lessen the tei-la! efficiency of the law Itself Their open service te their political masters has disillusioned multitudes The fearlessness Judge Menaghnn is new showing provides n reassuring example for the public. JERSEY ROADS IN A time when highway construction has become the greatest public activity In most of the States, tell bridges privately operated are obviously out of date. The transfer of the great Ocean Clty-Semers Point bridge from the owning corporation te the Highway Department of New Jersey and the elimination of the tell system is characteristic of n State which always bus been awtire of the value of geed reads. An An other link Is thus completed in what ulti mately will be u line ocean boulevard along the entire Jersey coast line. Jersey may new he n little prouder than ever of its highways, which ure still among the mebt inviting In the country. The irrcnt concrete pike, new almost com pleted between Camden and Atlantic I ity plnna te ereu It lute. In October are no' EVENING PUBLIC LEDGER nfoet is ene of the triumphs of modern read construction. Stretches of "hnrd" read almost as geed nrc te be found in northern parts of the State. Hut te the motorist who Is net In a hurry and net anxious te seek short cuts the older elder fashioned yellow gravel reads of the In terior, nearly always well kept nnd level nnd beautiful, continues te be nttractlve. There nrc hundreds of miles of them which seem almost tee geed te be real. They run for the most part through rich farming nre.is nnd in unlet, idyllic country, ami lend tourists In nil seasons through landscape tlint might have been copied from the can vases of the best of painters. The speeders arc net en them, for they nre wandering reads, nnd In some wny or ether n very able lllghwny Department keeps them free from dust. One of the best things about the newer system of concrete highways is that it will help te preserve the beautiful dirt reads of Jersey for travelers In the diminishing class which still has n disposition te be leisurely nnd the wish "for te admire nnd for te see" rather than a desire te rush headlong from one uninteresting place te another. THE DESERT OUTRAGE 'TMIE sufferings of 3700 passengers - stranded in nineteen trains In various Isolated and arid points in California, New Mexico nnd Arizona were acute, but tem porary. It Is the damage te the cause of the railway strikers that Is well-nigh Irrep arable. The abandonment of transconti nental trains by their crews, engineers, con ductors, firemen, wns an outrage for which public opinion can find no defense. It was the contention of the Rig Four Riotherheods that members of their elder would have te quit work If conditions proved hazardous. Definition of the extent of risk was hence left te the railway empleyes as Individuals. As a means of expressing sym pathy with the striking shepmen and also ns a pretest against the maintenance of armed guards nt the Sante Fe yards, some scores of het -heads conceived the Idea of marooning travelers In desert regleus. The conception was novel as It was Indefensible. While It Is true that the se-called desert stations, especially along the route of the Santa Fe, possess hotel accommodations and ether accessories of civilization, the very existence of these places Is artificial nnd wholly dependent upon the circulation of trains. A prolonged stoppage of traffic would be devastating In Its effect. Cllmutic conditions reach their maximum of severity in the arid stretches of the Southwest in midsummer. The thermom eter in the Pullmans, stalled at Needles, Calif . registered 1'JO degrees. It was impossible te heue a whole train lead of passengers In the little town. Ice melted away, previsions were spoiled. Aged travelers and babies were speedy victims of the ordeal and in several Instances barely escaped death. A delegation of passengers, appealing te a committee of the biotherheod men for re lief at Needles, was met with the rejoinder thnt "net n wheel would move until the armed guards were removed from the rail way yards." A- in many instunccs the trainmen were comfortable enough In their own habitations In these desert stations, the cruelty and brutality of their procedure were thereby aggravated. Brotherhood members indulging in this felly have justified their action en the ground of sympathy with the shop rratl-i In their dispute. Sympathy is ironical in this con nection. The public has very little of It for the reckless men In whom what should be ordinary instincts of humanity were sup pressed for a spectai ular play, the