0 ._estab ~ law; and that without an lished by express compact; ono nation would not de. liver up an abscondiog slave, to the citizen - of- Bomber country. , ' "" •--- r He else showed that, by' decisioit in tbe ease of Prig& vs.' the State of Felinsylva.; I'' Dia --tile Co - urt held that, Slave y was le.- ical, and coutd exist only by vir ue of - 411 e, loeal law. That if the Coosti titian bad ' not required the renditic;n of fugitivee from labor, every State Might have manumitted every alaie that entered a non-slavehold itig State with inieunity,ss there-Wes not pinochle in 'the lawi of nations Which re . furred the returci of the slae. _ _ 2. Vito gelation -_: which ' the Federal • Glivanmeut • bestir to .Slavery in the States. . I Under this head he showed that Slavery wastocr.t, snd under . the contr_el of State 1 aevereigitty;* that, the Feder d Government Thad IV) action VVer it, exceptin regard to a surrender of fugitives from service or ~, -laho , e. That slaves were spoken of in the COnatitutien as persons, and not as proper ty. That Congress could not regulate the. - slave taade among the) States, and! that ' - the continnance of , the sla've trade twenty :-. years after' t,he addption "of the Constitu. ' . tion, was not a., general ineartin but in avor of Such States as ShouLdLthink 1 adi.:zon• who was desirous' that no word , s'uould be - used in the Constitution wbich indkated: there could be property. - . in man. . _ . 3. .The power of Congress to establish - - Territorial Governments, ,and to proliib.- l it e tbe iiotroductionbf Slavery-therein.' e - Under this head be shovied, by the,ko - ceedings of the Convention which framed .... , the Censtituiion, that the necessity of a poerfw to establish temporary Government as initeitery_ to the establishment of State" ' Governments, rind to dispose of the public lands, was felt and anowledged; that.the . rule of these lands was looked to \for the, ; payment 'of the Revolutionary debt. And that ample provision was made to establish 1 Territerial Gorcinments . by the 31 sectior of the 4th article of the Constitution. whieh gave Congress power to dispose of, ' en.l.mdke all needful rules and regulation:'{ t : i q..-icting the territory or other prOperry, • lteleng:ng to the Iluited, States. That for sixty years this power Was universally ad .: '. :I VS' , all Courts, Federal an•i State, ' and by airstafesthert. Ana he vindicated rind' maintained the opinion of the Supreme - Court in the ease of the Atlantic .Inor-- - mice. Boers. Center, 1 Peters, 511. - 4 Under this head tie discussed the pi- , ......... • , feet of tal:;.;.e.sbtves. into i'' free Stat . Or Teri . itory, and e'liolding them,v h re Slave •/ ry - i - i prohibited— ~ . , , He assented tcothe doctrine .clearly an=' n• - tuueed in the case of Priggs. Peunsii vonia, that Slav&iry` couldinnly exist in a . State - where it was estahliihed bylair- and i consequently, if 'a sldve be taken where it • is not authorized, the master could not , , i coerce the srave.,l . ; . And tlra( where. Slavery was prohibited, in 111iribisjig north of .Missouri, if- Et slave - /Were Olin thereby his master; and remained there in his service,: he was free,. under the decisions oF:thereme Court, :a day numetousvleeisions the Supreme f . I ' 31: G. Ell For e ,aver mrxig va: i l F4OOD -1 --- NIL Erinott:-4Wel iri , gret, to inept yintr cOlUmnsi,' and pain j *Se finer Social ties ;4 your. readers .j.bf pflOieCleg ' I very peoallett, ,or controyciv, but dal ( myself, and :ustice - to ith Pairgtessor, rei s. very, brief potice of ,ri array ala ) tide., It heart) upo itlllfacel the in) teas of hoid toil,' is th , othi.imocintain -ha la borect'" and heho d thol lisiue Ther are several pointsl erre :to hotice, and t en I will leave him forever. 