Product registration decision expected next year
BY CURT HAULER
HARRISBURG -
probably will be late At present both J&J and
January before any decision the Department of
is made on whether the Agriculture are waiting for
Pennsylvania Department of transcripts of the hearing
Agriculture will grant and exhibits entered as
registration to Agrispon. testimony in the hearings.
„ ... , ~. . . , Agrispon, manufactured
But the local distributor of by Sn Corp, a Texas *
Agrispon, J&J Agn- distributed locally by J&J.
PI S U !? sI^,, J BSOS ?2 st ?S Principals in J&J Linde
product will be registered f ormer Governor Milton
for sale in the state they Shapp; his former Secretary
recently purchased a 50.000 of A g ricult ure James
square foot warehouse to M cHale; and McHale’s
seryeas a office, warehouse, f orm er deputy, Jane
and distnbution center. Alexander.
The quasi-judicial hearing j&j has purchased the old
Attention
Beef & Perk Raisers
CUSTOM BUTCHERING
iif HESS’ BUTCHER SHOP
2635 Willow Street Pike
Ttfff Willow Street, PA
717-464-3374 s
♦ —We Process the Old Fashioned Way—
| • Pudding • Hams • Bologna
t • Scrapple • Bacons • Dry Beef
We also Specialize in Beef
For Your Freezer, Sides of Pork,
YOU’VE HEARD
THE TALK.
There’s a better way to dry grain. It’s called
CHILLCURING ™ because it means CURING
without heat. Here’s what the talk is all
about.
THE GRAIN
Every kernel of grain is alive when it comes out of the field.
It is a seed, able to grow because it has the ability to take on
moisture Likewise, it can be kept in a state of preservation by
removing the moisture already in it.
But by heating the gram to dry it, the seed life is destroyed.
By removing heat and moisture from the gram, it becomes
dormant, and stays alive. Then it can ripen to full weight,
losing only water while keeping valuable protein, starches
and sugar.
THE SYSTEM
It’s simple. Gram goes from the field right to the bin. With
the unique AIRFRAME'” and AIRFLOOR™ the gram rests on a
solid bed that allows maximum ventilation
Clean dry air is the best curing medium for the gram.
GRAINLAMPS'” provide electric sunshine, cleaning and
drying the air beneath the floor, before it passes through the
gram.
Fans force air under the floor. Rising through the gram, this
dry outside air carries away moisture and heat.
At the peak of the bin a jumbo 40” turbine, the
WHIRLCOOLER”, puts nature to work for you. Wind and
rising air keeps it turning, venting the system naturally.
A special HARVESTAT” Control System monitors the
curing process. A simple setting controls the GRAINLAMPS’"
to make use of free, natural air.
on Agrispon concluded
earlier this month.
Sides of Beef.
Agrispon hearings
Gettysburg Shoe Factory in
Dillsburg to serve as its
headquarters. It will lease
extra space.
The Department hearings
were to determine whether
Agrispon should be
registered under Penn
sylvania's fertilizer and soil
additive law.
Registration was denied in
September by State
Agriculture Secretary
Penrose Hallowell.
SnCorp and J&J requested
a hearing on the decision.
The hearing began in early
November, and because of
the number of witnesses
appearing and the in
tervening Thanksgiving
holiday, the hearings did not
conclude until December 6 at
10 pm.
While the Department of
Agriculture has no official
position on the hearings, a
number of department
employees say they feel
hearing examiner Joseph
Klein, who acts as judge on
the matter, will rule with the
Department.
Klein is a Harrisburg
attorney.
McHale said Wednesday
he felt the hearing went well
forAgrispon.
“As far as I'm concerned,
we proved beyond a doubt
that Agrispon generates
nitrogen,” McHale said.
One of the central points of
the hearing was whether or
not a gallon of Agrispon,
which is 99 percent water,
can indeed provide any
nutritional benefit when
2. TU has been tried and proven in 17 states on
over 3000 farms. The research is in; CHILLCURING™ WORKS'
3. The CHILLCURING” system uses only the electricity to
power fans and lights, using about IVa KW hrs. per bushel.
Compare that cost to other systems that use increasingly
expensive fuels to get disappointing results.
4. The grain goes from the field to the bin and stays there till
you need it. Save time and money at harvest with the one step
HARVESTALL CHILLCURING™ and storage system.
5. If you’re in the market for grain storage, you owe it to
yourself to look further into HARVESTALL GRAIN
CHILLCURING”.
Check With Us For Our Early Season Discounts
applied over 10 acres of field
crops.
The Agriculture Depart
ment maintained at the
hearings that Agrispon had
not presented evidence to
prove the 26 claims made on
its label. The nitrogen claim
was among the 26.
Agrispon relied heavily on
the testimony of E.H, Lloyd.
Jr., a North Dakota scientist
working for Agvise.
Other witnesses for
Agrispon during the hearing
included Dwayne Vance of
North Texas State
University and Robert W.
Fisher of Virginia Com
monwealth University.
Agrispon also presented
several farmer witnesses
during the hearings. In
cluded were Albert Bentz,
Thomasville, York County,
who distributes Agrispon
locally; Claude Reinheimer,
Berwick; Albert Garber,
York County; Keith Nichols,
Spartansburg; and CUnt
Richards, a Maryland
farmer.
Nichols had served in the
Agriculture Department
under McHale as a regional
director.
Much controversy
revolved around the
reliability of testimonial
statements as opposed to
scientific data. And the
Agriculture Department’s
witnesses often questioned
the reliability of Agrispon’s
scientific witnesses.
Included on the Ag
Department’s list of wit
nesses were Edwin “Bud”
Advanced Ag Products
RD 2 Box 174 Elverson, Pa. 19520
215-286-9118
THE FACTS
l.You can’t beat Nature. HARVESTALL GRAIN
CHILLCURING™ uses the same elements that ripen and
preserve gram if left to itself: free flowing air and infra red rays
(sunshine).
Lancaster Farming, Saturday, December 22, 1979
Wallis, Jr., director of the
Bureau of Plant Industry;
Lyle Forer, chief of plant
pathology; and Tony Grigor,
chief of the Bureau of Foods
and Chemicals lab division.
Richard Fox and Dale
Baker, two Penn State
agronomists also took the
stand.
Baker’s lab assistant,
Christine Hunt, was sworn in
to talk about the ex
perimental procedure used
in the controversial Penn
State tests which included
Agrispon. But she gave no
testimony.
Among other witnesses at
the hearing was Robert
Miller, an Ohio State
University microbiologist.
Both sides seemed to feel
Miller justified their
position.
Eddie Albert, an actor
from the Green Acres TV
show, appeared as a witness
for Agrispon. He has been
active in promoting the
product.
Once representatives of
both sides receive the
transcripts now being
prepared they will have two
weeks to write a proposed
finding of facts and legal
brief.
Klein, the attorney who is
serving as hearing
examiner, will then review
all of tile evidence presented
him and will decide whether
to advise the Secretary of
Agriculture to grant a
registration for the product.
Klein’s decision is not
binding on the Secretary, but
v\'
*1
Agriculture Department
officials said for the
Secretary to go against the
Hearing Examiner's
recommendation would be
extraordinary.
Klein said be hopes to have
the final decision prepared
in a matter of weeks, not
months.
The Department of
Agriculture said it expects
the final decision by the end
of next month.
Waiting in the wings is a
second proposed registration
forAgrispon.
Ibis registration contains
only two of the original 26
claims listed (Hi the product
label now in dispute. But it
includes the claim that
Agrispon produces nitrogen.
The Department of
Agriculture has taken no
action on the new label
awaiting Klein’s decision.
Should Klein recommend
Agrispon be labeled and his
decision be accepted, there
would be no need for the new
label since both of its claims
are already included in the
original 26.
Should Klein’s decision go
against Agrispon, the new
proposed label will move.
But the Agrispon people
may take the old label along
with them to a higher court
in an attempt to overturn the
hearing board’s decision, if
it goes against the product.
For several hours Dale
Baker’s research plots were
tbs target of extensive cross
examination. Baker hin)°°if
(Turn to Page 122*
30f
121