fru.t of which can unly be general and righteous censure. WORK FOR A COMMISSION The suggested fact-finding couimis-ien for dealing with future negotiations in the soft -coal industry is geed n far u it gees, but it doesn't go fnr enough. The commission is te be chosen by the miners nnd operators, with the personnel te be approved by the President. This last clnu-e should mean representation of the third party, the consumers. Hut if would be better if the commis sion were n public body with Congre-s be hind It and having the power te investigate net enlv the soft -coal but the anthracite lndustrv. It sounds tee mi;eh like a clee corporation or family affair n? It stands. A disciple of the trnmp Humorists portrayed by Old He-s Gene Wrong Hoey is nt large in Pat- ersen. N. J. W hile i lie farailv was In bed he stele the front deer of n dwelling house, loci:, iiinges mm mi. Th police are new en the alert te prevent him from stealing n house te lit the deer The chain e- are. though, that the allege, thief is simplv n -ulTercr from a perverted sense of humor There nre such. Witness the two visitor- from suburban towns picked up bv a Philadelphia cop with their auto mobile tilled with "Ne Parking and "Safety .one" signs. Dispatch from Een. Rule of the den says Americans in Read Londen are no mere befuddled by the new Walk-en-the-Ecft" signs than the Hritlsh ers themselves. Always the rule hus beeu Keep te the Right." Hut there Is ex cellence in the change se long ns the ru cs of the read remain as they are. All vehicles keep 'te the left there Conformity te the new' rule for pedestrians keeps these en the outside of the sidewalk facing the traffic. Having noted the fuels It Hit. of Course (recorded iu n recent runt) us report) that people live longer In the country than In the city ; that women live longer than men : that whites live longer than .Negroes; und thnt theie are ever se many States whose residents live longer than the-e of Pennsyl vania ; the old colored porter in a local bar ber shop grinned and wiiii. "Dem figures Is neen me ; but figures weiildn t be interesting nohew if it wn'n't fe de exceptions. Twe goats in the Stranger Than Washington Park Zoe Fiction at El Pnse, Tex., nre nursing a pair of baby antelopes. A pigeon at (jlen Ridge, N. J thought te be hutching a hutch of eggs, was found bitting en eight young rats, all fast asleep And sprightly comment is estepped, darn It', by the knowledge thut the beem- ingly Impossible bterlcs ure probably sober sooth. A dispatch from Teklo says the Japa nese people believe the navy cut iu accord ance with agreement made at the Wash ington Conference does net cut deep enough, and that present military preparations are costing tee much uienej . It Is a sentiment that speaks well for the pence of the world. Sensational preacher of New Yerk clnssc "hlenillned hair, wooden nutmegs, half-cotton wool, waiered milk, pasteboard leather, padded forms and yellow journal ism" with "gambling den. drinking hells and haunts of shnme." Thus does over emphasis iiiiike u mock of reform. New Jersey Is planning n visiting auto tax because Pennsylvania authorities compel New Jersey fnrmeis delivering produce te takn out n Pennsylvania llcensa. About time te swep "reprisals" for "reciprocity." 1 PHILADELPHIA, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 1G, AS ONE WOMAN SEES IT Hew Leve Enabled a Country Girl Who Had Acquired Education and Culture te Bring Neat nets and Beauty Inte Her Heme Without Hurt ing Anybody Hy SAKAII I). LOWRIB I WAS listening te n very pretty, very charming friend of mine talking te n young country girl who hnd stepped in te have n chat with its en her wny home from delivering some chickens. The talk was mostly en clothes, nnd my friend ended suddenly by taking the girl off te her room te show her some of her things, with a possible lden of pntterns, etc. I heard them for the next half hours i.s busy ns school girls, while polgnelrs, tea gowns, fluffy ruffles and evening slippers were discussed, tried en mid gnyly admired nnd laughed ever. In the end the girl went off with one of the dresses, n green Inuslln, ruffled frock for a pattern und nlsq, I suspect, for "keeps." x Ever since this girl has been growing up she Is new just of ..ge these little con fidential confabs have been going en about clothes mostly, but from clothes te ether things, se thnt with no self-consciousness en the child's part, my frlqnd 1ms her entire confidence us well as her most loyal admira tion; the sort of homage a young girl glveR a pretty, charming woman