- &wr?fr ,? EVENING LEDGER PHILADELPHIA, WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER. 15', 101S. is PHILADELPHIA FOOTBALL OFFICIALS MEET SCHOLASTIC AND BASKETBALL COMMENT! " -TVfrV -mT m LOCAL FOOTBALL OFFICIALS FIND FLAWS IN THE CODE v ' Gridiron Season Reviewed From Technical Viewpoint at Meeting in Hotel Walton Will Make Recommendations to Rules Committee . .' By ROBERT WHEN the Football Rules Committee holds Its nnnual session In New York a few weeks hence the playing code will he closely" 'scrutinized nnd mljriy changes made In the game, for 1918, Many i,, errors nnd vague rui Ings were round in the 1913 code at n meeting of footbnll ofnclalB nt Hotel Wal ton last nlKht, nnd the gridiron solons will he naked to Straighten things out before next season For the first time In history the lending footbnll coaches nnd nlTlctnls residing In and near 1'hllndelphla held n post-seoBon conference and dis cussed the Intricate Plays that came up in the games this fall. Heretofore n meeting was called before the I Beason began, but It n. W. MAXWKI.li was deemed advis able to get the men together while the game wns fresh In their minds. Twenty five omclnls attended, nnd the meeting wns a success In every way. Chnrles J. McCnrty, of fjermantown. presided, and soon after he called the meeting to order It wns discovered that a numher of ptnys cropped up Inst tail that were not fully covered In the rules. The first Important discussion arose over the rule which protects the kicker. I.nst full many penalties were given for run ning Into the player after he kicked tho ball, and the question arose as to how long Is n player n kicker and when does he ceuse to become one? HOUGHING I'H.VALTV. According to tho rules, nn opponent Is penalized If he knocks the punter nif his feet, whether It Is Intentional or not. It Is easy to give tho penalty while the kicker's foot still Is In tlia air, but come doubt nroso as to whether It would be right to enforce the penalty after both feet are on tjie ground nnd the punter had taken one step forward. Chnrles Price, of Swarthmorc, and A. S. Tyler, of Princeton, held that ns soon as tho kicker took one step forward he ceased to become a kicker, and could be "clipped" or knocked oft his feet by the opponents. They contended thnt the player then wai a tackier, nnd no pen alty could he enforced. This wns the consensus of opinion, and the Hulis Com mittee will be asked to make the ruling clear. I'Vcd Glllendor, of Penn, who conches Bt. Luke's nnd officiates In many of the big Literu games, declared thnt the rules .were violated In every big game played lust fall, and tho offenders got away with It. He rend rule 9, section 1, which states that the backllcld men must be nt lenst one yard behind tho line of scrimmage when the bnll is put Into play, the only exception being tho mnn who stands behind the centre and tlrst receives the ball. Thnt mcirnt thnt the quarterback could crouch behind his centre nnd remain In the one-yard zone, provided ho got the ball on the snap back. It was shown that tho quarterback In many plays simply held his hands out and the ball was passed to the fullback. In cases of n forward pass, the quarter would slldo through the centre of the lino and the ball was thrown to him This wns one of the best plays used by Wash ington and Jefferson against Yale; Prince ton, Harvard, Dartmouth and others nlso used It, but not once wns It "called." It Is against the rules as It Is now worded and a clearer Interpretation Is asked. MCCARTY'S SUGGESTION'. Chairman McCarty brought up n ques tion which Is not covered In the rules. Rule 18, section 1. states thnt a ball passed out of bounds by the snapperback before It touches n player on his side, the ball shall go to the opponent nt the spot where It crossed the side line. McCnrty cited a case where the ball was on the offen sive team's two-yard line, near the side line. It was fourth down nnd the ball was passed out of bounds behind the goal line. This gave the ball to tho other team behind the opposing goal line. Of course, this has been ruled a safety, but there Is nothing In the rules which prevents It being called a touchdown. McCarty asked that the Rules Committee Insert a word In the