Wliofi
to H2
P
lBBLP
rrviffifijaiffift npTK
M
J-
U;S.Wojt(tia! Fight,
H x ' Palmer Declares
Continued From rate One
tho end, rfeKolved to sec the Injunction
order obeyed as best us 1 could, In the
hopo that production of. conl vould be
gradually resumed."
Mr Palmer then told ot the corifcrcucc
ho bad with John i. Lew la and Wil
liam Green, president and secretary ot
the miners union, on December 0,
which was arranged by John J. Keegan,
of tlie Department of Labor. At that
time, tho attorney general said, cttu
tlons had then been issued ngninst
.Lewis, Green and other officials of the
union.
Government Stooil Firm
Mr. Palmer Bald that Vhcn Lewis
and.Grcen arrived from Indianapolis he
toU them tho government's position
would be maintained uud that no
change in it would be permitted.
"Was Doctor Garfield's plan consul
ted?" Interrupted Senator Tonsend.
"At the conference with these gen
tlemen," Mr. Palmer tald, "I Informed
them thnt If the men went back to work
tho President's assurance of u fair set
tlement would bo carried out. They
pleaded for a 31 per cent ndvance In
wages, but I said that wns not part of
the job. I told them the government
could not surrender to the United Mine
Workers, and was bound to win in the
end. 'The President, the Department of
Justlco 'and the Federal Court hud
agreed.
Palnur Consulted Garfield
'Thcy left me nt 7 p. m. without
saying whnt they wcro going to do, but
cainu back later with Mr. Tumulty,
secretary to tho President. I then read
to them the President's statement of
December '0, nnd they announced that
they wero Teady to acquiesce In it." Mr.
Palmer said that between tho two meet
ings he talked with Fuel Administrator
Garfield.
"He was In accord with jour nt
tempt lo get n' settlement?" Senator
Towrtsend ashed.
"-Don't call it a settlement, sen
ator," Mr. Palmer replied. "I mnde
no compromise, no concessions with the
men, except one, which was that the
President's statement of December 0
be withheld until they could give it
to their union associates ut Indian
apolis first. I yielded to their request
on that point.
Likens Garfield and Wilson Plans
"There was no, material difference
between Doctor Garfield's plan which
called for a return of the men to work
and a" creation of u consultative body
to investigate and report as to the
facts on which a new wage agreement,
might be arrived at, and the Presi
dent' plan."
Senator Wolcott, Democrnt, of
Delaware, questioned this conclusion.
"I knew what the President meant
by his statement," Mr. Palmer rc
tprted. " "The- agreement with the
miners' Was drawn accordingly."
, "Did you discuss with Lewis and
Green how the commission was to get
this power of fixing wages nnd prices?"
; asked Senator I,rciiugliunen, Uepubli
can, of New Jersey, chairman of the
committee.'
"I did not." Mr. Palmer replied, lie
rx plained that the memorandum of
ngrccment was drawn up on the train
which took his party and Lewis and
Green froirf Washington to Indianap
olis. President Approved Memorandum
;Did the President approve that
memorandum?" Suator Townsend
Asked.
"He tlid," Mr. Pulmcr replied. "I
wired Hie memorandum to him."
"Did you submit it to Lewis, nnd
Urcen tirstj"
"Yes." '
At the request of the committee he
Inserted into the lcrords the copy of
the telegram sent to the President.
The examination of tho attorney Gen
eral was Interrupted at this point so
senators might uttend 'the Senate ses
sion. It was planned to continue the
inquiry late todaj.
Bartel Girl Freed;
Jury Out 21 Minutes
Continued From rare One
The father's lips arc Fcaled, and you
have heard the story Clura has told.
It appears that Charles Martcl was u
man of hot temper. If we believe the
testimony, his manner wns harsh and
even brutal at times. One witness has
called him n devil in his home."
Even the district attornej, Hiram II.
Keller, had seemed loath to have the
jury find the girl 'guilty of murder.
His address had been brief and without
licat. He had not demunded u first
degree erd!ct.
"I ask you U lay aside all jour emo
tions," he had Baid, "Tho facts arc
comparathcly few nnd not much dis
puted. Clam admitted that she killed
her fqther. Tho only thing for jou to
decide is whether she wns justified.