when nfar off she frankly imitates her. In this girl's case the Imitation went much deeper than clethes: she copied her quiet nnd loving way of doing drnstlc things, und happily for herself she hed enough character of her own te ninke net only the clothes but 'he manners she ussimllnted lit her own environment and the needs of her net lesser but different occasions. "COR Instance, the girl had the geed sense net te make n ten gown, but she did contrive n most delightful chnce frock for her senior graduation dnnce nt the normal school, nnd after a long study of nil my friend's slippers she enmc te the just con elusion thnt black ones would be her own "best buv" ns being suitable for most occa sions. The silk underthlngs she did net attempt, but the light featherweight of them nnd their simplicity, yet their fragile prettl ness. gave her an Idea that matured Inte quite ns delightful nnd practical little gar ments. And what wns true of her adapta tion of clothes wns even mere apparent In her adaptation of my friend's theory thnt there Is n right and hind nnd lovable way of doing everything which needs doing. The girl hnd no smnll problem of her own te face, and It met her ns se many preblmi de when she came home for the first time en her holidays from school nnd saw her family nnd her old home for the first time with seeing eyes. FWAS a kindly household nnd about as hospitable te pigs nnd hens nnd files nnd ubiquitous children ns it wns te the farm hands, the old people nnd the "careless men men eolk." the father nnd brothers who were mere kindly than they were clean. The mother of the family had long given up the task of getting order out of the chaos. And, in letting the house stay in n mess, she had pretty well lest her own sense of personal geed leeks. She wns amusing, nnd in her caustic way generous, but she wns really an "object" nnd nppenred te have become sardonically Indifferent te her un kemptness. The ether sons and daughter ns tney grew up had fallen Inte the family hnbits of never "red ing up." se that the sight that confronted the girl fresh from school nnd from nil the new-learned serenity of an orderly environment seemed about as hopeless as It was disheartening. ller getting away te school hnd been something little short of n revolution, a sort of romantic experiment In educntlen en the part of u family that for two generations hnd been content, nppnrently, te forge book learning. Even the inenev necessary te beard her In the town where the normal school was und the bare necessities of school books nnd city clothes were get together by a sort of miracle from funds hid in stock ings nnd held back secretively by one or another of the family for some cherished object, the pe. e-sien of wl Ich receded or came te the foreground of their hopes as crops were geed or bad, or the berry season was abundant or failed, or the chickens mul tiplied or dwindled. In fact, the girl's getting off te school was the result of mere than one dumbly offered sacrifice en the part of the elder members of her family ; and It was this ns much as her own frank, restless hopes ever the adventuie that made the whole thing leek se perilous te these of u- who were spectators. What if the experimein should fail with the girl! Or what if If succeeded tee well, made her home n futuie Impossibility! Or. worse still, what if she tried te change old habits in ethers ns they h,d s() easily been changed lu her. and hurt and alienated the queer, crechety hearts that had set her free from u bondage which tin hnd grown te ignore und even enjev . TALKING of clothes with inv friend, she talked of her dilemma with thing- ns the were at home. She saw with a child like candor the backwardness mnl nlmest .ni.Kn.lflHnn ef t l!it dim n 1 wM .'in liA fninlli U' "&il 41UII 14.111 " . M.. " -' ...... ... IUIIIIIJ love back of it, and her own debt te thnt love. Hew te change thing- without hurt ingthat was her liiiiin question! Whether te gradually dis-eclnte her-e'f from the' environment, her very levnl heart never seemed te allow her te eni, template. It was plain for n fnmil.v's N1i,. 