RfHB SSBBmmmmmm 1 r'HSH 2 EVENING LEDGERPHIL'APELPHIA, MONDAY, OCTOBER 12, 1914;. ! re f rF B W t CI f "E i ".i ! ' I I i ntmosphers and those packed In the Jtlcdchers wore not uncomfortablo with their coats on. BRAVES START PRACTICE. The Braves Appeared at the park by noon They Immedlatelv started batting practice. Most of their efforts were di rected against right-handers. The crowd cheered anl generally worked Itself up There was a sprinkling of fans In the ie Icefved scats of the grandstand even at this early hour. While the Braves were still at batting practice and the stands were rapidly fill ing a Pilgrim Father appeared In the main grandstand About his hat was a otrlng of frankfurters Another hung from his neck, and he bore a huge sign reading "FOR SALE-BRAVES' SAUSAGES Made From Connie s Goat. Tho Athletics appeared on the field at 12 50. Thev were r?iven a great reception by the Boston fans The bleacherltes cheered them to the echo, horns were blown, papers and hats waved as Con nie's Uam slipped Into its dugout In the meantime the Braves were poppeilng tho ball for nil It was worth Gowdy especially waa trying to kill It. He drove nvitrnl Into the blcJChClu , Cather, Connolly. Mann and Schmidt I duplicated this feat, to the great de- i light of the crowd The Braves also ' put In en extended period at bunting , practice and hammering al southpaw shoots to be prepaied for anything Mack ( might spring Outside tho park there were WOO peo pie All were clamoring for tickets, and It ieq lirrd the bravest efforts h the po lice to keep order Thoo In tho top seats of tho right fle'd bleachers amused them- 8104 by tusslns inonev down Into n crowd if small bovs, and young riots were ccntantlv in progress The town 1- baseball mad For that meitler, a larse section of the United States and Canada Is In the same fix. Hotels here are Jammed. Fans from all tectlons of the country have traveled hun dreds of miles to be on hand for this crucial strusale today There Is a man In the State colony at Knst Gardner who has been alei p for 10 months The doc tori can't wake him up. but they are watching cloreh todav for him to sud denly come to and ask the score The town Is simply so wroueht up that some Inhabitants have forgotten for the time being that they went to Harvard 4000 PRESENT AT SUN-UP. At sun-up them were upwards of IrtCO persons waiting outside Fenwav Park for the opening of the bleacher gates. At S o'clock others were arriving by tho hun dreds Among the first 50 In line were two women More than 1000 men and boys stood In Un throughout the night, and the women had been waiting for hours when the sal" of scats finallv begun Boys were willing to sell their places for from $1 :o to H From T o clock until the gates for the 6"-cent and $ seats were opened tho great crowd grew by leaps and bounds Thousands poured toward the pari; from every direction Tn addition to those waiting for unreserved seats, more than KO0 persons were massed about the re served seat entrance Shortly after 10 o'clock it was planr.'d to sell tickets for reserved seats which had not been called for There were not moro than 100 of these to satisfy the throng which was waiting. There were nine long lines of waiting fan3 stretching down the streets from tho ball park Between S and 9 o'clock wo men were arriving by the score All of those who had been waiting during the long hours of the night had camp-stool?, boxes or chairs, and were ocrved break fasts of coffee, sandwiches and fruit by venders swarming about the place A young armv of policemen patrolled the streets about the park, and thero was no disorder -The few tickets which have fallen Into the hands of speculators were bringing record-breaking prices today. Nothing less than $30 would oataln a regular $2 seat. Those In tho SS section were bring ing $10 to $50 Four New Yorkers paid $123 for four seats, which were to gether. The -scat sale makes it certiin that a crowd of more than 35,000 will wltnS3 the game today. It bing Columbus Day and a hvhJa' all attendance records fcr the local park are expected to be broken. IMPORTANT DECISION Connie Mac't muit make one of the most important decisions of his career in sel.-i.t:n his pitcher If the Brakes aro to bi stopped they must be stopped today. Bush, Shaw key and Bress'er are anxious for a tiv at the Whaling Miracle Men. Mack did not give the sllghtot intimation of his possible selection His final deUsion will proably not be mads until It U teen how the youngsters warm up. and it is even believed there Is a chance that Pender might be sent back The intn-dt n the series in towns t.r from Boston "as shown bv the fact that a majtrin nf -he lines were headed uv men who hae traveled long distances to reach here J F Friedel of Youngs town. O, headed one line He had "beat" his wa from Youngstown to Buffalo and then to Boston to see the same Another lino was headed by W. F. Woodock. o' Lisbon, Me. BUSINESS "NEARLY NORMAL" President Wilson Thus Regards Pre vailing Trade Conditions. "WASHINGTON' Oct 12 Business con ditions in the United States are nearly normal in the I Hef of President Wil son Outbids of the South, where the cotton situation has dislocated business generally, the industrial affairs of the nation are in good shap. according to reports to the White House. While the effect!, of tho war have been far-reaching, the President told his call ers today the courtry has maintained Us business equilibrium remarkably welt AXLE BRAKES, ONE INJURED Man Badly Hurt in Auto Mishap. Two Escape. WILKES-BARRE. Pa., 0t 12. Whan an axle broke on the automobile in whtah he was riding. George Wagner, elerk -f the Luzerne County Court, vat thrown violently to the ground and the automo. bile turned over on him lie suffered three broken ribs and two broken finger and was badly cut and bruised about the body. The accident occurred In the Po. cono Mountains Two friends who were riding with Wagner escaped Injury. The auto was traveling at a fair speed when the axle snapped l i inn III . il "Movie" Picture of the House WASHINGTON Oct 18 Speaker Clark went through the motion of calling the House to ordtr today for the special ben efit of a muvlng picture man Sunounded by a caturv of intensely bright lights the Speaker tapped the gavel, and announced calmly ' the House will be in order." while 50 page bovs looked on from the members' eats The movie man also took a film, of Srgeant-at-Arm Gordon about to quell disorder In the House by pre sentine the historic silver and ebony mace to the inake-believ riours. HURT WHEN AUTO SKIDS MILLVILLE. N J. Oct 12 An auto mobile driven by James McCaw skidded on the road between Tuckaboe and Mlll viUe last night, ran into a trea and de molished the front of the machine. Neil lie1 "aw who waa sitting. In the front seat, was burled over the wind shield and received a fractured skull Auto's Death Trail in New York I vV Yi'TtK t 1-' ixtcer pe--s:jns . 'i ii I at l-at f. ,r pr b v naJl '"V a tonvb le a idents .a and 4ut iew "iork. city yeMirdaji i 1 - Ml 1 Mllll . . NK '11 Composite Box Score First Two World's Series Games Mttrphr. rf Olctrlng, If Collins, 2h ....ltt.lt linker, .11 t.t 7 Mclnnls, II) Stnink. cf Harry, M . t.npp, c . . SrlinnRt c Heniler, p Wjckoff, p I'iank. WiiWl 0 Totals .-, S3 1 7 10 'Untied for Dank In ninth Innlnir, second game. BOSTON AH. S Moran, rf .Mann, rf , S Evcr, 5b 0 Connolly. If 3 Cnthrr, If 3 Mhltted, cf A brlunldti Hi R Oon dy, c ....,,..,,, !i MnrunWUo, s , 0 Deal, 3li fl Ituclolph, p 4 lames, p 4 Totals 07 8 SCOItK BY Athletics Boln SUMMAIIY Earned run HoMon, 8. Tw-o-bae lilts Sclmng, Deal, Ontrdy, Wxehoff, nnker. Three-base hits hlttcd, Oowdy. Left on bases Athletics, 7; Hoston, 14. Struck out Hj Ilrmlrr, 'li t N.vcknrr. 3 by l'lnnlt, fl by .lame. 8 by Hudolpli, 8. Double plays Harr, Collins and Mclnnlst Itendcr. Harry nnd Mclnnlsi Hemlrr and .Mdnnls) llaker nnd .Mclnnlsi Schmidt nnd Ural) Mnrnntlllc and Schmidt. I'lrst base on errors Athletics, Is llostnn, 1. Unsed on bulls OIT Dernier, 2 off AVjckoff, 1 off rinnk, 4; off Rudolph, 3 off .Tames 3. Hits apportioned Off Ilender, 8 In 8 1-3 InnlnRs) off Wyikoff, 3 In 3 2-3 Innlncs; off Hudolpli, S In 0 Innlnnsi off James. 2 In 9 innings, lilt l pllrlied linll Uy l'Linh, 'Marnntllle. Passed bnll Srhnng. Muffed foul fly Marnn tllle. 1 umblrs- Eters, Moran, Dropped thrown boll MrlnnK Time of 2 itnmes 3S4. I'mplres fur llrst name lllnren at plate, Klem on base, njron In left field, Illldrbrand In rlcbt Held. I millers for second name Illldrbrand nt plate, Hyron on liases, lUem tn left Held, Dlncen In right Held. Attendance 11,121. SIR JOHN FRENCH; LOVED BY BRITONS, GREAT WAR CHIEF Career of British Army Chief in France Marked by Success His Cam paigns in South Africa. t 'Finch' A predestined name The glsrl ous pold'er. the most eminent and most j-.opjlar ef English leaders of armies, has been placed, ns ceryfcoily In England foresaw and every body In our army ulshed, at tho head of the admirable troops who aro to co-operate In the cause of right ' Paris 1 igaro. His full name and title is Field Marshal Sir John Denton Pinkstone French, but to British soldier boys he 13 known as i "Jacky" French, the greatest of modern cavalry leaders. The navy was his first love. The son of a naval captain, it was natural that he should first turn towards his father's branch of tho servlce, and for four years he served as midshipman and naval cadet before Joining the army. It was this fact which gave rise to an amusing incident which occurred when some naval olticers, who wero dining w-ltn some soldiers, attempted a little chaff at the expense of the latter. "You haven't got a single leader worth a