Evening public ledger. (Philadelphia [Pa.]) 1914-1942, October 12, 1916, Night Extra, Page 12, Image 12

Below is the OCR text representation for this newspapers page. It is also available as plain text as well as XML.

    BVSMHG LBDGHH-KBILADEIiPHttA, THXTSBDAT, OCTOBER 12. WW
lb JUDGMENT BY BROOKLYN DODGERS IN FOURTH GAME HELPED THE feED SOX TO Win
IHING FOR STRIKE-OUTS
CAllilD THE DOWNFALL OF
MARQUARD IN SERIES GAME
Rttbe's Good Start Also Tended to MakeHim
Carilese Robins' Poor Headwork Contribut
ing Factor in Eed Sox Victory
i - -- .
BOSJOM, Oct 12.
FITCHINa for strtkt-euta arte! poor hsadTfork coat UrooWyn the fourth am of
ft werl4'a txMm. . Bwrton now has a. threogamo odvantsfc-o that the Na
''tMMl LMi champions probably wilt not bo ablo to overcome. Rube Mar.
Jiwrt repealH hta mistake of the first cnrae or tno aeries ana was spun y k
ttiw off too wit. "When Marquard succeeded In tannine two of tho first three bats
Mn to face him ad Brooklyn tallied twice In the opening Innlne on "Dutch1
lassnar. It looked Hko an eaay victory for the Dodcers, and probably would have
fcaan If the lanky Bouthpaw had used his head.
It wu to irfarquard's advantate to roservo his strength and play tho game Mfe
ftoc being given the lead, but ho tried to strike out every batsman who faced
Mm. and aa ft result lianded tho Ited Sox tho victory. It Is barely possible lliat
"Ckwr Meyers wae responsible for tho unusual number of balls Marquard wasted;
feat Judging; by tho way the btr Indian continually walked to tho pitching; mound to
Mafer with Marquard. we are Inclined to believe (hat the pitcher was at fault.
Marquard'a exhibition was friahlful and -Dutch" Leonard was not much better
unlit his confidence returned nlons; about tho middle1 of the trame. Brilliant support
Hy tho American league champions saTed Leonard In three of tho first four
Innings, and then tho southpaw star of Carrigan'e staff got back In his stride and
sM,rsult never was In doubt. Instead of Improvlnaj.and showing something that
rwembled major league pitching after being given tho lead, Marquard went conv
pietoty to pieces. Ills first bad break camo In pitching to Hoblitzell, tho first bats
wan to tho plate In the second Inning. Marquard quickly cot Hobby In the hole
liy breaking two strikes across, but was not satisfied with trying to retire hlm on
am easy chance.
Ho wasted -three balls and then tried to fan tho Ited Sox first baseman, who
usually Is a mark for southpaws, by cutting a curve ball over the outsldo corner.
Tho ball went wldo of the mark and Hoblltsell walked, starting nil tho trouble.
Marquard also got Lewis In tho hole, but wasted too many balls again and Lewis
mashed a drive against tho right-field fenco for a double, Hoblitzell stopping at
tWrd because he rematned between first and second too long, fearing that John
ton might catch the ball.
Marquard Seemed to Forget Art of niching
"tfE would have thought that Marquard'a poor pitching to HobllUell and Lewis
J would have been a warning to him rnd that ho would have changed ma tactics,
but the big southpaw apparently forgot how to pitch. He got two strikes across
on Gardner, wltlf only one ball called, but proceeded to try to fan him also, with
tbo result that he soon waa in a hole. If Marquard had clinched tho two left
handed hitters, who usually are marks fey a southpaw with a good fOHt ball, he
probably would havo won his gamcj but lie laid a straight ball right over the heait
of the plato and Gardner broke up tho gamo and took tho tight out of tho Dodgers
by sondlmr a drive over Myers' head to tho center-field wall for a homo run.
This ono Inning finished tho Dodgers, os tho lied Sox icgalned confidence.