10 could never bring into "that mess'1 ;nn ,,( Unpereon- who hnd made her new life ; that was just common sense, net snobbishness Well. I heard fragment- of these discus sions, lightly tteercd by the elder woman and gently analyzed by the gitl. and I gathered that the thing was in he done pain lebsly, or net nt all. THE child had charm, ilie clnrin of jeuth nnd health and a well-kept bedv and an intelligent. ncquiHiuvi- iimm nun piett wn.vs of u-lng her bed, lu a f.imily where nil the teetn went in the early twenties, her perfect ones for she had spent her berry -picking money ns n child In visits te the countryside di ntlst were of themselves an nlmest romantic asset She would have passed us u pretty fresh, schoolgirl any where, hut In thnt dark, iinndv farmhouse her neat iriinness wns u refreshing r,.6t I0 worried i.ves. Perhnps If she hnd been a homely girl or an awkward one she could net have put her difficult game through with se light a touch. Hut she used all her delightful differences ns se nianv spells of levenblenes.s. She iihked nothing of tin mnt all. except te let her work for them EACH day the famil moved line some new niul ifen-nnt. renovated spot in the house with a kind of laughing curiosity of pride nnd expeitnncy. The girl hud sllinu lited them Inte nil ntlltude of p!ent,re in their new -old environment, ii liking also le linve guests come und see. The change In volved no additional drudgerv te the mother in fact, the things she had ulwuvs frankly hated doing, nnd had long only half done, were done without her being aware of any hnnUhip te any one. ;.i the ease and tuiiusliigiuss nnd general rcieH feeling that the change wns accom plished, it was as greut a triumph of love ns love ever witnessed. Ne doubt when she gees hack te complete her course at the normal school, things will slip hack mere than n little, and no dmiht when she gees te her teaching next enr lu some distant town, nothing much will have i hanged le the outward eye In that queer old shuck lint I nm willing te wager thnt they will leek forward te her homecomings with a comfortable assurance thnt she will "red them up" again lu no time and set the household wheels spinning neislessly while she Is In their midst. And I feel sure, tee, thnt if she were nsked tedny hew she did it. he would take none of the credit te herself fnr her manner of accomplishing It, but refer in grateful nppreclntlveness te the happy councils of her adviser iu iuuuucrs us ncu n u uuvuea. &P V-. 5iiS$J -I Hinsll zfflfflSMwMm mMmSm uBaxMmm''' I M-J&MM$' v'effli BiinMIBH Hnf n ij'n Miff iiBi in :r;gH3St.aBateV-';r i licZ- ''".. j " .-i' . '.. NOW MY IDEA IS THIS! Daily Talks With Thinking Philadelphia en Subjects They Knew Best CHARLES E. KNAUSS On Modern American Church Music THE great advance In modern American church musk- which has been shown in the Inst few years is due principally te the congregations themselves, according te Chnrles E. Knnuss, organist nnd choir mas ter nt the Woodland Presbyterian Church. "We have just passed through a period of about twenty-live years of exceedingly bad chinch music." said Mr. Knnuss, "but It has net been the fault of the music itself in nil ca-es. One great trouble has been that in the city churches especially there has been a great deal of music which was originally written for boy choirs, nnd very effectively written, tee, but it has been mis placed and sung by mixed choirs nnd by sole quartets, and hence the effect intended by the composer has net been brought out. ' "The same thing in n slightly different sense is true of the better grade of English church music, such ns the works of Harnby, Stniner and ether composers of the same dnss. These works ure essentially choral works and they cannot be effectively pre sented by a quartet, no matter hew well that quartet slugs; nnd many of them sing very well, indeed. It Is nlmest as though an orchestral composition were played by a string quartet. Geed American Composers "A gient deal may he -aid with entire justice for many of the American com posers, such ns Dudley Ruck and ethers. These men have done their full share of the work needed te lift Ameiican church music te the plane which it should rightfully oc cupy. Hut, while it cannot be disputed thut they have done some things well, still the day of such music Is rapidly passing. "The most encouraging thing nheut the better composers in this country at the present time is the fact that they nte de veloping a st vie which is peculiarly their own, and thut it is a st.vle which Is pre eminently fitted te service- tn the American churches'. Among the-e men Feete, West nnd tluxlngteu Ilurker are the must promi nent. "This new American st.vle is primarily based upon the best of the English btyle of church music, but it does net ilgidly adhcie le the fatlffness which churneterUes much of the best Rrltish music for the church. It may be generally described as American church music along the best lines, nnd it is n new nnd gratifying development of the music of our ceuntiy. net only for the church alone, but for the nrt of music generally. Causes of the Change "This pleasing and interesting i linage for the better in the music of the American churches hub been brought about bv a com bination of circumstnnies. The fust nnd most impeitnnt of these circumstani es is the mere general musical cultivation of the pub lic, and heive of the individual members of the cougiegatiens. Wheie one person tvventv years age had an eclectic knowledge of music, today there eie literally hundreds who have it and the number is increasing nil the tune. "It fellows, as n matter of course, that this knowledge und desire for the better things In music must lu time reach into Un churches, where the congregations, new largely composed of persons who go te sym phony concerts und recitals by the great Interpretative musts nun urns constantly hear geed music outside the dumb, will demand better music iu the sei vices, ,U1, congregation is very likely le get whatever It makes up Its mind te have. A congiega cengiega congiega tlen innde up of persons, n large percentage of whom hnvc heaid the Philadelphia Or chimin "I'd the great soloists with even reasonable frequency, will net tolerate for a moment such music ns hns been the rule in many of the American churches for the last couple of decades, They will insist upon something better nnd, what is mere te the Kiint, they will get it. "The recend cause Is that the organists of the various churches hare fully realized 1922 "ER-R, WHO WON?" this marked change which has come upon the Fpirit of the congregntiens in se far ns the church music is concerned, nnd they hnve worked harder te bring nheut geed music thnn they did when the music in the. church wns seemingly n matter about which very few persons in the congregations con cerned themselves Werk of the Organists "Every organist who is of the right kind musically will enjoy doing this work, for It will be in thorough nccerd with his own feelings with regard te his nrt. The day has pased most emphatically when a singer in the church will he permitted, ns I heard myself net se many years age while visit ing another church, te get up and sing Nevln's 'Rosary' te the words of the hymn 'Just ns I Am.' And this is only a single one of many instances just ns flagrant. The congregntiens nrc far past this point new, and I nm glnd te 'ay that this feeling en their part has met with enthusiastic co operation from the organists ns a class nnd from many of the singers themselves as well. "In many of the churches there hns been a reaction hack toward the original st.vle of church music. I mean that of Palestrlnn and tlie ether composers of the early con trapuntal school. All religious music Is really based upon this music, and. there fore, It has been In a measure n return te first principles. While this music has net nlwn.vs the emetlnnnl feeling of many of the Inter composers, it hns n dignity nnd n inn jesly which is always fitting in church music, nnd It is nlvvnys wonderfully fine and effective whenever the organist hns a choir which can hnndle this difficult music. "My own experience with choirs hns been thnt singers in the churches nre usually am bitious enough te enjoy singing this music. Hut, nfter nil, the music te be selected fnr nny church depends te u verv great extent upon the type of choir which thut church has. Just as there are several types of choirs, ve there nre nlse several types of music, ench of which is especially ndnpted for the use of n particular kind' of choir. That church in which the organist most skillfull combines the music which lie selects with the tvpe of choir which he hns nlwn.vs hns the most effective music. Sole Velres and Choruses "Iu churches where there ar" boys' voices, or where the voices of the sole quartet nre net exploited, hut where choral i fleets are the things most sought nfter. the Palestrlnn school of composition has come back most strongly. These works nre almost nlwn.vs for chorus, and. therefore, cannot be ef fectively rendered hv n quartet or even by n sunll dr poorly trained chorus. The chorus which would essjiv Palestrlnn must he fairly large and exceedinglv well trained in order te innke the works effective. "Many churches nre obliged, for various reiseii'. te have n quartet choir. Very geed effects may he produced with the four voices If they nie geed ones, nnd ihe singers un well trained, as Is usually the case will, the larger churches which maintain this form of i hiirch music. Hut under no circum stances mi it lie considered