THE AIERICAN PRESBYTERIAN AND GENESEE EVANGELIST. Bellgione and Family Newspaper, IN THB INTICRICHT OF TES Constitutional Presbyterian Church. PUBLISHED EVERY THURSDAY, AT THE PRESBYTERIAN HOUSE, 1334 Obeetsut Street, (2d story.) Philadelphia. Bev. John W. Mears, Editor and Publisher. amstitait Urcsilightirin. THURSDAY, MAY 17, 1866 DIVISION AND REUNION IN THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH. LESSONS OF HISTORY. In considering measures for a reunion of Presbyterians, the past experience of the body should not be overlooked. We have already tried both separation and reunion, and we are not altogether in the dark as to their nature and tendency. Indeed, it will be our own fault, if, from the severe teachings of the past, we have not gathered some lessons of the deepest significance and value. Let us attempt to put some of these lessons on record : 1. Presbyterians do not place organiza tion above principle. Visible unity is their ecclesiastical ideal; but not their idol. For truth's sake, they do not hesi tate to risk all which is . merely external. There are far greater calamities with them than disruption of the mere outward body of the Church. A greater calamity with them is ecclesiastical oppression—is con sent to false doctrine on essential points— is silence upon great moral questions with which the whole community is agitated. A greater calamity than disruption would it have been for Scotland, if the indepen denoe of the Church had been tamely sur rendered in 1843, and if the glorious quar ter century of the Free Church had been wanting in her annals. A greater calamity by far than disruption is even now upon the Church of Englund, whose evangelical members remain in organic connection with, and so practically endorse, the ram- pant infidelity which they cannot disci pline and control. A far greater calamity would it have been in 1861, for the Asset& bly of the other branch to withhold their testimony and their moral support from the National cause, than to suffer the eon- sequences in the withdrawal of the South ern churches 2. Organization is, next to a desire for truth, a leading instinct, an essential fea ture of Presbyterianism. Disrupted Pres byterian bodies do not fly into fragments or degenerate into independency. Isola tion is abhorrent to their nature, as it is to Christianity itself. When divisions are effected, immediately the fragments, with perfect ease, become complete wholes again. And, sooner or later, tendencies to reunion are almost certain to appear. The breach of 1741-58, in this country, was filled up through almost its entire length with nego tiations tor reunion. And our branch of the Church demonstrated its Presbyterian in stincts by a reluctance, which it tpok twenty years entirely to efface, to accept the situa tion thrust upon it by Piovidenee, of lin in dependent Church. Ten years more have passed, and now we see the instincts of our brethren of the other branch, sharpened by some peculiar circumstances, .asserting themselves in a similar manner, and calling' quite emphatically fur a restoration of the old ties. In Scotland and through all the British colonies, the tendencies to reunion . are universal and powerful, leading to union movements on the greatest scale that has been witnessed in Christendom since the Reformation 3. In the course of these movements there have been developed in this country, two pretty clearly marked branches, or schools of thought and habits of action, in the Presbyterian Church. The one is rigid; the other, free. The one lays stress upon the particulars of a creed; the other, upon the essential parts of a system. The one makes human philosophy a test of ortho doxy ; the other is unwilling to go beyond a simple and unstrained interpretation of Scripture, in which the great principles of Calvinism are found. The one is more Cal vinistic than Calvin ; the other, more Pau line than Calvinistic. The one teaches litnit ed atonement, absolute inability, and literal responsibility for Adam's sin; the otr lic offers a free Gospel, teaches natural abilit , and denies authority to all mere theories of the mode of our connection with Adam. The one limit/Cale relations of the Church to the world ; the other expands them so as to bring the influence of the Church to bear upon every moral and religious interest of man. The one is austere, lofty, settling upon precedents, satisfied with old things and suspicious of new; the other is liberal, genial, prepared for something better than the past, which shall confirm and elucidate God's word, and be an advance upon all our present systems. History teaches us that these two ten dencies, have from the beginning, existed in our American Church ; that though they may be latent for a time, circumstances are sure to bring them, sooner or later, into New Series, Vol. 111, No. 20. conscious antagonism, and ,thaf it is hard, if not impossible, for theM to dwell ,together. under the roof