cent, ' contended tho officers, "with the excep tion of French, and he Is a sailor." "Yes, ' rotored the Infantrymen, "ho was In the navy Just long enough to see what a rotten service It was. Then he chucked it and went Into the militia, where he learnt to be what he is now." Certainly, as a young man Sir John hankered for soldiering. Says one who knew him In the nay, "You Invariably found him studying the lives of Welling ton, Napoleon, and the heroes of the Indian muntlny. and I was not surprised when he left us to enter the Klghth Hussars." Ultimately. Sir John was transferred to the ISth Hussars, in which regiment he served In the Soudan campaign and won his spurs. That soldier-saint. General Gordon. wa3 locked up In Khartoum, and French, who had been promoted to the rank of major, was one of the camel corps which made a desperate dash across the Bayuda Desert In connection with the tardily dispatched relief expe dition. At Abu Klea they fought a des perate action with the Arabs, but all In vain, for when they reached Khartoum they found that the flag was no longer flying and that Gordon waa dead It was during the South African War. however, that General French proved his genius as a cavalry leader. Perhaps the greatest compliment of his career was paid bv the enemy, De Wet, who thought highly of British boldiera, but scorned our officers. But when General French's name was mentioned to the great Boer leader he immediately changed his tone, declaring enthusiasti cally, "Ah, he is the one Boer General In the British army " French went right through the Boer campaign, and was perhaps the only general whose work was consistently sue Cfssful to tho end He landed In Cape Town the day before the storm broke October 10, 199, and he left for England on June 23. 10o, after achievements which stamped him as the greatest cavalry leader of our time One of his greatest feats was undoubt edly the relief of Klmberley, which was achieved b French's dashing exploit of xalloplns his division through the Boer lines. LAUKEL ENTRIES First race, ?50O. el!ln. for 8-year-olds and UP. S'i furlone Progressive. 1X4. Cornoraci r 1U. Dr R. L. Sarnger, 111 Americas. Ill r-rostbun 110 Uncle Jlmmle. 109, fikeets, 108 Buzz Around 10S Joe Finn. loS. Stetleta, 106. Laura, 108 'Miss Eleanor. 103, 'Galaxy. 103. sj J Ulli 101. Second race Vl for 3 ear-oil maidens. 5', furlongs Rovali 110. High Tide. 110; Jack of Clubs. 110 t'ncle Brn 110, Carlona, llu Leonn'ne lu" Peg 107. Sir L. Joe 107. Volant 107 Berly James. 107 Merry Twin kle. 107, May Queen. 107. Marvelous. 107. ftlvr King. 107 Meellcka, 107 Third race IVKI selling. 3-yeax-olda and up, SV-i furlong Chuckles, 116, Jim Easey, 114. YorkUHe. 113, Blue Thistle, 113. Granite 112 Belamour HI Water Uly. 110. Lohen grin 110 Besom 108 Early Hose. 106. Lady Lightning Ida Keuesaa. 10S. Honey liee 10 'Water Welles 106. Fourth race. I10TO for 3-year-olds Blue Point selling 5'? furlongs Disillusion. 10" Jim Savage 10A, (a)Oloamng UH Distant Shore MM Kemar. 101. Hsadmast 103 Hy droplane VS. 'alMontroea, 03. gtajaart Helen. W Broom Flower, 93 KUtb rate. f00. handicap, all ages 1 mile Plande-tc 111 Montresor, IM. (ti)WorklriK Lad. 104. TBornhUl. 108: TacUc. &9. (b)Azy adr St). Barnegat SS, Sixth race e00. for 3-year-c44 and up, 1 1-W miles Pate. HO; RoUUg hum; 10S. Guy Kisher 11" Lowtoofleld. 18 Goldy ins Dr T'uenner 105 Kim Box. 105. ConSdo, 105 J-nger us Mar h 104 pneiu. 106 Holton. liM tj jii 10J 'OtrraMl, V2 Bushy HcJ rr-" o!iwanr 0f 5 pcuMs c aimed. Wtiii " ti' in x faat. it M " pe. r eji-y ie;Hal.n.6e-fc entry AT1II.KTIC8 An. n. ii. Tit. sh. sn. nn. so. 2 ro. a. 2 0 Are 14S .000 .187 .143 .000 .2811 .000 .000 .200 .000 1.000 .oon .000 I I 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 7 a 17 4 n 2 8 1 1 0 o 1 1 I H M !l 1 .127 it- it. Tn. sir. 0 0 0 0 sn. l o n n o o 1 l n 2 o o nn, o o l l o 2 n 3 o o o o so. l l , t l l 0 ro. ,. 0 0 E. .We I O 0 0 0 0 n l 0 0 0 .000 .400 ,itx .333 .000 .107 .275 .000 .BOO .m .230 .000 .260 01 18 , 0 1 1 2 2 24 17 4 .1 0 0 0 n l o l 4 IS 2t 1 S 7 11 SI 20 INMNOS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 1 3 0 MACK KEEPS MEN SECLUDED BEFORE CAME IN BOSTON Athletics Express Confi dence, While Braves Are in Wild Excitement on Eve of Third Contest. By HUGH S. FULLEBTON BOSTON, Oct. 12 Boston and the Ath letics meet each other today for the crucial game of the series. It was con ceded bv both teams that today's game means the championship If Boston can win again tho Athletics will be a broken and desperate team, and the chances are that the miracle team will rush through to four straight victories. If the Ath letics rally and win, then the judges of the game believe that they will com strong and fight to a finish, probably carrying it to seven games For the first time In his carter Mack U in desperate straits