1 But first I peat my "dormer remark, Oat • ih6. articl first publiatied ' (The neglectlief Teeth, a d its consequenees) wus divestfil Ofiell pe utili ties, as far asla clear', isfatemvut of th case would allow, and no wian in c om m city could, or' would have suspe l eted Mr. M rray Was th e unfortnnate'prtfetitiOner, hd be uot com put; in paper, r iand acknowl- , edged it las his. So carcfull was lin the descriptiOn of ihe case alluded to, I fUrbOre to mention the resider e,' l gave bat the initials'lot the name, , ',and Savo n t the slightdstl intimation to' th 9 ,. pnbli .;by which the ,operator 'might become in). ilea ' ted ;11)0 your succeeding isue eontai ed a, communicaion from - Mr. .11,,.1.'! chaYgi g me: with ' making 'an "unpr)ncifil'ed dri e" at Lim, ind making an unprovoked and furl l rp ous onslaught on my penal ap . d rel glens cSarsOter, , charging me with placia; isu , and . luestioliing my honor sod I tnathfulness. ..I. was compelled to reply, and lhovd thus to end this controversy, but sadly were I and the community . disappointedi for your - - gni . of last week contains ailother fi3m 'his' pen,- to which I in, tion of the h i onest, reflecting al of my felloarl citizens. , ,I I His first holds 1 "I tvie an hate repugnan i ce ii bickering .i " and before the ail i says ' fq l now invite the.Dr avd kick' horns'witlirre on and "wel shall stick by you t 4 ject is exhausted." Do lies harmonize with, a,peace;lyvin that possesses an "inate e repugi cringe" and, controversy?! 11 1: , pal ilesir l oit, is to expose h"s distortion' of my 'reply:— 'ln the. ' Arius'of,3l,ii; t eli 11 L e , E guage: r 1 :• ,k , If, Mr, Murray his perfori °pert:tied,' dr effected , a cure, ' questO to report it to tla.' MI 1 (a faCt we did not know) w'o, award him a:1 . he merito4 1 Mr. )lurray in quoting riays.;—"l M. has 2erformed a surgical l operatio I •effected r a cure",,te.. "It is a, fact ri not knoi"—and theii Ihe says "be thorized -AO say t's•it '• Mr. 1.3 : Swage the Dr. 'all about the !tracts of the tiOU. IP , • . i r 1 1 • We knew Mr. M. `hail in char o the case mentioned, 'but we denied ' the k fowl edge of the fact, that be !Intik been re ..iest ed to'ieport it before the - Medical & iety, as 'tie makes known in his--4stl artiel , and this is the import of . n 1 Words-and we had authentic informatton' i tati the, pllysi "'den , bad been suhse * quetitlylealled to ad minister to the lady constitutio.nallY, go we cauld,not but doubt that h I had.perf cted, i,iure., Why s hould he distort m lan -1 gum?, and print a falso.i ,? 1 ., _ . : 1 . . „3 p sa, 1 op - pothis election , to the tr stie ship of Beaver Academy e account of hisl "incompetency." I said " I believedhitu II mar," -,nnsuitable to tlie p itien, no be- II cause he'liati not the ability po Perfornl the il 'duties 'incumbent to fbelo ee, 4iut in , my I) inter c ourse in, with him as st 'dent I lear ned 1 to doubt his integrity. Bu Ihe 'lnakethe substitution only that he in ay do Loner to I himself. I have fully . answered his elfarge I of•plagiarism, by denying tl pOssessiT of Ii the, works Ilie quotes from, iit I ask you f L, fellow.citizens as - ariters in thins discuion I to uote.Closely and critically the quotations said to he copied, and h's el arge willilose I timid! of its weight.,—but hl perverko my, true meaning . again, ' said in repl , to this charge: , ' , ' -' • ' "I i dise , loins all depei ange on 'Terri. , or any other author for the' artielte allude •to, further than any stioloht•of science is de pendant on the authorl of that. seienel. , -= 1 Harris is our acknowledged standaid auiU• and it islalmost impossible to' Speak on the subject of which the treats, wishcius emp oy ing not only biologic, bUt Wore or l'• of his form l of langu age" i "" 'I ' '.