of a single or ganization. Twice the attempt has been made. Once the union endured but twelve years, with a period of• seventeen years of disruption; the second time it lasted eighty years, and now nearly thirty years of divi sion have passed. And each of these ten dencies is, in our day, strong enough to rally about it numbers, influence, wealth, and talent sufficient to constitute a vigor- ous, independent, useful Church 4. The softening influences, which, at different epochs, led men in both of these schools to meditate union, are not perma nent, do not affect the main tendencies themselves, and cannot guarantee the sta bility, the peace, the homogeneousness of the united body. The truth is, the liberal school has never schemed for disunion, has never needed softening influences, bu , has always been the first to think of repair ing the breach, when a rupture has occur red. The New York brethren were inces sant for reunion from 1741 and onwards; and the "New School" of 1837-38 per- gated in their reunion movements unti their own sense of Christian manliness pro tested. On the contrary, both in 1758 and in 1866, outward circumstances of the most powerful character have been required to act upon the more rigid organization,' and make them, for the time being, insensible to the characteristic differences of the bodies, and thus dispose them for union. Let the truth be told : misfortune softened them in both instances, and gave room for an unwonted development of charity. Gillett tells us (Hist. I.; chap. v.) that almost from the consummation of the divi sion in 1741, the New Brunswick, or libe ral party, gained vastly upon the Philadel phians. In the numbers and talents of its ministry, and in the- extent of the field opened to their labors, the advantage was altogether with the New side. The Old side lacked vigor and spirituality; the tide of emigration from Ireland, so important to them, began to ebb. The increase of mem bership in the New side was to that of the Old side, nearly as eight to one. The New Brunswick party started with but eight or ten ministers, including, licentiates; in the seventeen years, they had so increased that the Synod of New York numbered seventy ministers at the Reunion. In 1742 the Synod of Philadelphia, (the Old side,) numbered twenty-six ministers. At the time of the Reunion, they numbered twenty two. No doubt some, at least, of the Old aide, regarded reunion as a " corollary" from these facts. Gillett says, "In these circumstances, they became less and less indisposed to reunion." We would speak with the utmost kind ness of our brethren of the other branch, and would most cheerfully recognize a sub stantial unity of spirit between 'many of them and. ourselves ; but is it not true, and ought it not to be declared, that the strength of the reunion movement in their body, to day, is due to like causes with thoSe which we saw at work in the " Old Side" from 1741-58 ? Does any one suppose that, if the Old School Church had maintained its organization entire, and to-day numbered, as it did in 1860, its three hundred thou sand members and nearly 3700 churches, with a General Assembly of over three hundred Commissioners, we should hear of any great pressure for reunion in its ranks ? Has it not been candidly avowed, that the corollary from the failure to reunite the Northern and Southern fragments of the Old School Church is reunion with the New School ? Say we not truly, that the rigor of the Old School has been softened by extraordinary circumstances—the loss of nearly one-third of her strength and the rise of portentous elements of discord in her thinned ranks ? Are not our brethren passing through the same process which the Old side experienced over a century ago, in which, for the time, they forgot and ig nored their characteristic tendencies, but did not fail to bequeath them to "their ecclesiastical posterity, to reappear after eighty years? Surely the utmost friendli ness of feeling should not hinder our searching this matter to the foundation, and pouring upon it all the light which God has providentially given to us, in over a century and a half of Presbyterian history in America. 5. Our own deductions from the past history, and present status of our branch of the Church, render us decidedly adverse to breaking up its outlines and destroyi ng i ts identity. We reiterate our often expressed Conviction of the unspeakable value, to the Church and the world, of liberal Presbyte rianism as represented in our body. To any movements which will really strength en those wholesome principles, we are fa vorable, of course. But any attempt to PHILADELPHIA, THU4SDAY, MAY 17, , 1866. merge once more the two great tendencies of Presbyterianism into one organization, under the influence of mere kindly feeling, or of a temporary suspension of the 'rigidity of the Old side, it seems to us would be a blind disregard of the teachings of history ; it would be to walk in a