"When tho gatno started the Hod Sox Doted like a team very badly won led, while
Brooklyn's victory In the third game sent the National Leaguers Into yesterda'
battle wlthplenty of ginger and fighting spirit. Itoblnson'n team looked Hko tho
better aggregation when tho play started, but as always Is the case a head
Je and careless pi teller will destroy a team's confidence and In the closing Innings x
tho Todgers looked just as weak as they did against the Fhlllles in the first two
games of the final series of the season,
omo of Brooklyn's errors of judgment wore almost laughable, and were
f tho caliber that ono could hardly Imagine a pennant-winning team being
guilty of, and It leully Is remarkablo that 'llobinson's toam was not beaten by a
'larger score. I'our errors wero credited to tho Dodgers, and all woro Inex
cuoable. Wheat and Merkle muffed easy files. Johnston fumbled a grounder
and Chonoy mado a wild throw. The latter's throw was tho only Brooklyn
error of commission that "figured In the scoring, but two of tho errors of omission
lost chanCes to rotlro the Red Sox, who scored later In the samo inning the
blunders wero made.
In tho fourth inning Mowrey failed to pick Lewis off second when Scott
gtounded ty him, and Carrigan scored the sensational left fielder by lining a
ingle Into center. In tho following Inning Hooper worked Cheney, who had
replaced Marquard, for a pass and started to steal with two striken and two
balls on Janvrln. Tho Red Box right fielder had a long lead and probably1
would havo reached second safely anyway, but Meyers dropped the third strike and
Jet whatever chance ho had to pick off Hooper.
W;
CuUhaw Is Exempted From an Error
ITII Hoblitzell at the bat and two men out, Cheney had Hooper napping oft
second, but Cutshaw muffed the ball and allowed htm to return In safety. For
no reason cutshaw was not charged with an error, although cneneys turow
was perfect and tho Brooklyn second baseman had plenty of time to get mm.
toblltzell then shot a double just Inside the foul line In left and Hoopor scored
'Boston's fifth run. Tho final run was scored by Janvrln, who camo all the way
from second when Cheney made a poor throw on Hoblitzell's Infield single.
Intelligent pitching and fielding would havo assured Brooklyn a victory, as It
U hardly likely that "Dutch" Leonard would have lasted the full nine Innings If
Marquard had got by for two or three innings. Leonard did not have a thing
when the game started and for four Innings was constantly In trouble but his
support and Brooklyn's failure to play up-to-date ball saved the southpaw. After
being given the lead, Leonard was Invlrclble and did not allow a single hit In the
last five Innings.
When Leonard does not have a good fast ball there Is no reason why he should
beat any team, as tho work on his fast ball makes his curve very effective, and bats
men do not relish tho way the Calif ornian cuts his "bean ball" by their heads.
yesterday he did not havo a thing on his fast ball until tho fourth inning, and his
j ' lack "of control mado It necessary for him to groove too many balls; but In the
closing sessions he pitched very few balls, being content to depend upon his auppoit.
Leonard was supported brilliantly and wan saved in the first Inning by a heady
lay engineered by Manager Carrtgon and Janvrln and Zack Wheat's failure to
kMjfi his eyes open. Hod Wheat been swako It Is llkoly that at least one more run
wuld hav boon scored In this session, while Indications pointed to a complete
jn'Mi by Leonard when the play was pulled.
Brooklyn Starts at a Dizzy Clip
OHNSTON opened tho game for Brooklyn by smashing the Tim ball pitched to
tho right centerfleld fence and reached third before Walker returned the ball to
tbs) infield. Johnston probably could have stretched tho drive to a home run, but the
ffct that no ono waa out and It waa too early In the game caused Coacher O'Mara
hold htm at third. It waa well that he was stopped at third, as "HI" Myers
MM through with a scorching single to right, scoring Johnston.
It "was apparent that Leonard was rattled and he passed Merkle, At
this attire Zack Wheat made his first stupid play when he swung at the first ball
pitched and forced Merkle at second, Leonard had pitched four successive balls to
Morkle after getting the first one across and the law' of percentage should have
JMM4 Wheat to look a couple of balls over or to move the runners up with a
Mrtfloe. Tho ball that he struck at was high and on the outside corner of the
lata. ,
Janvrin's everanxlety helped the Dodgers out at this point after Wheat had
takon Moond on a wild pitch, though Myers remained at third, Cutshaw rolled
grounder to Janvrln, but the youngster fought the ball and It bounded
away from Mm, Myers scoring, while Wheat went to third. With Mowrey at the
Outohaw started, to steal second find Wheat pulled a "bone."