rule clearing up the point nd say that It 1b a safety. Tho rule which says that nn incom pleted forward pass behind the goal line Is n safety was attacked by James A. Moffett, of Princeton. Moffett pointed out that In all other cases nn Incompleted pass results In the loss of n down and tho ball is brought back to the spot where It was put Into play. He declared that the rule should be enforced behind the goal line the same as In the middle of the field and was upheld by the other otllclals. This, too, will be put up to the Rules Committee. In one of the games last fall, a punt out was made, and the man catching the ball fell to the ground. The ball touched In the Held of play and the try for goal was allowed. It was held that the fair catch had been made, and the touching of the ball to the ground did not Interefere with the try for goal. The officials wera of the opinion that no try for goal should be allowed, and asked for a definite ruling on what constitutes a fair catch T Down South they have many peculiar plays, and a college in West Virginia pulled the funniest one of the year. There waa a big tackle on the team, and'ivery time his side got close to the opponents' goal line he would dash across and stand there with his hands on his hips. Then an end would climb on his shoulders and while there receive a forward pass- The play was worked several times, and It was dltticutt to get a ruling. Dr. Jack Keough held that It was a clear case of assisting the runner and a 15-yard pen alty should be Inflicted. The others, however, held different views, and the question was left open until the rules committee had a chance to act. Here Is another one for the solons to puzzle over, A fullback standing behind jila own goal-line received the ball from the snapper-back and fumbled. Instead of picking up the ball, however, he kicked It. What Is the ruling? Another peculiar play wa Introduced by Charles Price. Mr. Price did not state where it was used, but It Is as fol lows The team wtli the ball slgnald for a place kick. Everybody got the slg- lfeT jiY.,wf "A &kr a wiBi.n ".? HHK$Vt M mm tK-Jffl I 'M'WIM Met me at the Phila. Poultry Show IinOAD & WALLACE ST8, MtroilUD UulJJlnj Open 10 4 U, to 11 P E nrutut chow trr b.M. Dec, it la la. Iic, Ldr .EElMtitat.tb I ICO... Vi -U.'tWtn, HokUsg the xrofM'4 Mcor4 Th won- 4 ir t ank. cfaturr W, MAXWELL nat but the kicker, nnd when the ball wns snapped, he dashed around the end. Ill the meantime, the quarterback wns holding the bnll on- the ground waiting for some one to bbot It. Tho oppoilnb linemen broke through nnd one, seeing the bait held In position, kicked It In stead of falling on It, In a ense llko this, is it legal to kick the ball? GROUND RUIiKS. Tho ofTlclnls advocated a sot of ground rules to be used when the crowd gets on the fle!d. They favored n lullng which given the bnll to the shlo last touching It before It goes out of bounds. This will save many Injmlcs, ns the players who crnsh Into the crowd or a fin eo to get the bounding ovn niton times nre seriously hurt. It also wns suggested that n blocked punt behind the Bonl lino shall count ns n sarcty If the ball goes Into the crowd. Gus Sileglor nimle nn eloquent plc.i for more penalties for fouls committed behind the goal line. "In n gnmo that I witnessed Inst year," said Gus, "the star player on one team made n touch down. While he wns on the ground one of the opposing linemen Jumped on him. The star wns carried out of the game and the lineman disqualified. Knch side lost n tnnn, but one mirrored more than the other. There wns no dis tance penalty. SEVEIlt: PENAI.TV. "Now, I believe n team doing a stunt llko thnt should be severely punished. We all know thnt some coaches send In a substitute early In the gnmo with In structions to get Into a fight with the best player on the opposing team. If both men are disqualified, the coach sends In his regular player, while the other side Uses a substitute This practice should be stopped and In case of rough play be hind the goal line, the offenrlng sldo should either be forced to put the bnll Into play on Its own 10-yard line, or give the bnll to the offended side on tlte op-' ponent'a 33-yard line." It wns ruled that the timekeepers