for pitchers. His two veterans have fallen and all his advisers are criticizing him for using them. It is reported that he will send Bush In today to stop the rampant Braves and then fall back upon his youngsters to try to save the day. Stalllngs makes no secret of the fact he Intends to send Rudolph against tho Athletics nnd come back tomorrow with James and try to sweep the series. Tho Braves today are confident, full of wild excitement, and all day yesterday they were being made the heroes of Boston, which has gone seemingly insane over them. Stalllngs strove In vain to keep them away from their admirers, who were hurting their chances by excess of adulation. The Mackmen laid doggo in their hotel, keeping out of sight as much as pos sible. They declare they still are con fident that they will win, but the truth Is they are worried and upset. It is evident that Mack is more worried than be ever has been. He secluded his play ers as much as possible, refused to allow them to ride In the same car with their wives on the trip here, and yesterday herded the wlveB In one set of quarters and the players in another. Both clubs held long meetings yester 'day and discussed the situation. The Braves' spirit Is wonderful. Nothing shakes their confidence that they will win They believe It, and unless the Ath letic stop them today nothing will check their Impetuous rush to the highest honors. The students of the game and the of ficials are all In the air over the showing of the Braves They cannot understand it. It simply is a case of a fair ball team playing great ball and a great ball team plajtng only fair ball. The Braves know that if the Athletics ever get started they will batter their way to even terms and perhaps to victory. Their hope is to sweep the champions off their feet by the "attack brusque." The wagering on the series Is odd. They talk a lot of 2 to 1 Boston will win, but faw save college boys throwing away their "paw's ' money will bet. Boston is wild with enthusiasm and extremely canny as to real money. The betting is 6 to 5 that the Athletics will win today's game, with Boston demanding even . money or odds-whlch is strange, after they have won two games. If Mack loses todav, he will be fiercely criticised He is not tipping off his plans Stalllngs Is practically certain to pitch Rudolph, and It Is evident he has little faith that Tyler can win in his present form. Mack Is being advised against worklne Bressler. although In spite of their vaunted ability to hit left-handed pitch ing, the Braves could do little or nothing with Plank Saturday. Dick Rudolph has asked Stalllngs to give him another crack at the Mackmen. Stalllngs has said he would come back with Rudolph today, but It is realized that If Tyler Is to be used In the eerles, now Is the time to throw him In. With the Braves having a two-game lead and a home crowd to urge him on, tho time appears ripe for the southpaw. Unless an even greater game Is staged today, Saturday's tussle will still be talked of above everything else even when the scries Is over A dozen "turning points" In the game are being pointed out Ban Johnson expressed the opinion that 1'mpire Byrin's derision in calling Schang out at third In the ilxth Inning was "rotten " Photographs of fie play alio show Schang on the base with Deal tltl Raiting for the-ball. . "BULLET JOE" BUSH, ON THE ART SCHOOL GETS PART OF ESTATE Continued from rage One written for Mr. Sully and presented to him by her Majesty In person in Buck ingham Palace, London, May H, 1S3S. "Portrait of artist's wife, by Thomas Sully, being the original painting from life of Sarah Annls, wife of Thomas Sully, and painted by Thomas Sully at Philadelphia, In the year 1S3S. This por trait Is encased tn an oval carved-wood frame, gilded. "Portrait of Bosallo Kemblo Sully, daughter of Thomas Sully, and painted by him from life In Philadelphia. ISIS. "Full length portrait of 'Mother and Son,' by Thomas Sully, being an original full-length portrait of Jane Cooper Sully, daughter of Thomas Sully, afterwatd Mrs. William H. W Darlcy, and her son, Francis T. Sully Darlcy. " "Sleeping Child,' known ns "The Rose bud,' an original painting by Thomus Sully, Philadelphia. Pa. 1814 "Portrait of 'A Cavalier,' by Anthony Van Dyck. This picture was purchased by Rembrandt Peale In Paris In the year 1S03 and sold to Thomas Sully In 1S20." Other distributions of works of art and from the library of the decedent arc: To William T Elliott a painting. "The Scotch Landscape," by Julsom: to Thomas Nash a painting. "Burgos Cathe dral at Early Dawn." also "The Clltfs of Calala," by Hugurt; to the William Penn Charter School all tho testator's collec tion of mounted photographs and all framed photographs and engravings con tained In the residence 510 South Broad street; to the Tree Library of Philadel phia hl3 library of books, pamphlets and bound volumes of photographs To Louisa Baldwin Gilpin, widow of Washington H. Gilpin, is bequeathed a crayon portrait of Matthias W. Baldwin, all plate. Including the Baldwin chest of silver, collection of china and various other articles and $25,000 To Mrs. Gil pin's daughter, Mrs Stanlev Bright, n bronze group, "The Wrestlers," by Char pentler MARBLE GROUP FOR THE ACADEMY. To the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, a group of marble statu.irv executed by Donato Barcoglla, entitled "Awakening of the Sleepers." To the Museum Department of the Pennsylvania School of Industrial Art, Memorial Hall, Falrmount Park, Is given a large number of objects of art, con sisting of bronzes, metal work, furniture, pottery, glass and china. To the Presbyterian Hospital Ib given JtiOOO "to endow a free bed in the Cathcart Homo for Incurables at Devon, Chester County. In memory of my wife, Cecelia Baldwin Darley, with the provision, how ever, that as long as she may live Martha Rlgby shall have the right to occupy said bed." To the executors Is bequeathed $25,000 in trust, the income of which is to be paid to Clayton McElroy during his life, or If he dies before the teatator then to his wife, Margaret McElroy, during her life, the principal upon the decease of both to revert to their children To the executors Is given In trust $25,000, the Income to be paid to Katrena McElroy Capp, during her life, the principal to revert to her children 'upon her decease. To the executors In trust, J23.0!0 for the benefit of Cecelle Baldwin McElroy during her life, with the reversion of the princlpul to her children. To the executors In trust, $25,000 In come to be paid to Margaret McElroy, wife of Clayton McElroy, during her life, the principal to revert upon her death to her children. To the children of Washington H. and Louisa B. Gilpin is devised $25,000. ' INCOME OF $100,000 FOR NURSE. The testator also bequeaths $100,000 In trust, the net Income from which Is to be paid "to my faithful friend and nurse, Mies Ella Clark." who Is given the privi lege of disposing of the principal by will; to Sarah Louisa Seaman, $25,0u0; to Mrs. Clara Maxwell Dougherty, $2500; to Mrs. C Egner, $7500, to Cecelia D. Lambert, $5000, to Sarah Hebrew. $10,000; to Mrs. Elizabeth J Lambert. $VW; to Mrs. A. Maria Jones. $50TO. to William Hempel, Jr. $10,000. to Oscar F West, $10,000; to Frank T West, $5000, to Dr. Clarence Bartlett. $10 000. The testator directed that each servant who had been In his employ for three years or longer was to receive $1000, and those for less than three years $500. it Is alrJO specified that each of the servants Is to be given one month's notice and pay for that period. Directions are given the executors to sell and dispose of all pictures, works of art, bric-a-brac, household articles, furni ture, linen and china, not specifically dis posed of by tho will. SXTFTRAOIBTS WILL MEET 20O Deleg-ates From All Parts of Jersey Coming to Camden. Advocates of woman suffrage In New Jersey are today making preparations for the 21th annual convention of the New Jersey Woman's Suffrage Associa tion, which will be held In Camden, No vember 6 and 7. At this convention a reso lution will be adopted urging the Legisla ture at its next session to pass favor ably on the equal-suffrage bill. Details of the convention program were announced yesterday More than 2M delegates will be present, representing every pan of New Jersey Mayor BHU, of Camden, la to make tho addre of welcome, w jfs- ULjJiU JJlJLHlyJ ' 1 MOUND FOR MACKMEN AT FENWAY PARK THIS AFTERNOON BRAVES STRONGER THAN MACKS IN OPENING GAMES Except in Fielding, Boston Has Surpassed Athletics in All Departments Stallings' Pitchers' Work Superb. WAIT TILL WE FIND THE RANGE The pride thai goeth before the fall and the fall itself are gone; The Elephant is aroused today and the beast is rushing on; The Braves, rvho lurk in their otvn tepees, will try to pierce his hide, But it is the Boston crctv today rvho must contend with pride. The curves of the Boston pitching men today arc not so strange. And the Macs arc back of their howitzers searching to find the range; Came are the men of Bunker Hill, but the bravest foe may die When the far-famed maulers come to life and find their batting eye. The antc-eerles "dope" on tho world's series showed that In every department of play the Athletics were not only stronger, but actually outclassed tho Braves. This applied even to the pitch ers. It was generally conceded that Ru dolph, Tyler and James wero good hurl ers, buf when compared with the ex perienced Bender and Plank their chances for victory In the big series were deemed slender in the extreme. Now the series Is two games old. ind what have they revealed? First and fore most that confidence covers a multitude