"They were anordinary family, and
Clara was a normal girl. Ilcmembcr
that no ono was in the house but the
mother, father and children when the
tragedy occurred. When the neighbors
and friends came in the family was, of
course, hysterical,
"I am not going to take up jour time1
with p long address. Simply judge for
yourselves, from tho facts ghen."
From start to finish the district at
torney's' final plea had not consumed
fifteen minutes. It was unlike any
plea heard for years in the local criminal
court. Mr. Keller snt down eUdcnth
..satisfied that he had snld just suffi
cient for the ends of justice, but not a
word that would unfairly prejudice the
jury against Clara.
Little Testlirony Today
There was little testimony riven nt
today's final session of the trial. The
character witnesses weie called, neigh
, bors of the Bartcls who knew Claru
well and her teachers in the public
school. They gave her nu exemplar
character.
Then came the plea of J. Hibbs Buck-
man, which wrought up the crowd In
.the courtroom to u pitch of sjmpathy
and emotion almost equal to that of
yesterday, when Clara dramatically re
cited the story of tho murder and the
unhappy hours leading up to it.
Bartel Family Hitter
t The only unsympathetic faces lu the
Cliuttcs Ilartel'tr family. During Mr.
Iluckman's address Mrs. Steinmucller,
the aupt bo had given the most damag
ing testimony ngainst Clara testimony
which Judge 11 an alluded to later In
bis chargf as rebutted by other wit
nesses sat high up in the amphitheatre
of benches and glowered at tho district
atfornoy. She did not 1om n word he
said, or a changing line of tke expres
sion of his face. She sat throughout his
plea for Clara, bent over iu her pluc.
her hands gripping the bench in front of
her, concentrating her whole gaze upon
him.
The lawjer referred to hpr tcNtimony
during the trial. 'She turned pule and
red )y turns at his words, and whig-
iercd to her husband, who was sitting
leslde her.
In contrast to Mrs. Stcimuueller,
Mrs. Charles Ilurtel, Clara's mother,
mt on the opposite sldo of the court,
also hlsh up lu the tiers of benches und
a)so watching him Intently, She too
hung on bis words, but the expression
on her'foco was one of hope that grew
to certainty us ho marshalled tbo argu
ments In defense of the child sitting
ifuar lim u prisoner.
' Mrs, liartel wept quietly, but her
terfi were Ism bitter and despairing
tha- yesterday. There was less of a
mother's anguish in her face; more of
a mother's hopeful love, suro that the
ordeal would soon bo over nnd her child
restored to her. At times her shoulders
shook, but she did not sob aloud.
Clara wept, too, dabbing her eyes
from time to tlmo with her handker
chief, which she hnd rolled up, Into a
little moist ball. Bho was following
every word her attorney said, nnd evi
dently the story ho told of iinhnppiucss,
culminating in tragedy recalled ono
by ono the emotions she had known
In thoso terrifying hours, for her cjes
grew misty and staring, nnd her breath
cumc and went as though sho wcro pic
turing it all on the changing screen of
memory.
When ho told how Clara had gone
to meet her father when he returncd
home early the morning of the tragedy,
and had raised her lips to kiss him,
but ,hnd been repulsed, tho girl's un
happy memories became too strong for
her, nnd she sobbed aloud.
"A good many of you are fathers
nnd grnudfathcrs," ho Bald to tho jury.
"Imngluo jour own daughter under
such circumstances. I ask jou men to
say sho Is not guilty, and to let her
go back "and start again to make some
thing of her life. Lct'her build it up
as best she can."
Mr. Iluckmnn concluded and went
over to tho weeping girl, placing his
nrm about her shoulder. Tears were
streaming down his checks ns he took
his seat beside her.
Will Sell Iluclis Home
After leaving the courtroom Clara,
with her mother and her mint Mrs.
telliMbetu Whertltsy, rwit Id the home,
of Mrs. Nightengale.
Mrs. Bartel said tho family would sell
tbo Bucks county homo near Kdgcwood,
where tho tragedy occurred, but havo
mado no plans as yet concerning tliclrJ
future. When the mother suggested re
turning to the farm this afternoon,
Clara said, "Oh Mother, Aunt Amite
will be there, nnd I am afraid of her."
The inint Annie referred to is Mrs.
Anna Steinmucller, u sister of tho slain
man.
"Oh, I'm so happy, and wo are going
to bave a wonderful Christmas," Clara
-r-
exclaimed. "I am going to bare a tree
oven if it is a small ono.
1 This afternoon lata Mrs. Bartel nnd
Clara Will go to the Philadelphia homo
of Mrs. Whcrtlcy, nt 8210 Iluutlugton
street. Tho two younger sisters will
remain nt tho farm of Mrs. Otllly
Sceso, in Oxford Valley.
Speaking of Mrs. Nlghtcngnle, the
girl said, "Oh. I lovo Mrs. Nlghtcn
gnlo ; bIic has been so god to me. 1 want
to go back to school; I want to learn,
especially music, of which I am very
fond. Beforo this happened I wanted
to be a school teacher, but after this,
la ranot so sure."
ONE HOUR!
That's all we need to deliver your
VICTROLA
COMPLETE STOCK ALL STYLES ALL FINISHES
,The J. R. WILSON CO., 929 N. Broad Street
(Breed and Ctrartl)
VICTROLAS and VICTOR RECORDS EXCLUSIVELY
jSb
E.ir Terme 7 SI Open Evenlnn
HIS MMTts' VOICC
Our leroice i next door to you no matter where you live.
i AW H Si F rfC
NSS l HOLLANDER AND FLEISHMAN tfOHFIOENTlAjX
s'' COMPAKY ( IohveniehtL-i
fCrTl N.E.Cornor llth G CHESTNUT REDIT fl
IbbbbbH bPSVV eVtSkl I - A A. . " rf TbbbbbH aSMC 'T'BW 'W I 1 MBO"
ffl HBh tKXoi'il BH HH leaaaU"
I Hfl 00
00
.tfifSR1
.H
t.vn 'NIM- tl
,-.tfttWv- A1
-.flwl" .?
- YvUM ft W .-A 4PJ&Z
.frll lUl trtt T Cer" .f-l . -a "u-
aJaWWU"- ' iVvCauc?0";rv."rd,"
Ylj
..oii":. fti
iaii -rf oi ..o.tin''
tVvC " soettJ v?to
" -A -TJ TOI-
f "r"Tffc. -
J'
; ..rt
0-
v:x
T,p maX
ovSZs-
F"
rrmtSm 1
n i i 1 1 aoaai v ir
- . 1 VyV .Mi !
r&r vTiasaBa
"-.r Bf BAK rlN. rilamenda In eolld A.X. WJ
-""" TTf V?iv 'S Mr cold mounting 105,00 an. NZ-
TrcfSi. S ? t. -T
&? Af j&&Sz3Sm&
SUGGESTIONS Jt & Nf fe8fegp W
I THAT MAY AID JglL J$B. 7STs Jl
your choice pr$ w lj& iir.sfdVaonc1. X
85 i-lO T I r9 m Several d.ilxn. o 5
I l..rr.. fit9---y II 7; ..Uet fram. 875.00 O
Bracelet Watehea Tfr? 7 "?JS W . , . t i . W
KS runM Akf r XS XGBscxser fAA II m IHUkwlU i h -!f'.
. . .,. ..UT.' TMB ITXOL -TGmi"9KmBH?9a. "f .'y
V . Bracelet Watch. TiSwHf MlJ1 f"V
a m Ooarmnteed for 20 Tx "" i " Pn)
i Yan. frnm Mia.BO Uv 3-Atiiia Gent i lUnr IaTaJUere.
op. y dLamondi ona list in
s$Q5aifflX. U aivphlre or ruby Dlfitianm,
yaKaJK cpUr, S75.00. 360.00.
oua Kaia lilfUJI V IIhS H wWl H
liar Pine
Hracelete
Bracelet TVatehea
flreorhea i
rameoe
Thatne
nrsr Cnitrra
rarette Caaei
Puff link.
IHAMONni
Dlamnnft Rap nin..
IMnner Rlnaa W a I t h
RmhUm HI... n v m m m
Fanev Wona ninn Watclie. Driced
nlir!n" from 845 00 up.