, - -
Itumors have been flying thiek and fast since the series started, and It would
not bo surprising U at tant two mora franchises will be sold and the retirement
of ocut of tv saoat popular magnate in the game may be enforced by Ban
Jaba
J
THE COMIC SIDE OF THE BRQOKLYN TRAGEDY
ilTif rr orr n J fi Uimi ries J"""" I tfiJCUl- TUBY I
i T it errj )g;g. "( r Po,,lTlwlior7oe jv'r ,J1 I 'i'0 'L
-wI-VSfc. LrsssKLrgssf . fwMT Chap I
THAiT rifiORC g ti "quiclgy AMD A i) iFAJMll
EooooooSfA'1-1-
' FReD MERKLB iTtSfP6r .DiSHT
-?' r tH IM- riOM-r or Tt( eyCfCCTA.TOt0
JJPV fCl"" 303T .To .SMOUJ THfSt-k Tl5 MUFP
i - y
SUCCESS OF BEHR
IS GREAT MYSTERY
TO TENNIS WORU)
Game of Former Davis Cup '
Star Only a Step From
Mediocrity
RANKED IN NINTH PLACl
By WILLIAM T. TILDE.V, 3d
Jut why Karl Behr dtatrves No u
ralhtr a hard question to answer ornW '
for the great New Yorker has playm yZ
nine mu year, zjui wnen one coniMt,,
uir icv i me men wno are left to ehoM'1
fmm ami rAntraif ttialt. .. ... V'y
...... .. ,fc wlln w
the verdict mutt go to Behr.
Behr, alws a slow starter, btn M"J
lesion oy ro rauier unexpected dfrt J
une, in ni niciropoiuan, was by Dm.
.Miuiey, wntn inai vigorous peraon b(ir.
rled the somewhat slow Behr around iks
court so fast that he could not statu! iw.!
pace and fell by the wajslde, " I
Then Teddy I'en unkindly took awav it. ;
iiiiuu.o w.o . 7 nuncnsiu y rhal
A .U,..llu. ... . - '-
lentlng Behr and defeating him In a, fm
maicn. jeiu- ariauuca ni seaorlght oWtaek
to the heat affecting him. lie did kZ
OLD MAN EXPERIENCE HANDED .
SEVERE JOLT BY MATHEWSON,
,UACK COOMBS AND BABE ADAMS
Ev
Hy GHANTLAKD RICP:
l.l'i:iUi;NCi: Is supposed to play a
trading part In winning Kport. Tlie
experienced entry alwa Is supposed to
have the Jump. It was nmlnly for tills reu
hoii that ilnrquard and Coombs wero figured
as llrooklyn'n lending world series hopes.
They Imd been oer tho lofty hurdles befoie,
nnd therefore were supposed to know the
proper Way. Ynl the ltal statistics In the
matter fall to carry tills theory on to a
logical conclusion.
Their First Start
Malty pitched Ms first world scries cames
In 1905. Bereft of nil world series experi
ence, he yet canned In three shutouts, getting
u pitching record no one eer has equaled
or approached.
Babe Adams entered hli first world series
experience In 1909. He finished with three
victories out of three starts against one of
the hurdcst-hlttlng clubs the game has ever
known.
Jack Coombs bumped Into hit first world
series experience in 1910. About all that
Jack did as a starter was to peel off three
victories against the Cubs, and In each
game he was facing experienced mounds
men. So here we hae three pitchers with no
experlenco In world series warfare, and
their net hanest was nine lctorles out of
nine starts. This would Indicate that ex
perience In the big post-season scramble
was not such a ltal asset after all.
Despite the utterances of many cynics,
there is more to a world series for the
ballplayer than his share of the kale.
The glamour and the excitement sur
rounding the main championship are not to
be oerlooked.
"VA like to get In another world series
and play for nothing," Charles Lincoln
Ilerzog said, while discussing this phate of
the affair. "I don't know of anything that
Is more fun, and I'd hate to think that 1
had played In my last one. You get a thrill
there beyond anything you get In the sea
eon's play, for you always figure that .every
chance may mean the entire series.
"This Is why some ballplayers do better
than usual and why some others don t do
as well. There are a good many who can
play better when they are tinder no strain.
There are a good many others who might
be Inclined to talco it easy in a lM-game
stretch, but who, with only a seven-game
test, would work at top speed every second."
Some day we hope to bump Into a World
Series where:
1. Both managers were not confident of
winning-.