of minor weaknesses. Seconly. that In stead of the Athletics outclassing their opponents In all departments, the have been surpassed every w hoi e except in the field. Just now the outfleldB are a stand-off. Inasmuch as not one of the eight garden ers who have taken part In the series has had a hard chance. In fact, neither set of outpost men has had an average number of chancca. The Macklan trio had eight chances on fly balls, while the Braves had but five. With the outfield on even terms so far, let us see how the rest of the defensive department, exclusive of the pitching, compares, judging the men bv what they have done In two games only. Baker has played on even terms with Deal, but the latter's two-base blow In Saturday's game, which paved the way for him to fieore tho winning run, puts the substi tute ahead of the home-run "king in all around play. As for a comparison of the work of the two famous pairs around sec ond, Collins and Barry and Evers and Maranvllle. there Is little to be said. Each one of those men has played wonderful ball, and to say that any one of them has surpassed the other In brilliancy would be making a statement which would not hold good Some Boston followers will say that Evers and Maranvllle have out played their Athletic rivals, while many rooters for the Macks will contend that the reverse Is true. In all Justice to those concerned, it would not be fair to any one of these splendid performers. In the light of what they have done, to put one above tho other The Athletics" pair have had 25 chances and have not erred, while their opponents have had 19 and have made two errors Hencj In the averages as taken Maranvllle and Evers will show up to poorer advantage. But that Is Just where the figures fall Evers nnd Maranvlllo have played Just as well ns Collins and Barry, and those who saw the games and are willing to Judge Impartially realize this At first base Mdnnls has played one of the most spectacular games ever put up by a first baseman In a world's series fray. He has far eclipsed big Schmidt, although the latter haa been one of the hardest workers on the field. He has been full of "pep" throughout the H rounds of play But no matter how he might try Schmidt would never be able to execute the plays which "Stuffy" has made vi 1th apparent ease. In the game plajed here Saturday some of the pick ups Mdnnls made while leaning as far from the bag as he could could not be surpassed by any man that ever played the game The catching of Gowdy has been bet ter to date than Schang's Before the series Schang had the better of Gowdy (on paper again), but after two rounds have been played he hasn't shown up so well. Gowdy has allowed but one Ath letic player to steal, while five Braves have been credited with stolen baseB Of course, the Mackmen haven't been on the bags enough to make a vast number of attempts, yet Gowdy showed, when hi. threw Schang out at third Saturday when the Mack catcher tried to make a base on a short passed ball, that he has a great whip and that It would be sui cide for frequent pilfering attempts to be made. Schang's poor Judgment In throning behind, instead of In front, of Deal In the ninth inning Saturday, was partly responsible for the loss of the contest It is true that Barry was also to blame for not throwing to Baker Just here It might be mentioned that the reason given for Barry's failure to throw was because Deal was In the di rect line with him and Baker. However, he could have thrown to one side of the runner and Baker could have caught the ball probably as well as If Deal had not been In line. A for Jack Lapp, he played well, but waa in only three and two-thirds Innings of the first game The brief comparisons above have pur ported to show that In the first twr. games of the series the neldintr hi hn L equal. tcauw neither outfield haa r- passed the other; Baker and Deal have done equally well; so have Maranvllle and Evers and Barry. and Collins; Mc Innls has done better work than Schmidt, vv hlle Gowdy has eclipsed Schang. ' So much for the fielding. In the pitching department it cannot be denied that the Bruves pitchers, Rudolph and James, have shown up superblv. They hnve surpassed the expectations of the most sanguine Bostonlans by Jointly holding tho Athletics to seven hits In IS innings and not allowing the Mackmen a single earned run. The only score made by the Macks was in the second Inning of the first game and was the result of Moran's error. They gave six bases on balls against seven for Bender, Wyckoff and Plunk. The Athletics' pitchers struck out 11 Brave batsmen, while their oppo nents sent 10 Mackmen back to tho bench cooler on strikes While Plank did not deserve to los his game with James, lie certalnlv did not deserve to win It. It is true that the run mudc by Deal hnd to be scored as "earned." yet It was really the result of a double error of Judgment by Schang and Barry, and not Plank's fault. Plank gave up seven hits to James' two, henc It would not be fair to the Boston pitcher to say that he deserved to lose, which is the same thing as saving that Plank deserved to win. and this many followers m nit wnite tlephnnts have said, nnd incidentally some of the Athletic players ...w...iii.ii0 uine oi inc Atnietic players themselves said, Tlank deserved to win iiuc ne aiunt according to our view. He simply didn't deserve to lose. Avhcn we come to tho hitting of the two teams, it is a sad comparison for Phlladelphians. The difference in the last two games between the hitting of the Athletics nnd that of the Braves hasn't been even close. Of course the old argu ment may be brought up that It was the superior pitching of the Braves, rather than the weakness of the Athletics that caused them to look bo bad on the of fense But they have faced pitchers many times who were as good, if not better, than Rudolph and James, and have teldom batted so weakly In two suc cessive contests. Thero Is no getting nway from the fact that the mighty Macklan mauling ma chine has been severely silent. They made five hits off Rudolph and two off James. Collins' hit oft James was de cldedly a scratch, and there were many, Including Athletic rooters, who thought that Evers' throw beat him to flret Thes.e seven hits were made In seven different Innings, which shows how completely at the mercy of the opposing hurlers the Mackmen were. Then, too, tho strike-out record shows as well as the base hit col umn how badly the Athletics, were out guessed. While tho Athletics were making seven scatteied hits for a total of 10 bases, tho Braves were piling up 15 safeties, for a total of 21 bases. Their batsmen were better waiters than the Macks and they struck out fewer times. In base running again tho Braves sur passed the Macks. Barry dole the Ath letics only base In the ninth inning of Saturday's game That the Athletics did not run the bases with good Judgment Is shown bv the following facts: In the first game Murphy was thrown out trying to take third after Schmidt had caught a foul, in the second game the same player was out attempting to make cecond on a thrown ball which Schmidt allowed to get through him. Strunk was caught at second In the first game, trying to stretch a single Into a double; In the second game Collins was caught napping off first and Schang was caught trying to take third on a short passed ball. The Athletics claim that Umpire Byron made a gross error of judgment when he called Schang out on the occasion re f erred to above But it was a close play, and Byron no doubt called It as he saw it and he was In a position to see. There practically wero no kicks made by the players in Friday's game nn tho ,,mi- Ins, although the Braves were constant ly nagging at Dlneeu. However, both teams made a number of violent protests against Hlldebrand's decisions on balls and strike Saturday, and the Athletics several times had words with Byron, who was on the bases that ame game While all these things show that the Braves have a big edge on the Athletics, Judging bv the two garni played, the scores are the thinga which count and as the Braves have a total of eight to one and have been victorious In both con tests 7-1 and 1-0, there 13 o theory that can b advance which can snow that 1 VII, . K ' ' ,u was nt superior to the I 1 tVllnHrli In V. ..... -.. a.. . . ., ' stJbe TParlc. ' " 3W comt EDDIE COLLINS SAYS BIG JAMES HAD EVERYTHING Star Second Baseman Blames Saturday's Defeat on Inability to Hit, but Says Team Is Not Beaten. Athletics "Still in the Ring" and Hope to Show Old-time Form in Boston Today "Then Look Out." By EDDIE COLLINS Baturday'a dofeat hurt. There la no getting away from that fact. Unlike tin first game that wo lost, when we were beaten bo decisively and when we had no excuse to offer, our second downfall was 'the harder because o' closeness of the Bcoro and the manner In which It was made. It haa always been my con tention, and tho majority of the baseball knowing public will agree with me, that it never hurts so much to get trimmed good and proper by some big score nearly ns much as It does by one run, and that Is why this last setback comes so much harder to Us. It scorns as though It were the Irony of fate that follows in the wake of Eddie Plunk In a world's scries game. Just tako a look back at tho game ho pitched against Mathcwson, of tho Giants, last year. Saturday a was almost a duplicate of that one, or as near as It Is posslblo for two performances to be, and the re sult was the same In both Instances. All becauso we could not make a run, or oven come close. There Is no getting away from the fact that James, for Boston, certainly pitched a beautiful same and deserves