Jw VAM.IERES
?yecel.
Hear! rln, ZSVZW'
gllrertrare
X"l' Set, FoncT Stone
fllne, anr eliade
tone deelred,
from 810 at).
WATCnKS
9 - Stone IMamond
Ttlnc iet fi mild
Kold monntlnff, 865.
H a P
HOLLANDER. U FLEISHMAN
c o PtAJSLStr
NOriTW ast cohneu.-eleventh c CH
Ribbon Ilraeelet TTatch, aclld
cold. Special at 835.00. -
1111 BlliTlMliBlTMIM?
ESTNUT fhTr
82a 1 1 Kat 1 8SB ( bHS I MSu ,
S'-V "
'.-'fir ... .. .... ...
I,.. , ,. ,.. 'iia.d a.. ,.. . ,."VitVrLrt'A4.A.'i. J,MJ.!.5.A,.,v J
.',;.AW'VVTuT'!M'"'rnA'i,.si,Vrry IV ra-n: vm yiw i,x3m),.
M a-j - ' . V
ji n sina now yuu uun
I
"Weed Chain your Horse io Safety
American Chain Over-Shoes
Protected by Anuncaa and Foreicn Paleoto
The Principle of the Weed Tjre Chains for Automobiles
and Motor Trucks Humanely Adapted to Horses' Hoofs
i
I
American Chain Over-Shoes make horses sure-footed
on ice and snow covered roads and pavements. The
Chains are so constructed and arranged that they give
the animal 48 points of contact 1 2'under each foot
Awarded a prize of $500.00 by theAmerican Society
for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals the only
one of its kind ever granted. Warmly endorsed by the
Massachusetts S. P. C. ,A. and the rJew York
Women's League for Animals.
American Chain Over-Shoes cannot injure the foot or
leg in any way, as it is imppssible for the chains or center
link to touch the frog. They also prevent the "balling"
of snow and ice in the shoe.
American Chain Over-Shoes enable a horse to step
out fearlessly on the slipperiest pavements and roads,
and thus every, ounce of his strength can be used for
pulling power instead of being wasted in pitiful efforts
to keep on' his feet.
It is cruelty to send horses out without American Chain
Over-Shoes when pavements and roads are covered
with ice or snow. They strain their muscles and tendonsT"!
tall and injure hips or knees; and somebnTCSibreaa
leg which means the use of a pistol and the loss of
valuable horseflesh. American Chain Overshoes
should be kept in trucks and wagons ready for use at
the first indication of slippery-going.
DIRECTIONS FOR ORDERING
o, 1 HoiKifoe
lo. 2
T'
No. 3
eft!
AYl in. acroM l
jvj :
ta.l.
8ft
No. 3 Over.Shoea
M fc " "
No. b
No. 6 Honokoa
No. 7 "
No. 6
Eitia Luie Site
(6Vb !n. tenia middle)
(6'4 )
(7 )
uUt Ns. 6 Ora-Shou
" No. 7 " "
" No. 7 " "
. No. 8 " "
Thvem 14001b. bone Kquitet a No S CKun Over-Shoe aadvSe 1600 E. hone rtquutte No 6Cha!a
Ovcihoe. Amcticui Chun Ovrrhoet for Mulet are mad. m ouIUaMdninandUrsectzci.aad&tiJJMuki.
Price for eoj Uei 88.00 per aet of four for loc. or mulei.
DISTRIBUTORS FOR PHILADELPHIA
Kennedy-Willing & Co., 526 Arch Street Kline-Savidge & Co., 3rd & Race Streets
Supplee-BirJdle Hardware Co., 507-515 Commerce Street
ARTD-ROtLS
ISTlwere
AJtheRrst
btandard
rolls
made in
America
ft
17
m,
ARID-ROLLS
come in
Beautiful
&
JTa. ar.
f ffl Boxes
l -
ARTO-ROLLS
waiaapaBaMPaaaanasajaBM
d mr?
j.wu
sing
Ml
I
1 1 1 idma
.... LIMA
ij'fi K
lli'ii! i IT
Each Arto-Roll has
the patented music
staff upon which the
words are so ar
ranged that the first
letter of each word
shows the tone at
which the word is to
,be sun g
thus show
ing voice
modulation
before note
is sounded.
ARTOROLLS
play
longer
than
other
rolls
fl
"
V
s Choruses
41 fc i
ARID-ROLLS
are
made of
Superior
Paper
ARID-ROLLS
special
poterrfecl
coreiiiai
guarantees
even
flr
1
2
if
tt
i i' i i hum i i ff
Here is your list of
Christmas January
ARTOROLL;
"LTERE'S merry music for a Merry Christ-
mas happy songs for a Happy New
Year! Get them for your player-piano, give
them to your friends, these wonderful new
Arto-Rolls special Christmas selections, and
also the new January numbers issued far in
advance to allow you to enjoy them over
the holidays.
Youll find below all the new hits from Broadway
ballads and melodies to sing, fox trots, one steps, and
waltzes to-dance. Stop at , the nearest Arto-Roll dealer
and get yourself more cheer for the holidays the new
Arto-Rolls listed below!
Special Christmas ARTO WORD Rolls
125 Christmas Chimes Ballad-Reverie
196 Children's Nursery Songs Medley
528 Silent NigHt, Holy Night Xmas Song
347 Story Book Ball (Mother Goose Rhymes) . .Fox Trot
(Complete Uhiistvias Catalogue Contains Other Favorite Selections)
January ARTO WORD Rolls
1036 When You're a Million Miles from Nowhere.Ballad
1029 Dreamland Brings Memories of You Waltz Song
1028 I Love You Just the Same, Sweet Adeline. .One Step
1031 Waiting (from "Listen Lester") Fox Trot
1044 Troubles (the new novelty hit) Waltz Song
1021 Back to God's Country Fox Trot
"1034 Only . .' , Fox Trot
1032 While Others Are Building Castles Fox Trot
1033 Bubbling Over Waltz Song
1027 When You're Alone Fox Trot
"1025 In Siam Fox Trot
1030 Meet Me in Bubble Land Waltz Song
1047 I Might Be Your Once-in-a-While Fox Trot
-1026 Hand in Hand Again '. Waltz Song
1035 Irene (from the play "Irene") Fox Trot
Most Popular . Songs from Previous Listings
1005 You'd Be Surprised Fox Trot
1010 Wonderful Pal One Step
"969 Golden Gate, Open for Me Waltz Song
"982 Caroline Sunshine Waltz Song
"1007 Let the Rest of the World Go By Waltz Song
1023 Tell Me Fox Trot
953 The Vamp Fox Trot
"1002 Now I Know Fox Trot
985 Poor Little Butterfly Is a Fly Girl Now. . .Fox Trot
981 Nobody Knows an.d Nobody Seems to Care . . Fox Trot
These Word Rolls, $1 Without xcords, SOc.
Sold by Most Dealers Featured by
MANHATTAN
R. H. Macv & Co., 3rth St. and B'wav.
Bloomingdale B.ros., 3d Ave. and soth St.
Anguera Piano Co., 316 West 43d St.
Nassau P. C. Co., 61 and 131 Nassau St.
M. E. Mark3, lag West 125th St.
Wuertz Co., 1518 and 2936 3d Ave.
Schleicher & Sons, 105 E. 14th and 37
W. 14th St.
Terminal Graphonola Shop, Hudson
Terminal Concourse.
BROOKLYN
Goetz & Co., 81 Court St.
Sterling Piano Co., 518 Fulton St.
United Music Store, 1441 Broadway
NEWARK
Broad and Market Music Store
Jacob Doll & Sons
Hahne & Co,
JERSEY CITY
Jacob Doll & Sons, 146 Newark Ave.
(Special ARTO Catalogs of Italian and Jewish music rolls-
ana without words.)
STANDARD MUSIC ROLL CO.,
1437 Broadway, New York
Also Makers of the famous
SingA Word Roll,
obtainable in most of the
above titles.
-with ,
.throighouf
Live dealers wanted
everywhere
I S
psj,s
a
'll
I
i
4' "
y
.'t '
4 n
, '.,... .,,. .j... tjt,, . 1
4VL dC3JVffc3sAafelK.a, f .k . , -t
u