lis Ideal for winks which vwr IginnUy written for a chorus. Real churehly fleets can best be produced with u chorus or with a choir of boys' voices in places where tin- ergnnist has sufficient time nnd Intelligence le tinin them properly. Outlook Is Excellent "On the whole, the outlook for better church music in this ceuntrv is excellent, fnr better than it has been for many yenrs past. As I have siiid. the mailer starts with the members of the Cfiiiftregnluu It felf first of all The choirmasters anil the organists have come te r-ulue dearly that the rendition of cheap stuff is net going le gel tin m nnvwhen- except outside tile doers of their churches. "With tlie situation ns ft is nt present, tlie Ideal ergnnist or choirmaster is the one who will take the materia! at his dis dis pesal and then have the musicnl scie-e and knowledge te knew what music is best adapted te these voices. Then there must be it sufficient number of rehenrsnls te nllnvv the choir te become thoroughly familiar with um mono- in uu ns piuiHCs before the con lU.,W.. .. ,,, - ---:----- SHORT CUTS Barbers have been regulated. Next! As the Shipping Beard sees It. geed wine needs no Uusch. As we understand it, the Wcstera Union Is willing te bury the issue. The Hareld McCermlcks say they r glad their troubles nre ever. Optimism. The fact that Lloyd Geerge's goat wen n prize in a show proves that nobody ba it.. When a hearse has been searched for hooch It Is a cinch the spirit has departed. Colonel D'Olier takes the ground that the fair only has te be known te be appre ciated. We gather that the friends of the op penent of Senater Frellnghuysen aie oil out le inui.c a Jicceru, As things stand new, the money saved en bridge tells by Ocean City people won't be spent en Sunday candy. And while the Mayer Is busy with high-speed transit service let net the vir tues of a Parkway bus bervlce he forgotten. If the Grand Duke Cyril Is joined hy Percy and Hareld in his fight for the throne of Russia It ought te make a geed comedy film. California fruit crop Is tied up bv tht rail stilke. Oh. well, "putters-up" will have less reason te complain of the tariff en sugar. The way the Chceter nvenue busine'i men leek at it, the time te Bayly skip and step grumbling Is when you can force the traction company te step the skips where it had previously skipped tbe steps. j What De Yeu Knew? QUIZ 1 What queen, by loyal edict, prehlbltel the me of theatre passes? - Who said "Familiarity breeds con tempt"? 3. Where nre the Fortunate Inlands'' 4 Hew does the katydid make its noise' G. Who v ns the Muse of History In Oieek mythology? B What is meant by a clinker-built ship' 7 What Is a bagman In Kngllsh commercial parlance? 5 What Is the meaning of the Turltun title "efrendl"? 3. What Is the middle name of Themas A. Kdlsen? 10. What Is a quadriga? Answers te Yesterday'a Quiz I. Pausnnlns, n, noted (.reek geographer and writer en nrt, who lived in th second century A. I)., mny be said e hnvu been the author of the first guld hook for tourists. His "Gnzeteer nj Hellas" Is the best extant seurce et Information en the topography, local history, religious observation, archl-if-cture ami sculpture of classical Oreece ". Pennsylvania, Ohie. VlrcInU nnd Missouri are States leading in the production et lead. 3 Hcik-s Is Piemler of Czecho-Slevnk a 4 Ills nnint) should be pronounced 'Bay' nesh," with thu accent en the last )! Inble 5. The act of knapping la the uet of break ing stone. The word Is from the Seetcli. C A three-quarter length portrait Is call" a Kit Cat Kit Cats were originally mutton pies, popular In England, es pecially the latter part of file neveij tetnth nnd the cnily part of the eight" renth centuries The Kit Cat (iuh fenneil In Londen at about that perleA It brought teitether wits, humor ists und llterury men The portraits et the members, painted In three-quarter lenmli size by sir (ledfrey KnelU-f; bec.iMie Known ns Kit fats and 'll turn eventually hecame a geneiic ne ter nil pie-uier of that size . 7 ciiailes Hrndlaurh wns a noted UnglH-J i.id'cnl ul llclan nnd advocate ft s. eulariMii. Mtheush elected le Par llHinem In ISSu. he was prevented fro-",. tiik.liK his seat because he refused cm alii- stl" grounds te tul.e the ea-lh. ' was eventually seated three yeuis ia'" Hrudlaugh died In 1S91. ... 8. A Marailiuii tunning course Is 2C ml'" 3 sti yards. 9, Epigraphy Is the study of Inscription! , 10, The paladins were the twelve necrs w the Emperor Charlemagne, The ternw pntndln subsequently came te mean i paragon et knighthood. Mwi 4 I K(i v "'