=.t. Mr N. repeats but phrt of * sentene in the paragraph. • • l., .L ",I , diselaini all dependance. n Ifarris 01 • - 1 , tiny other author, for the ar t icle, alludei I I to." ' .• ' Tivice'he repeats th 7 1 to gi ' the fa si hood the more effect. I appeal s toy t Does not Mr. Murray- distort,' the truth does he tint km - ell - my i langua'ge—is it i 38 wicked tolgive but I half an 'idea, or p: of a iii i ntenedl when designed Ito inisrep i •' sent, as to give utterance to the basest truths? l• , .' ; 1 • In his'previous art' 1 , , A . ic ehe veracity by' denying the authei three eases alluded to Won't give ,Baines: In my t•erilY-..3 names-to' the yublie ; but stili, , their 4istlifiilness, be.u'use fur the-"par ties may have klied; oI named has moved away. • But ' ! edges - edges in'his last paper, the fee 'cotidiiioned ulcer" in:the last which wohld int yield to his tit flatting himself ignerantl of the •and advising Dr. I,lannen to t: in his , own, pr. rilfer, it to in, bands., _H a ead his adini;oion. i I lately eftsed front th office c of Ott:it:ins, and knew butt ascot surgery then, than 4 - ,s, does nnw, And . yet lip. oldiy psomisingly asoeits, ;there win of the ant.-- o&, in all new. than nitiy be or;; at tirighton the ease of the antrum. If he kne not whilt it was b wioutd he docide tr ly'whatwhit was-unt, when the; d i sc se was in the 4- gion of the Antiuna Bu r t we re not dip posed to iratillf his vain curiosity : by en teringfurther into the i vestigatzon•of matter, believing, my verac ity I has never been , litnpeaeLd by tl is Tho cnnituunity.— lish truth 'as I have before s ted,•llSau estab.. , - Notice also the egotismdisplayi lin 6 his omelets, the self iuiportancertthe / 7 11 of bis I language. : l in hi* last he says, : 1 3 can prepare my own articles , , ' t rue, hs a heard no . One doubt their , originality, the l bear t!iti iMage,of tim, author: "I have posed this: literarj fraud," "ratuavrare smart; under Cho' severity, of hfil l eFPoserer In speaking of his election he. esys."T,hp poop ln . sad chino John, l and I ent with - the . i'vOte eves I prey onaly polkelldr 6,6 i •,;" again, "You •knowlediH.infr iiti p it y then you feel it • ow," "it to bird fee's "trout to rise high than 14 foie :tarn/ ! We' hate wondei if the tint of 1 siapii I,l'ai neeesaitated th autos p s tip-, Pill ilk place with the 6 en 1 itithl Nat,- ilig p" of his article. -. MaireyeaYe' 1 c allerign him or any other pan to oint to anything in my ife incomPatibie th ' Christian profettsto •."' - 1 . 11,e !me present the pow it, of relnistien m uis!r.. Ile is a man " coring Goll:With . al ! his hear:, and soul, nd _naind , .. and i e . . , it nith, and Lis aeighlaor ae •himeelf i" a'alled of Gocrto preath the wontlerfdl ri heir 'of the Gospel of Christ—,orte-whor ohrirtSian life,and Godly .CeMyetsation ,ex 7 era an elevating arid refining influence in fo cietY. "lie vaunted, not hitriself, is not' puffeillup, he thinketh no! evil." He ler , earhe social circle that he mat draw:men • toC rrist l he loietli tho Chanibers - of the 1 . '8 rte eni that lie may ,give te "balm of- I • c ua lation." Faith { in God, `•hope and t i f rn stness fore the incees of his mission , a ! d charify and levit , 'ndness, are.his c 'erecter. Dees lie t love strife? henr To lfilY. '4Dlessed are tti • I peacernekers" Does he delight in !the rivolities , i of life r!, 'while the blood of souls tainithe