2. Karh game was not considered the
crucial gamo of the series.
Dmtons to Tackle Hurley Boys
lUnfr John Marshall, nr UIton Io'
Club, announced lt nlsht that, h had made
arrangements with the Hurley V, C. to tackln
UUalonn on mir nom lot hi niaia roau aim
Tarony. next oaiuruay aiiernoon
lembern of fha Allied Leaaue thll
aeaaon, and aicordtnr to liner Jiarsnaii inn
ltn.ith .(..at
DlKitona an members ot the Allied League thla
MAn. mnfi acrordlnr to nrler Marshall thn
Tainnylten nlll land the buntlnx with the star
players aireaay securcu tor me coining- aeaeon.
SCRAPS ABOUT SCRAPPERS
tl T I-.IITC If TAWPF!
By LOUIS 1L JAFFE
Johnny Ertle'a blr iure bonti i atparently are
oer nov. Jlrt. he M owed I'htrhdelphlana Hint
lie hii highly overrated! then . Yorkern
were romliifed that Mllte McNutty was a better
b artlat than tlm Kewrle .wu mitt leldr.
Haneier, l.etore KrtlVs real at lt waa dlcov
ered the Ht Paul bantam lollectea BretlJ
little hunhroll m the atrengili vt hla foul vic
tory oer Kid William.
Speaking '- Wllllama, the wlearre who re
around a few ueek ago declaring that the
cnamolon naa all In nnd It na only a matter uf
another lonr light for hlm to le the title have
taken to tho tall gruio The Kid. although not
the ram wonderful little battler ot two jeara
ago,tlll ii kod and them iloeen't aeem to be
any'dangeroiuitXontendera In hi path.
EJJIe O'Keefe Is ronndent he could outpoint
Champion William in a twenty-rounder, but for
some reaaon nr other, known to hlmaelf. the
Balthnoreail doem'l want, any of the Quaker
Oty lad'a Lnnn. O Keefo la willing- to agree to
lie pounds, ringside. I.ut the weight goiernlnir
a bantam rhimplonihlp tilt will Ixi 118 or ISO
pounds, aa WlllUmi cannot make the "sixteen"
poundage any more.
The sprained anUIe suffered by AVIIIIe ltannen
while dulng road vnrk lias the Tolnt Hreezo
favorite In pretty had shape and he hardly can
keep on hla feet Ilannun will be unable to box
again for a month.
Tounc Morphasr.
a sailor scrapper and tall.
made a great imprejulon on the Ryan Club fans
when he slopped Johnnj Murphy. In the thlnl
round. The tar poeiesee a pippm nani-neim
lunch, which he dlretts to the body with good
eneci. ......
The reopenlur ehoir of tha Palace A C . Tbr
rlaiown. his been completed with l'ats fJl
venter oppoied to Hull Hmllh. In an eight-round
aemtnnal to theYoune Jack (fllrlea-IIenry
Hauber match. Tuesday night. The Utter
mix la scheduled for fifteen rounds. The open
inr number will 1 a negro welterweight set-to
botwten 'iouus Lonrey and Battling Miuldn.
a sailor sh
lrlah Tatay Cilne, who meeta Jtuck Fleming
at the Olympla I'lub hers, next Mondaynlght.
la matched for five other bouts, lc : October
IS, Mo Jloran, NefC York; 13. Mickey Donle.
Alltntowni KT. Allle Nacli, New York, and 81,
Joe Welllne. Nee' York. Cllne la one of the
moat popular llghtwelghta in the Kaat, and he
grained moat ot hi J preitlge by his winning form
In 1'hlladelphla lait ear-
compete at lAingwood, Southampton or Ktw.
port.
He went Into the national with llttU
practice, up 10 mat time nis main Vic.
tones were over Charlie Bull and TrtWa.
Davis. He defeated Davis crushlngly in theJ
nat vs. West match, outplaying hit oa-1
JJUIIClllr AW1. Me,.....,,!, Ill CIIU
Behr nearly went down to defeat in it.
first round of the national, when lie met '
Connie Doyle. Doyle won the first hrJ
sets easily and twice had a commanding11'
lead In another, but Behr. alware . .
sourcefiil. called on his reserve and pulle
me matcu out ot me nre. lie men dtfegled '
Jl 1'. turned, but was put out of the run.
nlng in the thltd round by Ltndley llur,
rav, who ttearly outplayed him. '
IJehr's game Is hard to analyze. Jurtuh;
he beats people remains somewhat of an.l
eulgma, tor a more careless, muitferent at4 ,
tempera menUl plajer cannot be found.