treadmill; to return upon our own track. Unity is desirable; but attempts at unity in a line twice, re buked of Providence, cannot easily be shown to be the duty of Christian men and minis ters. The present relations of the two branches 1 as distinct ChUrches are harmonious, hon orable, and to mutual edification. They may be rendered still closer, doubtless, with increase of benefit. Possibly the: mass of the two bodies may, by further in , tereourse, find themselves alike upon the platform of a wise, safe, scriptural, Liberal Presbyterianism. They have not found it so yet. Until they do, we shall go simply for cultivating our present friendly and courteous relations, and for presenting a substantially even front to the enemies of truth in the world. But we can never give our consent to a union, which does not honor that liberality, and blazon it as a star upon the forehead of the new, Organization. WHAT 'SHOULD CONE OF THE RE- There are frequent expressions of inter est, not to say of anxiety, beginning to be heard as to the fruits and tests of the re4i val which has been so generally enjoyed t6r the churches during the past six months. We do not add our voice to this inquiry out of fear.; we see no reason to question, the genuineness or preciousness of the work. But we think it meet to express the very reasonable expectation, that the Church shall show a large increase of efficiency and shall be a more decided power among men than before. 1. We expect to see a nearer approxima tion to that condition of permanent revival, which we regard as the only normal condi tion of the Church, and the one quite indis pensable to her final triumph. In not a . few instances reported in 'this revival, the work has taken this steady, enduring char Rater, going on for months, or even a, year, without sensible abatement. Frequently the means used have varied almost in no thing from the regular exercises of the Church. All, of, which seems to point to the time, when religion will be recognized as the highest concern of the Church at all times; when a fresh and lively interest will be taken by Christians in the work of the Lord the year round; when conversions will be looked for, as the result of the re gular services of the Church. The week of prayer, prolonged into nineteen weeks of daily united prayer among Christians of this city, is •an indication of like signifi canoe. In proportion to the results of the late revivals, we do not believe the press ure upon pastors has been bxhaustive. Hence, it will be natural for them to direct their revived and strengthened flocks to this view of the subject. 2. We look for a higher state of piety and efficiency among the individual mem bers of our churches. We expect Sabbath schools to be reinforced with teachers; we expect Mission-schools to spring up among the destitute, and every form of effort for a dying world, and especially for the neglect ed and perishing masses, to be reinforced with zealous, self-denying laborers. In Boston, a cultivated layman, a man of lei sure and of decided abilities, H. F. Durant, Esq., has been moved to devote himself to evangelical. abors. And so acceptable has he proved himself in this capacity, that Rev. Dr. Adams has shared his own pulpit with him, thus wisely endorsing and encourag ing one who, was so manifestly an instill ment of God for this work. Men and women will be found working for the sal vation of souls, not as something out of their line, but as the simple and natural result of a humble, believing, earnest, pray erful spirit. There are certainly neighbor hoods, where the people of the world will feel themselves in close quarters under the zealous labors of their converted compan ions, and amid the multiplied numbers and the victorious spirit of the revived people of God. 3. We look for a concentration of efforts against prevailing social evils. A revived Church will be followed by a raised moral tone that will be felt in the community. We expect a new and more vigorous assault upon intemperance than has been made for a dozen years. The recent powerful move .. ments in defence of the Christian Sabbath have been part of the revival. And a re vived Christianity will appear in a bold stand against mere partisanship in politics; in the reinforcement of every effort to keep the vile and corrupt from places of power; and in a strengthened public sentiment- in VIVALS ? favor of equal justice to all races, and of the wholesome • execution of ' law upon those guilty of the highest offences' known 'to human government We have the utmost confidence that thresulti of these revivals will be counted in the , ballot boxes; and they will strengthen the party described Senater Wilson in his,speech in the United States Senate, May 9 I believe it to be a• liberty-loving and pa triotic organization, -to be composed of the noblest, truest, and best men of our country; that an overwhelming majority of the thought ful, reflecting, conscientious, Bible reading, God fearing men of the country are in its ranks. Every breath that that organization has breathed has been a breath for liberty, for patriotism, for justice, for humanity, for the elevation of every being that breathes God's air and walks his earth. We could not believe a revival genuine, which did not add strength to the sound political tendencies, elements, and organiza tions of a free and intelligent people. 