should use better watches In the game, the watches to be furnished by the home team. In case the watch falls to work, and tho timekeeper doesn't discover It until the game has been In progress for sonto time. It wns suggested thnt the officials get together and decide on tho length of time that has elapsed. This Is another Job for the Rules Committee. Among those present nt the meeting were Frank Sommer, Penn: Gus Zelglcr, Penn; David C. Murray, Hnverford; W. J. McAvoy, I.afnettc; lien Clime. Swnrthmore; Dr. John Keough, Penn; Ed. Dennis. Penn; Hip Reed, Muhlen berg; A. M. Palmer, Chnrles McCarty, Germantown Academy; Charles Price, Swarthmorc: James Motlltt. Princeton; Paul Sangrce, Haverford; George Slg mund, Penn; Fred Glllcndcr, Penn; Reu ben T. Shnw, Ohio Wesleynn; Albert C. Tyler, Princeton; John Jncoby, Penn, and Robert W. Maxwell, Swarthmorc. FRESH-SOPH FOOTBALL (SAME MAY BE LOST BY DEFAULT Annual Penn Intcrclass Clash Has Been Delayed Ilecause tho game hns been delayed so long the annual football scrap between the University of Pennsylvania freshmen nnd sophomores Is in danger of going to one class or the other by defnult. Tho sophs wanted to play the gnmo the week following the Cornell match, but the freshles asked more time. Another week was lost by Inability to agree on a date, nnd now Franklin Field Is covered with snow. Yet the Under graduate Committee, which has sole Juris diction over such matters, has ordered the two teams to piny the game. New ST.JOSEPH'SOPEN SEASON IN CAGE WITH FORDHAM Coach Donahue's Squad in Initial Contest With Col lege Freshmen Tonight OTHER SCHOLASTIC NEWS Schedule for Today IIAMttVrilAI.t, SI, .torpli' College . I'nrdlmm Col lege rrr.hmen at HI, .toe Bynimnhim, lllli nnd Stllrs Mrrrtu, 7i30 p. m. Mrilln Mirth School t. Cheater High Pilimil, nt Clientrr. Mrnjrr'd ltii.lnr.. College v. Temple Preparatory, nt Temple I'rrpnrnlorj-. rnrillinm Cnllrge freshmen t, Ilretel InMllnlr, at llrrtel Institute, 3 p, m. .St. Joseph's College basketball team will open tho season In the game with the Fordhnm College freshmen nt the St. Joe gymnasium, 17th nnd Stiles streets, tonight. Mnnngcr Alexander Snwors had oiiglnnll.. Intended to open the season next Friday afternoon with lirown Prc pmatory School, but the opportunity to list the contest with Fordhnm wns not uorlookcd. Co.tch Donahue has many good men to select his team from, for with Galla gher, Murphy nnd Martin, forwards; Cap tain Hyrne, centre; Rollly nnd J. Mar tin, guards, he hns n strong flrst-tcnm aggregation. On the second team nro Mnhoney nnd heckle, forwards; Median, centre, Dougherty, Connors, Gnllnghcr and Moloney, gunids, The Fordhnm freshmen will llnd any of theso players worth watching. Rnsketbnll nt night is popular with both the LaS'.illc College nnd St. Joseph's College teams. The I.nKalle tnanngcincnt finds that the Interest on tho part of the students Increases when tho games nro played In tho evening nnd consequently virtually nil the Uih'nlle games nro scheduled to start nt 8 o'clock. St. Joseph's College nlso plays many games at night. The LaSallo College quintet opened Its season Inst night in tho game with IJrown Preparatory School. It was n walk-away for tho Collegians, the Drown Preparatory youngsters falling to scoro but a single field goal. Coach Al Illoom mnde good use of tho game by trying out his candidates. It was LnSallc'H initial contest nnd tho men made a very good showing. Tom Gillespie, manager of tho 1015 foot boll team nt La Sallo College, has been-ra-electcd mnnngcr for tho coming year. He will begin negotiations with the schools for l'.'lC football games nt once, ns La Salle believes In nn enrly start on Its footbull schedule. Seme of tho players who are making good on the basketball team Include Cap tain Frank Cnllnghan, who plnya forward, a guard during thd 1014 season; Danny McNIt-hol. gunrd on this year's quintet, who played forwaid Inst year; Rrennnn, guard, captain of thin year's football team; Ruf, veteran centre, and O'Donncll, forward, running-mate to Cnllnghan. With this veteran squad, I-, Salle's rec ord should be exceptionally good this year. Camden High School wns scheduled to open the season yesterday w till the Salem High School five, but owing to poor train connections the Snlem students were un able to carry out their plnns and can celed 'he game. Cnir.den opens tho cage season tomorrow at Mlllvllle High School and expects u hard match Tho Jersey plnverp arc without n game for Saturday nnd are anxious to meet one of the local high sehonls or academy teams on this day In n game nt Camden. '. THE OWEN MAGNETIC "The Car of a Thousand Speeds" THE announcement that the Owen Magnetic is to be sold in Philadelphia will appeal to those who appreciate all that is high grade in motor car construction. We fully expect to duplicate the success attained in New York, where owners will be found amongst families of social leadership, great captains of industry, bankers, and in fact among all thinking people who realize the great advances ac complished by the elimination of the objectionable gear shift and troublesome clutch, making possible a simplicity of construction, ease of operation and a wonderful flex ibility hitherto unknown; furthermore, every car possesses an individuality that does away with the dull monotony of duplication. We have on view seven and five-passenger touring cars, runabouts and inside drives, and a little later we will have ready for delivery limousines and landaulets by America's leading coach builders. To insure a demonstration we ask those who are interested to kindly phone us, making an appointment. CARL H. PAGE MOTORS CO., Inc. , r250 North Broad Street Spruce 5138 York. ' New Haven ORGANIZED BASEBALL MADE THE PEACE OVERTURES TO THE FEDERAL LEAGUE "Outlaw" Chiefs Will Join Ranks of Amer ican and National Circuits. By a Staff Correspondent Nt:w YORK, Dec. 15. Organized base ball today Is accepting credit for a won derful victory In bringing the Federal League to terms and ending the warfare which would have evenlunlly ruined tho great national pastime. The National League li given credit for forcing the Ftds to give up their fight for recogni tion ns the third major league, but as n mnttcr of fact It was organized bnll that sought pence. For tho good of the game In the fu ture It wns deemed advisable to make President Tenor's announcement rend so thnt tilnmnleptt u-lifi mm, 1ini-1,ni a r1n. sire to stoit nnother Independent circuit will nlwn.s remember the grent failure of the Feds. Those who believe thnt tho Feds were beaten Into submission nre fnr from (he truth, ns Gllmorc really won his lmttK When the final settlement Is made, and If the obstinate Ihin Johnson, president of the American Iengtle, docs not in terfere with the program. It will bo found Hint the main backers nnd prin cipal cng In the I'edernl League organ ization will be taken iiiro of, while the lesser lights will receive far mora tlinn would have been their lot If tho Feds hnd been so hopelessly beaten ua ono In led to bellevo by the reports of organized bait. Organized ball considers It n victory, but It Is not. Ilasebnll is still In the same position where It will always bo In tho future. Any organization with plenty of money nnd nerve can follow tho ex ample of the Feds nnd eventually force recognition. It was forecast In tho Kvbni.no I.EDoim a yenr ago that tho Feds could not be beaten If they stuck together, nnd tho developments nt tho opening session of the National League meeting proved thnt conclusively. Just what arrangements will be mndo nftcr the Feds hnve withdrawn their suit now in the hands of Judge Lnndis and the American League has signified its FRANK BAKER'S SALE" MAIN CHICAGO TOPIC American League Magnates Gather for Their An nual Meeting CHICAGO, Dec. IS. Disposal of "Home run" Raker and waiting for peace bul letins from New York wcro tho main events carded for today's meeting of tho American League. President B. B. Johnson wns to meet tho Executive Com mittee at noon and this afternoon was to sco the first regular session. Arrival of Connie Mack with Colonel Shlbe, of tho Athletics, preceded by an apparently authentic report that they were ready to make a deal for tho dis posal of Maker led to a belief that tho "Home-run King" would bo 30M to the highest bidder. A deal between tho 'White Sox and tho St. Louis Drowns hus apparently fallen through. In return for Scholk, Scott and Fournlcr Mnnngcr Rowland naked for Pratt, Sisler. Koob. Khotton nnd Austin. Manager Hedges said: "Why don't you ask mo to throw In the grandstand?" Athletics to Play Dodgers NEW YORK, Dee. 15. President Ebbets. of the llrooklyn club, after a connultatlon with ManiiKcr Uoblnion. announced he had selected his prO'Heaeon dates as follons March :il nnd April 1 In WnshlnKton April 4 and Z at Kl bcts Flelil. llrookln, with New York Ameri can: April (I, 7 und S with Itoston Americans at Ehbets Field, and April 10 and 11 at Kb bets Held with Philadelphia Athletics. Brooklyn Newark Probable Terms of Baseball Peace Pact If baseball peace is assured tho terms are expected to include tho following! Withdrawal of the Federnt League anti-trust suit. Passing of the Federal League. Placing the International League on a firm foundation, End of exorbitant salaries for players, some of which have exceed ed $10,000. Better baseball in the major leagues than has been seen for three seasons. Sale of'tho Cubs to Charles II. Weeghman, now owner of the Chi cago Federals. Sale of the Cardinals to E. Philip Ball, of St, Louis. Advent in organized baseball of some wealthy backers of the Federals. willingness to accept tho proposition Is not known. It Is generally believed that the International Lenguo circuit Is to bo changed so thnt half tho magnates will bo taken care of In Harrow's League, while the rest will buy Into organized bnll. The National League magnntcs havo consented to tho purchnslng of stock In thrco clubs by Federal League owners and the American League will allow two others to buy tho controlling Interest. The Nntlonnl Lenguo clubs which arc to havo Federal Leaguers In control nre tho Car dinals nnd Cubs, while Edward Owlnuer will be allowed to purchnsu nn Interest In the Plrntcs, nlthough Rnrney Dreyfuss will stilt hold tho controlling Interest. Just what will become of President Gllmore Is not known, ns apparently no nrrangements havo been mndo to tako care of this wonderful promoter, who made the Federal League possible. Qll moro will bo Invaluable to organized ball, but his Inst-mluuto fnlluro to comply with tho request of other mngnates In his lengue. who desired a settlement Is said to havo placed him In a hnd light with tho magnates of both factions. According to Inside Information, hnlt MORAN SIGNS PHULY THREE-YEAR CONTRACT Believe Manager Will Get $10, 000 Salary No Figures . Announced Yet NEW YORK, Dec. 15. Pat Mornn Blgnd a thr-year contract to manngo tho Phillies this afternoon. Tho terms wcro not nnonunced, but it Is said that the salary Is $10,000 a year. Muran would not discuss the figures, but Pres ident nnker admitted that "n very hand some Increase In salary had been given to Moran." Peace plans with tho Federals nro like ly to hit a snag when It comes time to purchaso Interests In National Lcaguo ball clubs. It Is said that Rrltton, of St. Louis, nnd Taft, who owns tho Chi cago club, havo placed n prohibitive price upon their holdings. It Is believed that tho samo condition prevails In the American Lengue. While peaco rumors are flying thick and fast and tho magnates nro awaiting news from Barney Dreyfuss' trip to Chi cago, where ho Is conferring with tho American League owners, there is n wild scramble for the stars In the third or ganization. Pat .Moran Is said to be after tho services of Leo Magee, nnd others nre In the market. Players who only broke, reserve clauses will bo taken back Into tho fold, it Is said, but iron-clad contract Jumpers will be barred. Benny Kauff, of tho Tip Topsr, nnd Hal Chase, of Buffalo, are said to be blacklisted. Gilmore May Be Made President of Chicago Gubs if Details Can Be Properly Settled tho stock In the Chicago Cubs wilt bo turned over to Charles Weeghman and William Walker, backers of tho Chicago Feds. Wceghmann nnd "Walker want President Gllmorc, of the Feds, to be made head of tho Cubs, but whether Oil more will accept or be agreed upon by orgnnl:cd ball Is not known. This un certainty Is duo to tho nhlmoslfy Ban Johnson holds against the Feds' great leader. Phil Ball, principal backer of tho St. Louis Feds, has received nn exceltcnt proposition from Mr. nnd Mrs. Schuyler I'. Hrltton, owners of the National Lenguo club, which will permit him to buy a