When Behr Is good he Is very good ,but Jt'
Is but a step to absolute mediocrity oti.n (
taken hy him owing to some slight tlilrg'J
which rnflles the calm of his tennU g.
Ills serve is speedy, and carries excel., J
lent pace. He placet It very well HlgJ
ground strokes aro clean cut, paceful audi
accurate, without any great tncrit nisi
voiicyiuK w-"i" ""in uunai3ient.j
Ills volley is ueep ana quite fast. AH MJ
BhotB are hit with a peculiar abort wlci3
from the shoulder that Is very distinct he. .
Behr's whole game Is a w ell-roundi t
carefully conceived and cleverly exeeUHU
piece of tennis, but Just why It beat go)4 '
men win long remain a mysiery
vAltwlnr Tlattllnr
Runboat Hmlth and Jack Dillon's kayo win over
Hallor OranJo, the victorious light hex vj-w eights
have been matched to box to a referee's decision
In Boalon. October 24. This will he their
F, Willi
'ateenth battle.
T.elmky's. lclorr over
l,evlnil;y havlnc the edge.
Other Sports on Page 14
SUITS TO ORDERS
$4 -1 .80
5 Our 7
Big Window
11
Rednced freia
ISO, ;j .DJ itt
PETER MORAN & CO. "SJESft
B. IS. COIt. ST1I AND AKCH STS.
flolrl
ITOTritlX
Huipidor
lyaJl dealers
Htnufacturmrs
ifS&i
Lr4Siv:
v
Oh You "Billy Moran"
My tall and Vt inter fabrics
are I he talk of I he (own. "wet
and rlcheit effects. Faultless
'It guaranteed. We will tailor
Vreu a dandy garment
at
1103 Arch St.
Tbe Taller Open Krenlan
79J? rj 795
,. Model 5-V f.WR Toledo rf Model 83-4 f.o.b. Toledo
v 4
aaEVAk4buu VlsBisssV T m. flsasssaw
BfaJBMssssB?,,,S-i- magasssssssstsisa sj .- fm-
s
You Ought to Own This Car
Fine it's a beautifully finished, luxurious can
$14.80
FORREST World'. Serie. ;.
TODAY AND FRIDAY AFTKHKOON
Kisct Kepreducllon of Kterr Detail ef
tlamea on Tom liar's tlettrlo tVaoder
Its possession will enrich your life and the
lives of every member of your family.
The freedom and wider range of activity
made possible by such a car are worth
many times its price.
The price is by far the lowest at which so big
and fine and comfortable a car ever sold.
Big he wheclbase is 112 inches.
Bell Phone
Comfortable it ha3 cantilever springs and
4-inch tires.
Model 85-6, 35-40 horsepower six cylinder
motor, 116-inch wheelbase $925.
Come in today we can't get them as fast as
we sell them so order youraright away.
OVERLAND MOTOR CO., Distributors
-Walnut 4897 323-5-7 North Broad Street, Philadelphia
The Willy.-Overland Company, Toledo, Ohio
'Md. In U. S. A."
I
I
rKHlAY MGUT IK ID AY MOlIT 1-..ssMsMssWWsssss..sM
LINCOLN A. C. igmgmmmmmm -
aeon. iuu. .4r. nun ntivn geageBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeBgeageB
UI'.TO-TIIE-MINUTK MOUTH aaaaSBSssssssBsssBaaaaasaaaaasssssBaaassssssssBSSSssa
" " .''', ' ' . -
IrJ . ",ae--rr-VT--' " Ek- VlVA 7 tlMJ I ll tfsftrtt f a B tjMl. I Vf "T'1 ' "e-T" Wl r 1 yKTC W--TWe. 1 gssssBsssHsssssssssssCX H '
ssssssssssssssssss9ss9taX- jf ajJss'B ssssr p y, jm L si m s sV T H
BBBMHtoyife ii i n ii amiimnuimmmmmmm mai i mufii ' " i " '"" ''- " ' " mw ' mmr i i ssssssasssssssssaassssjssistasis P