4. Once more, we look for an accession of strength to the benevolent enterprises, and to all the departments of labor in the Church. Have Christians grown in grioe is the Church active and Aroused ; has the Holy Spirit — communicated himself, so that her whole character is greatly elevated? Then we may use the language of Paul, in soliciting aid for the poor saints from the Corinthians :—" Therefore, as ye abound in everything, in faith, and utterance, and knowledge, and in all diligence, and in ypur love to us, see ,that ye abound in thin grace also." It will ibe wrong, and we think difficult, for any man to believe him self converted unless his substanee is truly consecrated to the Loid. At least a general revival should lessen the proportion of those inexplicable monsters, those lulus. naturm (we cannot say gratne) in the Church—penurious Christians. We expect a wider circulation to Bibiles, to. pure liter's, tare, and,religious newspapers by a revival. The religious paper, representing all the interests of the Church and of Christ's kingdom, should follow every revival as a supplementary instructor and' guide to en- lightened aotion for Christ, and as an apOlior to the position of the new converts. We count, too, .on reinforcements to the ranks of candidayls for the . mlnistry., 'The blessings upon our collegos lead us to look, early for such results. rlf they do not fol low, then may., we question the. Divine origin of these movements: By their fruits we shall know them. 5. We regard it as one-of the most'hope ful signs of the Reiival, that no obe seems disposed to view it as ended. 'For our selves, we trust we see but' the beginning. And we counsel churches and neighbor-- hoods that have not, been,visited, or that have had, but n ;partial blessing, to hope on and pray on, and- wait for the promise of the Father,.and " ye shall be baptized with the Holy Ghost not many days hence." The prophetic expectations that have olung about our year, make us look for far greater things than the truly great already Vouch safed. Why may not . the latter half of the year transcend unspeakably the former, in spiritual glory and fruitfulness ? REUNION 'A 'PRACTICAL FAILURE. It will be remembered that at former meetings of the Dayton (N. S.) and Miami (0. S.) Presbyteries, a plan for harmonious action upon the overlapping parts of their field was adopted. Feeble churches on either side were to unite, and the:resultant churches to ally themselves in a fair pro portion to the two Presbyteries. As usual in such arrangements, the more liberal party fulfilled so much of the arrangement as depended upon themselves, and the conse quence sraa the accession to the Miami Pres bytery f one of these united churches. But when it came to the turn of the other branch a hitch took place, and the proposed union failed. At the last meeting of the Dayton Presbytery the Herald says:— * Considerable time was spent at both the regular and adjourned meetings in consider ing the practical . working of the plan of union agreed upon between the two Presby teries of Dayton and Miami one year ago. It was hoped • then that good would grow out of the proposed union; but the past year's experience has hardly' warranted the expectation. A protest was read from our members of the Second Church at Green ville, against the union, and the commis sioner heard from the nited . Church. A conference was also had with a committee from the Miami Presbytery, after which Presbytery substantially resolved 1. To decline giving their sanction to the union of our church at Greenville with the 0. S. at that place ; and 2. Expressed the opinion that our sense of selfrespeet, and the obligations we owe to the N. S. Presbyterian Church that has, under God, accomplished sp not-le a work since the great rupture of suggest to us the propriety of disci:manning any further efforts in this direction, until we have practical evidence that."our 0. S. brethren are able and willing to cooperate with us-on the general principle of equivii:. Genesee Eva,±Lgelist, No. 1043. lent' exchanges; or, which tlke Preshyteg think still-better, until the two AsSerntlies shall initiate: some just and feasible pla'p of organic union. A NEW VICTIM WANTED. The slave spiritin Russia, perhaps encour aged by the success of its expedient of assas sination in this country, has prompted a similar attempt upon the great leader of emancipation in the Old World, the Czar of Russia. Happily the same success did not fol low the copy as was mysteriously allowed to