large Interest In that club, and It Is be- llcved that he may possibly be able to buy the franchise outright If negotia tions now pending nro put through. Tho main discussion this momlng wns whnt would become of the Federal League players who Jumped organized bnll. Some time ago tho announcement wns made that the National and Ameri can Leagues would not permit any of theso Jumpers to return to the mnjor leagues. At this time the Feds declared that they would not consider any poice plans which would not tako all of their players who were considered nf mnjor lenguo calibre. It Is hard to seo how oiganlzctt ball forces can hope to bar men llko Benny KnufT, Davo Davenport, Ed Rousch nnd other youngsters who merely Jumped rc servo clauses, when final settlement Is made. There Is not enough uvallnblo material for thrco high-class leagues un less tho Jumpers nro tnken In as it Is planned to make them exempt from tho draft. H was said today that nn effort was being made to get Billy Dvnns, American Lenguo umpire, to manage one of the International League teams after tho con solidation, but ono magnate declared that this was out of the question because Dvnns hnd been virtually agreed upon n tho new mnnngcr of the Clevelnnd Americans to replace Lee Fohl. obeeErothers MOTOR CAR There is abundant evidence that this is an exceptionally economical car. Owners say that the gasoline consumption is unusually low. When they speak of tires' they almost invariably report mileage records which are remarkably high. And there is a sound logical reason why the car should cost little to keep. It is light the actual scale weight is only 2235 pounds. This light weight is partly due to the use of well-designed steel forgings; and pressed steel parts; and the absence of heavy castings. The all-steel body is electric ally welded into a unit This gives it that stability and rigidity which must other wise be sought in the use of heavy parts or bracings of steel or wood. The motor is 30-35 horsepowe The price of Touring Car or Roadster, complete, $785 (f, o. b. Detroit) The price of the Winter Touring Car or Roadster, complete, including regular mohair top, U $950 "(f. o. b, Detroit) i Dodge Brothers, Detrdit THORNTON-FULLElg AUTOMOBILE CO. 2041 Market Street BELL mONE 8HUC 4337. WOHLFARTH MAY JOIN THE CAMDEN . FIVERS RUMOR Owners Must First Obtain ms lteiease From Jag. per Management MAGNATE DENIES RUMOR, iU..ui-, ui ,ne i-amden Eatn. League basketball five attach eonnldw able significance to Eddie Dolan'a bu tied trip to Homestead last Friday ,m". are of tho belief that the Camden nl,. I7AlTHka h M A - ...... ... ....., , u.u CIUD owneriu an effort to sign "Dutch" Wohtf.nu Wohlfnrth has been baking pc, "j cakes nt Homestead for two years im ,' ....II ...1..1 -.in. i., ... ""all. ..c. .,., ..t ,ui ma ,0lj go well con tent. In fact, that bo refno,i ... . offer from the Jasper management mil' which team ho wns under reserve nri ' ,n 4t. ..,... .1.- . . P"Tjs iu tun mm i. ui tiiu present season. , A player of tho typo of WohlfAm", aiongsiua Jimmy urown wnuu ..:." jj Camden flvo out of Its present slumn nt? present Hoy Steele Is tho only mn,i,.: of tho Cnfndcn quintet who can S ll entty emcrgo from a scrlmmoge with th. 1 bnll. Brown Is a flrst-rnto scoring btij ' but Delghan has no psrtlcnln,. Si...' It aside from the '-vet that he Is a bIum.? 1 With Wohlfnrth doing tho greater D,rf 'I oi tho heavy woik, Steele would he r llcved of that burden nnd could HTO.I most of his time to playing forwarifil Timlin t-n. .,.!'., .. '...?. """I t .,., v.. ,,.,, n uiiciiau WOU1Q 1)9 Iffl.-J7 proved nt least 23 per cent, ' M Poor crowds have attended tho KimM11, at the 3d Regiment Armory, but I'M winning team would bring out th ' patrons to tho same number that mn. V ncsscd closing games of the 1914-1S uc. H Samuel Herman, one of tho Carwleo 'J owners, declares the Wohlfarth runr i to bo unfounded. In order to obtain the I player In question Cnmden must fint ' obtain his relcaso from Jasper. Owner Linton stated tho Camden management ' hns not approached him on the subject '' of Wohlfnrth, nnd furthermore declared iiini any ouenor ms release would have to bo a very flattering one. ati IE X I V It n V ec .If It: .1 K If B KX