a world of credit. On the first day Rudolph won handily and was much of a mystery to our batters, but this big fellow James looked twlco as good to me. The way he was moving along, I didn't see how w0 wero ever going to set a run. When yoi stop to figure that we only got one clean hit. the other a fluky Infield tap, that only two men got ns far as second and that only 23 Athletics fnced him In tho whole game, you can begin to get an Idea of what wc were up against. Thit'j pitching, that is all, and you must glvq credit where credit Is due. But, as good as was big James' work, our own Plank's was not far behind. Whilo In tho matter of hits and btcadl nrss James had considerably tho better of It, when It came to tho pinch, with men on bases, Plank was always the master of the situation. In the very first inning Boston came near to getting away with a lucky break. After Mann hnd been retired, Evers got a life on a swinging bunt In front of the pluto that Plank could not even make a play on. Cathers, playing In place of Connelly, fanned, but Whlttcd finally worked his way to first via the base-on-balls route, and things looked dangeruds with big Schmidt up. However, Plank had his number, and his best was a fly to Strunk. DEAL'S MISTAKE HELPS BRAVES. Again, in tho second, a base on balls started trouble. ,A sacrifice by Maranvllle put Gowdy on second, but Deal hit to Baker, who nipped tho Braves' catcher go ing to third. Then a play followed, which was duplicated later on, that beat us out of the ball game. Deal took a big lead off nf flret and by a quick throw Schang had him caught off, but Deal made a break for second nnd made it. Likewise In the fatal ninth, with one down Deal doubled to centre; In fact, Strunk was luckv to hold the hit to a two-bagger after tho ball got over his head, and again Schang caught him away off bv a sharp throw to Barry, only to i , ., :; ;. : r hj , .- have n,m KO tno otner way nnd s,lde lnt0 thlid safely. If Deal had made the play intentional and got cnught oft In order to make the p'av that he did and go to third, It would not hurt so much, but to think tnat an opponent can make a mistake and still get awy with it to his advantage Is discouraging, to say the least. A nice plav by Barry probably saved Plank trouble In the fourth after Schmidt and Marnnvllle had singled Likewise in tho sixth two Bostonlans were on the bases, but our left-hander tightened and no damage was done Thereafter until tho ninth tho Braves did not threaten. But In this final round they managed to squeeze over tho run that beat us. As al ready descrlbtd, Deal doubled and worked hi? way to third with only one out It looked pretty good for us when Eddie fanned James and made It two down Then Mann followed with a tantalizing drooping liner, which I feel that I ought to Invo got; at any rate, I would give nnythlne for another try at it. However tho best I could do was Just touch It, and the run was In. HELPLESS BEFORE JAMES All this time we were absolutely help less before James. I simply do not know how to explain tt. I know I have never seen our team apparently so lost against any two pitchers as we have been against Rudolph and James In this series Of course, the two mentioned have done great work, but during the seaaon I have seen so much better pitching, and still we hit It. Take the plavers Individually. I cannot recall when we have all gone bo bad at once. All of us have experi enced slumps at one time or other In our hitting, but never so many at once before Go right down our batting or der Eddie Murphy, the leader-off. has come the nearest to holding his own. he has managed to get on one or more times In each game, Oldring has been nowhere near his true self, and the same Is true of myself and Baker In order When can any of ou remember of seeing "Stuff)" Mclnnis strike out twice In one game be fore? Not this vear, I am sure of that And the same is true right down the line. Seven hits In two games does not sound very good for a club that is sup posed to have a reputation of being called sluggers Those are simply the plain, hard facts, we have not hit a lick reasons therefor (a) too good Ditching acalnst us. or (W the entire club off Its stride take your choice. Rudolph, unquestionably. In my mind, will come back at us In the opening game In Boston today, and we will go at him better prepared than we did on opening at Shlbe Park If we can cop the first game In Boston I will feel confident that we will come through all right, otherwise they will have us on the defensive, and it will be hard going Defensively I am satisfied we hae more than held our own. It's only the base hits that have been shy. and without them any club isn't worth a nickel. I do rot care who they are up against- We are still in the ring, f nd look out for us to day, 6ombody Is due, for lacing. 1