the original. Had the aim been as true, or had watchful friends been, for the moment, as remote as in the case of our lamented Lin coln, the Czar would have perished within two Jays of a year of the former—on the 16th instead of the 14th of April. Is not slavery the same everywhere ?' Can it be safe, or wise, or just speedily to restore to power those who fought a bloody civil war to perpetuate it? Is the nation in haste to bring back to our Congressional halls its plantation tone, its bully and menace, its bowie knives and pistols, and canes, its ungovernable passions; its last resort in-brute force? The temper of the country is well- repre sented in the joint resolution which was offered in the House by Mr. Stevens, and passed by a unanimous vote : Resolved, By the Senate and House of Representatives in Congress assembled, That the Congress of the United States of Ameri ca has learned with deep regret the attempt made upon the life of the Emperor of Russia by an enemy of emancipation. The Congress send their greetings to .His Imperial Majesty and the Russian nation, and congratulates the twenty millions of serfs upon the provi dential escape from - danger of the Sovereign, to whose bead and heart they owe the bless ings of their freedom.. PUBLICATION COMMITTEE'S TRACTS. The minor issues of our CoMmittee should not be overlooked while Mr. e are in terested by the adMirable quality and ap pearance of the' greater ones. We , have before us half a dozen tracts of ' their second series, every one, of which has its separate excellence and adaptedness. One of •them, by Dr. Duffield, nylon the theme "Every Christian a Home MiSsionaty," is a very full and inspiring survey 'of= the great field of lebor stretching before us and within reach of every servant of Chriat in the land. Another, on "The Family Altar," by the Rev. M. R.. Vincent,; effec tively urges the duty ,of family, wdrship, and gives practical directions for most ,suc cessfully discharging it. "Poor Little Ellen" is a most toiching and powerful temperance tract. " Poor yet Rich," shows the power of Divine grace to sustain the soul in extreme poverty, loneliness, and old age. For catechetical instruction, three little treatise§ have been provided : (1) "What we are to Believe," the ,doctrinal part of the Shorter. Catechism; with proof texts. (2) Shorter. Catechism, mith proof texts. (3) Four Catechisms for the Young, with prayers and' Divine Songs; three of them by Dr. Watts, and the fourth, the Shorter Catechism, with analyses and proof texts. We hope parents and Sabbath schools will largely avail themselves of this series. TOO BAD. The, guerilla who barbarously murdered General McCook, whom he meanly shot as he lay wounded and helpless in his ambu lance, and whose barbarous act thrilled the whole.people with intense indignation, has been liberated on his parole by tbe'Presi dent, and straightway elected sheriff of his county in Alabama,, by supporters of the President's policy. There is a day of reckoning-coming yet, both for the authors of such crimes and for those who would conciliate, tolerate, and applaud them. TENNESSEE. Andrew Johnson's own. State gives little encouragement to her distinguished lon in the course of extreme lenity to - rebels, which he an rudely avows and persists in attempting to enforce. The Senate of that State, by a two-thirds vote, has passed a stringent bill for the disfranchisement of rebels, which Governor Brownlow endorses, and pledges _himself to enforce by every means in his power. NINETEENTH WEEK OF PRAYER. Wednesday, United Presb. Church, Race near Sixteenth St. Thursday, Salem Methodist, Lombard St. below Broad. Friday, West Spruce St. Presbyterian, Seventeenth and Spruce Sta. Saturday, Olivet Presbyterian, Twenty second and Mount Vernon. TABOR CHURCEL — This prosperous church still gives proof that the blessing of God is with its pastor and people. On last Sab bath it received an accession of thirty eight members, seventeen by letter, and twenty-one by , profession. TERMS. Per annum, in advance: BL NW Carrier, 8 74 50 - Miss cents additional, after three months. Clnlbst.—T en or more papers, sent to one address. payabfistrictly in advance and in one remittance B Mail, $2 50 per annum. By Carriers, $3 per. annn tr. l[lnlstere and ElLinisters 9 Widows, $2 50 in advance. Home Missionaries, $2OO in advance. Fifty cents additional after three months. Remittanees by mail are at our risk. Postage.—Five cents quarterly, in advance, pal by subscribers at the office of delivery. Advertisements.-123 3 4 cents per line for t first, and 10 cents for the second insertion. One square (one month) $3 two months.. 5 • .. three " 7 six . 12 one year........ - 18 The following discount on long advertisements, in serted for three months and upwards, is allowed:— Over 20 lines, 10 per cent off; ever 00 lines, 20 per cent.; over 100 lines, 33% per cent pit. LAFAYETTE AVENUE CHURCH. THE F crsE LAW, ETC. Baoosiyx, May 12, 1866 DEAR BROTHER : —Next Sabbath will be our second communion-season since the commencement of the revival; we expect to receive one -hundred and eight into La fayette Avenue Church. The whole num ber received during the revival is two hun dred and sixty. Our membership has now gone beyond one thousand. God be praised for such a band of workers as this young church ! They are establishing a new mis sion-chapel as a memorial of this precious season of grace. The new "Excise Law" shut up our grog-shops in these twin cities last Sab bath, and the new broom sweeps clean. If the Christian community will only keep hold of the broom-handle, we shall exorcise some evil spirits therewith. Last Sunday the Scripture scene was reversed. The Lots remained in Sodom, while the "lewd fellows of the baser sort" fled over to Ho boken and Jersey. City, because Sodom was quite too respectable and Sabbatical for them. The first anniversary of the new " Na tional Temperance Society" was a superb success. Three thousand persons were present, including many leading clergy men. Brother Beecher and Gen. Howard (our Havelo'ck) spoke admirably. Yours ever, THEO. L. CIIYIER. ANOTHER PLAN.—The Northwestern Presbyterian, despairing of any revoca tion or modification of the recent acts of the Old 'School General Assembly con cerning' the South, now comes out with a new, suggestion. The men who are to compose_ the,4.ssembly are not likely to be much impressed with suggestions from- that *tarter. We copy them, not because they , have any immediate inter est for our readers generally, or because they are any foreshadowing of the doings of the Asseinbly concerned, but simply to show the tact of the champions of re• trogression in sliding frOm a position which the Chriatiimity of the North will overwhelniingly rtipnifiaie. The plan is "All that is now asked is , that the Assembly will take actibri in six:imam:it With the present state of affairsi changed as it is since last May. The ,` situation' is wholly altered. Then the churches South were, a scbisi:natical portion of our own Church : now, they are a distinct and regularly organised body. Then, the Church South was pledged to the Southern Confederacy; now,, it acknowledges the 'United States 'Goirernment and Constitu tion as hiving 'rightful - authority.' ?hen, there was 'in one of its public acts a declara tion that its mission was the conservation of slavery ; now, it publicly and unanimously re pudiates the ,obnoxious sentiment. Changes so important '0 these demand from us, not annulling or repudiatinit:aets,. but a new act. And what should that act be , " 1. Recognise the, chspge, with gratitude to Him wlcio rules "2.'Strike' from" our' rolls the Synods, Presbyteiies; ' ministeA .. and churches, who have nonstituted-thernselves a distinct Church and thus becomaia,foreign body. "Declare the sisterhood of the newhurch as belonging' to 'the Evangelical family, and that'mimstetif and members win be-received from. her just: :ass from: the Ne . School, the Method*, and qt.hers—that ' 'upolt•i _per icitileu sonar examinationvto their e. faith and'Ohtistian exOerience.' ..•''''-': "Declare' thatly this recognifiork we do not contract. , our limits, we beine4fill `The Presbyterian Church in the United *cites of America ;' and that we will, as h4rltofore, send missionaries, organize churches, form Presbyteries, and constitute Synods, in the Southern and South-western States, as we do elsewhere. ,: " We throw out this thought very briefly; we may recur to it to elucidate, defend, or modify. We think that the substance of it may be so put by.the next Assembly as to be perfectly satisfactory, ,to a Synods named above and to the great ,139 „of our ministers and people, the land over., PHILADELPHIA SABitAOCIATION. —The Twenty-fifth Anti `Report this Society has been liiidilPlOhr table. The field of operations of this,,society is confined pretty much to the hOatmen on our canals, the mission centres' being Easton, Lewisburg, Pa., New Bruns ivickotc. The work seems to be faith fully thine by tract distribution, personal conversation, and open-air services with boatmen, with the manifest blessing of God. The Corresponding Secretary, Rev. Jeremiah Miller, has, however, given a wider range to his labors, having traveled considerably through the State and addressed Sunday4chools, preached on the Sabbath, and labored at Harris burg, and in this city, with good results, for the maintenance of our Sabbath laws. The receipts and payments of the year were $3300. John A. Brown is Presi dent. It seems to us that an enlargement of the field of the Society's operations, so as to include efforts to reach the neglect ful and Sabbath-breaking masses of the city, especially during the warmer part of the year just commenced, would be a good work.. The imperjlted% interests of the Sabbath demand more general rally and more comprehensive efforts and steady reliance on the part of the friends of the day: